10 Grammar Rules Every Teacher Should Know Judy Baker Antioch University Seattle Washington Top Ten Grammar Rules 2 This guide is not protected by copyright. It is the author’s intention that it be reproduced, in whole or in part, wherever and whenever educators and educators-to-be find it useful to do so. Enjoy! Top Ten Grammar Rules 3 Table of Contents Introduction Page 2 Rule # 1 Know the Parts of Speech Page 2 Rule # 2 Understand the Parts of Sentences Page 3 Rule # 3 I [is not an] Object! Page 3 Rule # 4 Use Combination Pronouns Correctly Page 5 Rule # 5 Force Your Subjects and Verbs to Agree Page 5 Rule # 6 Get Your Nouns and Pronouns to Page Agree, Too! 6 Rule # 7 Capitalize Correctly Page 7 Rule # 8 Punctuate for Meaning Page 8 Rule # 9 Stop Apostrophe Anarchy Page 9 Rule # 10 Don’t Trust Your Spellchecker Page 10 Conclusion Page 11 Top Ten Grammar Rules Self Test Self Test Answers 4 Page 12 Page 13 Introduction If we’re like most people, we react to learning grammar as if we have been exposed to the plague: we count ourselves lucky to have escaped. Once we’ve survived “grammar school,” we move on with our lives, conscious that grammar is out there, lurking. As a result, we use language cautiously. We stay on the safe paths of informal communication and avoid risky areas where grammar might catch us unawares. For teachers, though, grammar’s threat is unavoidable. Our written and spoken language is examined under a microscope for any violation of grammatical laws. Should one be found, we are labeled illiterate and unqualified to teach (regardless of our knowledge and skills). This guide is designed to be a “booster shot” against bad grammar (whose symptoms are misunderstanding, confusion and the near-fatal appearance of ignorance). Like children’s medicine, it is packaged to be as palatable as possible. Take once before teaching—in small doses Top Ten Grammar Rules 5 according to your tolerance; thereafter, on an as-needed basis. RULE #1 KNOW THE PARTS OF SPEECH Picture a car. It moves on a road. The car is red, and it moves quickly. In this image you’ve got all the parts of speech: The car is your noun—it is the thing that you are discussing. It moves—that’s the verb, the action the noun takes. The car is red—red is an adjective describing the noun. The red car moves quickly—this is an adverb modifying the verb. The red car moves quickly on the road—“on the road” is a prepositional phrase, consisting of a preposition (on) and its object (the road). A prepositional phrase locates the noun and verb. Add conjunctions (connecting words like “and” and “but”) and articles (a, an, the) and you’ve got all the building blocks of language. Try your own visualization. Do you see how the parts work together to complete the image? Now when you need to specify a word in a sentence, you can define its function by knowing its part of speech. You’ve won half the battle! Top Ten Grammar Rules 6 RULE #2 UNDERSTAND PARTS OF SENTENCES Sentences, too, have parts: subjects, predicates, clauses and objects. These, too, are related to functions: The subject is the primary “noun” segment of the sentence. It tells us what is being discussed. The predicate is the primary “verb” segment. It tells us what the subject is doing. Objects are nouns other than the subject which are acted upon by verbs or prepositions. They tell us what is being affected by the subject and verb. Clauses are sentence fragments included to expand the meaning of the sentence. (Prepositional phrases are a kind of short clause.) They tell us something about the subject or verb that is indirectly related to what’s happening in the sentence. A sentence must have at least a subject and predicate to be complete; objects and clauses are additional levels of complexity. Keeping our image in mind, here are examples: Subject The red car Predicate moves. Subject Predicate with Object Top Ten Grammar Rules 7 The quick red car Subject The red car hits a huge pothole. Predicate with Prepositional Phrase moves quickly on the road. Clause with Prepositional Phrase Subject Predicate with Object and Prepositional Phrase Moving quickly on the road, the red car huge pothole by the curb. hits a Recognizing the parts of a sentence helps us to identify common writing problems like sentence fragments (a sentence is missing either a subject or predicate) and runon sentences (a sentence with too many subjects and predicates). When you want to analyze a sentence, first break it down into the subject and predicate, then look at other elements (clauses and objects) to see if they add or detract from the meaning. Remove any parts that are superfluous or confusing—this is the key to clear writing. RULE #3 I [IS NOT AN] OBJECT! Let’s analyze one sentence closely: Top Ten Grammar Rules Predicate 8 Subject with Prepositional Phrase Object The red car a huge pothole hits by the curb. “Pothole” is the object of the verb: it is the thing affected by the action. Objects of verbs usually answer the question “what?” as in “The red car hit what?” Objects of prepositions work the same way. There are two problems with objects. The first is that not all nouns in the predicate are objects. For instance, this sentence seems to consist of a subject and predicate with an object: The red car is a fast vehicle. After all, there are two nouns and a verb in between just like our example above, right? Also, “vehicle” answers the question “what?” very nicely. So, what’s the problem? Latin is the problem. Here’s the grammatical [il]logic for why “vehicle” isn’t an object: The Latin derivative verb “to be” (is/was/has been/had been) acts like an equal sign; it indicates that a secondary noun is the same as the subject. Thus, this noun is also a subject and not an object. Other verbs, Top Ten Grammar Rules 9 on the other hand, involve the subject in an action. Thus the secondary noun is being acted upon and is an object. You’re probably wondering why anyone but Hamlet should care about this “to be” dilemma. It becomes important because of the second problem with objects: case. You can also thank Latin for this one. In Latin, you mark all nouns with a case. In English, we have only preserved cases in pronouns. Do these look familiar? who/whom she/her I/me he/him we/us they/them The first of each pair is the subject case. You use this whenever the pronoun isn’t an object. The second of each pair is—you guessed it—the object case. This is used whenever the noun is the object of a verb or of a preposition. Here’s how it works: Subject Verb Object He hit me (not He hit I—“me” is the object of a verb) Subject Verb Preposition Object Top Ten Grammar Rules 10 The car drove over her (not over she—“her” is the object of a preposition) You’ve been doing this without even knowing you were doing it, right? What messes everyone up is “to be.” Perhaps you’ve heard someone answer the phone with this sentence: This is she… Seems wrong, doesn’t it? You want to say “this is her.” But, “her” is the object form and “to be” doesn’t take an object. Thus “she” must be in the subject form. See? This rule is why you should never say: Whom is it? or Yet, it is correct to say: It is whom? You ran over whom in your car? and you report it? (WRONG!) To whom did “Whom” is an object in both these cases. Short Cut To see if “whom” is correct, try replacing it with “him.” If you’d say “he” in the sentence, it’s who. If “him” is correct, it’s whom. Don’t Top Ten Grammar Rules 11 forget the “to be” dilemma when deciding which sounds right. RULE #4 USE COMBINATION PRONOUNS CORRECTLY A quick word about those pesky combined pronouns…you know the ones: He and I vs. They and We vs. Him and Me Them and Us These are actually very simple, if you understand objects and object case (which you now do, right?). Combined pronouns follow two hard and fast rules: 1. 2. “I/We/Me/Us” ALWAYS comes second. (It’s an ego thing. After all, “ego” is a Latin word.) Combined pronouns are both in subject case if they aren’t objects. Otherwise, they are both in object case. They are NEVER in different cases (i.e., he and me, him and I or they and us are all WRONG). These routinely cause speakers and writers trouble because we don’t think in these grammatical terms (we always think of ourselves FIRST!). Once you’ve learned to identify what’s an object and what’s a subject, it’s easy! Top Ten Grammar Rules 12 Short Cut The tried-and-true way to see if your combined pronouns are correct is to drop one and see if the sentence makes sense. So: He and I spent all day in the sun. He…spent all day in the sun. (CORRECT!) She told he and I about the book. She told he… or She told I…about the book. (WRONG!) Remember, too, not to put yourself first when combining pronouns: “him and me” not “me and him.” RULE # 5 FORCE YOUR SUBJECTS AND VERBS TO AGREE When you hear “verb subject agreement” it means that the verb form in a sentence matches its subject form. Luckily for us, there are only two forms that verbs and subjects can take: singular and plural. To match, singular subjects have singular verbs and plural subjects have plural verbs. You do this unconsciously all the time: Top Ten Grammar Rules 13 He goes to the store. They go to the store. Millions watch his show. I learn many things from books. You and I (not me, mind you) get into trouble in complex sentences where the verb and subject aren’t right next to each other or where there is more than one subject (called a compound subject). For example: Subject Verb Cicely, who works with young kids, carpools 30 miles each day. Subject Verb A doctor and two lawyers from UW argue about politics the whole way. For compound subjects (like the one above), you have to do some detective work before you can determine whether you use the singular or plural form of the verb. The clue you’re looking for is the conjunction. “And” makes ALL compound subjects plural, even if they are made up of singular nouns. Thus: A butcher, a baker and a candlestick maker go merrily, merrily along. Top Ten Grammar Rules 14 Mechanics and a welder begin their strike Wednesday at noon. Should “or/nor” be the conjunction, things get a little trickier. With these the compound subject is singular if it is made up of all singular nouns. It is plural if at least one noun is plural. For instance: singular singular singular A butcher, a baker or a candlestick maker makes the girls cry. plural singular Neither the mechanics nor the welder ever leave a tip for the waitress. Short Cut As with the combined pronoun rule, the triedand-true test for verb subject agreement is to drop all but one of the nouns and see if each fits. When you have “or” and at least one plural, though, the singular nouns will sound wrong. Think of it as the plural noun(s) carrying the most weight. Thus, the verb is plural for all of the subjects. Top Ten Grammar Rules 15 RULE #6 WHILE YOU’RE AT IT, GET YOUR NOUNS AND PRONOUNS TO AGREE, TOO! If you thought it was tough to get verbs and subjects to match, you’ll really have fun getting nouns to stay on the same wavelength. The rules are the same as those for verbs. That is, singular gets singular and plural gets plural. Compound nouns that use “and” are always plural; those with “or/nor” are singular if each noun is singular, plural if at least one is plural. This is old hat to you, right? So: plural He entertained his friends from work in the study while she ignored them in the kitchen. singular singular The Board of Directors and the CEO met yesterday. We think they will announce a stock split today. plural singular The neighbors or a burglar are sneaking around outside. Should we attack them? singular & singular (leads to two separate pronouns) She submitted a proposal to John for a new office. Today, she learned that he approved it. Top Ten Grammar Rules 16 Pronoun problems often happen for the same reason that other “agreement” problems do—the sentence is complex. Yet, pronouns suffer from a modern problem, too. (Latin isn’t to blame!) When we became aware of gender issues in the 1970s, using “he” to describe anyone we didn’t specify became insensitive (e.g., “I saw someone moving around in the back of the store. He was probably looking for something.” POLITICALLY INCORRECT) To avoid using “he” we often cheat and use “they” thinking that we are being neutral. This is a nice theory, but it’s bad grammar. As obnoxious as it is, we must use “he or she” to describe this person. So: A student who has first lunch eats first. His or her fourth period comes afterwards. Although it probably seems illogical, the terms “each,” “everyone” and “every” along with “any” and “someone” should be singular, while “all” is plural. Thus: Everyone who has first lunch eats first. His or her fourth period comes afterwards. (CORRECT!) All students who have first lunch eat first. Their fourth period comes afterwards. (CORRECT!) Each student must turn in a notebook. If they don’t, they will fail. (WRONG!) Top Ten Grammar Rules 17 Each student must turn in a notebook. If he or she does not, he or she will fail. (CORRECT!) Someone’s been sitting in my chair, and they’d better watch out! (WRONG!) Someone’s been sitting in my chair, and he or she had better watch out! (CORRECT!) Every student was assigned a mentor. It is his or her job to set up meetings. (CORRECT!) Every student was assigned a mentor. It is their job to set up meetings. (WRONG!) To avoid mistakes, train yourself to use “all” when you are thinking about a group and “every” “any” or “each” when you are thinking about individuals (every one, any one and each one). Then the verbs and pronouns will coincide with your mental picture, and the correct grammar will follow. RULE #7 CAPITALIZE CAREFULLY This rule is easy (especially after the nuances of verb subject and noun pronoun agreement!). In normal writing you only capitalize proper nouns—formal names of people, places and things: Linus Torvalds, inventor of Linux, is a Finn who used to work for the largest company in Europe—Nokia. Top Ten Grammar Rules 18 Titles are capitalized only when they stand in for the name of the specific person or thing. For instance: The President landed at the airport. (“President” stands in for “Bill Clinton”) Words like airport, hospital, school, mall and store aren’t capitalized because they are used in a general sense. When we want our reader to know the specific airport, hospital, school, mall or store, we must cite its actual name: The President landed at Boeing Field then stopped by Nordstrom’s in the mall. Capitalization is important in citations (entire manuals are dedicated to these—check out the MLA handbook for humanities and the APA manual for sciences). Capitalization also highlights titles, subtitles and labels in texts. For these uses, you are free to choose whatever style you like, provided you are consistent and clear throughout the text. There is one important caveat for capitalization. Capitalizing words in regular text for emphasis isn’t good style, it’s bad grammar. If you’d like to show inflection by marking a particular word (as in the previous sentence), use Top Ten Grammar Rules 19 italics, underlining, bold or—if the word(s) carries the utmost importance—use all capital letters (referred to as ALL CAPS). If you simply capitalize the first letter of a word, you give the reader the impression that it is a title or formal name, which can be very confusing. Compare: I want every student to know These Rules. (WRONG!) I want every student to know these rules. (CORRECT!) I want every student to know these rules. (CORRECT!) I want every student to know these rules. (CORRECT!) I want every student to know THESE RULES. (CORRECT!) I want every student to know THESE RULES. (OVERKILL!) RULE #8 PUNCTUATE FOR MEANING We all know that a period ends a sentence. What about the other punctuation marks: ; - -- () and : ? Here’s how they work: Top Ten Grammar Rules 20 Semicolons connect short sentences; they do it easily. Hyphens connect easy-to-misunderstand word phrases. They also join two segments of a typeset word that is broken up because of space. If you come across a dash—and you read what it says—you learn relevant information about the main sentence. A sentence that includes parentheses (like this) adds an idea that isn’t necessary for understanding. Colons point to a number of things: a list of items, a response to the main sentence or other information directly responsive to the main sentence. Entire books are written on the comma. In this guide, we’ll narrow things down to only 5 rules. 1. Commas separate words or phrases in a series of at least 3. Two styles are acceptable for their use: Top Ten Grammar Rules 21 a comma before the conjunction (1, 2, and 3) and no comma before the conjunction (1, 2 and 3). Commas NEVER follow the conjunction in a series (1, 2, and, 3—WRONG!). You should choose your style and keep consistent within a text. Examples are: Butchers, bakers and candlestick makers are funny. Going to the beach, getting a tan, and soaking up the sea air are my goals. 2. Commas are used in dates that have at least 3 elements; they also follow dates with at least 3 elements. (See a pattern here?) So: I was born January 5, 1963, in a town called Hope. I was born in January 1963 in a town called Hope. 3. Commas succeed introductions and precede extensions to a sentence. As in: However, it’s hard to say who’s right. You’re lying, aren’t you? 4. A commas should not separate: a subject and its predicate Top Ten Grammar Rules 22 a verb and its object a preposition and its object However, you will find commas that come between these. To be correct, these must separate elements in a series or set off an entire clause. For instance: Subject Predicate Going to the beach, getting a tan, and soaking up the sea air are my goals. Verb Objects of the Verb I called two stores, a warehouse and a salon to find the shampoo I wanted. Preposition She went to Minnesota. Subject Predicate Objects of the Preposition Michigan, Illinois, and Clause The woman, a stunning blonde, walked right up to the police chief. Top Ten Grammar Rules 23 In general, to use commas correctly you must forget the old rule that commas go wherever you pause. Instead, use them to separate words and phrases so that the sentence makes more sense. If you follow the rules above and you’re still not sure where your commas go, decide if your sentence is too complex. It’s better to break it up than to rely on punctuation to make it clear. RULE #9 STOP APOSTROPHE ANARCHY The apostrophe [ ’ ]serves two functions: it marks contractions (don’t, can’t, won’t, didn’t, etc.) and added with an “s” it identifies possession. Possession is how we refer to the relationship between two nouns, one of which “belongs to” (possesses) the other. The owner-noun is possessive. Examples are: Nobody’s fault (the fault belongs to no one) New Year’s Eve (the eve of the new year) a dog’s bite (the bite of a dog) Apostrophes NEVER come before “s” to make a noun plural, and they NEVER occur with a verb. Thus: An onion’s smell is strong. Onions in the sun smell strongest. Top Ten Grammar Rules 24 If you smell onions, you cry and your nose runs. You’ve probably come across words that end with an apostrophe. These are possessive nouns whose last letter is “s” or “z” (like physics, ethics, Charles and Liz) or are nouns that are both plural (with the “s” on the end) and possessive (with an apostrophe). For example: Physics’ heroes are not well known. (the heroes of physics) Liz’ bookbag is still here. (the bookbag belongs to Liz) Students’ parents are welcome to attend. (the parents of students) It is also acceptable to show possession for nouns ending in “s” or “z” with the usual ‘s added on: Physics’s heroes are not well known. (the heroes of physics) Students’s parents are welcome to attend. (the parents of students) As with all options for rules, you should choose one of the two styles and be consistent in your text. Short Cut Top Ten Grammar Rules 25 To determine whether something is possessive or not, try a reverse question. Take the word that follows it and say “whose is it?” The answer word is possessive, and it should get an apostrophe. For example: Students’ parents are welcome to attend. Whose parents are welcome to attend? The students’ parents are. Onions in the sun smell strongest. “In” doesn’t belong to anyone, so “onions” isn’t possessive. Walla Wallas are the country’s favorite onion. Whose favorite onion are Walla Wallas? The country’s. Having said all that, let me explain the one exception to the apostrophe rules: the word “it.” Someone somewhere decided that “it’s” couldn’t represent both “it is” and possessive it. So he or she decided that “its” would be the possessive form. Instead of clearing up confusion, this exception causes it. These days it’s rare to see “its” or “it’s” used correctly. Here’s the right way: Look, it’s a black labrador retriever! (it is a black lab) Top Ten Grammar Rules 26 I think its name is Barney. (the name of it is Barney) Short Cut To check your its/it’s form, replace it with “it is.” If the sentence makes sense, write “it’s.” If the sentence doesn’t, write “its.” Also, “its” answers the question “whose is it?” above. RULE #10 DON’T TRUST YOUR SPELLCHECKER They didn’t teach this rule back in grammar school (at least my generation). It is well known that spellcheckers don’t catch everything (their/there, for instance, or to/too/two). Unfortunately, when it comes to grammar, spellcheckers often “correct” what isn’t wrong. This is almost always the case with possessives. Rarely does a spellchecker recognize that one of its words with an ’s added is spelled correctly. Instead, it might suggest that you use the plural form (with just an “s,” no apostrophe). Don’t be fooled into uncorrecting your possessives. Simply double check the spelling of the regular word (there are things called dictionaries that can help you do this) and triple check that you’re using the possessive correctly. Finally, rest assured that you are smarter than your computer—at least for a while. Top Ten Grammar Rules 27 Besides possessives, two other apostrophe constructions often confuse computers (and writers, too!). They are: your/you’re and who’s/whose “Your” means “belonging to you.” It is the possessive form of “you.” “You’re” is a contraction for “you are.” So: You’re a mean one, Mr. Grinch. (You are a mean one) Your heart is made of coal. (the heart belonging to you) “Whose” means “belonging to the person mentioned before” as in: The Grinch, whose heart was made of steel, stole Christmas. (the heart of the Grinch) “Who’s” is a contraction for “who is” as in: Who’s that masked man? (who is he?) Short Cut Like “it’s” “you’re” and “who’s” can be replaced with the full form, “you are” and “who is,” respectively. If the full form doesn’t Top Ten Grammar Rules 28 make sense in the sentence, the correct spelling is “your” or “whose.” And—you probably guessed this was coming—“your” answers the question “whose is it?” and “whose” is the very question that proves possession in the first place. Conclusion Ouch!—you are now inoculated against bad grammar. You understand why things are right when they’re right and wrong when they’re wrong. You can address your administrators, write letters to your students’ parents and even correct your students’ grammar mistakes without trepidation. Before you ride off into the grammatical sunset, though, you should know three things: 1. 2. All writers make mistakes—dumb ones!--all the time. Good writers are good editors; they reread and double check everything (and still miss some). Don’t expect that having learned the rules, you will automatically write correctly. It’s more practical to assume that now that you know the rules, you’ll catch yourself making mistakes more often. Consider yourself a success every time you do. This guide doesn’t cover everything. In order to beat the grammar bug for good, keep a writing manual by your Top Ten Grammar Rules 29 side at all times. Strunk and White, St. Martin’s and a score of other works systematically present more complex and obscure rules that you will occasionally run into (like not ending a sentence with a preposition, for instance). I like to think of these books as “protection.” Practice safe text. 3. If the axiom that you learn only 10% of what you’re taught but 90% of what you teach holds true, the best way to learn good grammar is to teach it. Go for it! Top Ten Grammar Rules 30 Self Test Rule # 1—mark the parts of speech for each word in this sentence: Renaissance instruments play on a different scale. Rule # 2—identify the subject, predicate, objects and clauses in this sentence: Without being told, we knew the answer on her mind. Rule # 3—fill in the correct pronoun “who” or “whom” in the sentence below: I wasn’t sure that Izzy ________ I called the night before would come. Rule # 4—fill in the correct pronouns “he and I” or “him and me” in this sentence: Frankie and Johnny is a song written about ________________. Rule # 5—fill the verb form “think” or “thinks” to match its subject in the sentence below: Top Ten Grammar Rules 31 Students, who are a tough audience, _______________ all lessons are boring. Rule # 6—fill in the pronoun “their” or “his or her” to match its subject in the sentence below: Any parent who wants to meet _____________ child’s teachers should attend Open House. Rule # 7—capitalize the correct words in this sentence: Does the constitution insure every american the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness? Rule # 8—add the correct () -- - ; or : to the sentence below: The best movie this year at least for me was Casablanca I saw it for the first time on video last week. —add the correct commas to the sentence below: In the end my mother her sister her sister’s boyfriend and I stayed friends or did we? Rule # 9—choose the correct word “your” or “you’re” for the blanks in this sentence: Top Ten Grammar Rules 32 I’m told that ____________ the smartest kid in class, and _____________ work is outstanding. Rule # 10—choose the correct word “its” or “it’s” for the blanks in this sentence: Leaving aside ________ obvious problems, _______ a good place to start looking. Turn the page for the answers!! Self Test Answers adjective noun verb prepositional phrase 1. Renaissance instruments play on a different scale. Clause subject and prepositional phrase 2. Without being told, we her mind. predicate with object knew the answer on 3. I wasn’t sure that Izzy whom I called the night before would come. Top Ten Grammar Rules 33 4. Frankie and Johnny is a song written about him and me. 5. Students, who are a tough audience, think all lessons are boring. 6. Any parent who wants to meet his or her child’s teachers should attend Open House. 7. Does the Constitution insure every American the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness? 8. The best movie this year (at least for me) was Casablanca; I saw it for the first time on video last week. In the end, my mother, her sister, her sister’s boyfriend, (this comma optional) and I stayed friends, or did we? 9. I’m told that you’re the smartest kid in class, and your work is outstanding. 10. Leaving aside its obvious problems, it’s a good place to start looking.