Met Office College - Course Notes Basic Cloud Physics Contents 1. Introduction 2. Atmospheric aerosol 2.1 Aerosol sizes 2.2 Aerosol properties and condensation 2.3 Aerosol sources 2.4 Aerosol and visibility 3. Condensation and the growth of cloud droplets 3.1 Curvature effects 3.2 The Kelvin effect 3.3 The solute effect 3.4 The Köhler curve 4. The formation of precipitation 4.1 Water clouds 4.2 Growth by condensation 4.2.1 Growth by coalescence 4.3 Ice and mixed phase clouds 4.3.1 Growth by deposition 4.3.2 Growth by accretion (riming) 4.3.3 Growth by aggregation 4.4 Summary of precipitation formation 5. Artificial cloud modification 6. References Crown Copyright. Permission to quote from this document must be obtained from The Principal, Met Office College Page 1 of 17 Last saved date: 12 February 2016 FILE: MS-TRAIN-COLLEGE-WORK-D:\116106716.DOC Met Office College 1. Introduction To a synoptic meteorologist such as a forecaster on the bench, the smallest atmospheric features of interest are probably individual convective clouds with horizontal scales of tens or hundreds of metres. However, there are many processes which take place within such clouds which occur on much smaller scales than this. These small scale processes contribute to the form that a cloud will take and, of particular interest to the forecaster, they also determine whether the cloud will produce any precipitation. It is the study of these processes which forms the specialised branch of meteorology known as cloud physics. The scales of such processes are often of the order of microns (10-6m) and so are frequently referred to as microphysical processes. Although the forecaster does not need a detailed knowledge of this subject, a basic understanding of the processes which lead to the formation of clouds and precipitation, combined with a knowledge of the larger scale physical and dynamical processes in the atmosphere, should lead to improved forecasts. A good understanding of cloud physics is also required for the development of NWP models. The current representation of microphysical processes in most NWP models is rather crude or nonexistent, but it is thought that more sophisticated parametrizations should lead to better precipitation forecasts by models. A lot of research effort and money is therefore invested in studying this subject both in the laboratory and using data from aircraft flying through clouds carrying highly sophisticated measuring equipment. The aim of this note is to give a basic introduction to cloud physics, outlining the processes important in the formation of clouds and precipitation, and how conditions in the larger scale environment affect these processes. 2. Atmospheric aerosol The basic ingredient required to form clouds and precipitation is water vapour in the atmosphere. However, although water vapour will readily condense onto the surface of the earth when the air becomes saturated (forming dew), in the free atmosphere away from the surface, the air can become highly supersaturated but the vapour will not condense unless it has a surface onto which it can do so. In fact, relative humidities of about 800% are required for water vapour to spontaneously condense and form droplets without a surface to form on. Since we rarely observe supersaturations of more than 1% in the atmosphere (i.e. a relative humidity of 101%), yet frequently observe clouds and rain, there must be something present in the atmosphere onto which the vapour can condense. In fact the air is full of microscopic particles which provide the very surfaces required for condensation. Page 2 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Basic Cloud Physics These particles are known as atmospheric aerosol and are composed of tiny solid or liquid particles which have a small fall speed in air and therefore appear to be suspended in the atmosphere on short timescales. The sources of these aerosols, and their concentrations within the atmosphere vary widely in time and location, but without their presence in the atmosphere, clouds would never form. The size and chemical constitution of these aerosols determines how readily water vapour will condense onto them and we shall see later that certain types of aerosol are much more likely to lead to cloud formation than others. 2.1 Aerosol sizes Having said that aerosol is composed of microscopic particles, there is actually a huge range of sizes of aerosol in the atmosphere. The smallest particles are of the order of 10-10m (or 0.0001m) in radius and the largest can have radii of several tens of microns. Particles larger than this will have appreciable fall velocities and so are not classed as aerosols as they do not appear to be suspended in the atmosphere. Aerosols are classified by size into three types; Aitken nuclei are the smallest aerosols, with radii of less than 0.1m. They are also the most numerous aerosol in the atmosphere. Large aerosols have a radius of between 0.1 and 1m and are less numerous than Aitken nuclei although they constitute a larger proportion of the total aerosol mass in the atmosphere due to their larger size. Finally, giant aerosols have a radius greater than 1m and are less numerous than large aerosols. The actual concentrations of these three different sizes of aerosol varies greatly depending on the nature of the airmass. Polluted urban air contains many more Aitken nuclei than maritime air, but the numbers of giant aerosol vary very little between different airmasses. 2.2 Aerosol properties and condensation Aerosols can also be classified by how readily water vapour will condense onto them (i.e. how suitable they are as cloud condensation nuclei or CCN); Hygroscopic aerosol begin to dissolve when water forms around them. This solute effect gives them an affinity for water and allows condensation to occur at relative humidities well below 100%. This makes hygroscopic aerosol the most efficient form of condensation nuclei. Section 3.3 will describe this process in more detail. Wettable aerosols do not dissolve in water but allow it to spread out into a film on their surface. They also serve as cloud condensation Page 3 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Met Office College nuclei but require the air to be saturated for net condensation to occur. Hydrophobic (or unwettable) aerosols are not suitable as condensation nuclei as water does not spread out over their surfaces but instead forms spherical drops. This effect is similar to what happens when rain falls on a recently polished car or when water droplets run off a duck’s feathers. 2.3 Aerosol sources The source of most aerosols in the atmosphere is the earth’s surface, and as a consequence, aerosol concentrations reduce with height, as shown in figure 1 (note the logarithmic scale on the x axis). Figure 1. Measurements of Aitken nuclei concentration against altitude over western Germany on October 5th 1973. [adapted from Pure and Appl. Geophys. 112] The major sources of Aitken nuclei are combustion processes and so the Aitken nucleus count tends to be particularly high around urban and industrialised areas. However, natural sources such as forest fires and volcanoes also generate appreciable quantities of these small particles. As stated in section 2.1, the Aitken nucleus count in maritime air is lower than that for continental airmasses. This means that there are less aerosol particles competing for the available water vapour in maritime air and so each individual cloud droplet will grow larger. One consequence of this is that maritime clouds can produce rain more quickly than continental clouds. This effect is actually parameterised in the Unified Model, with maritime cumulus clouds able to produce rain Page 4 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Basic Cloud Physics when 1.5km deep, whereas clouds which form over land have to be 4km deep before rain can be produced. The fact that some Aitken nuclei are also found in unpolluted maritime air means that there must be other sources apart from combustion. It is thought that gas-to-particle conversion is one such source. This occurs when certain gases in the atmosphere react chemically with each other (often due to absorption of solar radiation) and leave behind tiny solid particles. These reactions are enhanced by high relative humidities. This process is thought to be a major source of sulphate aerosols in the atmosphere. A number of complex chemical and mechanical processes also occur within low level clouds which can alter the distribution of aerosol sizes and increase the availability of effective cloud condensation nuclei. Windblown dust and pollen is a major source of large and giant aerosol, particularly in arid regions. The sea surface is also a source of larger aerosols in the form of salt particles. Bubbles bursting on the sea surface eject a fine spray of droplets into the air. When these drops evaporate they leave behind salt crystals which will act as hygroscopic nuclei. Despite the rapid increase in man-made pollution during recent times, it is estimated that only about 5% of the aerosol in the atmosphere comes from human sources. However, the nature of much of this anthropogenically generated aerosol is thought to interact significantly with solar radiation thus affecting the energy balance of the earthatmosphere system. 2.4 Aerosol and visibility Aerosols with radii between 0.1m and 1m (large aerosols) scatter visible radiation very efficiently. This is because their diameters are very similar to the wavelengths of visible light. Although much of the scattering of light occurs in the forward direction, removal of light from the direct beam results in distant objects becoming indistinct to the observer, and the contrast between an object and its background is reduced. In some cases all the light from an object may be scattered out of the direct beam before it reaches the observer and so the object will be invisible. High relative humidity will increase the size of some smaller hygroscopic nuclei so that they come into the size range which scatters visible light efficiently, forming haze and reducing the visibility. 3. Condensation and the growth of cloud droplets The usual mechanism for producing condensation of water vapour in the free atmosphere is adiabatic cooling of moist air due to vertical motion. As has already been mentioned, condensation will not occur unless sufficient cloud condensation nuclei are present. However, it is a property of the atmosphere that there are always sufficient quantities of these CCN available for cloud Page 5 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Met Office College droplets to form and so supersaturations greater than about 1% are almost never observed. In this section, some of the mechanisms that allow these cloud droplets to grow or dissipate will be examined. 3.1 Curvature effects When examining the relationship between a surface of water and the adjacent moist air, it is usual to consider a plane (i.e. flat) water surface. An equilibrium state is reached between the surface and the air when the number of water molecules leaving the surface (i.e. evaporating) is equal to the number entering the surface from the atmosphere (i.e. condensing). The equilibrium state is reached when the air is just saturated (RH = 100%). If the relative humidity is less than this, more molecules will evaporate than condense and so the RH will increase until it reaches 100% again. If the humidity is greater than this, the opposite will be the case. If the water surface is curved, as it clearly is on a cloud droplet, the equilibrium state will be reached at a different point. This is because the water molecules on a curved surface are less tightly bound than those on a flat surface as shown by figure 2. This means that is easier for water molecules to escape from a curved surface (i.e. evaporate) than it is for them to escape from a flat surface. So even at a relative humidity of 100%, more molecules will be evaporating from a spherical water droplet than will be condensing onto it. The greater the curvature, the higher the value of relative humidity required to maintain equilibrium. A droplet of radius 0.01m would require a relative humidity of 112% to remain in equilibrium, a value which is never observed in the atmosphere. A droplet of radius 0.1m requires an RH of 101% for equilibrium, a value which is observed in some clouds. Thus a wettable aerosol particle needs to have a radius of at least 0.1m to act as a CCN. Hygroscopic nuclei which smaller radii than this can still act as CCN for reasons which will be discussed in section 3.3. Figure 2. Water molecules in (a) a plane water surface and (b) a small water droplet. The molecules in the curved surface expose a greater surface area to the surrounding air and so are less tightly bound. Page 6 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Basic Cloud Physics 3.2 The Kelvin effect The greater the curvature of a droplet (and therefore the smaller the radius), the higher the supersaturation required for it to remain in equilibrium. However, if the radius of the droplet should increase (if for instance it collides and joins with another droplet), then the environment will be supersaturated with respect to the droplet. This will initiate further condensation onto the droplet and it will thus grow even bigger - a positive feedback. The radius of the drop will always remain larger than its equilibrium radius and so it will continue to grow. This growth is known as the Kelvin effect which is an unstable process since a small increase in the radius of the drop results in rapid growth. If the droplet were to reduce in size for some reason, the Kelvin effect will mean that the environment is now subsaturated with respect to the drop and so evaporation will occur resulting in a rapid dissipation of the droplet. This effect is illustrated in figure 3. The curve shows the equilibrium relative humidity against droplet radius. If a small change to the droplet size occurs to move it off this equilibrium curve then the drop will either grow or dissipate rapidly. Since relative humidity rarely exceeds 101% in the atmosphere, it is clear from this graph that a droplet must reach a radius of at least 0.1m before it can grow rapidly by the Kelvin effect. Figure 3. The equilibrium curve for a water droplet illustrating the Kelvin Effect. If a droplet on the curve is displaced to the right of the curve it will grow rapidly. Similarly, if a droplet is displaced to the left of the curve, it will dissipate rapidly. Page 7 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Met Office College 3.3 The solute effect The solute effect is a mechanism that will allow smaller cloud droplets to reach a size which allows them to grow by the Kelvin effect. In section 2.2 it was stated that hygroscopic aerosols begin to dissolve when water forms around them, allowing net condensation onto the droplet at relative humidities of less than 100%. This will be examined in more detail here. When a hygroscopic aerosol begins to dissolve, some of the molecules in the droplet will not be water molecules but molecules of the substance of the nucleus (salt for instance). Some of these molecules may occupy positions at the surface of the droplet thus reducing the number of water molecules available for evaporation as shown in figure 4. Because of this, the evaporation of water will be reduced even if the RH is less than 100% and the droplet will grow as it is not losing as many water molecules as it is gaining from its environment. As the droplet size increases, the solution becomes more dilute and the effect decreases so the drop starts to behave more like a pure water droplet. Similarly, if the drop were to suddenly increase in size (once again due to colliding with another droplet) it will become more diluted and so will evaporate back towards its equilibrium size. Because of this negative feedback, the solute effect is known as a stable process. Figure 4. A droplet with a hygroscopic nucleus is a mixture of water molecules and dissolved molecules of the nucleus. As the droplet grows by condensation, the number of solute molecules remains the same but the number of water molecules increases so the droplet behaves more like pure water as it grows. Page 8 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Basic Cloud Physics The solute effect means that hygroscopic aerosol as small as 0.01m can still serve as condensation nuclei, and that condensation can start at relative humidities of as low as 60%. 3.4 The Köhler curve For a small cloud droplet to grow large, a combination of the solute and Kelvin effects is required. A droplet needs to grow by the solute effect to a size at which the Kelvin effect will lead to rapid growth. If the droplet should become too dilute before it reaches this critical size, it will remain in equilibrium as a haze particle if the relative humidity is 100%, or start to evaporate if the RH is less than this value. This growth mechanism can be expressed graphically on a plot of droplet radius against relative humidity known as a Köhler curve. An example of several such curves is shown in figure 5 (note that the RH scale has been exaggerated at values greater than 100% since we are particularly interested in what happens when the air is supersaturated). The different curves represent the behaviour of droplets with different chemical constituents. The curves on the left hand side of the diagram represent growth by the solute effect where droplets will grow and shrink in response to changes in RH. If however a droplet radius increases beyond the turning point of the curves, the Kelvin effect takes over and the drop is said to be activated. It can now grow rapidly at the expense of the smaller droplets since as water vapour condenses from the environment onto such a droplet, the RH will fall and so the haze droplets will shrink. Figure 5. Köhler curves for water drops with different concentrations of solute. The bold curve is that for a pure water droplet. Drop (1) contains Page 9 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Met Office College 10-19 kg of ammonium sulphate, (2) contains 10-19 kg of salt, (3) contains 10-18 kg of ammonium sulphate and (4) contains 10-17 kg of salt. 4. The formation of precipitation 4.1 Water clouds Figure 6 shows the relative sizes of typical cloud and rain droplets. If a typically sized cloud droplet (with a radius of 10m ) fell out of the base of a cloud into air with 90% relative humidity, it would evaporate by the time it was 3cm below the cloud base. Clearly then, cloud droplets must grow considerably before they are able to form precipitation which will actually reach the ground before evaporating. The conventional borderline between a cloud droplet and a raindrop is usually considered to occur at a radius of about 100m. A drop of this size would fall about 150m below the cloud base before evaporating in air with 90% RH. So if the cloud base is low enough, such a droplet may reach the ground before it evaporates completely, giving drizzle at the surface. Typical raindrops have a radius of about 1000m (1mm) although much larger drops can form in convective clouds. So to become a raindrop, a cloud droplet must increase its radius by a factor of 100, and in this section, the main mechanisms for this growth will be examined. Figure 6. Relative sizes of cloud and precipitation droplets, showing radius in microns and fallspeed in cm.s-1. Page 10 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Basic Cloud Physics 4.2 Growth by condensation Once a cloud droplet has become activated it grows quickly at first, reaching a radius of 10m within a few minutes. However, the rate of growth is inversely proportional to the radius of the drop, so the growth slows down as the drop gets bigger. This means that a cloud droplet would take about 8 hours to reach drizzle size by condensation alone, and would probably evaporate before it reached the ground unless the cloud was very low. Since precipitation is sometimes observed to fall within half an hour of a cumulus cloud forming, there must be other processes that accelerate the growth of cloud droplets into precipitation. 4.2.1 Growth by coalescence Within a water cloud, droplets sometimes collide with each other and join together to form a larger drop. This is known as coalescence. Larger droplets have faster fall speeds than smaller droplets and it is this difference in fall speeds that allows the collisions to take place. If all the droplets within the cloud were the same size they would all be falling at the same speed and so collisions would be rare. The turbulent motions of air within clouds also lead to collisions between different sized drops as small drops are carried upwards within rising air currents more quickly than large droplets. In both cases it is the relative velocities of the colliding drops that is important rather than their absolute fall speeds. If, however the collecting drop is very much larger than the small drops around it, coalescence becomes less efficient. This is because the large drop forces air to flow around it as it falls, and very much smaller droplets will be swept around the large drop instead of colliding and joining with it, as shown diagrammatically in figure 7. Figure 7. A large precipitation droplet falling through much smaller drops may sweep them to the side instead of coalescing. Page 11 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Met Office College Cloud droplets need to have a radius of at least 18m before they will begin to grow by coalescence. Once a droplet reaches a radius of about 25m it will grow rapidly by this process. Figure 8 shows the radius of a cloud droplet as a function of time as it grows by (a) pure condensation and (b) pure coalescence. Statistical models of droplet growth suggest that light rain may be formed by coalescence alone within 20 minutes of a droplet reaching 25m radius in a maritime cumulus cloud. Including the effects of the continued growth of the smaller droplets by condensation can reduce this time to 10 minutes. Figure 8. Curves of droplet size against time for growth by (a) pure condensation and (b) pure coalescence. 4.3 Ice and mixed phase clouds Water droplets can occur in clouds at temperatures well below 0°C, and are referred to as supercooled droplets. A pure water droplet will actually only freeze at temperatures of between -35°C and -40°C. This is known as homogeneous nucleation. If a water droplet contains a foreign particle known as a freezing nucleus it can freeze by heterogeneous nucleation at temperatures much closer to 0°C. This process occurs when water droplets collect on the surface of a particle and bond together to form an ice-like structure. The chances of freezing occurring are enhanced if the crystal structure of the nucleus is similar to that of ice (i.e. hexagonal). Some small soil and ash particles can nucleate ice at temperatures of between 0°C and -15°C, and many organic substances such as tiny particles of decayed plant matter also nucleate ice well. However, only a tiny proportion of the total atmospheric aerosol content acts as ice nuclei. Page 12 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Basic Cloud Physics Clouds with tops of between 0°C and -4°C are likely to consist entirely of water droplets. These are the conditions in which aircraft are most likely to experience icing problems. With cloud top temperatures of 10°C there is a 50% probability of ice being present, and this increases to 95% if the cloud top temperature is below -20°C. Older clouds tend to have higher concentrations of ice particles whereas newly formed cumulus clouds tend to consist entirely of water droplets. It is possible for ice particles within clouds to multiply without the necessity for a nucleus. As water droplets freeze they release heat to their environment so that a shell of ice forms first around the surface of the drop, trapping liquid water inside. As this liquid core then freezes it expands, setting up large stresses in the outer shell. This may cause it to shatter, throwing off tiny ice splinters which can then act as ice nuclei themselves. This process occurs most efficiently at temperatures of between -3°C and -8°C. The fragile arms of dendritic (branchlike) snow crystals may also break off as the crystal falls, and these too can act as nuclei for further crystal formation. 4.3.1 Growth by deposition In a mixed phase cloud consisting of both water droplets and ice particles, the air can be close to saturation with respect to the water droplets but supersaturated with respect to the ice. This is a consequence of the saturated vapour pressure at a given temperature being lower for ice than for water (i.e. water evaporates more readily than ice), as shown by the es versus T curve in figure 9. At a temperature of -10°C if the air is just saturated with respect to water then it will by supersaturated with respect to ice by 10%. As we have already seen, this is a far greater degree of supersaturation than ever occurs in the atmosphere with respect to water. Page 13 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Met Office College Figure 9. The vapour pressure versus temperature curves for saturation with respect to water and ice. A consequence of this is that in a mixed phase cloud, the ice crystals will grow rapidly at the expense of the water droplets. This can be understood by looking at a sequence of steps illustrated in figure 10. 1. In the initial state, water droplets and ice crystals exist together at temperatures below 0°C. The air is just saturated with respect to the water droplets, but supersaturated with respect to the ice. 2. Because the air is supersaturated with respect to the ice crystals, water vapour will be deposited onto them, freezing on contact. The deposition of vapour onto the ice crystals lowers the relative humidity of the air. 3. Because the RH is reduced, the air is no longer saturated with respect to water and so the water droplets begin to evaporate. 4. Further deposition of water vapour onto the ice crystals occurs so the crystals continue to grow. The continuation of this process means that eventually all the water droplets will evaporate and the ice crystals will grow rapidly. Page 14 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Basic Cloud Physics Figure 10. An illustration of the steps in the process of growth by deposition with allows ice crystals (hexagons) to grow at the expense of supercooled water droplets (circles). This process occurs most efficiently at temperatures of around -12°C, the temperature at which the saturation vapour pressures with respect to ice and water are most different. An ice crystal can attain a radius of 100m within 2.5 minutes of its formation by this mechanism, and so precipitation can form very rapidly in mixed phase clouds. This process of ice crystal growth is often referred to as the Bergeron-Findeisen process after the Norwegian and German meteorologists who first described it. 4.3.2 Growth by accretion (riming) Once an ice crystal has acquired a finite fall speed it can grow by colliding with supercooled water droplets which freeze on contact with the ice. These droplets form a coating of rime ice. If the freezing occurs rapidly then air bubbles may be trapped within the ice and the rime takes on an opaque appearance. However, if the water droplets accumulate on the ice crystal at too great a rate to freeze rapidly, the water has a chance to spread evenly over the surface and forms clear ice. Ice crystals which become rimed to a state where their original form is no longer clear are known as graupel or soft hail. Hailstones are an extreme case of growth by accretion. They form in convective clouds with strong updraughts and high water contents, but a significant portion of the cloud has to be above the freezing level. The way in which hailstones are formed is still the subject of some Page 15 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Met Office College controversy. One theory is that they grow to a large size by repeated recirculation within the cloud and where updraughts are strong enough to support them. As ice crystals move up and down within the updraughts and downdraughts they grow by riming water droplets. Depending on their vertical velocity within the cloud and the water content, they form alternate layers of clear and opaque ice. 4.3.3 Growth by aggregation Ice particles in clouds can also grow by colliding and joining with other ice crystals. As with the coalescence of water droplets, this will only occur if the fall speeds of the crystals are significantly different. Aggregation is also influenced by the shape of the crystals and the temperature. Dendritic crystals such as snowflakes will tend to stick to each other when they collide as their structures will become intertwined. However, crystals with smooth surfaces will tend to bounce off each other. Warmer temperatures also increase the possibility of two crystals sticking. 4.4 Summary of precipitation formation In the tropics where rain bearing clouds tend to be convective with high water contents, the collision-coalescence mechanism is very important and rain may form in a period of 10 minutes from the appearance of a cloud by this process. Coalescence of water droplets can also generate precipitation in mid and high latitudes, and the seeder-feeder mechanism of enhanced precipitation as raindrops from mid level clouds fall through orographically induced low level clouds is a good example of growth by coalescence. In mid and high latitudes, ice particles become important in the formation of precipitation. Rapid initial growth of ice at the expense of supercooled water by deposition in mixed phase clouds can lead to precipitation sized droplets. Further growth by accretion and aggregation can lead to large ice particles forming very quickly. These may melt as they fall through the freezing level giving rain at the surface, or stay frozen depending on the temperature of the air below the cloud and their size, leading to hail, snow, sleet or soft hail. 5. Artificial cloud modification Since the 1940’s many experiments have been carried out to modify the formation of clouds, either in an attempt to increase rainfall, or to dissipate clouds and fog and suppress the development of heavy precipitation. The introduction of solid carbon dioxide particles into a cloud can cause supercooled water droplets to freeze spontaneously. This creates many small ice crystals which are all competing for the available moisture in Page 16 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc Basic Cloud Physics the cloud and so there is insufficient liquid water left in the cloud for growth by the deposition process. This means that the cloud or fog dissipates. Silver iodide has a similar crystalline structure to that of ice and so can act as a very efficient ice nucleus. Introducing silver iodide into a cumulus cloud can induce explosive development of the cloud, but only if the large scale condition of the atmosphere is unstable enough to support such growth. Most cloud seeding experiments have proved inconclusive, or at best have only resulted in very localised modifications of clouds. 6. References Further and more detailed information can be found in the following sources. J.M. Wallace and P.V. Hobbs. Atmospheric science - an introductory survey. Chapter 4. R.R. Rogers and M.K. Yau. A short course in cloud physics. B.J. Mason. The physics of clouds and Clouds, rain and rainmaking. Page 17 of 17 Last Saved Date: 12 February 2016 File: ms-train-college-work-d:\116106716.doc