GEOL 360X: History of Life
Peer Review Cover Sheet #1
Paper’s author fills out top part
Title of Paper:
Last 4 digits of Student ID Number: ______ ______ ______ ______
Reviewer 1
Last 4 digits of Student ID Number: ______ ______ ______ ______
Carefully read and edit this paper, marking grammatical and spelling errors as
well as any other problems you find. Then complete the following checklist and
grading rubric.
Check off all that apply to this paper:
___ Addresses #1 from assignment
___ Addresses #2 from assignment
___ Addresses #3 from assignment
___ References cited clearly in the body of the paper
___ At least 3 references cited (no encyclopedias)
___ All references cited included in “References Cited” section
Grading Rubric: Each row is worth either one or zero points.
Category
Free of major grammatical and spelling errors
Essay is well organized and written
Entire checklist checked off
yes
1
1
1
Total _____
no
0
0
0
GEOL 360X: History of Life
Peer Review Cover Sheet #2
Paper’s author fills out top part
Title of Paper:
Last 4 digits of Student ID Number: ______ ______ ______ ______
Reviewer 2
Last 4 digits of Student ID Number: ______ ______ ______ ______
Carefully read and edit this paper, marking grammatical and spelling errors as
well as any other problems you find. Then complete the following checklist and
grading rubric.
Check off all that apply to this paper:
Check off all that apply to this paper:
___ Addresses #1 from assignment
___ Addresses #2 from assignment
___ Addresses #3 from assignment
___ References cited clearly in the body of the paper
___ At least 3 references cited (no encyclopedias)
___ All references cited included in “References Cited” section
Grading Rubric: Each row is worth either 1 or zero points.
Category
Free of major grammatical and spelling errors
Essay is well organized and written
Entire checklist checked off
yes
1
1
1
Total _____
no
0
0
0