BEAVER LAKE BEAUTIFICATION AND ACCESS LOTSURVEY RESULTS As of 2 March 2009 In order to better serve the community, the Property Committee, in conjunction with the Ladies’ Auxiliary, Nature Club, and Board of Directors, sent the following survey to the membership through the newsletter and through a mailing that was attached to the Cross Connection survey sent out by the Office. The latter was sent to only members who owned homes in the Beaver Lake subdivision while the newsletter was sent to everyone. We do not know how many completed forms were returned as a result of the newsletter; however we can surmise that the bulk of the forms were in response to the Cross Connection Survey because its return was mandatory. As a result, it is suspected that the survey is somewhat skewed towards members who have dwellings at the lake. There were 469 surveys returned. About 699 were sent out yielding a 67% return rate. 1. First, I will go over the yes/no questions in a table type format. The results are as follows: YES AND NO QUESTIONS Are you aware of our access lots? Have you or your family used an access lot in the past 12 months? Would you use Reserve Lot-7 if playground equipment was improved? Should we Hire a Professional Landscaper Do you think we should install basketball hoops in the parking lot north of the clubhouse? Would you Volunteer to provide some self help for Beaver Lake beautification? Yes No No Comment % Yes 388 53 28 82.7% Observations Most are aware of lots but don't use them 185 239 45 39.4% Over 1/3rd use access lots-good tally 70 339 60 14.9% Some interest 53 336 80 11.3% Lack’s Support 112 287 70 23.9% Some interest 84 267 118 17.9% Some interest The primary observation is that most people know that Beaver Lake has lots for use by the membership and that a lot of them are being used. As you will see later, there is particular interest in fishing from the lakeside lots. There was some interest in using Reserve Lot #7 if we keep and upgrade the playground equipment however most said they won’t use it. This seems reasonable since there are so many retired people living at Beaver Lake. The same rationale follows for the low number of people who want basketball hoops or who would volunteer for self help projects around the lake; however, there is a substantial number, quantity wise, of volunteers who want to help. Almost all of them left their name and number. 2. Next, the members were asked to list the lots they used the past year and the results are listed below. Lot SU 10 AL 1 AL 3 CL 14 AL 2 AL 4 AL 5 AL 6 AL 7 # Used 24 11 11 8 7 5 5 5 5 Lot AL 11 AL 12 AL 8 AL 9 AL 1466 AL 1669 AL 1860 AL 453 AL 2100 # TIMES 5 4 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 Although the 18 lots listed were used only 119 times according to the surveys returned, that number must be compared to the 39.4% who said they used an access lot for some purpose. This tally is therefore only indicative of which lots are most popular in a rough way. Obviously Special Use lot 10 in the southwest cove if the most popular according to the survey. 3. The survey asked what the lots in general were used for so we could determine which upgrades would be more favorable. The results are as followed: LOTS USED FOR Fishing Resting Picnics Swimming Play Walking boating Wedding Beach Nature Study # TIMES 119 41 38 10 12 6 5 3 2 1 It is obvious that the lots are mostly used for fishing or sitting. This emphasizes the importance of benches and peers. Picnic tables are also important and most of the swimming responses were for the clubhouse area. Boat docks are used but then again, there are only a few access lots with boat docks. 4. The next question involved spending money for upkeep and upgrades on the lots and the values of $0, $1000, $5000, $10000 were listed as possible amounts. The results are indicated that some funds were needed but didn’t list an amount. Also, the dollar figures were for all lots but the survey may have been misleading in that it was unclear that this amount would come from the dues and not an assessment. Had it been clear, the results may have been different. The left column shows the amount indicated on the returned surveys or the comment made by the member. The right column indicated the number of surveys that supported the left side amount or comment. Some comments were made on the survey that applied to this area of the survey but written elsewhere. FUNDS TO BE USED FOR LOT UDATES (TOT) Dollars $0 some $100 $200 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $5,000 $10,000 $50,000 maintain $100 for each lot to pay Whatever it takes 0 (except for Clubhouse) After Well Proj depends on usefulness Keep, but no basis to provide answer to this question same as past years depends on value for money Sell off No Comment Percent of those with comments that want some money spent Percent that had no comment # TIMES 105 37 3 5 2 49 1 72 42 1 21 1 2 1 4 2 1 2 1 8 109 67.5% 23.2% There were 280 members reporting a dollar amount from $0 to $50,000. Since there is no way to know how much “some” or “maintain” etc. is, these numbers were left out of this figure. The average dollar amount for the 280 members was $3152.86. 5. We looked if people used the access lots and how much money they would like to spend on them, now the survey asked what improvements the membership would like to see on the lots in general. The following table lists the ideas and accoutrements suggested and the number of times they came up in the surveys returned. There were 404 suggestions or comments received and 180 surveys received did not have any comment or recommendation. The table shows the top 4 items the membership would like to see is bathrooms, tables, benches and grills; however, in most cases, the respective lot was not specified. Please note that 8 members wanted to sell the lots, one of which said to sell some and trash cans, a most affordable and useful item, was mentioned only twice. ACCESS LOT IMPROVEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS Bathrooms Tables Benches Grills Pavilion Docks Maintain Trees Playground Do nothing Parking porta potties Trash cans Handicap access Dog park Horseshoes Marking signs Sell the Lots Beaches Grading OTHER COMMENTS A door on the woman's bathroom by boat ramp (only one has a door) AL3: fix dock and level ground. AL9: replace dock to middle of lot and put in table, trashcan and sand. AL4-DEEPER, AL8-CLEAN WEEDS Decent Dock/Platform Fire Extinguisher keep natural make permanent members bring own items one time assessment SEA WALLS Signs for rock throwing Take the top 3 or 4 and START taking care of them. Eliminate the others because you do not have resources to take care of them. The trash, dead trees and abuse enforcement never keeps up! any and all Better answer next year, haven’t used any garbage container? Cove H smells, literally, from the trash dumpster. none - not until economy recovers nothing remove poison ivy Resand Beach area, more tables at beach Review needs after the well project is completed. RL 13= tennis/B.B. comb courts double; RL10=sand volleyball court & horseshoe; SL1=tennis/B.B. comb courts double. No comment/recommendations # TIMES 71 74 62 45 24 23 24 21 21 7 7 3 2 2 2 2 2 8 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 180 6. The survey requested recommendations for the entryway for the clubhouse and most of the north side of the lake, i.e. the intersection of Clubhouse Circle and Rock Bluff Road. This is the area where the sign is and flagpole was. Some suggestions were: a new sign, mulch, rocks, more bushes, plants (which type) etc. The resulting suggestions are as follows along with the number of members responding who suggested them: The most support was for a new sign with rocks and shrubs, much like it is today. A new flagpole is needed even though only 6 suggested it. ENTRYWAY IMPROVEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS New Sign Rocks Shrubs Leave as is mulch nothing maintain Flowers flagpole Lighting Plants Low Maint Stuff landscaping Widen Bench fountain Paint sign Boulders Gate/keyed entry Great Now improve looks directions trees Improved & upscale sign with more prominent landscaping. Evening lighting on sign. Should give a sense of an upscale community. Landscaping should allow minimal needs to manage. indicate clubhouse location Keep clean Lit brick wall looks cheap message board MINIMAL Mr. landscape Nautical sign no ideas No improvement required since Beaver Lake is private and that is not the only entry point to the lake. no maintenance nothing # TIMES 62 33 30 22 17 14 13 8 6 6 5 5 3 3 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ornamental grass Parking pay off debt perennials Professional landscape with perennials only Remove sign restore divided road SOMETHING status quo SURVEY update water feature no comment 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 222 7. The members were asked for recommendations for the shrub island in front of the clubhouse and whether or not we should expend funds to hire a professional landscaper to design and/or do the work. The suggestion offered in the survey for a rock garden with a flagstone path through the middle was widely accepted as the results below show. Some other ideas presented that would enhance this idea were for benches where a member could leave a meeting for a break etc. Also, as shown in paragraph 1, there was little support (11%) to hire a professional landscaper. The surveys showed a bias towards using volunteer and staff help to do the work. CLUBHOUSE ISLAND IMPROVEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS Rocks Shrubs Path Remove Flagstone Rock Garden Smaller Shrubs Maintain low maintenance plants Nothing Remove for parking Garden Benches Mulch Patio Good Idea Plants Remove gnats Tables Fountain Whatever you have funds for! use money to mow # TIMES 75 76 70 66 56 23 20 22 4 5 6 4 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Update Steps Replant remove, plant grass Read Survey!! proof input pay off debt Ornaments ornamental grasses NATURALIZING PLANTS Mr. landscape More Friendly match west landscaping just redo it - smaller shrubs, etc. - but, leave it there and maintain regularly I think the area should just be addressed and then maintained. I don't feel a lot should be spent on an area that isn't used by many members. If the association organized some events at the clubhouse we might feel different. ground cover get bids/get cost/determine upkeep No comment 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 179 8. On the north side of the clubhouse parking lot is an area which could accommodate basketball hoops. The survey asked the membership whether we should use this area for such items. The table in paragraph 1 shows that just under 24% of the members would want them. This definitely shows interest in that only 15% of the surveys returned had no comment. Since there are a lot of senior citizens living at Beaver Lake, it follows that they would probably not want basketball hoops, but the younger members would. 9. There were a number of general comments provided. These are summarized as follows: One member volunteered to donate a picnic table so special kudos and appreciation to the family who offered this to the Association. GENERAL REMARKS You must plan this with guaranteed resources, not volunteers. You cannot keep up with Volunteers that MAY or MAY NOT be there! Example trash pickup! A. If you want to really make the place beautiful reduce our common areas to a a number we can truly keep up beautiful. 1. Clubhouse. 1. Boat ramp. 3. Dam. 2 or 3 access areas! Get rid of the rest of the taxes we pay on them! B. enforce laws on property owners that have junk all over their lots and cars that do not move! Would Univ or state offer free or low cost consulting for a water friendly landscaping plan we still need another Loading Ramp & Parking area, Keep ATV's off Nature Trail volunteer insurance? USE VOLUNTEERS Use summer help There was such a fuss a while back about our debt, now seems to be the wrong time to be spending extra on beautification vs maintenance. # TIMES 1 1 1 1 2 3 1 The thing I would most like to see for improvement is street lights. (Just a suggestions) (around the whole lake) The dock on AL9 is not the property owners adjacent to it. That dock was put in by a B lot owner 18 or so years ago for B&C lot owners to park their boats to run to their houses etc. Not for overnight parking or hoarding of the access lot! If a small dock was put in the middle of lot it would get used a lot I think but no overnight parking should be allowed. Also a lot of the other lots have so much large chunks of concrete they cannot be utilized. street lights sex, alc, drugs AL7 SELL LOTS FOR WELL PROJECT sell access lots Recommend Matt Boice with Mulhuls 402-616-2023 for Island design provide beer! PICKUP LITTER Only docks mow lots better MENTION PRIVATE COMMUNITY MAINTENANCE, OBEY RULES Let ladies do it Keep Lake Full I would like to make a comment about Karen Killian's Beach Party that was held over at the Clubhouse/beach area. It was a very good turnout, but experienced some bad weather. I was shocked that the upstairs of the clubhouse was not opened up to the members who attended and donated to Murray Fire Dept. Instead everyone was forced to get soaked or go home which I found to be quite disappointing. I though for sure it would be opened up especially because there were a lot of kids there. I have reviewed the lots on the website. In my opinion there are too many access lots and the cost to upkeep is expensive. Unless I am missing something, my thought would be to sell some lots which would create revenue in a lump sum, utility hook up, and on going association fees. A few of these lots are prime water locations which would generate much money. Not sure if this will be viewed, but I will list the lots and aa short opinion. If further information is needed, please contact me @ 235-2291. AL1=sell; AL2-AL7=fishing pond I always see people, but not sure I would update. AL8=sell, maybe give opportunity to owner to north or south, may want to dig out for their boat; AL9=sell, AL335=keep/improve clean up; AL 453,454,462 = sell; AL 635 keep/improve clean up; AL719=sell;AL906=sell; AL968=not sure on this one; AL1030B=keep & maintain silt pond; AL1059=sell; AL1229=keep/maintain. Always fishing happening here. Al1446=nice lot/keep maintain; AL1523=sell; AL1669=keep/maintain; AL1860=sell or keep & maintain, nice lot; AL2100, 2101=boat launch; Block C=sell; Block F=Keep/maintain; Block G= keep/maintain/ Silt Pond. CL14=keep/maintain, nice lot. CL15=sell; RL3=keep/maintain; RL6=keep/maintain; RL7=Great for park; RL8=keep maintain; RL10=keep maintain; RL11=keep maintain, lots of fishing; RL12=keep maintain; SU7=keep maintain. Grills/picnic tables & trashcans should be sufficient on most lots. On a couple I would recommend another bathroom or portapotty for summer usage, many of the people who use lake with no access to facilities will either go in lake or who knows where. By making some of these lots more enjoyable should increase lots sales off the water and would or should increase utility fee hookups (possibly). Hoops on S side Golf Cart/ATV Access, Need civic committee Golf Cart/ATV Access Get Estimates for all and get vote fence far from roadway Do Well Project 1 1 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 design contest Clubhouse needs better cooling CL14 would be a great spot for playground equipment 2nd Boat Ramp 1 1 1 1 *I would volunteer to check IDs and lot names of people who use our facilities. There are TOO many kids just being dropped off at the clubhouse that don't even belong to B.Lake. Too many parents aren't supervising. My husband and I don't even like to go to the pool because it's unsupervised, kids are unruly, and there's too many "visitors." It's a disaster just waiting to happen. *We have an 8' treated picnic table that I will donate if it can be placed on AL335. It would also be great if we had a place to tie up our boat w/out bothering our neighbors - This A/lot is great for us & new neighbors but the rip-rap makes it hard to use. Allen Tegtmeier, 360 1 1 10. Surprisingly, there were 84 people volunteering to help with Beaver Lake beautification. This shows a lot of self help interest and the Property Committee will take advantage of this when it comes time. 11. Recommendations to the Board based on this survey are as follows: a. Put a portable toilet on RL 10 and perhaps CL 14 during the spring, summer, and fall. Plan for bathrooms on one of these lots. There was a lot of support for bathrooms. b. Do a better job of what we do now such as mowing, shoreline brush removal, removal of dead trees and poison ivy. c. Trim the overgrown trees on some of the lots to provide better access to the lots. d. Better off-street parking for high use access lots. e. Ask a volunteer to design a new island in front of the clubhouse using a rock garden, benches, pathway, and some low maintenance, drought resistant shrubs. Have the staff prepare the site and query the local landscaping vendors for ideas and support—perhaps a discount for the plants etc. in exchange for a sign in the office area and free website advertising. f. Update the Beaver Lake sign at the entryway. i.e. new paint, perhaps a cutout of a boat etc. g. Install benches on the access lots for the most used lots outlined in paragraph 2 above. Place close to the lake for fishing. i. Add/update/replace docks, seawalls, and landings on most used lots (para 2). Maintain those already in existence on other lots around the lake according to the Access Lot Summary. h. Clean up and replace as necessary new picnic tables and grills. Consider adding new tables on lots outlined in paragraph 2. i. Keep RL7 as a playground type area. Fix and maintain the equipment already there and perhaps add a few items as funds permit. Prepare a small area for parking and remove the signs restricting vehicles. j. Hold a fund raiser of some sort to get funds for access lot improvements, playground equipment etc. (not indicated in the survey but a good idea just the same). k. Add signs identifying the access lot on both the lake and road sides of the lot if not already there. l. Coordinate with the volunteers to see if they could do self help projects this year and authorize the Property Committee, Ladies’ Auxiliary, and Nature Club to organize and plan to get them done. m. Add more trashcans to the most used lots. n. Install or fix a basketball hoop at the north side of the clubhouse parking area. Just sink a power pole with a backboard and hoop. Keep it cheap. Could paint court markings on the asphalt as needed. o. Install a new, lighted, flagpole and flag. Not much mention in the survey, but still needed. Property Committee