CE 527 Solid Waste Management Composition, Generation and Control of Landfill Gases Dr. S.K. Ong ____________________________________________________________________________________ 1. Principal Constituents 2. Generation of Landfill Gases 3. Estimation of Gas Production 4. Migration of Gases 5. Control and Management of Landfill Gases ______________________________________________________________________________________ 1. Landfill Gases - Principal Constituents Decomposition of the organic fraction of municipal solid waste (MSW) results in different gases, composition varies with age of the landfill and MSW (see Table 11-2, 11-4). Component Methane Carbon dioxide Nitrogen Oxygen Sulfide, disulfide Ammonia Hydrogen Carbon Monoxide Trace constituents Characteristics Temperature Specific gravity Moisture Content High Heating value Percent (dry volume basis) 0.01 - 0.06 Value Trace Landfill Gases Constituents (see Table 11 - 4) Example Compound Concentration (ppbv) Median Mean Maximum Benzene 932 2,057 39,000 Chloroform 0 245 12,000 Toluene 8.125 34,907 280,000 2. Generation of Landfill Gases (Different Phases) (see Figure 11 - 11) can be divided into five generalized phases. Phases Phase 1 - Initial Adjustment Aerobic Description short aerobic phase immediately after landfilling the waste, where easily degradable organic matter is aerobically decomposed resulting in a carbon dioxide generation (oxygen from air trapped in landfill) increase in temperature Time few days to a month depending on the moisture content Gases CO2 O2 N2, Leachate COD , pH Phase II Transition State (Anoxic Phase) Nonmethanogenic Oxygen is depleted anaerobic conditions begin to develop nitrate and sulfate serve as electron acceptor CO2 bloom as a result of hydrolysis of complex organic compounds and some acid fermentation reduction in oxidation reduction potential (nitrate and sulfate reducing conditions (-50 to -100 mV), production of methane (-150 mV to 300 mV) 2 weeks or more N2 O2 CO2 H2 H2S COD , VFA , pH , Fe and Zn , SO42- , NH4+ Phase III Acid Phase Anaerobic, Methanogenic Unsteady Hydrolysis and conversion to intermediate compounds production of significant amounts of volatile fatty acids methanogenesis begins 3 months or more N2 0, H2 (max), CO2 (max), CH4 COD (max), VFA (max), pH (min), Fe, Zn (max), NH4+ SO42- Phase IV Methane Fermentation, Anaerobic Methanogenesis, Steady Phase production of CH4 remains steady at 40 to 70 percent by volume, conversion of VFA, H2, CO2 to CH4 microbes responsible are strictly anaerobes called methanogens both acid formation and methane production proceed simultaneously (for slowly biodegradable organics, eg., cellulose from paper and wood) may be as long as 30 years H2 CO2 CH4 pH = 6.8 - 8.0 COD metals Phase V Maturation Phase readily available biodegradable material has been converted to methane and carbon dioxide CH4 CO2 N2 O2 (diffusion of air into landfill) humic and fulvic acid Electron Acceptors Environment Electron Acceptor End Product of Electron Acceptor Process Energy generated (kcal/mole) (Acetate) Aerobic Anoxic Anaerobic H2O Aerobic -25.3 N2 Denitrification -23.74 HSSulfate reducing -1.52 CH4 Methanogenesis -0.8 ____________________________________________________________________________________ What do we mean by electron acceptors? C6H12O6 =============> 6CO2 O2 ===========> H2O NO3- ============> N2 2.1 Factors Affecting Methane Production i. Oxygen Absence of free oxygen needed for methanogenesis to grow (strict anaerobes) Redox potential needed < - 330 mV Oxygen always diffuse from the atmosphere into the landfill Oxygen readily taken up by aerobic bacteria at the top of landfill, therefore limiting the aerobic zone to about 1 m of compacted waste Gas recovery system will create a vacuum resulting in air migrating into the landfill ii. Hydrogen Hydrogen plays a role in limiting the conversion of fatty acids and alcohols by acetogenic bacteria Low hydrogen pressure is maintained by conversion of CO2 P H2 to CH4 by methanogenic bacteria iii. pH and alkalinity Methanogenic bacteria operates within a narrow pH range of 6 to 8. In landfill, buffering usually comes from the soil and demolition waste to help to maintain a reasonable pH range. iv. Sulfate Both sulfate-reducing bacteria and methanogenic bacteria convert acetic acid If sulfate is present, methane production may be reduced v. Nutrient Needs nutrient especially nitrogen and phosphorus All micronutrients, eg., cobalt, calcium are assumed to be present in the landfill Most landfill will not lack nutrient but lack homogenization of waste that may result in pockets of nutrient-limited environment Phosphorus is, if any, the nutrient that is most likely to be limiting in the anaerobic degradation process vi. Inhibitors Sensitive to various inhibitors such as common ions, organic compounds Common ions Parameter Sodium Potassium Calcium Magnesium Ammonium (total) Simulating Effect 100 - 200 200 - 400 100 - 200 75 - 150 50 - 200 Moderate Inhibition 3500 - 5500 2500 - 4500 2500 - 4500 1000 - 1500 1500 - 3000 Significant Inhibition 8000 12000 8000 3000 3000 Effects of organic Compounds on 50% reduction of methane generation Compounds Concentration (mg/L) Acetaldehyde 440 Acrolein 20 - 50 Formaldehyde 50 - 100 Chloroform 20 Phenol 2444 Nitrobenzene 12.3 Vinyl chloride 5 - 10 vii. Temperature Generally mesophilic bacteria in landfill (30 - 45 o C) Anaerobic heat generation is low in comparison to aerobic processes viii. Moisture Content Methane production increase for increasing moisture content Exponential increase in gas production rates between 25 to 60% moisture content Moisture facilitates exchange of substrate, nutrient, dilution of inhibitors and spreading of microogranisms Too much moisture may limit oxygen transfer from atmosphere, in landfill covers - resulting in shut-out 3. Gas Production Generalized equation organic matter + water ====> biodegraded organic matter + CH 4 + CO2 + other gases If we assume the waste has a formula of CaHbOcNd, then CaHbOcNd + (4a – b - 2c + 3d)/4 H2O => (4a + b - 2c - 3d)/8 CH4 + (4a – b + 2c + 3d)/8 CO2 + d NH3 Example: Use sucrose C11H22O11 C12H22O11 + [4(12) – (22) - 2(11) + 3(0)]/4 H2O => [4(12) + 22 - 2(11) - 3(0)]/8 CH4 + [4(12) – 22 + 2(11) + 3(0)]/8 CO2 + (0) NH3 C12H22O11 + 342 H2O => 6 CH4 + 6(16)= 96 6 CO2 6(44) = 264 Gas produced with 1 lb of sucrose CH4 = 96 x 1/[(342)(0.0448 lb /ft3)] CO2 = 264 x 1/[(342)(0.1235 lb/ft3)] Total theoretical amount of gas = _______ ft3 = _______ ft3 = 6.266 + 6.2504 = _____ ft3/lb = _____ L/kg Theoretical CO2 and CH4 generation Waste CO2 + CH4 produced (L/kg of waste) Cellulose (C6H10O5)x 829 Protein (53% C, 6.9% H, 988 22% O, 16.5% N, 1.25% S Fat (C55H106O6) 14.3 Total Gas (CO2 + CH4) Production from Municipal Refuse Condition Typical US Municipal Refuse C97H145O58N Full Size Landfills (short Term data) Lysimeters or closed containers (1 - 3 years) Gas Composition (% CH4) 50 51.5 71.4 Gas Production (L/kg) 520 (53% CH4) 50 - 400 5 - 40 4. Migration of Landfill Gases Typically, the advection-dispersion equation is used to describe the movement of landfill gases. The onedimensional equation is written as: concentration changing with time where CA Vz Dz G z movement due to convection or advection movement due to diffusion generation = total porosity (cm3/cm2) = retardation factor accounting for sorption and phase change = concentration of compound A = convective velocity in the vertical direction (cm/s) = effective diffusion coefficient (cm2/s) = lumped parameter to account for all generation terms (g/cm3.s) = depth (m) Equation can be solved numerically using the proper boundary conditions. However, the equation can be simplified to obtain an analytical solution. Assuming steady state and sorption and generation are negligible, an ordinary differential equation can be solved. 0 Vz d CA d z Dz d 2CA d z2 If we neglect the convective forces then we have: 0 Dz d 2CA d z2 Integrating, we have: n A Dz d CA d z by discretizing and multiplying by the cross-sectional area, we have: NA DzA where nA NA A CA z CA z = gas flux (g/cm2.s) = mass of gas per unit time (g/s) =cross-sectional area = difference in concentration from point 2 to 1 = C2 - C1 = difference in distance z2 - z1 or Note that Dz where D gas D gas 10 / 3 2 = diffusion coefficient in air (cm2/s) = gas-filled porosity (cm3/cm2) = total porosity (cm3/cm2) Example Problem: An open landfill site has some household waste containing benzene in the waste. The site is rectangular in shape with its longest cross dimension equal to 300 m and its shortest cross dimension is approximately 180 m with an exposure area of 54,000 m2. Estimate the potential emission rate of benzene from the site with cover of 20 inches of soil and a total porosity of 0.4 and a gas filled porosity of 0.2. Wind speed = 4 m/sec; soil temperature = 30 o C. With cover NA D i A( gas )10 / 3 C s Wi 2L = (0.081)(54 ,000 x 10 4 )( 0.2)10 / 3 (504 .6 x 10 6 )( 0.0004 ) 20 x 2.54 (0.4) 2 = 0.0051 g/s 5. Control of Landfill Gases Movement of gases are controlled to reduce atmospheric emission minimize release of odorous emissions minimize subsurface gas migration allow recovery if energy from methane Control Systems passive active Passive Systems pressure relief vents to release gas pressure in landfills several vents may be connected and gas flared with a gas burner perimeter interceptor trenches (gravel packed) to convey landfill gases, may be used with an impermeable membrane in the wall facing away from the landfill. perimeter barrier trench or slurry wall made up of relatively impermeable materials such as bentonite (acts as a physical barrier) to gas movement. use of geomembranes Active Control Extraction Wells - perimeter gas extraction for landfills. - perimeter gas extraction trenches (horizontal pipes) - gas extraction wells within landfills (solid waste depth must be at least 25 ft). General Guidelines for a viable gas recovery system - minimum in place waste quantity, 500,000 to 1,000,000 metric tonnes at a minimum depth of 15 m - well spaced so that their radii of influence over lap. Radius of Influence is dependent on porosity, length of well screen, depth of well, and applied well vacuum. Radius of influence determined by conducting gas drawdown tests in the field. Pressures at regular distances from the well are measured when vacuum is applied. Typical radius of influence ranges from 100 - 200 feet. - typical diameter (4 - 6 ins. PVC or HDPE pipe and can be as large as 12 inches) - should penetrate 80 - 90% of refuse with lower 70 - 80% perforated or screened. - wells installed after the landfill or portion of the landfill have been completed - available vacuum in the collection manifold at the well head is typically 10 inches of water - selected diameter of header pipe based on a maximum gas velocity of 50 ft/sec and a maximum head loss/100 ft of pipe of 1 inch of water column. Management of Landfill Gases - Flaring - thermal destruction. Most modern facilities have flares to meet Clean Air Act. - for effective destruction, combustion temperature = 1500 o F, Residence time = 0.3 to 1.5 s - Energy recovery system, - gas purified to remove as much moisture, hydrogen sulfide - compressed to higher pressure before it can be used effectively - burned in gas turbines or internal combustion piston engines