Molecular Symmetry (Structural Classifications) Molecular structures Linear Planar triangle Tetrahedral Trigonal bipyramidal Octahedral Pentagonal bipyramidal Square antiprism O=C=O SO3 CH4 PCl5 SF6 IF7 TaF83- Symmetry Operations: an action such as reflection, rotation, … Symmetry Elements: associated with each symmetry operation, a plane, a line , a point, … A symmetry element is an axis (line), plane, or point about which symmetry operations are performed. Aspects of Symmetry and Point Groups Symmetry operations: 1. 1. 2. 3. 4. Proper rotation, Cn Reflection, Inversion, i Improper rotation, Sn Proper rotation, Cn simple rotation about an axis passing through the molecule by an angle of 360/n. This operation is called a proper rotation and is symbolized by Cn * 180º rotation C2 * For a H2O molecule, please locate the C2 axis * * C3 C3 * 2 C3 For a BF3 molecule, please locate the C3 axis 2. Reflection (mirror) plane, Reflection of all atoms through a plane Please locate the two vertical reflection planes in H2O 3. Inversion (Center of Inversion), I Reflection of all atoms through a point Please locate the center of inversion in SF6, XeF4, etc. 4. Improper rotation, Sn The combination, in either order, of rotating the molecule about an axis passing through it by 2/n and reflecting all atoms through a plane that is perpendicular to the axis of rotation h 1 4 4 C4 2 3 2 3 4 h 1 through an S 4 operation An S4 improper rotation axis How many S4 rotation axes for a CH4 molecule? 2 1 3 Symmetry element Symmetry Operation examples None Identity, E CHFClBr Mirror plane Reflection, H2O Rotation axis Rotation Inversion center Inversion, i Improper axis Rotation -reflection C2 p-C6H4Cl2 C3 NH3 C4 [PtCl4]2- C5 C5H5- C6 benzene Ferrocene (staggered) S4 CH4 S6 Ethane(staggered) S10 Ferrocene (staggered) Some important points 1. Do not confuse an inversion operation with a two-fold rotation A D B C A B i C D B A C D 2. S1 operation is equivalent to the mirror reflection 3. S2 is equivalent to a center of inversion Exercises: B A D C C2 1. Which conformation of CH3CH3 has an S6? 2. Identify a C3 axis of an NH4+ ion. How many C3 axes? Summary of important symmetry operations and symmetry elements Symmetry element Symmetry operation Symbol Identity E n-Fold symmetry axis Rotation by 2/n Cn Mirror plane Reflection Center of inversion Inversion I n-Fold axis of improper rotation Rotation by 2/n Sn followed by reflection perpendicular to rotation axis One molecule may have more than one symmetry elements NH3 H2O SO2Cl2 SF6 To summarize the collection of symmetry elements a molecule has, we introduce the concept of point group. Point Groups (or Symmetry Groups) The complete set of symmetry operations than can be performed on a molecule is called the symmetry group for the molecule Point group symmetry elements examples C1 C2 Cs C2v C3v Cv D2h D3h D4h Dh Td Oh E E, C2 E, E, C2, 2v E, C3, 3v E, C E, 3C2, 2v, h, i E, C3, 3C2, 3v, h E, C4, 4C2, 4v, h, i, S4, … E, C, v, … E, 3C2, 4C3, 6, 3S4 E, 6C2, 4C3, 4S6, 3S4, i, … SiBrClFI H2O2 NHF2 H2O, SO2Cl2 NH3, PCl3, POCl3 CO, HCl, OCS N2O4, B2H6 BF3, PCl5 XeF4, trans-MA4B2 H2, CO2, C2H2 CH4, SiCl4 SF6 Classification of Point Groups 1. Groups of low symmetry a) C1 no symmetry at all CHFClBr b) Cs only one mirror plane H2C=CClBr c) Ci only an inversion center HClBrC-CBrClH 2. Cn groups (n=2, 3, 4, …) Contain only one Cn rotational axis Example: H2O2 3. Cnv groups (n=2, 3, 4, …) Contain Cn and nv (a set of n vertical mirror planes: these mirror planes contain the Cn axis) Examples: H2O NH3 SO2Cl2 SClF5 ONNi(5-C5H5) 4. Cnh groups (n=2, 3, …) Cn + h h: mirror plane, perpendicular to Cn O Me C Examples: O trans-HClC=CHCl S Mo R 3P O O X Mo X O O C Me O PR3 O O S O Re O O O O S O Re O O O S O O 5. Dn groups (n=2, 3, …) Cn + n C2 A Cn principal rotational axis is accompanied by a set of n C2 axes perpendicular to it example: Co(H2NCH2CH2NH2)3 6. Dnh groups (n=2, 3, 4, …) Dn + h h: horizontal mirror plane, perpendicular to the principal axis Cn generating nv mirror planes Examples: trigonal prism trigonal-bipyramidal pentagonal prism, pentagonal-bipyramidal PtCl42C6H6 BF3 PCl5 7. Dnd groups (n=2, 3, 4, …) Dn + a set of n vertical mirror planes (v) do not have h mirror plane Examples: R3WWR3 Me H H Me Ferrocene XB 8. Sn groups (n=4, 6, 8, …) N contain only Sn axis S1 Cs S 2 i CI RN NR BX BX NR H Me Me H B X N R When n = odd, Sn Cnh n can only be even 9. High symmetry point groups 1) Tetrahedral point groups T point group: 4C3 + 3C2 Td point group: T + 6d Th point group : T+ i (CH4, SiCl4, etc…) 2) Octahedral point groups O point group: 4C3 + 6C2 Oh point group: O+i 3) Icosahedral point groups I point group: 6C5 Ih point group: I+i 10. Point groups for linear molecules A-B A-B-C A-A A-B-A CO, CO2, N2 Summary: Some typical shapes of point groups Procedure in identifying point groups n= 2 Cn Dn Cnv Cnh Dnh (plane or bipyramidal) Dnd S2n 3 4 5 6 Important points: The symmetry elements used to identify a point group do not form a complete set of symmetry elements for the molecule under consideration Using the highest symmetry point to assign the molecular symmetry Exercises: Mer-[Fe(CN)3Cl3]3- IF7 Mo(CN)84- P4 XeO2F2 TeCl4 ClSbO trans-HClC=CClH Cyclopropane cyclopropene C8H8 C8H4F4 Applications of symmetry 1. Molecular polarity A polar molecule is a molecule with a permanent electric dipole moment Cannot have a permanent dipole perpendicular to any mirror plane Cannot have a permanent dipole perpendicular to any axis of symmetry Molecules having both a Cn axis and a perpendicular C2 axis or h cannot have a dipole in any direction. Molecules belonging to any D, T, O or I groups cannot have permanent dipole moment + C2 - + The presence of a mirror plane or a C2 axis rules out a dipole in the direction shown. Exercises: RuCp2 and FeCp2, are they polar? 2. Molecular chirality A chiral molecule is a molecule that is distinguished from its mirror image in the same way that left and right hands are distinguishable A molecule that has no axis of improper rotation (Sn) is chiral Sn: including S1= and S2=i Exercises: (1) [Cr(ox)3]3-, is it chiral? (2) The skew form of H2O2, is it chiral?