English Language Materials The Language Centre Newcastle University Avoiding plagiarism Writing for Arts and Social Sciences Teachers’ Notes and Answer Key Task 1 Discussion This task is intended to raise awareness of plagiarism and ways to avoid it. Discussion about the comments made by students A – F could highlight the following issues: Student A: Not all words can be changed (e.g.: technical terms, proper names must remain the same) It is not enough to change words. The sentence structure and style must also be the writer’s own (and therefore different from the original for the most part. Student B: Attitudes to plagiarism and tutors’ expectations about their students’ work vary from country to country and academic culture to academic culture. Plagiarism is indeed a serious matter in UK universities and international students must learn how to avoid it. Student C: Quotations should be used sparingly. An assignment that is little more than a series of quotations will not be awarded a good mark and may be failed. Student D: While this is true in some cultures, all students at UK universities must follow what is considered good academic practice in this country. Student E: There are two kinds of plagiarism: plagiarism of ideas and plagiarism of language, so ‘Yes’, it would be wrong to pass other people’s work off as our own. This includes failing to acknowledge published sources, copying another student’s work and getting another person to write an assignment for you. Student F: This is certainly one of the reasons why we must acknowledge source. Others are given above (Student E). A definition of plagiarism: The Mcmillan English Dictionary for Advanced Learners defines plagiarism as “the process of taking another person’s work, ideas or words, and using them as if they were your own.” 1S1 and 2S1: Writing letters of application – Teachers’ notes and answer key Created by Alicia Cresswell on 01/11/03 D:\106731577.doc Task 2 Recognising plagiarism Student 1: PLAGIARISED. This is a good summary of the source text but the source is not acknowledged. Student 2: PLAGIARISED. Although the source is acknowledged (author’s name and date in brackets at the end of the student text), the resulting text is almost identical to the source. Student 3: NOT PLAGIARISED: The source is acknowledged and the quotation is clearly marked as such by the use of quotation marks. Student 4: NOT PLAGIARISED: The source is acknowledged and most of the words in the source text have been changed. However, this is a rather mechanical approach to paraphrasing. If a longer text was given this treatment (i.e.: changing vocabulary only and leaving sentence structure intact), the student could be accused of plagiarising the source. Student 5: PLAGIARISED: This student made an attempt to change the sentence structure to begin with, but most of the text is virtually the same as the source, both in grammatical structure and vocabulary. The source is not acknowledged. Task 3 Vocabulary Word/phrase is source text The whole of southern Africa catastrophe the world has ever seen the productive generation is being hit has dropped has precipitated global outcry a revolution of sorts have prevented keep them alive delivered some gains those with vested interests in the status quo Could be replaced by: Countries in southern Africa crisis, disaster in human history people/adults in their prime is being affected has fallen has caused/generated worldwide protests demand for change have stopped save their lives had some success those who benefit from the current state of affairs 1S1 and 2S1: Writing letters of application – Teachers’ notes and answer key Created by Alicia Cresswell on 01/11/03 D:\106731577.doc Grammatical structure: Join these two sentences into one, incorporating changes to vocabulary whenever possible: It is the productive generation that is being hit – the workers, nurses, teachers, farmers and parents. In some countries, life expectancy has dropped to below 40. People’s lives are being cut short by disease, which has brought life expectancy down to less than 40 in some countries, thus drastically reducing the number of key workers and leaving many children orphaned. Split this long sentence into two, incorporating changes to vocabulary whenever possible: But although the revolution has begun and has delivered some gains in the shape of cheaper Aids drugs, there is every sign that those with vested interests in the status quo – the multinational pharmaceutical companies and the governments of countries where they are based – are now very effectively closing down the opportunities for future change. The demand for change has been so strong that cheaper Aids drugs are now available. However, further progress is unlikely because those who benefit from the current state of affairs, namely large pharmaceutical companies and the governments of some of the richest countries in the world, are doing all they can to protect their interests. Change the order of clauses in this sentence, incorporating changes to vocabulary whenever possible: But although the revolution has begun and has delivered some gains in the shape of cheaper Aids drugs, there is every sign that those with vested interests in the status quo – the multinational pharmaceutical companies and the governments of countries where they are based – are now very effectively closing down the opportunities for future change. Those who benefit from the current state of affairs, namely large pharmaceutical companies and the governments of some of the richest countries in the world, will continue to do everything in their power to protect their interests, and in so doing will put an end to the progress made in response to the growing demand for change. Style: The source text uses hyphens to introduce explanations. You should use other devices to do this; for example, the phrases “namely” or “that is to say”. The sentences in the source text are quite long. You could try writing shorter sentences. 1S1 and 2S1: Writing letters of application – Teachers’ notes and answer key Created by Alicia Cresswell on 01/11/03 D:\106731577.doc Task 5 Bergsten, C.F. and L.B. Krause (eds.) (1975) World Politics and International Economics. Washington: Brookings Institution. Kegley, C.W. and E.R. Wittkopf (2001) World Politics: Trend and Transformation 8th Edition. Basingstoke: Palgrave. Meek, J. (2001) The future’s bright, the future’s grey’. The Guardian Thursday 2 August 2001. Roberts, J. (2002) Environmental Policy. London: Routledge. Robertson, D.P. and R.B. Hall (2003) Public Ecology: An Environmental Science and Policy for Global Society. Environmental Science and Policy 6/5: 399-410. Wilkinson, D. and I. Skinner (2002) Environmental Sustainability in UK Structural Funds Programmes 2000-2006. Report published by the Institute for European Environmental Policy. Retrieved 03/11/03 from: http://www.ieep.org.uk/PDFFiles/PUBLICATIONS/EncSustainabilityInUKSFPro grammes.pdf 1S1 and 2S1: Writing letters of application – Teachers’ notes and answer key Created by Alicia Cresswell on 01/11/03 D:\106731577.doc