DEDICATED TO MAKING A DIFFERENCE World Business Council for Sustainable Development Case study 2004 Collect-a-Can Inspiring entrepreneurial endeavors Currently, trade, domestic, and industrial wastes amount to millions of tonnes per annum. Significant quantities of hazardous elements go to special landfills. Recovering and recycling steel and aluminium cans used for beverages, aerosols, oil, paints and clean food reduces the need for landfill and thereby extends the life of existing landfill sites. Additionally, through the Collect-a-Can system, those who collect cans sell them for recycling and make a living doing so. Collect-a-Can was established in 1993 by Iscor – an African steel maker – and Nampak – an African packaging company – to proactively address the possibilities raised by steel beverage can recycling, as well as its shareholders’ portion of environmental responsibility. Therefore its core business is facilitating the recovery of used beverage cans in Southern Africa. While Collect-aCan is a not-for-profit company, funding by its shareholders is seen as an investment. The main objective of the company is to facilitate the successful recovery of beverage cans for recycling in a cost effective manner thereby ensuring that the beverage can remains an environmentally friendly product. Its corporate vision sees a land where the beverage can exists in harmony with the environment. Collect-a-Can employs 120 people and has five strategically positioned branches in South Africa – Pretoria, Aeroton, Vanderbijlpark, Cape Town and Durban. In addition, the company has branches in Gaborone, Botswana and Windhoek, Namibia. It also has Agencies in Swaziland, Zimbabwe, Mozambique and Lesotho. The cans are sold to steel mills who require a certain portion of scrap steel to manufacture prime/virgin steel. Recovered cans are used not only to manufacture cans but all types of prime steel as well. The use of scrap is integral in steel making, thereby saving scarce raw materials such as iron ore, dolomite, lime etc. Further, using a percentage of scrap in steel making reduces the manufacturing costs and decreases the length of the supply chain. Job creation Approximately 37,000 can collectors sell cans to Collect-a-Can, about 82% of whom would otherwise be unemployed. This drive has inspired vital entrepreneurial endeavour. Some collectors who run small business enterprises earn more than R 15,000 (US$ 2,300) per month from Collect-a-Can, and in turn create jobs or supplementary income. Some recovery enterprises employ as many as 65 people. To induce collectors to recover used beverage cans, Collect-a-Can: Pays cash for cans (as opposed to offering coupons or other merchandise); Empowers local entrepreneurs and communities, soliciting their help in collecting and returning by providing a source of income, thereby creating a win/win situation with the unemployed people of Southern Africa; WBCSD page 2 Creates awareness and installs a sense of environmental responsibility in local populations; Forms alliances with associated industries e.g. SAB Miller, Coca-Cola, Namibian Breweries etc. thereby helping them continue to produce their beverages in cans in a cheaper, environmentally friendly way. These companies actively support Collect-aCan and have added their voice to educational and promotional programmes to spread awareness amongst communities. Breweries in neighbouring countries also contribute actively in their respective areas; Encourages fund-raising exercises with schools, churches and charities through can collection. Collectors are paid higher prices than the reigning steel price. Three processes are involved: Financial incentives are offered for collectors to deliver to Collect-a-Can branches. Where practical, cans are collected from the collectors' location of storage. Those who recover cans, but do not have a vehicle in which to transport it to a branch and outsource this part of the process Collecting cans in southern Africa receive a lower price for their cans Bigger financial incentives are offered to collectors to deliver their cans on behalf of Collect-a-Can to its point of sale. Collectors who compact or bale the cans, which reduces their transport costs receive higher prices from Collect-a-Can. Can prices are adjusted from time to time. Current prices for cans delivered to Collect-aCan branches are: Used beverage cans Aerosol, oil, food and paint cans Clean food cans Aluminium cans R 44 cents per kilogram R 15 cents per kilogram R 30 cents per kilogram R 5.00 per kilogram (aluminium prices change on a monthly basis) Litter abatement In 1990 the “Keep South Africa Beautiful” organization conducted a survey in 80 cities and towns, which showed that beverage cans constituted 8% of the country’s litter. In a follow-up survey a few years later, this declined to 2%. The most recent information indicates that this figure now stands at less than 1%. Collect-a-Can’s efforts in the recovery of steel beverage cans help municipalities, who are feeling the brunt of financial infrastructure and space pressures, to reduce the volume for landfill sites. South African municipalities report that over R 195 million (US$ 31 million) a year is spent on litter abatement, which equates to 15 cents (2 US cents) per piece of litter. Thus every beverage can that is recovered from litter saves the taxpayer at least 15 cents. Eco-tourism Another major advantage of can recovery is its positive effect on eco-tourism. Collect-aCan has been instrumental in contributing to keeping the Southern African sub-continent WBCSD page 3 beautiful. Statistics from Kruger National Park show that, based on the number of beverage cans sold in the park, Collect-a-Can recovers more than 200%. Hence, for every can sold in the Park an extra can is brought into the Park. Another example is the work done in the Okavango delta in Botswana. All cans used in this pristine area are brought back to mainly Maun, where they are collected and brought back to the Collect-a-Can branch in Gaborone. Collect-a-Can’s impact The Collect-a-Can initiative reaches the collectors who supply the company with cans by word of mouth, as well as written and specially targeted advertising. By enlisting the help of local communities and the people who need money the most, Collect-a-Can’s activities have had the following impact: Based on its latest internal market survey, more than 37,000 people, 82% of whom are unemployed, are earning or supplementing their income through can recovery. More than R 270 million (US$ 43 million) has been paid out to collectors in the last ten years. Increased awareness amongst the public, especially the youth, who are sensitized about the importance of environmental responsibility. In 1993, the Collect-a-Can project achieved 25% recovery of the total output of cans. The company aimed for a post-consumer recovery rate of cans of 50% by 1996, a figure that was easily surpassed. Since 1997 southern Africa ranks amongst the best in the world in steel beverage can recovery. The current recovery rate for southern Africa is 66%, which compares favourably with recovery rates quoted by developed countries for beverage cans and is the highest recovery rate for one-way packaging in southern Africa. Can litter used to contribute 8% towards total litter, but currently contribute less than 1%. Challenges The Collect-a-Can system presents numerous challenges, both for the company, its shareholders and the collectors. First and most importantly, the unemployed people who collect cans do not have any savings, bridging finance or overdraft facilities, or any infrastructure. Furthermore, they do not have an employment record or any business management exposure as it would be virtually be impossible for the company to have a record of all collectors as not all collectors deliver their cans to Collect-a-Can directly, but rather to entrepreneurs who in turn sell the cans. Additionally, there is a very high turnover of collectors as there is no loyalty to collect cans. WBCSD page 4 While the shareholders have agreed to fund the company, this does not mean that the company has unlimited funds for its operations, although they see their funding of the company as an investment and not an income generator. The recovery of cans is not profitable; hence Collect-a-Can endeavors to recover cans in the most costeffective method possible and significantly reduce the financial burden for shareholders. To ensure that the company remains sustainable by minimizing its dependence on its shareholders, Collect-a-Can has embarked on numerous self-funding initiatives, including using its experience and network to add value. This includes trading in associated products and acting as a consultant. The company has so far reached approximately 80% self-funding through these various activities. This last point creates one great opportunity for the company, which is to use the synergies that exist between the companies actively using steel and aluminium cans to create win/win opportunities by utilizing each other’s infrastructure. Collect-a-Can is motivated by the need to ensure that its actions address the country’s environmental needs. Given the increased focus on environmental pollution issues, the company aims to alleviate the need for the government to introduce any detrimental legislation pertaining to pollution and the beverage can, including placing customer deposits on cans for their use or the banning of the beverage can. The government has adopted a “the polluter pays” principle, and if the beverage industry does not proactively take shared responsibility then the government will be forced to do so and its actions will be far more expensive. The beverage industry understands that it is more cost-effective to fund Collect-a-Can than any government imposed alternatives. Through this system the companies also address social responsibility by providing an income to those who are unemployed and collect cans for money to survive. Collect-a-Can is striving to sustain their practices and give them an income. Unemployed entrepreneurs and local communities can be enlisted to help Collect-a-Can achieve the company’s goals in a sustainable way. The company is therefore a unique example of how manufacturers and suppliers of one-way packaging can address their environmental and social responsibilities while remaining economically viable and sustainable. About the National Business Initiative (NBI) The NBI is a leading non-profit organisation using business leadership and resources to meet the challenges of a country and a nation in transition. The NBI, as a voluntary coalition 150 foremost companies representing South Africa’s top business leadership, the NBI acts at the intersection of the private and the public sector to contribute to political, ecological and socio-economic stability and to enhance the country’s competitiveness as a key to sustained growth. The NBI is the WBCSD’s regional partner in South Africa. About the WBCSD The World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD) is a coalition of international companies united by a shared commitment to sustainable development via the three pillars of economic growth, ecological balance and social progress. Our members are drawn from more than 35 countries and 20 major industrial sectors. We also benefit from a Global Network of 40 national and regional business councils and partner organizations involving more than 1,000 business leaders globally. 4, chemin de Conches Tel: +41 (22) 839 31 00 E-mail: carpenter@wbcsd.org CH – 1231 Conches-Geneva Fax: +41 (22) 839 31 31 Web: www.wbcsd.org Switzerland