PTC Assessment-Teacher Version
ARISE Curriculum.
PTC Lab Inquiry-based Assessment
S. Gell draft 5 2.2.10
Notes for teachers: The questions are annotated both by level of difficulty
and by focus. The difficulty levels roughly correspond with Blooms
Taxonomy:
Level I. Knowledge, Comprehension
Level II Application, Analysis,
Level III. Synthesis, Evaluation, Creation.
Given that this document is designed to mimic an inquiry-based lab
activity, the focus is on the higher levels of Blooms. However, for some
students questions that are particularly difficult may not be appropriate.
As for content, I have labeled questions that relate directly to the PTC lab
as Core Content (CC) while questions that relate to extension activities will
be annotated as EX.
In the PTC lab we examined natural variation in a human gene for tasting
PTC. Use what you learned in this laboratory exercise to help you answer
questions about guppies and their ability to see colored patterns.
Guppies are small fish that live in warm fresh water. Male guppies are
known for their brightly colored patterns. These patterns are thought to be
important for mate choice, with females preferring males that have bright
and unusual coloring patterns1.
”Sexy” Male Guppy (Image from Ref 1)
Q1: (II, CC) A. For a male guppy, what would be one a major advantage
and one major disadvantaged of having very brightly colored tails in the
wild? [Broad area 1.1]
Advantage – brightly colored males would be more attractive to mates
and therefore likely to have more offspring.
Disadvantage – brightly colored males might be more visible to predators
1
PTC Assessment-Teacher Version
Scientists studying guppy behavior noticed that the females needed to
be able to detect Ultra-Violet (UV) light to make decisions about the
quality of the markings on males2. Humans cannot see colors in this range,
but many animals can. In order to detect UV light, animals must have a
UV-light receptor in their eye. This receptor gene is called opsin. Scientists
sequenced the opsin gene from two related species of guppies.
The genomic sequence for part of the UV-light receptor (opsin) for the
two guppy species is below.
Species 1: P.reticulata
CTG GTT TGC TGG ACA CTT TAC GCC AGT GTA GCC TGG TAC ATC TTC TCA AAT CAG
_L__V__C__W___T___L__Y__A___S__ V__A___W__Y__ I__ F___S__N__Q
Species 2: G. holbrooki
CTG GTT TGC TGG ATA CCT TAC GCC AGT GTG GCC TGG TAC ATC TTC ACA CAT CAG
_L__V__C__W___T___L__Y__A___S__ V__A___W__Y__ I__ F___I__H__Q
Q2: (I,CC) [LS1(9-11)-2a,c]
A. Translate each DNA sequence into an amino acid sequence using your
codon table. Write the answer on the line provided below the sequence.
B. Circle any coding changes in the amino acid sequence.
C. Put a box around any silent or non-coding changes in the DNA
sequence.
Q3: (II or III,CC) A light receptor, like a taste receptor, is used to sense a
particular signal and then transmit that information to the brain. How
might changes to amino acid sequence effect a light receptor? [LS1(911)FAF+POC-2b]
Any reasonable answer would be acceptable. Ideas: Mutations in the
receptor could affect its ability to detect light. (ie sensitivity, light
wavelength/color) Mutations could also affect the ability of the receptor
to send messages into the cell or could affect the receptors ability to be
correctly made and placed in the right location in the cell. I would also
accept an answer that suggested changes in amino acid sequence
2
PTC Assessment-Teacher Version
could change the way the protein folds making it work improperly or
differently.
Q4: You noticed that sequence TTCTCA (P. reticulata) is recognized by
the restriction enzyme FshI, but the sequence to TTCACA in G. holbrooki is
not.
A. (II, CC) How could you use the restriction enzyme FshI to distinguish
between samples of DNA from these two species?
I would place both DNA samples (actually PCR products) with the enzyme
and only the P. reticulata sample would be cut by the enzyme. When you
run the digested samples on a gel the P. reticulata sample would have
two bands while the G. holbrooki sample would only have one.
Q5. You have discovered a new population of guppies and want to
determine if the opsin gene in this population has the same
polymorphisms (nucleotide changes) as the other species.
A. (II, CC) Explain how the FshI enzyme could be used to help you
determine this.
If the new population has the P. reticulata allele, the DNA from this
population will be cut by the FshI enzyme, if it has the G. holbrooki allele it
will not.
A1. (III, CC). If the restriction enzyme cuts the DNA from fish in the new
population of guppies, can you be confident that the fish carry the P.
reticulata allele? If the enzyme does not cut the DNA what does that tell
you about the DNA sequence?
If FshI cuts the DNA then one can assume that sequence in the new fish is
the same as P. reticulata. However, if the new population had a novel
gene sequence at this site the enzyme would fail to cut giving a
misleading result. *Answering this question correctly requires a high level
understanding of the use of restriction enzymes. I would consider it an
extension question for students that need an additional challenge.
B. (II, CC) Starting with DNA isolation describe the 4 major steps in this
experiment and briefly explain why you need to do each.
1. DNA isolation – DNA isolation is required to remove any material
(such as DNAases which could degrade DNA) that would interfere
with later steps in the experiment.
3
PTC Assessment-Teacher Version
2. PCR amplification – PCR allows us to generate many copies of
the sequence of DNA between the primers. This allows us to see the
DNA when we run it on a gel
3: Restriction Digest – The restriction digest cuts DNA that carries the
sequence recognized by the restriction enzymes. In this experiment
it will allow us to determine which allele each fish has.
4. Gel Electrophoresis. Gel electrophoresis will allow us the
visualized the digested and undigested DNA and so we can
determine the type of alleles in the new population of guppies.
C. (II, CC) After you cut the DNA with FshI what would you expect to see
if the new population contained fish that were homozygous for the P.
reticulata allele? For the G. holbrooki allele? What would you see if there
were heterozygous fish?
If the population is homozygous for the P. reticulata allele then each
sample should have two bands when cut. If the sample is homozygous for
G. holbrooki allele then there will only be one band in each sample. If the
sample is heterozygous there will be three bands in the digested sample
two from the cut P. reticulata allele and one from the uncut G. Holbrooki
allele.
D. (II,CC) What controls would you include in this experiment to show the
genotypes of fish from the new population of guppies? [Broad Area 2.5]
Students should include undigested controls for all samples. There should
also be samples of both P. reticulata and G. holbrookie (digested and
undigested) included as positive controls for comparison.
4
PTC Assessment-Teacher Version
Q6: (II, CC) You tested 6 individuals from the new population of guppies.
Based on the data below determine if each individual is homozygous for
the P. reticulata allele (P/P) or the G. Holbrooki allele (G/G) or is
heterozygous for the two alleles (G/P) [Broad area 3.10, LS1(9-11)-2b,
LS3(9-11)-7a]
U = uncut (not digested with FshI), C = cut (digested with FshI)
Genotype of individual samples. (G/G, P/P G/P)
1 __G/G__
2 __G/P__
3.___P/P_
4.___G/P_
5.___P/P_
6.___G/P_
Q7: (III, Ex) Following your observation that different populations of
guppies have different alleles of the opsin gene, you want to determine
which allele represents the ancestral state of the guppy opsin gene. How
might you do this? [Broad area 2.4, LS3(9-11)-6a]
Compare the sequence of the opsin gene from the guppies to a distantly
related species of fish. Whichever species’ opsin sequence most closely
matches the sequence of the distantly related species likely represents
the ancestral sequence of the gene.
5
PTC Assessment-Teacher Version
Q8: (II, Ex) By looking at the data below, determine which allele (P.
reticulata or G. holbrooki) is most likely the ancestral state of the guppy
opsin and explain how the data supports your hypothesis. [Broad area 1.2
and 4.12, LS3(9-11)-8d]
Common ancestor
Zebrafish
G. holbrooki
P. reticulata
P.reticulata: TGG ACA CTT TAC GCC AGT GTA GCC TGG TAC ATC TTC TCA AAT CAG
G. holbrooki: TGG ATA CCT TAC GCC AGT GTG GCC TGG TAC ATC TTC ACA CAT CAG
Zebrafish*
TGC ATA CTT TAC GCC AGT GTA GCC TGG TAC ATC TTC TCA AAT CAG
Answer here: The sequence from the opsin gene of P. reticulata most
closely matches the distantly related species zebrafish. (only one
difference in nucleotide sequence, compared to 4 differences for G.
holbrookie). Therefore, the common ancestor of both guppies and
zebrafish most likely had a sequence close to the P. reticulata sequence.
Q9: (III, CC) Imagine that P. reticulata live in only clear, fast moving,
rocky streams while G. holbrooki live in slow moving water with lots of
green algae that can block the light. Make a hypothesis regarding what
selective pressures could be driving the evolution of the opsin gene of
these fishes. Remember opsin is important for detection of light in the
eye. [LS3(9-11)-7c,8a Broad area 1.1]
The mutations in the opsin gene of G. holbrooki may have evolved in
response to the selective pressure of low light conditions. Under these
conditions the opsin gene may have evolved to be more sensitive to low
light or to detect colors of light more likely to penetrate the dark green
algae.
6
PTC Assessment-Teacher Version
Q10. (III, CC) Based on your data from the newly discovered population of
guppies, what type of environment do you think these fish might have
come from? Explain your reasoning. [Broad area 1.1, 4.12]
I would accept any reasonable answer if well supported. Here are a few
examples.
1. The new population might live in a mixed environment where they
experience both clear quick water and slow green water either because
of water quality changes at different times of year or because of the close
proximity of these different environments. This is suggested by the
presence of both allele types. If different allele types confer different
abilities to see light, fish with both receptors might have an advantage in
a mixed environment.
2. The fish may have recently shifted from one type of environment to
another and are currently undergoing adaptation and population shift
from mostly one allele type to another.
3. There are slightly more P alleles (7) in our sample population than G
alleles (5), this might lead students to conclude the water is more like the
environment for P. reticulata than the environment of G. holbrooki.
References
1. Olendorf et al. Frequency-Dependent Survival in Natural Guppy
Populations. Nature. Vo1 144. 1 June 2006.
2. Smith et al. Ultraviolet Vision and Mate Choice in the Guppy.
Behavioral Ecology. Vo1 13. 2002.
* Not based on real data.
7