NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 1 of 13 Assessment Schedule – 2012 Classical Studies: Explain a work or works of classical art (90512) Assessment Criteria Achievement The candidate explains the work or works of art by identifying, describing, clarifying, explaining and / or interpreting artistic features. The candidate provides a general explanation of artistic features. Knowledge and interpretation are at a basic level, and specific detail may be lacking. One or more parts of the question are underdeveloped or omitted. Achievement with Merit Achievement with Excellence The candidate analyses the works of art by discussing methodically and demonstrating understanding of artistic features. The candidate analyses the works of art in detail by discussing methodically and demonstrating an informed understanding of artistic features. The candidate incorporates an analytical element in the answer based on sound knowledge of the art works. Most parts of the question are covered, but treatment may be unbalanced. Relevant supporting evidence is present, but may not be consistently provided. The candidate’s answers are focused and analytical. They are based on a thorough knowledge of the art works themselves, as well as the historical and artistic context in which they were produced. All parts of the question are answered and most in depth. Supporting evidence is relevant, accurate and consistently provided. NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 2 of 13 Evidence Statement Candidate chooses TWO questions from ONE topic. A holistic judgement on the level of achievement attained will be made over the two questions. GREEK VASE PAINTING – Question One Analyse in detail and with supporting evidence: the mythological subject matter of the friezes shown in Reproductions A(i) and (ii) and the ways in which it reflects the function of the krater Achievement Achievement with Merit Achievement with Excellence Subject matter Subject matter Subject matter The candidate must: The candidate must: The candidate must: demonstrate some knowledge of the subject matter as it relates to both sides of the vase demonstrate a greater degree of knowledge and understanding of the subject matter, as it relates to both sides of the vase show depth of knowledge and clear understanding of the subject matter, as it relates to both sides of the vase The candidate may not discuss the subject matter. identify the main figures correctly. identify figures correctly. Eg: Discussion of the subject matter of each side of the vase may be unbalanced. Discussion of the subject matter of both sides of the vase must be consistently excellent. Eg: Eg: In Reproduction A(i), Hephaestus is taken up to Mt Olympus; He is escorted by maenads and satyrs, the followers of Dionysus. As for Merit plus more embellishment. identify some figures correctly. Reproduction A(i), the god Hephaestus rides his donkey to heaven; He is accompanied by the followers of Dionysus. Reproduction A(ii), the god Dionysus leads the procession up to heaven. No discussion of the myth. Links to the function of the krater The candidate: may respond to this part of the question, briefly, but this is not essential. Eg – A vase like this would be used for wine. Dionysus, the god of wine, is one of the main figures on this vase. Other answers possible. In Reproduction A (ii), the god Dionysus leads the procession to Mt Olympus surrounded by his followers. The myth: - Dionysus got Hephaestus drunk and escorted him to Mt Olympus, where he was forced to release his mother from the throne she was trapped in. The myth: - Hephaestus had been thrown out of Mt Olympus by his mother, Hera, because he was lame and rather ugly. Years later, Hephaestus sent his mother a golden throne in order to punish her. When he refused to release her, Dionysus, the god of wine, got him drunk and escorted him to Mt Olympus, where he was forced by Zeus to release his mother. Links to the function of the krater Links to the function of the krater The candidate must discuss links to the function of the vase: The candidate must discuss analytically and in detail. analytically in some detail Eg –This vessel is a column krater, traditionally used for mixing wine and water during a symposium. Many aspects of wine-making, wine-drinking and celebrating are shown on this vase and this links to the function of NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 3 of 13 with reference to the reproductions. the vase, for example: Eg – This is a column krater, traditionally used for mixing wine and water. Many aspects of wine-making and wine-drinking are shown on this vase, for example: The effects of drinking wine and the theme of celebration are also shown on this vase for example Dionysus managed to get Hephaestus to Mt Olympus by getting him drunk. Dionysus, the god of wine and entertainment is shown in Reproduction A (ii), carrying a wine horn/keras. Dionysus’ followers, maenads, and satyrs appear to be in a celebratory mood as if they have been drinking. (Plus examples.) Grapevines / bunches of grapes used to make wine are shown on both sides of the vase. Other answers possible. Other answers possible. Analyse in detail and with supporting evidence: the techniques used by Lydos to bring the figures of the myth to life. The candidate must provide at least one example from each side of the vase. Eg: The painter brings this myth to life by showing the followers of Dionysus with raised arms and feet lifted off the ground, as if they are dancing. Other answers possible. The candidate must: The candidate must: demonstrate a greater degree of knowledge and understanding show depth of knowledge and understanding discuss analytically and in some detail how Lydos brings this myth to life provide excellent evidence from both sides of the vase. provide more evidence from both sides of the vase. Examples must be specific and clear not general (eg “the maenads have raised arms” is far too general). Eg: Lydos has used a variety of methods to bring this myth to life: - Figures are depicted in a variety of poses; for example, in A (i), the maenad in front of the donkey looks back, whereas the satyr behind the donkey has the lower part of his body in profile as if walking forward and yet the upper part of his body is twisted in a ¾ pose. - Figures use a variety of gestures; for example, in A (ii) the maenad following Dionysus has both arms raised as if she is dancing. Other answers possible. discuss analytically and in detail Eg: Lydos has included a good number of items that give a sense of revelry and / or celebration for example, on both sides of the vase there are bunches of grapes, grapevines and ivy branches. Dionysus carries his wine horn and one of the satyrs carries a wineskin. He has also used a variety of techniques to bring the painting to life – for example, he has used stippling to give the impression that the satyrs have hairy bodies and has painted the robe of Dionysus and the satyr’s wineskin red, adding an element of naturalism. Other answers possible. NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 4 of 13 GREEK VASE PAINTING – Question Two Analyse in detail and with supporting evidence: Makron’s skill in depicting drapery in the scene shown in Reproduction B(i) Achievement Achievement with Merit Achievement with Excellence The candidate must: The candidate must: The candidate must: demonstrate some knowledge of how Makron depicts drapery demonstrate knowledge and understanding of Makron’s skill in depicting drapery show depth of knowledge and clear understanding of Makron’s skill in depicting drapery provide some evidence, although it may be brief and lack specificity provide good supporting evidence, which is discussed in some detail and with specific reference to the painting. provide detailed supporting evidence, which is consistently well explained, detailed and closely linked to the paintings. Eg: Eg: Makron is a master at depicting drapery. The figures are painted close to each other yet Makron’s skill at painting drapery enables the viewer to distinguish each figure, even when their garments overlap. Makron is also skilled at adding texture to the drapery. For example, lines drawn closer together suggest that Helen’s chiton is made from fine material whereas broader lines are used for her himation to show that the fabric is thicker. Makron draws lines with amazing precision and accuracy, allowing the viewer to clearly distinguish each figure, even though the figures are drawn very closely together. For example, the precise line drawings for the himatia enable us to distinguish between Helen and Aphrodite’s himatia. the candidate may not demonstrate an awareness of the extent of Makron’s skill. Eg: Thin lines are used on the women’s clothing to show that the fabric is made from fine materials. The wide lines on the cloaks show that they are made from thick material – for example, Helen’s cloak. The hemlines are uneven and show zig-zagging. Other answers possible. Other answers possible. Makron is also skilled at adding texture to the drapery. For example, lines drawn closer together suggest that Helen’s chiton is made from fine material, whereas broader lines are used for her himation to show that the fabric is thicker. Also, Makron has given the chitones a three dimensional effect by adding dilute slip. Makron also uses less angular zigzags than his predecessors to indicate the folds of cloaks. On Paris’ cloak, for example, lines curve, and, in the section between his legs, end in hooks. Other answers possible. Analyse in detail and with supporting evidence: the compositional similarities between the friezes shown in Reproductions B(i) and B(ii). NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 5 of 13 The candidate must: The candidate must: The candidate must: briefly discuss composition and provide some evidence demonstrate a greater degree of knowledge and understanding show depth of knowledge and understanding discuss the compositional similarities in some detail provide excellent evidence from both sides of the vase. Eg: discuss analytically Both sides of the vase are similar as Makron has painted one main group of figures and framed it by a single figure on either side – for example, on side A there are Paris, Helen and one other woman are framed by Aeneas and another woman. provide good supporting evidence from both sides. Other answers possible. discuss analytically and in detail Eg: Eg: As for Merit plus: The composition on both sides of the vase is beautifully balanced as Makron has painted a central group of figures and framed it by a single figure on either side to form a rectangle – for example on side A, starting from the left, there are Paris, Helen and Aphrodite framed by Aeneas on the left and Peitho on the right. On side B, the central group of Helen and her two attendants, Kriseis and Aphrodite, is framed by Menelaus on the right and Kriseus on the left. Another similarity in the composition is how the pose of Paris on side A is mimicked by the pose of Helen on side B of the vase. For example, both Paris and Helen have their legs spread wide apart; the body is painted in a ¾ pose yet the head is in profile and looking back. Another similarity is how the placement and pose of Paris on side A is mimicked by the pose of Helen on side B of the vase. For example, both Paris and Helen look back as they walk away. Other answers possible. Similarly, the pose of the female attendants on side A mimics the pose of the female attendants on side B. On both sides, the women’s pose is static and Aphrodite has an arm extended, whereas Peitho (on side A) and Kriseis (on side B) lift up a hand elegantly. Other answers possible. NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 6 of 13 GREEK VASE PAINTING – Question Three Analyse in detail with supporting evidence: the mythological subject matter of the scene shown in Reproductions C(i) and (ii) and the ways in which the poses of the two heroes reflect this subject matter the ways in which the Berlin Painter directs the viewer’s attention to this figural scene and, in particular, to the two heroes. Achievement Achievement with Merit Achievement with Excellence Legendary context Legendary context Legendary context The candidate must: The candidate must: The candidate must: demonstrate some knowledge of the mythological context demonstrate a greater degree of knowledge and understanding of the mythological context show depth of knowledge and understanding identify some of the figures correctly identify the main figures correctly discuss briefly how the pose of at least one of the heroes is linked to this context. discuss how the pose is linked to the context analytically, in some detail and with reference to the reproductions. Eg: This frieze shows the death of the Trojan prince Hektor at the hands of the Greek hero Achilles. Achilles’ body leans towards Hektor and his arm holding the spear is stretched out as if he is ready to thrust it into Hektor. Hektor stumbles back as if he is about to fall. Other answers possible. Eg: This scene takes place during the Trojan War and it shows the death of the Trojan prince Hektor at the hands of the Greek hero Achilles. The two heroes are watched by their patron deities, Athena on the left and Apollo on the right. The pose of the two men suggests that Achilles is the aggressor and Hektor is about to be defeated. For example: Achilles - his body leans towards Hektor as he gets ready to deliver the fatal blow - his legs move forward, showing that he is moving closer to Hektor - the arm in which he holds his spear is stretched out behind him as if he is ready to thrust it into Hektor’s leg. Hektor - his body leans back, his back is curved and his knee is bent as if stumbling back. Other answers possible. discuss all aspects of the question analytically and in detail provide excellent evidence. Eg – As for Merit PLUS: Some reference to why Achilles wants to kill Hector OR Apollo’s arrow hints at the later demise of Paris OR the scene takes place outside the walls of Troy OR Achilles challenged Hektor to a duel AND Achilles’ legs move forward, heel raised off the ground, showing that he is moving closer to Hektor. Athena stands behind Achilles, arm stretched out in front of her as if to encourage Achilles. Apollo, on the other side, walks away from Hektor and as he does so looks back and waves an arm as if he is waving farewell. Other answers possible. NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 7 of 13 Analyse in detail and with supporting evidence: the ways in which the Berlin Painter directs the viewer’s attention to the figural scene and, in particular, to the two heroes. The candidate must: The candidate must: The candidate must: respond briefly to both parts of the question OR respond to one part of the question in some detail. demonstrate a greater degree of knowledge and understanding show depth of knowledge and understanding Eg: discuss in some detail and analytically both parts of the question even though they focus more heavily on one part of the question. provide excellent evidence for both parts of the question. The Berlin Painter has painted the whole vase black so the figural scene stands out. link their answer to the painting. The two heroes are placed in the middle of the frieze, therefore the viewer’s attention is focused on them. Eg: Other answers possible. The viewer’s attention is easily directed to the figural scene because: this is the only figural scene on the vase the figural scene is painted in red against a black background. The viewer’s attention is directed to the two heroes because: the two heroes appear to be positioned closer to the viewer as if in the foreground discuss analytically and in greater detail Eg: The viewer’s attention is easily directed to the figural scene because: the rest of the vase is almost totally painted in black slip with some decoration on the base of the vase, on the handles and above the figural scene. The viewer’s attention is directed to the two heroes because: they appear to be positioned closer to the viewer as if in the foreground, whereas the two gods on either side appear to be set further back as if in the background both heroes are positioned in the centre of the frieze and their bodies are slightly larger. the bodies of the two heroes are slightly larger than those of the gods on either side. Other answers possible. Other answers possible. NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 8 of 13 ROMAN ART – Question One Analyse in detail and with supporting evidence: the mythological and allegorical subject matter of the reliefs shown in Reproductions D (i) and D(ii) Achievement Achievement with Merit Achievement with Excellence Subject matter Subject matter Subject matter The candidate must: The candidate must: The candidate must: demonstrate some knowledge of the subject matter as it relates to both reliefs OR demonstrate a greater degree of knowledge and understanding of the subject matter, as it relates to both reliefs show depth of knowledge and clear understanding of the subject matter, as it relates to both reliefs demonstrate good knowledge of the subject matter as it relates to at least ONE relief identify the main figures correctly. identify some figures correctly. Discussion of the subject matter of each side of the relief may be unbalanced or lacking in detail. Discussion of the subject matter of each relief may be unbalanced. Discussion of the subject matter of each relief must be consistently excellent. Eg: Eg: Eg: identify figures correctly. Reproduction D(i): Reproduction D(i): Reproduction D(i) – Aeneas and his son have landed in Italy and they make offerings of fruit to the gods. - Aeneas brings the shrine with the gods of Troy / his household gods to Rome - Ascanius and his friend are both wearing wreaths to show that they are about to make offerings or a sacrifice to the gods Reproduction D(ii) – Mother Earth/Tellus is shown sitting with two children on her lap. She is surrounded by vegetation and animals, and on either side of her sit two minor gods. - Ascanius makes an offering of fruit to the household gods - Aeneas covers his head with his toga to show his piety - Ascanius’ friend leads the Lavinian sow to the sacrificial altar. - inside the shrine are Penates. Other answers possible. Reproduction D(ii): - on either side of Tellus sit personifications of water on the left and wind / the sea on the right. Other answers possible. Reproduction D(ii): - the personification of water sits on a swan - in front of her, fresh water flows from a spilled jug. Other answers possible. Analyse in detail and with supporting evidence: the ways in which the mythological and allegorical reliefs of the Ara Pacis provide a vehicle for Augustan propaganda. You may refer to other reliefs from this altar in your answer. The candidate must: The candidate must: The candidate must: demonstrate some knowledge and understanding of demonstrate a greater degree of knowledge and show depth of knowledge and understanding NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 9 of 13 how the mythological and allegorical reliefs promote Augustus OR demonstrate good knowledge of how EITHER the mythological OR the allegorical reliefs promote Augustus provide some evidence. understanding of how both the mythological and allegorical reliefs promote Augustus discuss analytically and in some detail provide more evidence from both reliefs, although treatment of each relief may be unbalanced. Eg – Eg: The mythological relief connects Augustus to his great ancestor Aeneas and promotes the idea that Augustus is the second founder of the Roman empire. Eg: The allegorical relief relates to the new age of fertility and prosperity brought in by Augustus’ rule. For example, Tellus / Mother Earth and the rich vegetation symbolise fertility and prosperity. Other answers possible. The mythological relief connects Augustus to Ascanius/Iulus, the founder of the Julian line. This suggests that Augustus, like his ancestors, is a man of divine ancestry, descended from Venus’ son Aeneas. In the allegorical relief, Tellus/ Mother Earth carries two well-fed babies. This hints at the prosperity that Roman families enjoyed during the rule of Augustus. The rich vegetation and the sheep and cow sitting at her feet are also symbols of the new age of fertility and growth brought to Rome by Augustus. Other answers possible. discuss analytically and in greater detail provide excellent evidence from both reliefs may or may not refer to other reliefs. Eg – The idea that Augustus is a man of divine ancestry is also suggested in the mythological relief depicting the story of Romulus and Remus; here Augustus is connected to Mars the god of war, who was also the father of his great ancestor Romulus. In the allegorical relief, Tellus symbolises earth and the personifications sitting on either side of Tellus symbolise fresh water and wind. This suggests that the elements (earth, wind and water) are now in harmony thanks to Augustus. The idea of harmony is further emphasised by the swan, which symbolises Augustan peace. It was Augustan peace that made it possible for Rome and the empire to enjoy economic prosperity and growth. Other answers possible. NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 10 of 13 ROMAN ART – Question Two Analyse in detail and with supporting evidence: the ways in which Titus’ military success is celebrated in the two reliefs from his triumphal arch, shown in Reproductions E(i) and (ii) Achievement Achievement with Merit Achievement with Excellence The candidate must: The candidate must: The candidate must: demonstrate some knowledge of how Titus’ military success is celebrated in the two reliefs OR demonstrate good knowledge of how Titus’ military success is celebrated in at least one of the reliefs demonstrate a greater degree of knowledge and understanding of how Titus’ military success is celebrated in the two reliefs show depth of knowledge and understanding provide some evidence discussion may be lacking in detail. provide more evidence from both reliefs, although treatment of each relief may be unbalanced. Eg: Eg: South panel: South panel: - The soldiers are carrying many of the prizes that they captured in Jerusalem, such as the Menorah. North panel: - Emperor Titus rides his triumphal chariot into the forum, surrounded by his lictors. Other answers possible. discuss in some detail and analytically - Titus’ soldiers are carrying many of the prizes that they captured in the temple of Jerusalem, such as the Menorah, the trumpets of Jericho and the table of the shew bread. The weight of the plunder is so heavy that their knees are bent. This emphasises how great the victory was. North panel: - Emperor Titus rides his triumphal chariot into the forum surrounded by his lictors, who wear laurel wreaths to show that they come triumphant. Also, behind Titus stands the winged goddess Nike / Victory, holding a corona triumphalis over his head. This also symbolises Titus’ great victory. discuss analytically and in greater detail provide excellent evidence from both reliefs. Eg: South panel: - Cushions are also used on the shoulders of the soldiers to carry the huge weight of the spoils. This further emphasises the victory of Titus. North panel: - Titus’ quadriga is led by the figure of the Amazonian Virtus / the goddess Roma. This highlights Titus’ valour during the battle against Jerusalem. Other answers possible. Other answers possible. Analyse in detail and with supporting evidence: the stylistic features that create an illusion of space and depth and the overall effect that this illusion has in each of these two reliefs. The candidate must: The candidate must: The candidate must: NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 11 of 13 discuss stylistic features that create an illusion of wither space or depth and provide some evidence from at least one of the panels. have sound knowledge and understanding of the terminology and discuss both space and depth in some detail and analytically provide good evidence from both of the panels. The candidate may not have a clear understanding of the terms “space” and “depth”. As a result, their evidence may overlap. Eg: Space in the South panel: - All the figures are carved in the lower part of the frieze, whereas the upper part is relatively empty except for the menorah and the placards. Depth in the North panel: - Low relief is used to depict the lictors, whereas high relief is used to depict the horses. Other answers possible. show depth of knowledge and understanding discuss analytically and in greater detail provide excellent evidence from both panels. Eg: Eg: As for Merit plus: Space: - In both friezes, all the figures are carved in the lower part of the frieze, whereas the upper part of the frieze is relatively empty. This gives the illusion of space. For example, in the south panel only the placards and the spoils are depicted in the upper part of the frieze and this emphasises the open space up above. Depth: - An illusion of depth is achieved through the variation in carving. For example, in the frieze with Titus, low relief is used to depict the lictors placed in the background, whereas high relief is used to depict the horses, placed in the foreground. Space: - Similarly, in the north panel, the empty space is only interrupted by the fasces, carved in low relief and on the right, the figures of Titus and Victory. Depth: - The relief used to depict the horses varies even more – for example, in the centre of the frieze the horses are very deeply carved and this gives an added impression of depth. It is as if the horses are swinging around the corner. Other answers possible. Other answers possible. ROMAN ART – Question Three Analyse in detail and with supporting evidence: the ways in which the design and decoration of the temple incorporates features of Eastern origin as well as Graeco-Roman elements Achievement Achievement with Merit Achievement with Excellence The candidate must: The candidate must: The candidate must: demonstrate some knowledge of how the design and / or decoration of the temple incorporates Eastern and Graeco-Roman elements demonstrate a greater degree of knowledge and understanding of how the design and / or decoration of the temple incorporates Eastern and GraecoRoman features show depth of knowledge and clear understanding of how the design and / or decoration of the temple incorporates Eastern and Graeco-Roman features OR demonstrate good knowledge of how the design and / or decoration of the temple incorporates any TWO of the following Eastern or Greek or Roman elements discuss analytically and in some detail provide good evidence provide excellent evidence. Discussion of the different features must be consistently excellent. NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 12 of 13 provide some evidence Discussion of the features may be unbalanced. Discussion may be lacking in detail. Eg: Design: Eastern feature: - The adyton/inner shrine is an additional shrine used for the statue of the god. Design: Greek feature: - This temple has a surrounding colonnade. Design: Roman feature: - The temple is approached from the front. Other answers possible. Eg: Eg: As for Merit plus: Design: Eastern feature: Design: Eastern feature: - The inner shrine or adyton, is an additional shrine usually found in Eastern temples. It was used for the cult statue of the god, which was kept under a canopy. This adds to the mysticism surrounding eastern religions. Design and decoration: Greek feature: - The temple of Bacchus has a peristyle or peripteral colonnade, typically found in Greek temples. As a result, the exterior of the temple has the same appearance all round. - In addition, the adyton was placed on a higher level than the cella and the statue was placed high up on a podium, as if to elevate the cult god even higher. Design and decoration: Greek feature: - The colonnade has unfluted Corinthian columns. This is also a Greek feature but used more in Roman than Classical architecture. Other answers possible. Other answers possible. Analyse in detail and with supporting evidence: the features of the interior of the cella including the adyton that might inspire awe in its devotees. The candidate must: The candidate must: The candidate must: demonstrate some degree of knowledge and understanding demonstrate a greater degree of knowledge and understanding show depth of knowledge and understanding provide some evidence. discuss features in some detail and analytically provide consistently excellent evidence. provide very good supporting evidence. Eg: One feature that would inspire awe is the colonnade that lines the walls of the cella. The columns are big and in the Corinthian style; the size and design of the columns makes them awe-inspiring. Other answers possible. discuss analytically and in great detail Eg: Eg: One of the features that would have inspired awe in the devotees is the colonnade that lines the walls of the cella. The columns are fluted and have Corinthian capitals. The elaborate design of these capitals would have added to the beauty of the temple and created a sense of wonder in worshippers. In addition, the columns are set on pedestal bases that sit on three shallow stone steps; this feature would have made the columns seem higher and enhanced the magnificence of the colonnade. One of the features that would have inspired awe in the devotees is the colonnade that lines the walls of the cella. The columns are fluted and have Corinthian capitals. The elaborate acanthus design of these capitals complements the fluting and adds to the beauty of the temple, thus making it awe-inspiring. In addition, the columns are set on pedestal bases that sit on three shallow stone steps; this feature would have made the columns seem higher and enhanced the magnificence of the colonnade. Another interesting architectural detail that added to the beauty of the colonnade involved setting the columns against NCEA Level 3 Classical Studies (90512) 2012 — page 13 of 13 a series of piers; this arrangement added extra depth to the colonnade and gave the columns greater prominence. Also, the added depth would have created a play of light and shadow / chiaroscuro, when the huge door to the cella was open. Other answers possible. Other answers possible. Judgement Statement Achievement Achievement with Merit Achievement with Excellence A M E