Diversity Index and Environmental Assessment

advertisement

Diversity Index and Environmental Assessment

Lab developed by Nancy Nicholson

INTRODUCTION

Scientists usually use the term “DIVERSITY” as a synonym for “variation,” especially if discussing the concept in an evolutionary context. For ecologists, use the idea of diversity in a different technical sense. They subdivide the concept as

Diversity (inventory balance of an ecosystem or subunit of an ecosystem)

Richness – number of species/kind of organism present

Evenness – the abundance of each species or kind

These two measurements are first recorded as a tally of the ecological unit (forest, lawn, stream, coral reef) under study. This tally is technically called a frequency distribution because it contains the “laundry list” of organisms in addition to their numbers. From this information, several formulae might be used to calculate a single number or value that represents the DIVERSITY INDEX. This index can be used to compare ecological units that may be of very different composition: microbial or large organisms, terrestrial or aquatic.

The Diversity Index we will use is called the Shannon-Weiner Index, symbolized by H s

.

It is relative independent of sample size and is not strongly affected by the way organisms are classified. For instance, an investigator could choose to classify the organisms in a community by food habits or growth forms or leaf shape instead of species names. In this system, a set of images on a sheet of paper can serve as a field data tally and the information coded according to image for entry into a spreadsheet for calculation of the Index value.

As you can see from the sample calculations below, Sample one has a higher diversity than Sample Two. With this information in hand, the investigator can now ask what are the observed factors that would contribute to the domination of Sample One by a single species (or form) while Sample Two has an even distribution of just two of the species.

There might be natural stress factors (temperature, light, moisture, soil conditions) present that limits the number of species that can occupy a site.

The Shannon-Wiener Index can be calculated using logarithms to the base 2 or base 10: we will use logs to the base 2. Your hand calculator is also a handy tool for calculating the index, as you can type in values in sequence, use the function feature to find the log and fill out a data sheet table if you do not have an electronic spreadsheet already set up.

S

H s

= -

(Pi) (ln Pi) , where

i =1

H s

– symbol for the diversity in a sample of S species or kinds

S - the number of species in the sample

Pi – relative abundance of i th species or kinds measures, = n i

/N

N – total number of individuals of all kinds n i

- number of individuals of i th ln – log to base 2

species

These are sample computations using a table that follows the formula above.

Sample One Species 1 Species 2 Species 3

Sample Two

Sample One

16

44

16

2

16

2

Species #

1

2

Pi = n i

/N ln Pi (Pi) (ln Pi)

16 16/48 = 0.3333 -1.0986 (0.3333) (-1.0986) = -0.3662

16 16/48 = 0.3333 -0.3662

3 16 16/48 = 0.3333 -0.3662

Sum -1.0986

H s

1.0986

Sample Two

Species #

1

Pi = n i

/N ln Pi (Pi) (ln Pi)

16 44/48 = 0.9167 -0.0870 (0.9167) (-0.0870) = -0.0796

2

3

2 2/48 = 0.0417 -3.1780 -0.1324

2 2/48 = 0.0417 -3.1780 -0.1324

Sum -0.3444

H s

0.3444

The higher index for sample one indicates that it has a higher uncertainty of composition.

That is, if you were to select two individuals at random from the first sample, it is more uncertain that they will be the same than if you try the same selection in the second sample. Both sample are equally rich in species (3), but sample one is even and the more diverse. Sample tow is uneven in its species make up.

If factors controlling distribution of species at a site can be determined to cause the different compositions of the samples, then we are in a position to propose that Sample

One is a candidate for “environmental degradation.” The actual determination needs to be made in the light of other observations. If the stresses on the sampled community are caused by human activity, we could talk about “degraded” habitat. However, an agricultural field might fit the characteristics of Sample One. This illustrates how careful observation of the context of data can determine the type of hypotheses developed about a site and whether or not they can be confirmed.

If we sample a site in our lawns or in the Western Woods, we might come up with fairly high diversity index values. Before we complete the study, we need to look at those

2

values, determine if we have native or introduced species and look up what is known about our study organisms.

METHOD

Sample the available lawn space with the Frisbee or bucket lid method of the Clover Lab.

Your data count at each throw will be recorded on a sheet with pictures of the species’ leaves. It is suggested that you use 24 throws if using a Frisbee and 12 throws if using a bucket lid. You will calculate the Diversity index H s

using an Excel Spreadsheet or set up a data table as in the sample calculation.

Write up the lab according to the format for the Clover Lab. Address the following questions in your discussion section:

1) What is the diversity of your sample compared to diversity for the whole class?

2) How many of the species in your sample could qualify as “weeds?”

3) Briefly describe one question you would ask about the differences or sameness noted in between the calculations. In other words, is your team sample of about 1 square meter enough to indicate the diversity in the Alumnae Hall lawn area

(about 1000 square meters)?

4) Identify two ecosystems on the Miami/Western campus that could be evaluated according to this Index. Explain your choices briefly (future possible investigations).

3

Download