GEORGE RUSSELL DESCENDANT LINEAGE Issue: Establishment of a parent to child connection between Revolutionary War Patriot George Russell and his daughter, Mary Russell, spouse of Noah Jarnagin. Solution: Present reasonable family lineage links based on the contents of the following documents. Family Lineage A – NSDAR Records The children of George Russell and their spouses are listed under the section titled, “CHILDREN OF REVOLUTIONARY ANCESTOR” on the following NSDAR Record Copies: 658228 A-660 796258 785889 A-869 843432 dated 28 Aug 1985 dated 05 Feb 2000 dated 09 Mar 2004 dated 26 Jun 2006 NSDAR Nos. 658228 A-660, 796258 and 843432 Child William Russell George Russell Jr. Sarah Russell Lydia Russell Mary Russell Jemima Russell Elizabeth Russell Lewis Russell NSDAR No. 785889 A-869 Spouse Agnes and Charity ---Isaac Lane Col. James Roddy Noah Jarnagin George Horner John Horner Esther Horner Child George Russell William Russell Sarah Russell Lydia Russell Mary Russell Elizabeth Russell Jemima Russell Lewis Russell Spouse Sarah Witcher ---Isaac Lane James Roddy Noah Jarnagin John Horner George Horner Ester Horner Of the children listed on Page 3 of record copy No. 658228 A-660 none show check marks under “CHILDREN OF REVOLUTIONARY ANCESTOR.” However, under the heading, “REFERENCES FOR LINEAGE,” the references for Generations 1 thru 7 and Generation 8 show proof of acceptance check marks. On Page 2 under the heading, “LINEAGE,” all the names listed for Generations 7 and 8 show proof of acceptance check marks. [i.e., John Horner, Sr., Elizabeth Russell, George Russell and Elizabeth Bean] Of the children listed on Page 3 of record copies Nos. 796258 and Page 4 of 843432 only William and his spouse, Agnes, have the NSDAR proof of lineage check marks by their names. See Family Lineage F. Of the children listed on Page 3 of record copy No. 785889 A-869 only Lydia and her spouse, James Roddy, have the NSDAR proof of lineage check marks by their names. See Family Lineage F. It should be noted that the NSDAR does not always show the proof of lineage check marks for each one of the patriot’s children, but rather limit them to the child directly linked to the applicant. Conclusions: The NSDAR Record Copies list all of George Russell’s children and their spouses. 1 The NSDAR accepted the lineage documentation submitted with these applications. Therefore, Elizabeth was proven to be the daughter of George Russell by NSDAR record copy 658228 A-660 and William and Lydia were proven to be the children of George Russell by the other NSDAR record copies. William Russell, John Horner and Noah Jarnagin were thus proven to be brothers-in-law. The marriage of the three Russell children to three members of the Horner family suggests a very close tie between the Russell and Horner families. See Family Lineage B. Family Lineage B – Grainger County, Tennessee Property Records Grainger County, Tennessee property Indenture records received from the Knox County Public Library located in Knoxville, Tennessee show the names highlighted in yellow in Family Lineage A above as follows: Record 68: Dated 25 Dec 1797 and registered 27 Jan 1799 shows a property Indenture agreement between William Russell and John Horner. The document was witnessed by Noah Jarnigin and signed by William Russell. Record 149: Dated 24 Sep 1799 and registered 06 Dec 1799 shows a property Indenture agreement between William Russell and Frederich Moires. On Line 8 of the text a survey line is referred to thus: “thence along a conditional line between said William Russell and John Horner.” The document was signed by William Russell. Conclusions: The property transfer transaction between family members, William Russell and John Horner and witnessed by Noah Jarnigin (Jarnagin) supports the same strong family connections shown on the NSDAR records and indicates they lived on adjacent or near properties. Since William Russell was proven to be the son of George Russell in Family Lineage A, it is reasonable to assume that the connection between George Russell, Noah Jarnagin and John Horner has also been proven by these records. They were George Russell’s sons-in-law. See Proof of Family Lineage on Page 7. The appearance of the three brother-in-law names on the Indenture documents is an additional indication of the accuracy of the children’s lists shown on the NSDAR record copies. Family Lineage C – Grainger County, Tennessee Property Records Grainger County, Tennessee property Indenture records received from the Knox County Public Library located in Knoxville, Tennessee shows Noah Jarnigin (Family Lineage A and Family Lineage B) and his father, Thomas Jarnigin as follows: 2 Record 92: Dated 10 Apr 1797 and registered 02 Nov 1798 shows a property transfer agreement between Thomas Jarnigin and Noah Jarnigin. Starting near the end of Line 2 the text reads in part thus: “Noah Jarnigan of the County of Grainger & State aforesaid, Son of the said Thomas Jarnigin.” Reference is made on Line 13 of the text to 3960 acres granted to Thomas Jarnigin by the State of North Carolina. This document was signed by Thomas Jarnigin and witnessed by Major Lea and Lovina Lea. Record 18: Dated 02 Apr 1798 and registered 07 Jul 1798 shows a property Indenture agreement between Noah Jarnigin and Robert Dumvill. On line 8 of the text a line is referred to thus: “the closing line of Thomas Jarnigin 3960 acre tract.” This document was signed by Noah Jonagin and witnessed by Major Lea and Enoch Windes. Conclusions: The property transfer of Record 92 establishes the father and son relationship between Thomas Jarnigin and his son Noah Jarnigin. Record 18 refers to the closing line on the 3960 acre parcel that is common to property that was owned by both men. The witnesses Lovina Lea and Major Lea that are shown on Record 92 are Thomas Jarnigin’s daughter and son-in-law. See Family Linkage D. Record 18 links Noah Jarnigin with his brother-in-law and witness Major Lea. See Family Lineage D. Family Lineage D – NSDAR Record Copy, NSSAR Record Copy and NSSAR Patriot Index NSDAR Record Copy 341195 dated 22 Oct 1943 lists all of Thomas Jarnagin’s children and their spouses under the section titled, “CHILDREN OF REVOLUTIONARY ANCESTOR.” Generation 4 spouses on this approved application are shown as Noah Jarnagin and his wife Mary Russell. NSDAR No. 341195 Child Noah Lavinia Anne Chesley Preston Benjamin Martha Spouse Mary Russell Major Lea Samuel Carson Martha Barton Elizabeth Conway and Betty Shields Susan Lea Daniel Coans 3 Rhoda Jeremiah Pleasant Major Lea* Mary Clark and others Mary Smith * Nephew of sister’s husband NSSAR Record Copy 161394, ACN 32281 dated 05 Aug 2008 shows lineage to Thomas Jarnagin. Generation 8 spouses on this approved application are shown as Noah Jarnagin and his wife Mary Russell. It is noted that all names in the genealogy lineage on the first page bear the NSSAR check marks. NSSAR Patriot Index: Family Group Record for Thomas (Jonakin) (Jarnagain) Jarnagin show child number 2 as Lavinia (Jarnagain) Jarnagin and her spouse, Major Lea, and child number 4 as Noah (Jarnagain) Jarnagin and his spouse, Mary Russell. Conclusions: The NSDAR Record Copy and Patriot Index establishes the relationship of Noah and Lavinia to their father, Thomas Jarnagin and also establishes the identity of their Spouses: i.e. Mary Russell and Major Lea Similarly, the NSSAR record copy establishes the relationship between Noah and Thomas just as does the Indenture Records in Family Lineage C. These records, therefore, indicate tacit approval of Mary Russell as Noah’s wife. See Proof of Lineage on Page 7 of this document. Family Lineage E – Pension and Bounty Land Request of Sarah Russell Lane A declaration document filed in McMinn County, Tennessee on April 14, 1855 and signed by Sarah Lane declared that she was the widow of Isaac Lane who died on November 9, 1851. The purpose of the document was to obtain a pension in the name of her deceased husband under a Federal Law enacted on February 3, 1848. Also include in the document was a request to obtain bounty land under another Federal Law passed on March 3, 1855. Reference is made near the bottom of Page 1 of the document to an 1853 or 1853 declaration for pension for Sarah Lane by her agent, James Hickey. Proof of her marriage and the death of Isaac Lane are included in a statement on Page 2. An affidavit type document signed by Sarah (Russell) Lane’s sister, Mary (Russell) Jarnagin, is also part of the pension, bounty land request file. Mary Jarnagin is identified as the widow of Noah Jarnagin, deceased. In her oath Mary indicated that she knew Sarah Russell and Isaac Lane prior to their marriage and was present at their wedding. Conclusions: Sarah Russell’s name appears in both the declaration document and in Mary Jarnagin’s affidavit. She is identified as Issac Lane’s widow in both records. The NSDAR Record copies in Family Lineage A list Sarah Russell and her spouse, Isaac Lane. Mary Russell and Noah Jarnagin are also listed. The information in Family Lineage E agrees with that in Family Lineage A and F. 4 Mary Jarnagin’s statement suggests strongly that it was prepared in order to assist her sister with the pension, bounty land request. Sarah Russell and Isaac Lane are shown is all three Tennessee records in Family Lineage F. Mary Russell and Noah Jarnagin are shown in the two of the Tennessee Records. It can be assumed that the family relationship between sisters, Mary and Sarah, has been established by these records. Family Lineage F – Records of the Tennessee Society, NSDAR Publications from the Tennessee Society, NSDAR received from the Knox County Public Library located in Knoxville, Tennessee show the following lineage information: Pages 1384 and 1385 of the publication titled, “Membership Roster and Soldiers Tennessee State Society of the National Society, Daughters of the American Revolution 1894 – 1960,” and dated 1961 lists George Russell with the following children: George, William, Sarah, born 1760, died 1857, married Isaac Lane, born Feb. 14, 1760, died Nov. 9 1851, Lydia married James Roddye. It is noted that this reference was approved by the NSDAR as proof of the children’s ancestry on NSDAR Record Copy No. 785889 A-869 dated March 9, 2004. Page 618 of the publication titled, “Membership Roster and Soldiers Tennessee State Society of the National Society, Daughters of the American Revolution 1970 – 1984,” and dated 1985 lists the same information shown in Lineage Link A. [i.e. George Russell with his children William, George Jr., Sarah, Lydia, Mary, Jemima, Elizabeth, Lewis and their spouses] This publication also makes reference to the approved 1961 publication shown in the paragraph above. Page 548 of the publication titled, “Register of Qualified Soldiers and Patriots of the American Revolution Buried in Tennessee,” copyrighted in 2000 shows George Russell with his children. The children are listed as follows: George, William, Sarah Lane, Lydia Roddye, Mary Jarnagin, Jemima Horner, Agnes Roberson, Elizabeth Horner, Lewis. It should be noted that in this publication George Russell’s daughters are identified by their married names. Conclusions: The approval of Elizabeth Russell as George Russell’s daughter on NSDAR Record Copy No. 658228 A-660 dated 28 Aug 1985 provides supporting evidence of the accuracy of the children’s names shown on Page 618 of the 1985 Tennessee publication. This information when combined with the acceptance of the names shown on Page 1385 of the 1961Tennessee publication by the NSDAR, and included in Record Copy No. 785889 A-869, provides sufficient evidence that the NSDAR accepts the accuracy and quality of historical documents researched and published by the Tennessee Society and that those documents should be acceptable to the NSSAR as well. Family Lineage G – History of the First Baptist Church, Whitesburg, Tennessee This page from Ancestry.com files list Charter members, Members for the first five years and Church minutes of the Bent Creek Baptist Church that was established June 12, 1785. Charter members: George Russell and his wife, Mrs. George Russell 5 Members of the first five years: George Russell and wife plus children William, Elizabeth and Jemima Church minutes: In 1790 both Elizabeth and Jemima were met and received. In 1791 George was cited on two occasions. Elizabeth Russell was dismissed in January 1800. Jemima Russell, alias Horner, was also dismissed but no date was recorded. The final entry for the Russell family indicates that George Russell’s name appeared on a listing of those who had died and his children William, Elizabeth and Jemima were shown on a list of those who were dismissed. Conclusions: By showing George Russell and his wife with their children William, Elizabeth and Jemima, this record adds to the totality of information contained in the assembled records and serves as an important verification of the children’s names shown in the Family Lineage F documents above. i.e.: “Membership Roster and Soldiers Tennessee State Society of the National Society, Daughters of the American Revolution 1970 – 1984,” and “Register of Qualified Soldiers and Patriots of the American Revolution Buried in Tennessee.” The Jemima Russell entry includes the alias Horner which suggests she had married George Horner prior to her dismissal. The Horner name is consistent with the names shown in the Family Lineage A and Family Lineage F records and again provides additional evidence of the accuracy and quality of the historical documents researched and published by the Tennessee Society, NSDAR. With William, Elizabeth and Jemima established as George and Elizabeth’s children by this church record it can be concluded that another level of proof has been given to the Tennessee Society, NSDAR records and that Mary Russell and the other Russell children not listed in the church record were indeed George and Elizabeth Russell’s children. ___________________________________________________________________________________ 6 Proof of Family Lineage With Noah Jarnagin established as George Russell’s son-in-law in Family Lineage B; and with Mary Russell established as Noah’s wife in Family Lineage D and Family Lineage E; and with Mary Russell established as George Russell’s daughter in Family Lineage F and Family Lineage G, it can be concluded that these facts, when combined and weighed with the breath of the included documentation, present a preponderance of compelling evidence that Mary Russell was in fact the daughter of Revolutionary War Patriot George Russell. Application Approval Request With the proof of family lineage established between George Russell and his daughter, Mary Russell Jarnagin, it is respectfully requested that the Supplemental Applications of William A. Welch and John D. Welch in the name of their Patriot Ancestor, George Russell, be reviewed and approved. W.D. Welch 20 May 2009 7 GEORGE RUSSELL DESCENDANT LINEAGE Family Lineage A – NSDAR Records GEORGE RUSSELL DESCENDANT LINEAGE Family Lineage B – Grainger County, Tennessee Property Records GEORGE RUSSELL DESCENDANT LINEAGE Family Lineage C – Grainger County, Tennessee Property Records GEORGE RUSSELL DESCENDANT LINEAGE Family Lineage D – NSDAR Record Copy, NSSAR Record Copy and NSSAR Patriot Index GEORGE RUSSELL DESCENDANT LINEAGE Family Lineage E – Pension and Bounty Land Request of Sarah Russell Lane GEORGE RUSSELL DESCENDANT LINEAGE Family Lineage G – History of the First Baptist Church, Whitesburg, Tennessee 8