Eart 110N The Dynamic Earth Lab Lab#6—Earth’s Gravity Objectives: You will measure the rate of decrease of gravity with height in Baskin Engineering Building, using a Lacoste-Romberg gravimeter, and see how well it compares with the standard, calculated free air correction. You will then convert your relative gravity readings to absolute gravity values by comparison with the known value at a base station, find the free-air gravity anomaly for each of your gravity stations and, finally, calculate the Bouguer anomaly. Introduction: The absolute acceleration of gravity, g, as opposed to the universal gravitational constant, G, can be measured with considerable accuracy. One needs only to time the period of a precisely constructed pendulum or the duration of free fall of an object in a vacuum. Changes in gravity from one place to another can be measured even more accurately—to within one part in 108 or 109—with a gravimeter. By tying these relative changes to stations where absolute g is known, geophysicists made gravity maps of continental areas during the first half of the 20th century that revealed lateral variations in density of material below the surface. A Dutch geophysicist, Venning Meinesz, also made less accurate gravity maps of some oceanic areas by means of compensating (counter-swinging) pendulums mounted in a submarine. Now global gravity maps are made using satellites: by tracking perturbations in the orbits of satellites and by measuring small topographic variations in the sea surface. Earth’s gravity departs from that of a spherically symmetric body, GM/r2, because of its rotation. The centrifugal force causes the earth to bow out at the equator and in at the poles, giving it a spheroidal shape. This simple shape plus the direct effect of the centrifugal force dictate the average latitudinal variation of gravity: g() = geq(1 + sin2 + sin4) where is latitude and (1) geq = 978031.846 mgal (1 mgal = 10-3 cm/sec2 = 10-5 m/sec2) = 5.302359x10-3 = 5.8655x10-6 The value of g given by equation 1 is called gravity on the spheroid or standard gravity. These values of the numerical coefficients were adopted by the International Union of Geodesy and Geophysics in 1967 as providing the best fit of this smoothly varying function of latitude to the actual global gravity measurements at the time. Slightly better values could now be calculated, but the IUGG 1967 standard gravity formula is still retained in calculations of gravity anomalies for the sake of uniformity. The spheroid is the shape the earth would have if, while maintaining the same mass, lateral density variations along each thin spheroidal shell within the earth were smoothed away and a (shallower) ocean of uniform depth covered the surface. This shape is the reference surface for maps. Gravity anomalies are defined relative to that expected on the spheroid. For stations at sea level the gravity anomaly, which is always defined as the observed minus the expected value, is g gobs g(), because gexp is gravity on the spheroid—i.e., g() from equation 1. For stations above sea level, gexp is smaller than g() because the decrease in gravity with increasing distance above the spheroid is easily calculated and quickly swamps the variation in gravity due to lateral density variations inside the earth that we are most interested in. For the 1 elevation range found on earth this variation in gexp with elevation is, to a satisfactory approximation, the same as for a perfectly spherical earth, and is called the free air correction FA_corr. It is given by FA_corr GM earth g d GM earth ( ) Δh (2 ) Δh 2 Δh 0.3086 Δh mgal 2 3 dr r r r (2) where g is the average acceleration of gravity and h is elevation in meters. Then the free air anomaly is gFA gobs gexp = gobs (g() + FA_corr)= gobs (g() 0.3086h) (3) Its peculiar name stems from the notion that it only corrects for elevation above (or below) the spheroid, as though there were nothing but free air between the observation point and spheroid. On land, the Bouguer anomaly is a refinement of the free air anomaly that corrects approximately for the attraction of mass that lies above the spheroid. As shown in a lecture handout, the simple Bouguer correction is the attraction of a planar horizontal layer of infinite lateral extent and thickness h and is given by SB_corr = 2Gh = 0.1119h mgal (4) where h is elevation in meters and the density contrast is = rock air rock 2670 kg/m3. At sea the simple Bouguer correction is taken to be SB_corr = 2Gd = 0.0675d mgal (5) where d is ocean depth in meters and the density contrast is = seawater rock 1610 kg/m3. The simple Bouguer anomaly is gSB gobs gexp = gobs (g() + FA_corr +SB_corr) (6) Gravity Meter: The Lacoste-Romberg gravimeter is basically a mass suspended on a spring. It measures changes in gravity by measuring the amount the spring stretches or contracts. The instrument is insulated and connected to a battery and heater that keep it at a constant temperature. It is very sensitive and extremely delicate when the suspension is hanging free. Always keep the suspension clamped except when you are taking a reading!! Gravity Measurement Procedure: The procedure for each measurement will be: 1. Keeping the suspension clamped and the connection to the battery inside the case intact, remove the gravimeter, place it on the hemispherical support, turn on the light and level the instrument (exactly!). Exact leveling will be difficult or impossible if people are moving near the gravimeter. 2. Unclamp the instrument gently and completely (turn knob fully anticlockwise) and turn the big aluminum wheel left or right until the black pointer on the little round dial comes on scale. Turn the wheel so the pointer is well to the left of middle on the dial. Check and fine-tune level. 2 3. Look through the eyepiece and slowly turn the aluminum wheel toward larger values. The indicator line should be on the left side and moving slowly toward the middle. Check and finetune the level. Very slowly turn the aluminum wheel in the same direction until the left edge of the indicator line lines up with the 3.10 reading line. By always approaching the reading from the left side, you avoid possible backlash in the screw system and obtain more reproducible results. 4. Check the level one more time. If it is off, level the instrument again, back off the wheel so that the pointer is to the left of middle, and repeat step 3. If it is good, gently clamp the instrument all the way clockwise and turn off the light. 5. Record the time as well as the gravimeter reading. For example, if the digital dial reads 34054 and the aluminum wheel reads 446, the reading you should record is 3405.446—that is, the last digit on the dial should be the same as the first number on the aluminum wheel. The third number read from the wheel (6 in this example) will be very rough at best. 6. To make replicate measurements, repeat steps 2-5. 7. Carefully put the gravimeter back in the case, close the case up, and move to the next station.. Gravity Measurements: We will make our measurements at the Baskin Engineering Building to take advantage of a secondary base station where we know the value of absolute gravity. a. Station 1: Base station at circular paint spot on the concrete walkway just outside the stairway at the SW corner of the building (near the post office). Absolute g = 979900.55 mgal, elevation h = 243.2 1.5 m, and latitude = 37.000 N. b. Station 2: Ground floor inside the stairwell at the small white “X” marked on the floor. c. Station 3: First floor inside the stairwell at the small white “X” marked on the floor. d. Station 4: Second floor inside the stairwell at the small white “X” marked on the floor. e. Station 5: Third floor inside the stairwell at the small white “X” marked on the floor. f. Station 1: Base station again. Your two measurements of gravity and time will enable you to assess and correct for instrument drift, which you should assume occurred linearly with time. Elevation Measurements: Use the tape to measure the heights of the stations to the nearest centimeter above the base station. You will need to use a level to measure the height of station 2 above station 1. For the rest of the stations you can dangle the tape down the stairwell. Devise an accurate way to measure the elevation difference between stations 4 and 5, which is complicated by the presence of a concrete abutment that is in the way. Analysis: After you make the measurements, you should return to the lab and start your analysis of the data, which gets a little involved. You should try to finish steps 1-2 below and at least begin on steps 3-4, so you understand how to turn your readings into absolute milligals. At home you can enter your data into spreadsheet rows for each station and complete your analysis and discussion. 1. Each gravimeter manufactured is calibrated against a known g change when it is manufactured or repaired, and each has a different set of multiplicative constants to use to adjust 3 the relative gravity differences to milligals. In our case, assuming the readings are between 3400 and 3500, convert your reading to milligals using Adjusted Value = 3596.98 + 1.06096(Gravimeter Reading 3400) (7) 2. Use base-station readings a and f to estimate the drift rate. Then correct the individual readings for drift by using the time each of them was made. If replicate measurements were made, find the mean and standard deviation for the drift-corrected readings at each station. 3. Enter your relative elevations, times, and drift-corrected gravimeter readings for each station in Excel, and use equation 7 to adjust them to relative milligals. These ‘adjusted’ g values should be placed in the column next to the drift-corrected raw values. 4. Enter the value of absolute gravity for the base station in the next cell to the right of its adjusted gravimeter reading. Use this to convert your relative gravity readings at stations 2 through 5 to absolute gravity values in milligals and enter them in the same column containing the adjusted value for station 1. Using the base station elevation above sea level, figure and enter elevations above sea level for stations 2 through 5 and place them in the next column to the right. 5. Plot your absolute gravity values versus elevation above sea level in Excel. Show the bestfitting straight line to your points, the equation of this line, and the R2 value describing the goodness of fit. To do this, select your graph rectangle, use menu commands Chart/Add Trendline/Options and choose ‘Linear’ to show the best-fit line, and check the boxes to display the equation and R-squared value on the chart. Select the panel on your chart containing the equation of the line and R2 and, using menu commands Format/Selected Data Labels/Number, click ‘Number’ and dial in 4 decimal places. 6. How well does the coefficient of x in the equation of your best-fit line agree with the calculated coefficient of h in the free air correction (equation 2)? Calculate the percent difference between the two. 7. Evaluate whether the difference could be entirely due to measurement uncertainties. In other words, estimate the percent errors in your measurement of gravity and height differences between the ground and third floors. Are they big enough to account for the discrepancy in the coefficients in number 6 above? Or is it necessary to ascribe the discrepancy to some real differences between the real earth and the simplified earth model assumed in equation 2? 8. Use equation 3 and the latitude to calculate* the free air anomaly for stations 1 through 5, placing these values in the next column to the right. 9. Use equation 6 to calculate* the Bouguer anomaly for the station 1. 10. Generally, Bouguer anomalies are large and negative (e.g., ~ 100 mgal) over continents and large and positive (e.g., ~ +100 mgal) over ocean basins, whereas free air anomalies are small on average over both continents and oceans (e.g., 10 to 30 mgal). How typical is our base station? Any ideas to explain the abnormalities? (P.S. I don’t have the answer to this one myself.) * Be careful to keep track of the signs of the corrections in your calculations! 4