Scaling the Electromagnetic Spectrum David W. Rhyne, Educator, MathScience Innovation Center Developed with funding from the MathScience Innovation Center. Adapted from Jones, Gail, Taylor, Amy & Falvo, Michael. (2009). Screening My Calls: Scale and the Electromagnetic Spectrum. Extreme Science: From Nano to Galactic. (pp. 293-303). NSTA Press. Major Understanding The electromagnetic (EM) spectrum delineates the most significant energy in the Universe. All this energy comes to us in the same form, and the differences are defined solely by scale. The EM spectrum wavelengths range from the macro scale that we live in through the familiar micro scale and the less familiar nano scale to the atomic and pico scale. Understand that scale allows us to use vital components of the EM spectrum while protecting ourselves from unwanted intrusions or even danger. Grade/Subject Grade 6 Science, Physical Science, Technology, Physics Objectives Explain the relationships between wavelength, frequency and energy in the EM spectrum. Investigate how Faraday cages block or screen wavelengths of the EM spectrum. Use scientific notation to define the scale of the EM spectrum. Explain why “Size and Scale” is the first of the Big Ideas of Nanoscale Science and Engineering. Time Background: Big Ideas of Nanoscale Science and Technology Properties of the EM Spectrum Scale Activity: Wave Properties Demonstration: Faraday Cages Activity: Control Experiments Activity: Screening Signals Activity: Determine Wavelengths Activity: Building Faraday Cage Demonstration: Share Closure Practice Assessments Scaling the Electromagnetic Spectrum http://MathInScience.info 5 min 10 min 10 min 5 min 10 min 10 min 10 min 15 min 5 min 2 min Variable Variable © MathScience Innovation Center, 2012 Materials For the class: Computer Projector PowerPoint AM/FM portable radio Prebuilt Faraday cage using wish mesh (optional) For each group of students: Cell phone (optional) and/or small radio Aluminum foil Aluminum screening material Aluminum tape Small boxes (large enough to hold cell phone or small radio) Scissors Ruler State and National Correlations Virginia Standards of Learning: 2010 Science (PS.6, PS.9, PH.8, PH.9, PH.12); 2009 Math (6.5, 7.1, 8.1). National Science Education Standards: Physical Science: Transfer of Energy; Science in Personal and Social Perspectives: Science and Technology in Society NCTM Standards: Understand appropriate use of exponential and scientific notation. Develop understanding of very large and small numbers. Instructional Strategies 1. Background on Big Ideas of Nanoscience and Technology 1.1. Discuss size and scale in the context of the Big Ideas (PowerPoint Slides 1-4). Due to its nature, the Electromagnetic (EM) Spectrum serves as an ideal medium to discuss scale and its effect on properties. 1.2. Introduce the nature of the EM scale with the video What the Heck is Light, which is linked on Slide 5. 2. General Properties of the EM Spectrum 2.1. Use Slides 6-8 to discuss properties of the EM Spectrum focusing on wave properties and wavelength. Slide 6 shows wavelength and energy using scientific notation and illustrates the inverse relationship between these two features. Common names for waves are at the bottom. 2.2. Visible light is just outside the nanoscale (generally defined as 1100nm) (Slide 7), while X-rays are at the bottom of the scale—note the increasing power as wavelength gets shorter (Slides 7-8). Scaling the Electromagnetic Spectrum http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2012 Practice 3. Activity: Wave Properties of Light 3.1. Slide 9 links to an applet at http://phet.colorado.edu/sims/wave-on-astring/wave-on-a-string_en.html. Use the applet to complete the “Activity: Wave Properties.” This activity can be completed as a whole class or small group activity (provided students have computers with Internet access). 3.2. Students complete Questions 1 and 2 on the Activity Sheet. 3.3. Use Slides 10-13 to review wave properties of light and point out the dual (particle) nature of light with photons. Slide 11 illustrates the photoelectric effect which was used to prove the particle nature of light. Slide 12 illustrates the relationship between electricity and magnetism in the EM Spectrum. Optical properties of some substances can be very different based just on scale. Slide 13 shows gold particles of different sizes (within the nanoscale) suspended in solution. Note the different colors (optical properties) illustrating how wavelengths of visible light are refracted (bent) differently by the different size particles. A similar phenomenon involving oxygen and nitrogen molecules explains why the sky is blue. 4. Blocking Out Signals: Faraday Cages 4.1. Show video linked in the picture on Slide 14 demonstrating a grounded Faraday cage under high voltage. Video is at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bZwlD-Z0zmE. The link to the text in the same slide shows an airplane being struck by lightning (http:/www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IRfbC0RHsY). 4.2. Use Slide 15 to discuss how Faraday cages, first invented by Michael Faraday in 1836, work. Made from conducting material cages divert EM charges to the outside, making the cage a hollow conductor. Inside the cage the charges are cancelled, depending on the effectiveness of the conducting material. 5. Activity: Control Experiments 5.1. Slide 16 outlines materials needed for several experiments to follow. These materials can vary depending on availability and student abilities. 5.2. Conduct the Control Experiment (Slide 17) outlined in Step 1 of the “Activity: Experimenting With Faraday Cages.” You can save class time by pre-wrapping the boxes (not the lids) in aluminum. If you want to reuse the boxes repeatedly, you may want to wrap a layer of polyester film (e.g., Mylar®) on top of the aluminum to protect the aluminum from tearing. Be careful to leave an exposed aluminum edge Scaling the Electromagnetic Spectrum http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2012 along the top rim of the boxes if you wrap them in polyester. 5.3. Repeat the experiment (Step 2 in “Activity: Experimenting With Faraday Cages”) (Slide 18), but this time have both the boxes and the tops wrapped so that the tops fits snuggly, making a good connection between the aluminum on the boxes and tops. 5.4. Students complete Questions 3 and 4 on the Activity Sheet. 6. Activity: Screening Out Signals (Slide 19) 6.1. Provide participants with a square foot of aluminum screening material. Precut the material to save time and wrap the edges in heavy tape (duct tape) to protect against sharp edges. Conduct Step 3 of “Activity: Experimenting With Faraday Cages.” 6.2. Students complete Question 5 on the Activity Sheet. 7. Activity: Determining Wavelength 7.1. Use Slide 20 to review the relationship between wavelength and frequency. Have the participants complete Questions 6 and 7 on the Activity Sheet. 7.2. Shorter wavelengths have higher frequencies and energy and are more difficult to block. To block a signal with a Faraday cage using wire mesh, you need a mesh size about 1/10th the wavelength. Higher conductive materials (e.g., copper) work best. 8. Activity: Building a Faraday Cage 8.1. Conduct Step 4 in the “Activity: Experimenting With Faraday Cages” (Slides 22- 23). Answer Question 8 on the Activity Sheet. Closure Discuss results of experiments (Slide 23). Discuss why understanding wavelength and frequency matters. Point out locations where wireless equipment will not work (Slide 24). Note the increasing need for electronic security measures to protect against theft (financial and personal information, national security). Point out that space weather (radiation from the sun) can create electronic challenges and beautiful aurora borealis and can be dangerous in space travel. Electromagnetic pulse (EMP) is being studied as a weapon to knock out an enemy’s electronic signals and command structure. Extensions 1. Faraday Cages. Have students design and build their own Faraday cages. Several designs can be found on the Internet. Have them explain what materials would make the best cages. Scaling the Electromagnetic Spectrum http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2012 2. Frequency Allocations. Have students conduct Internet research on government frequency allocations. Explain why the government allocates frequencies. How do allocations in the U.S. differ from other countries or regions. Assessment Sample items are provided for use in checking students’ understanding. Experimenting with Wavelength and Faraday Cages Solution Sheet Paper Pencil Assessment Product and Rubric The following table shows how the assessment items are related to specific objectives. Objective PaperPencil Test Explain the relationships between wavelength, frequency and energy in the EM spectrum. 4,5,8,9 Investigate how Faraday cages block or screen wavelengths of the EM spectrum. 6,7,8 Use scientific notation to define the scale of the EM spectrum. 2 Explain why “Size and Scale” is the first of the Big Ideas of Nanoscale Science and Engineering. 1,3 Major Understanding Teaching Tips Product/ Performance Project and Rubric Student 1. Some tips about the materials used in this lesson: Any container made with good conductive material can serve as a Faraday cage/box. Boxes wrapped in aluminum foil can be protected from wear and tear by adding a layer of Mylar® plastic. Aluminum foil may need to be replaced around boxes periodically due to wear and tear. 2. Where do we get the supplies: Scaling the Electromagnetic Spectrum http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2012 Portable AM/FM radios are readily available at reasonable prices on many websites. Boxes large enough to hold radios are found at craft stores. Materials to build a Faraday cage can be found at local hardware stores. 3. What are the answers to the Paper/Pencil Test? 1. e 2. b 3. b 4. b 5. c 6. a 7. a 8. b 9. a References Building a Faraday Cage – Why and How Visit this site for background on Faraday cages and how to build them. http://snallabolaget.com/?page_id=1102 Interactive Simulations, University of Colorado Visit this site for a variety of computer simulations, including “Wave-on-aString” used in this lesson. http://phet.colorado.edu/en/simulation/wave-on-a-string MathScience Innovation Center Information on educational programs available to students, teachers and school divisions and procedures for registering for programs. http://www.msinnovation.info MathScience Innovation Center: On-Line Educational Programs Learn through on-line virtual classrooms, web-based lessons, and on-line courses. Access proven lesson plans and instructional modules. http://mathinscience.info National Science Teachers Association Jones, Gail, Taylor, Amy & Falvo, Michael. (2009). Screening My Calls: Scale and the Electromagnetic Spectrum. Extreme Science: From Nano to Galactic. (pp. 293-303). NSTA Press. This book focuses on scale from the very large to the very small, the importance of scale in life and how to incorporate scale in teaching. Stevens, Shawn, Sutherland, LeeAnn & Krajcik, Joseph. (2009). The Big Ideas of Nanoscale Science and Engineering: A Guidebook for Secondary Teachers. NSTA Press. This book is a guide for secondary teachers incorporating nanoscale science and engineering into the classroom. http://www.nsta.org/recommends/ Scaling the Electromagnetic Spectrum http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2012 YouTube Search for brief video clips on a variety of topics, including “What the Heck is Light” and Faraday cages. http://www.youtube.com Scaling the Electromagnetic Spectrum http://MathInScience.info © MathScience Innovation Center, 2012