EXPERIMENT - VI PRODUCTION AND ANALYSIS OF POLARIZED LIGHT NOTE: The first thing is switching on the Hg spectral lamp so that it can warm up and stabilize. 1- OBJECTIVE AND THEORETICAL BASIS According to the theory of polarization, from a monochromatic light beam it is possible to obtain any kind of polarized light by using a linear polarizer and a /4 wave plate. With a second polarizer (sometimes referred to as analyzer) it is possible to analyze the resulting polarized beam. The first objective of this experiment is to establish the electric field oscillation (polarization plane) of a linearly polarized beam transmitted by a linear polarizer. There is an easy way to do this by putting a dielectric surface in the way of the beam (i.e. a prism glass of index n) and observing the reflected light. By changing the angle of incidence, we shall reach an angle for which the component of the field contained in the plane of incidence is not reflected, so that the reflected beam is polarized with the remaining light, i.e. in the plane perpendicular to the plane of incidence. (Plane of incidence: that containing the incident direction and the surface normal). The angle of incidence for which this phenomenon occurs is called the “Brewster angle”, after Brewster, the Scottish physicist who discovered its existence. Once we are on it, we change the orientation of the polarizer. By doing this, at some point we shall produce a beam with its electric field fully contained in the plane of incidence. For this situation we must have no reflected beam at all. In other words, for Brewster incidence we don’t have reflected parallel component, and by selecting the incident polarization, we don’t have perpendicular reflected component either, therefore obtaining null reflection (Fig.1). By finding this null, we can be certain of the polarization direction being parallel to the plane of incidence and also of the incident angle being the Brewster angle. Prism n No reflection! P Source Fig.1 Description of the situation in which no light is reflected on the polished surface of the prism. This is a combined effect of: a) the incident polarization, given by polarizer P, (parallel to the plane of incidence, the plane of the paper in this drawing); and b) the angle of incidence (equal to the Brewster angle ). The second objective is the production of light with circular polarization. When a beam is incident on a quarter-wave plate “/4” (Fig. 2) a /2 phase shift is introduced between the two orthogonal components of the electric field: the ordinary and extraordinary components, the first one perpendicular to the optical axis of the anisotropic material of which the plate is made, and the second parallel to it (in the case of retarder plates). For this geometry both components travel in the same direction, though at different speed, so that the outgoing beam is composed of two phaseshifted fields. For other geometries (i.e. incidence different than perpendicular) these components may have different propagation directions. This is the reason why they are also referred to as ordinary and extraordinary rays. The directions of these components on the plate are often named “neutral lines” of the plate. The reason is this: if the incident beam is linearly polarized along one of these lines, only one component will be excited, and no change in the polarization will be noticed. Let us see, however, what happens for an incident field linearly polarized and oriented in a given direction, forming an angle with a neutral line. The ordinary and extraordinary waves will be both excited, will propagate at different speed, and after crossing the plate they will have relative phase shift. This means that the polarized state of the beam has changed. The birefringence and the thickness of the plate are made so that the phase shift is exactly /2. In these conditions (see Fig.2), the resulting polarization is a centred ellipse, with different values for the main axes (the projections of the amplitude, Ecos and Esin) located along the direction of the neutral lines. E cos E cos E sen E sen E E Fig.2 Pass of a linearly polarized light beam through a wave ”/4” plate producing a centred elliptically polarized beam. In order to obtain circularly polarized light, the ellipse axes must be equal in magnitude (Ecos = Esin). This is achieved for a particular polarization angle of the incident field: =45°. Then, the ordinary and extraordinary components have the same amplitude, and the outgoing beam will be circularly polarized. To check the result we place an analyzer after the “/4” and notice how the transmitted intensity is constant for any transmission direction we choose for the analyzer. If the starting position of the polarizer P is, for instance, parallel to one the neutral lines, we should rotate the polarizer an angle 1=45° in order to obtain circular polarization after the quarter-wave plate. The third objective is the production of an elliptically polarized light beam, whose associated electrical field ellipse has certain ellipticity “e”. As we will see later, and because of the procedure we follow in this experiment, the ellipse has its main axes parallel and perpendicular to the horizontal plane, roughly the plane of the laboratory table. If the ellipticity is defined as e = ( Minor axis / Major axis ) Then, if we assume the polarizer in the position parallel to a horizontal neutral line, there must be two angles, 1 y 2, for the polarizer to rotate so that an ellipse of a given ellipticity “e” is reached: 1 (< 45°) such that e = ( sin1 / cos 1 ) = tan 1 , (a horizontal ellipse is obtained), and 2 (> 45°) such that e = ( cos2 / sin 2 ) = cotan 2 , (a vertical ellipse is obtained. This is the case represented in Fig.2). In order to obtain the same value e in both cases, 1 y 2 must verify: tan1 = cotan2 , and 1 and 2 appear as being complementary [1 = /2 - 2] Assuming a starting position with the light polarized in the direction of a horizontal neutral line, then we would only need to rotate the polarizer an angle 1=arctan(e) in order to obtain a horizontal ellipse of ellipticity e. By rotating 2=arc tan(e) a vertical ellipse of the same ellipticity is obtained. [COMMENT: In both cases the direction of the polarizer rotation is optional. Depending on the choice, the resulting ellipse will be dextro- (cw rotation of the field if the light comes to the observer) or levo- (ccw rotation of the electric field). As a result, we may obtain four ellipses with the same ellipticity value e] In summary, by keeping the /4 phase plate in a position where its neutral lines are horizontal and vertical, all ellipses originated from incident linear polarized light will be centred on these axes, and the ellipticity will be controlled by producing certain rotation in the incident polarization direction. In order to check that the resulting beam has the desired polarization we measure the maximum and minimum intensity transmitted through an analyzer along its 360º rotation for the transmission direction. Remind that the intensity is proportional to the square of the electric field amplitude. Thus, these intensities are related to the ellipticity as follows: (Minimum Intensity / Maximum Intensity) = ( Ellipse Minor Axis / Ellipse Major Axis )2 = e2 e I m ín I m áx 2-MATERIALS • Spectral lamp (Hg). • Goniometer. • External collimator for calibrating the goniometer. • Glass prism. • Two polarizers (one with angular scale). • A /4 phase plate. • Photo detector device. • Optical bench. • Filter for the green emission line of the Hg lamp. • Small diaphragm, suitable for the collimator arm of the goniometer. 3- ALIGNMENT AND EXPERIMENTAL SET-UP Place the polarizer and the filter between the lamp and the entrance pupil of the collimator arm of the goniometer, trying to obtain an homogeneous exit beam. Be careful with the lamp, it can be hot. If the output beam is already correct, don’t change it. Goniometer set-up: The fixed arm of the goniometer (collimator) has a lens, in which object focal point is placed a diaphragm. There is also a small holder where a second tiny diaphragm (about 1mm in diameter) can be slipped in. The second arm of the goniometer, a mobile telescope arm, will be used later to analyze the reflected light. Preparing the telescope arm: (This is a general procedure for any measurement carried out with the goniometer. Because in this experiment we only use this instrument to detect the null in the reflected light, the calibration is not a critical point, though it is always convenient). Place the small diaphragm in its place in the collimating arm. Focus the eyepiece of the telescope arm of the goniometer on the cross by moving it along inside its housing. With the lateral wheel of the telescope, and without changing the conditions of the eyepiece, focus is to infinity. (This is easy with an external collimator. Hold it in front of the telescope arm and focus the cross of the external collimator by moving the wheel. At this points you can see two reference crosses). Place the prism on the platform, and this at the correct height so that the beam reaches one of the prism faces. Now move the telescope arm, aiming at the collimating arm. Then, try to observe the image of the diaphragm. To get a sharp image move the wheel of the collimating arm. When done, the collimator is producing an image of the diaphragm in the infinity, easily observed with the telescope. We may put apart the telescope arm temporarily and remove the small diaphragm, so that we have a brilliant (though somewhat divergent) collimated beam that will be used to align the rest of elements. On the bench we shall place the /4 phase plate, the analyzer and the photo detector, all of them in the correct height and position as to be properly reached by beam. (Fig. 3 describes the order of the elements). Now, place again the small diaphragm in its holder. Polarizer Lamp Goniometer’s “/4” Analyzer Diaphragm Collimator Arm Photo detector Amplifier / Display Fig. 3 Series of elements on the bench for generating different kinds of polarized light 4- OPERATING METHOD 1.- Horizontal transmission of the first polarizer. Place the prism on the main platform of the goniometer. The platform must be horizontal (perpendicular to the rotation axis of the goniometer arm). This is achieved with the small screws under the platform. Adjust the height of the platform. The beam will reflect on a prism face with an angle o incidence equal to the Brewster angle, and the reflection should be observed through the telescope arm. We now turn the platform, in such a way that the angle of incidence on the prism approaches the Brewster angle (lets remind that this angle is measured from the surface normal). For a typical glass n 1.5, and tanB = n2/n1 1.5 => B 56° => The angle formed by the light and the face of the prism will be approximately 90-56=34º, and the angle formed by the incident and reflected beams, slightly over 110°. This is a good starting point to find the right position in a short time. The reflected beam has to be found with the telescope arm in such situation: We should observe only the sharp image of the small circular diaphragm, not a prolate figure, or a blurred image with a faint orange phantom, thus meaning that we are observing the light after some refractions in the prism. We can check now that the intensity of the image changes is we rotate the transmission direction of the incident polarizer, and we fix it in the minimum. Now, to get closer to Brewster incidence, we must slightly change the angle of incidence by rotating the central platform of the goniometer and following the reflected beam through the telescope arm, which must be rotated accordingly. This can be done in a few small steps, trying to obtain an intensity minimum as low as possible. Though zero is not possible (cause there is always an interval around Brewster), the intensity can be really low. You can check this zero with the person supervising the experiment, if you don’t feel sure about it. At this point, the polarizer transmission points in a direction parallel to the plane of incidence (the horizontal direction). We must take the angular position found for the polarizer. This measurement is done on a scale in 2º steps, with a vernier of 10 units, thus producing a 0,2º (12’) precision. This position will be our reference for horizontal polarization. 2.-Production of circularly polarized light. We first remove the small diaphragm and the prism used in the first part, and put the telescope arm apart, because it won’t be used again during the experiment. The linearly polarized beam goes through the /4 wave plate, the analyzer and the photo detector. Depending on the photo detector used for the experiment, an adequate procedure must be followed for the measurements. For instance, the “zero” of the photo detector must be adjusted to the background level of light in the laboratory. The zero is the darkness light, and the light coming from the lamp will be the measured intensity signal. Each time we change the scale, or change any other light source in the lab, the zero must be adjusted. In order to do it, the light coming from the Hg lamp must be blocked, but not the ambient background light coming from the lab. Very often photo detectors have a protection cap that must be removed, and sometimes they have two buttons for the coarse and fine adjustment of the zero. Remove temporarily the holder with the /4 wave plate, and rotate the analyzer till the photo detector signal gets as low as possible. (Sometimes this level is slightly under the calibrated zero, because the ambient light is partially polarized and is also modified by rotating the analyzer). At this point the polarizer and analyzer have orthogonal transmission directions (“crossed” polarizers). Let both polarizers in those positions and place again the /4 wave plate in its former location on the bench. An immediate increase in the detected signal will be observed. However, by rotating the /4 wave plate we should be able to reach the former minimum. Actually, we are calibrating the wave plate by aligning its neutral lines with the transmission direction of the polarizers (horizontal and vertical). If we now rotate 45° the first polarizer, the wave plate will produce circularly polarized light. This must be checked with a slow and complete turn on the analyzer. The maximum and minimum signal should be very similar (ideally equal, as corresponding to a constant projection). The ellipticity of the resulting light is: e = ( Minimum intensity / Maximum Intensity )1/2 3.- Production of elliptically polarized light of a given ellipticity e: (the actual value of e will be provided by the person supervising the experiment). First, we take the first polarizer to the initial position (horizontal transmission lines). From this position it will be rotated by: 1 : e = tan 1 => 1 = arc tan (e) ; 2 : e = cotan 2 => 2 = arc cotan (e) ; 1 + 2 = /2] After the wave plate we shall obtain elliptically polarized light, whose corresponding field axes will be found by measuring the minimum and maximum transmitted intensity in the detector when the analyzer is rotated. The actual value for the ellipticity is again given by: e = ( Minimum intensity / Maximum Intensity )1/2 Finally, and if you have some time left, the first polarizer is taken again to the initial position (horizontal transmission lines), and the same two rotations are made, 1 and 2, though this time in the opposite direction to that chosen in the first place. Again we check the ellipticity of the resulting polarizing ellipses with the analyzer and detector. 5- QUESTIONS 1.- To what extent do you think that parts 2 and 3 (production of circularly and elliptically polarized light) depend on the result of part 1 (linear polarization characterization)? In other words, do you think that the desired elliptically polarized beam can be obtained without previously finding the Brewster angle? 2.- What do you think is the difference between a polarizer and an analyzer? 3.- What would you expect from an experiment like this performed with the same elements but using, for instance, an orange spectral line, instead of the Hg green one? What do you think that would be different, and what would remain the same? 4.- Identify the main sources of error when producing polarized light in this experiment?