The Drift on Plankton Chris Lundberg, Mathematics & Science Center Revised from The World of Phyto- and Zooplankton: Life at Low Reynolds Number, by Dr. Mark Patterson, Virginia Institute of Marine Science Major Understanding Objectives Plankton are the minute drifters of rivers, ponds, lakes, estuaries, and oceans. They also play an important role in aquatic food chains. Because of their small size in relation to their aquatic environment, both phytoplankton and zooplankton exhibit a wide variety of physical adaptations that aid in their survival. In this lesson, students will observe how fluid motion at small scales is very different from those of experienced by a larger organism and will perform an experiment to test their own hypotheses concerning the many physical adaptations of plankton. Observe and describe the role of phytoplankton and zooplankton in the aquatic food chain. Develop a hypothesis concerning plankton shape and conduct an experiment using a scale physical model to test their hypothesis. Discover and explain how differences in physical structure affect the sinking rate of phytoplankton and the evolution of feeding mechanisms in zooplankton. Understand and appreciate the impact of size and scale on the forces and limiting factors affecting aquatic organisms. Time Introduction Activity: Observation of Live Plankton Activity: Plankton-Sinking Syrup Experiment Practice and Review of Results Closure Materials Observation of Live Plankton Activity Zooplankton, phytoplankton samples from biological supply company, local pond, or hay infusion set-up. Microscopes and Dissection scopes 10 min 30 min 30 min 10 min 10 min Plankton-Sinking Syrup Experiment (For a class of 24: 6 set-ups for groups of 4) Student Handout: The Drift on Plankton 1 Stopwatch Mixtures & Solutions 1 MysteryCargo.info 1 Meter stick or small metric ruler Plasticine modeling clay (for 4 similar sizes) 1 liter plastic bottle (with top cut off) 16 toothpicks 2 bottles of corn syrup 1 Coat hanger (to retrieve models from syrup) Paper towels Note: See Sources of Lesson Materials below in Teaching Tips for more information and preparation of lesson materials. State and National Correlations Virginia Standards of Learning: Life Science (LS.1, LS.4, LS.5, LS.7, LS.10); Physical Science (PS.1, PS.6, PS.10); Biology (BIO.1, BIO.5, BIO.7, BIO.8, BIO.9, PH.1) National Council of Teachers of Mathematics: Content Standard A (develop descriptions, explanations, predictions, and models using evidence, think critically and logically to make the relationships between evidence and explanations); Content Standard C (structure and function in living systems, regulation and behavior, populations and ecosystems, diversity and adaptations of organisms). Instructional Strategies Introduction Review with students the definition of plankton and describe how they experience their water environment much differently than larger organisms. Teachers may want to review the background information on plankton for this part. Teachers can use the PowerPoint presentation to introduce the concepts of types of plankton, reasons for their unique adaptations, and to introduce the sinking plankton lab activity. Activity: Lab observation of plankton Obtain living plankton samples for students to observe. Have students look for ornamentation, fat globules (which may affect buoyancy) and make drawings of their observations. Discuss the role of these shapes in regard to defense from predators and influence on the sinking rate of the organism. Introduce syrup experiment by stating that they are going to replicate the world of plankton in a larger, easier to observe setting. Activity: Sinking Syrup Experiment. Set up the experiment for students with cylinders, syrup, and materials. Students should work in groups of 4. Hand out the materials and the Drift on Plankton Student Handout and model or review the directions below for the activity: Have each student prepare a ball of clay of same mass. Direct students to take turns dropping their ball into the center of the solution Mixtures & Solutions 2 MysteryCargo.info and recording the time from drop to hitting the bottom. Have students hypothesize what shapes might help slow down the sinking time of their balls of clay. Direct students to use 4 of the toothpicks to modify and change the shape of their clay ball of “phytoplankton.” Students should make drawings of their creations on their answer sheet. Have students hypothesize which of their creations will sink the slowest. Sample hypotheses are: there is no effect of cell ornamentation on sinking rate, there is no effect of buoyancy changes (make a hollow ball), there is no effect on size on sinking rate. Direct students to again take turns dropping their ball into the center of the solution and recording the time from drop to hitting the bottom. Record which shape sank the slowest. Have students repeat the experiment, but this time allow them to drop their creations by the side of the syrup cylinder wall and record their results. Practice As a practice activity for an in-class or homework assignment, instruct students to perform one of the following two options: Conduct a web quest to find photographs or diagrams of different kinds of plankton. Make a drawing or print out a picture of the plankton and describe how its shape or form helps its floating function. Then, design a possible experiment a scientist could conduct – with a completed experimental design diagram – to test how well the plankton can float. Search for materials and items around the home that are designed to float in water. Make a list of these items and describe what allows each item to be able to float. Then, design an experiment – with a completed experimental design diagram – to test how you would change the buoyancy of one of these items. Closure Bring the lesson to closure by reviewing student results and the concept of surface to volume ratio with students. Ask students to respond to the following questions to relate their experiment to plankton and other living organisms in the Chesapeake Bay: How might sinking rate affect the delivery of food to benthic creatures? In the bay in the summer, hypoxia in deeper water is a problem for organisms. Would certain kinds of phytoplankton be less likely to cause an organic matter accumulation? How can an increase or decrease in limiting factors such as nutrients or water temperature affect the amount of plankton in the bay? Extensions 1. Explore Plankton Physics. Have students research Archimedes’ Principle and explain how relative density, volume, pressure, buoyancy, weight, displacement, and gravity relate to the classroom experiment and to the characteristics of microscopic aquatic organisms. 2. Create a Cartesian Diver. Have students create their own Cartesian Diver. Go to our Household Science for Kids or Cartesian Diver links for information and directions to create and conduct your own experiment. Mixtures & Solutions 3 MysteryCargo.info 3. A Copepod Feeding Mechanism Experiment Students can perform the experiment below to model and understand the challenges for zooplankton in regard to obtaining food. Materials Corn syrup, Small Styrofoam bowl, Nylon stocking, Cake sprinkles, Popsicle sticks, Toothpicks Directions Fill a small bowl with corn syrup to create a “corn syrup aquarium.” As you fill your aquarium, periodically add the cake sprinkles. Try to get a uniform suspension of them in the tank. Direct students to try to sieve the particles out of the tank using a filter made of pieces of nylon stocking strung between two Popsicle sticks. Make drawings of what happens. Brainstorm with students other methods to retrieve the particles. Direct students to fabricate tools (to replicate a copepod’s mouthparts) to be able to grab the food particles. Assessment Sample items are provided for use in checking students’ understanding of experimental design and plankton adaptations: Paper-Pencil Test: The Drift on Plankton Answer Key to Paper-Pencil Test Product: Create a Paper Plankter Rubric: Create a Paper Plankter The following table shows how the assessment items are related to specific lesson objectives: Objective Observe and describe the role of phytoplankton and zooplankton in the aquatic food chain. Develop a hypothesis concerning plankton shape and conduct an experiment using a scale physical model to test their hypothesis. Discover and explain how differences in physical structure affect the sinking rate of phytoplankton and the evolution of feeding mechanisms in zooplankton. Understand and appreciate the impact of size and scale on the forces and limiting factors affecting aquatic organisms. Major Understanding: Plankton are the minute drifters of rivers, ponds, lakes, Mixtures & Solutions 4 Paper-Pencil Test 2, 7 Product/ Performance 3, 4, 5, 12, 13, 14 1, 6, 8, 11 9, 10, 15 See attached product and MysteryCargo.info estuaries, and oceans. They also play an important role in aquatic food chains. Because of their small size in relation to their aquatic environment, both phytoplankton and zooplankton exhibit a wide variety of physical adaptations that aid in their survival. Teaching Tips rubric Check out these teaching tips for background information, teaching notes, and sources to obtain materials and living or prepared specimens for this lesson. Answer Key to Paper-Pencil Test Background Information Sources of Lesson Materials Student Handout: The Drift on Plankton References Chesapeake Bay Network This site provides general information, publications, and data concerning plankton in the Chesapeake Bay. http://www.chesapeakebay.net/info/plankton.cfm MathInScience.info Visit our educational resource site to acquire web-based lessons and resources for students and teachers. http://mathinscience.info Mathematics & Science Center Web site of the Mathematics & Science Center with a variety of information on programs and opportunities for students. http://mathsciencecenter.info The Plankton Net The homepage of all things plankton related and marine biology links by the Plankton guy, Dr. Warren Currie. Information on plankton ecology, research, images, and databases. Originally hosted by University of Guelph, Canada. http://www.geocities.com/planktonguy/index.htm Virginia Institute of Marine Science Web site of the Virginia Institute of Marine Science, with information concerning programs and current research. Contains link to the ocean sciences teacher resource page, The Bridge. http://www.vims.edu Patterson, Mark. 2000. The World of Phyto- and Zooplankton: Life at Low Reynolds Number. Virginia Institute of Marine Science. Photographs and graphics used in this lesson are courtesy of NOAA Photo Library and the Mathematics & Science Center. Mixtures & Solutions 5 MysteryCargo.info