English/ESL unit Romeo and Juliet A teaching unit for Stage 5 English with links to ESL pedagogy NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 1 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au A student: 1. responds to and composes increasingly sophisticated and sustained texts for understanding, interpretation, critical analysis and pleasure 2. uses and critically assesses a range of processes for responding and composing 3. selects, uses, describes and explains how different technologies affect and shape meaning 4. selects and uses language forms and features, and structures of texts according to different purposes, audiences and contexts, and describes and explains their effects on meaning 5. transfers understanding of language concepts into new and different contexts English syllabus Stage 5 outcomes 6. experiments with different ways of imaginatively and interpretively transforming experience, information and ideas into texts 7. thinks critically and interpretively using information, ideas and increasingly complex arguments to respond to and compose texts in a range of contexts 8. investigates the relationships between and among texts 9. demonstrates understanding of the ways texts reflect personal and public worlds 10. questions, challenges and evaluates cultural assumptions in texts and their effects on meaning 11. uses, reflects on, assesses and adapts their individual and collaborative skills for learning with increasing independence and effectiveness. NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 2 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources Introduction to Shakespeare and stage play 2.2 Students learn to use writing and representing as an aid to research, planning, classifying information and learning 5.9 Students learn about the selection, organisation and coherence of information and ideas in texts 5.7 Students learn about predicting, speculating, hypothesising and paraphrasing as strategies for accessing texts with unfamiliar ideas and structures 4.1e Contribute information and express ideas in group tasks and classroom discussion. Research the life of Shakespeare by brainstorming what students already know about Shakespeare and the era in which he lived. Handout 1:The life of Shakespeare 6.8e Take notes when reading texts for information and organise them for learning purposes. Visit the library and ask students to find 10 facts about Shakespeare’s life and his plays using the Internet, CDROM and reference books. Internet access 5.5h Transfer information from texts into given formats (tables, diagrams, story maps). 6.8e Take notes when reading texts for information and organise them for learning purposes. 11.5 Students learn to use individual and group processes to generate, investigate, document, clarify, refine critically evaluate and present ideas and information drawn from books, the internet and other sources of information. NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate Handout 2: The Globe Theatre Working in groups of three, students read Handout The Life of Shakespeare. Ask students to use their library research information and the information from the handout to create a timeline of the key events in Shakespeare’s life. Students should select the events and details they think are most relevant to someone studying one of Shakespeare’s plays. Groups present their timeline and explain choices to the class. Research The Globe Theatre. Give students research questions on the Globe Theatre. Students will need access to the Internet to complete their research. If time or computer access is limited, divide the questions into lots of 3 or 4 and distribute to students in pairs. Discuss findings as a class. November 2004 Page 3 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales 10.9 Students learn about the ways in which particular texts relate to their cultural experiences and the culture of others. 4.1e Contribute information and express ideas in group tasks and classroom discussion. 8. 4 Students learn to track and explain the treatment of a common theme or idea in a range of texts in different modes and media. 4.6c Respond to different cultural attitudes and practices as exemplified in stories (express opinion, ask questions, make comparisons). 7.1 Students learn to ask perceptive and relevant questions, make logical predictions, draw analogies and challenge ideas and information in texts. 7.4 Students learn to compare and contrast aspects of texts 7.8 Students learns to demonstrate abstract principles through concrete examples. 5.6 c Identify some common social and literary stereotypes in texts (villains and heroes, traditional gender roles). 5.6d Identify key aspects of narrative (theme, plot, final resolution). Teaching and learning activities Resources 2. Romeo and Juliet – developing background knowledge Discuss as a class: What are some of the great love stories of modern times, from different cultures and from past times? Draw on stories from novels, film, television, plays and poetry including the students’ cultures. Examples for discussion have been provided in the table Romeo and Juliet and other love stories. Students should come up with their own examples and identify similarities and differences in the themes and plots of a range of love stories to complete table in OHT1. OHT 1: Romeo and Juliet and other love stories Consider: Who are the main characters in love stories? What are the problems or complications that these characters deal with? How do the love stories usually end? 5.1i Make simple hypotheses and generalisations. 7.9 Students learn about the ways bias, stereotypes, perspectives and ideologies are constructed in texts, NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 4 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources 7.11 Students learn about generalisations, clichés, appeals to authority, and appeals to popularity and public opinion. 4.1e Contribute information and express ideas in group tasks and classroom discussion. Ask students what they know about the story of Romeo and Juliet. Create a plot overview on the board. 4.9 Students learn about appropriate language forms and features and structures of texts to use in an increasingly wide range of contexts 6.5m Complete Handout 3. Link the discussion back to the love stories given as examples in OHT 1. including the codes and phrasings that signal them 4.10 Students learn about the metalanguage for describing, explaining and justifying the composer’s choices of language forms and features and structures of texts in terms of purpose, audience and context. Make comparisons between different texts by the same author or make judgements about different texts on the same topic. 5.1i Make simple hypotheses and generalisations. Discuss the ending of Romeo and Juliet and introduce the term ‘tragedy’. Handout 3: Shakespeare’s plays Consider: Why does tragedy seem to be less popular in modern love stories, particularly in film? Why are some of the most enduring love stories tragedies? Focus terms include: characters setting plot conflict fate free will tragedy resolution themes 4.11 Students learn about the influence of purpose, audience and context on the use of particular language forms and features and structures of texts. 4.13 Students learn about NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 5 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources codes and conventions, including emotive, evocative and impersonal language and signs, used to signal tone, mood and atmosphere in spoken, written and visual texts. 4.14 Students learn about the appropriateness of the use of Standard English, its variations and levels of usage. NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 6 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources 9.1 6.5k Hypothesise using information from the text (about author, character, ideas and events). 3. Viewing the film Zeffirelli film version of Romeo and Juliet Demonstrate understanding of the main storyline and most key information points when retelling or paraphrasing. Students create a viewing log in their books by drawing up 4 columns to complete whilst viewing: character development, issues in plot, themes, film techniques. 9.2 7.3 Students learn to respond to and compose texts that reflect their expanding worlds from the personal to the public. Students learn to relate the content and ideas in texts to the world beyond the texts. Students learn to infer from and interpret texts 11.10 Students learn to use conjecture and hypothesis as learning strategies 4.5c 5.8h Use a dictionary or thesaurus to check understanding of key words. Students read the list of characters at the beginning of the play and discuss what roles and relationships they think the characters will have. View the first few scenes of Zeffirelli’s Romeo and Juliet. Stop briefly early in the film and ask students: Which characters have we seen so far? Which will have the most important roles? (Ensure students are clear about the relationships between the families and within each family.) What problems are going to arise? What questions do you want answered at this point? View about one hour of the film, completing the log as they go. Finalise viewing of the film revising and summarising at the start of each lesson the key events. 1.1 Students learn to respond to and compose a range of imaginative, factual and critical texts which are increasingly demanding in terms of their linguistic, structural, cognitive and emotional and moral complexity. 5.8g Incorporate new vocabulary from texts into personal vocabulary (specialised terminology). NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate Post viewing activities Plot sequencing activity (Handout 4a). Students place key events of plot into the order that they happened in the film. Handout 4a: Sequencing the events from the plot Display OHT 2. Students match characters to appropriate adjectives chosen. As they read Romeo and Juliet, they will collect quotes and actions that describe a character. OHT 2: After viewing the film November 2004 Page 7 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content 4.8 4.14 Students learn about the ways in which spoken, written and visual texts are shaped according to personal, historical, cultural, social and technological workplace contexts. Students learn about the appropriateness of the use of Standard English, its variations and levels of usage. ESL Scales Develop understanding that languages change over time. Identify patterns of change in the English language over time. 5.8d 5.8g Ask for guidance and support from the teacher to accomplish specialised reading tasks. Incorporate new vocabulary from texts into personal vocabulary (specialised terminology). Teaching and learning activities Resources 4. The language of Shakespeare’s time The following tasks are to prepare students and give them confidence in engaging with the play, Romeo and Juliet. Explain to students that the English language has changed significantly over the last centuries. English can be divided into Old English, Middle English and Modern English. Give students Handout 5a with examples of English texts written over the last 1200 years. Handouts 5a and 5b: Old English, … Working in groups, ask students to place the texts in order from the one they think is the oldest to the one they think is the most modern. Answers to 5a and 5b Students then place all of the texts on the cline in Handout 5b, according to those which they think are Modern English, Old English and Middle English. Put up OHT with correct answers and a definition of modern English. Explain to students that they will become increasingly confident and comfortable with Shakespearean English the more that they hear, read and use the language. Read student Handouts 5c and 5d on Shakespearean language as a class. Start the activities as a class. Handouts 5c, 5d and 5e: The language of Shakespeare Homework handout: Terms of address in Shakespeare’s time Homework: Terms of address vocabulary match-up. 5. Engaging with the playscript 3.1 Students learn to respond to and compose increasingly 5.6f Identify important conventions of texts (chapters in a book NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate Before starting the playscript, consider with students some of the differences between film and stage play. Use Handout November 2004 Page 8 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content complex texts in different technologies considering the effects of the technology including layout and design on meaning. 1.8 Students learn about the features of increasingly complex imaginative, factual and critical texts, including the cognitive, emotional and moral dimensions of the text and its linguistic and structural features. ESL Scales etc) 5.8g Incorporate new vocabulary from texts into personal vocabulary (specialised terminology 4.8a Use knowledge of sentence structure and text organisation to identify meaning of unknown words (in cloze activities). 4.4 A student learns to experiment with and explain altered perceptions of ideas and information that result from changes in language features and structures. 1.6 A student learns to respond to and compose texts that use inference and figurative language, such as symbolism and illusion, in complex and subtle ways. Teaching and learning activities Resources 6 to guide discussion and to familiarise students with the text layout of a playscript. Handout 6: A stage play – one more medium Class copies of the play Romeo and Juliet The Prologue: Read the prologue to Romeo and Juliet. Handout 7a: Vocabulary matching Discuss with students: What is a prologue? Why does the play have a prologue? What does the prologue tell the audience? What is the role of the chorus in the play? Handout 7b: Romeo and Juliet, The Prologue Handout 7c (optional): The Prologue Students match the terms and definitions from The Prologue. (recently arrived ESL students) Students complete cloze exercise on the prologue and complete student activities. Place students in groups and ask them to write out a plain English version of the prologue or sequence the plain English version provided. (recently arrived ESL students.) Discussion questions: What have we learned from the prologue? Why do you think the audience has been told the ending at the start of the play? 1.7 Students learn about the ideas, NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 9 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources information, perspectives and ideologies presented in increasingly demanding imaginative, factual and critical texts and the ways they are presented. 6. (a) Close analysis of the play 1.1 Students learn to respond to and compose a range of imaginative, factual and critical texts which are increasingly demanding in terms of their linguistic, structural, cognitive, emotional and moral complexity. 4.8 Students learn about the ways in which spoken, written and visual texts are shaped according to personal, historical, cultural, social, technological and workplace text. 4.4c Use language acquired from new sources or experiences (excursions, performances, conversations, English-speaking peers). 4.6a Talk about the text, relating ideas to personal experience or previous learning. 4.6b Make comparisons with own country and culture when reading. Class copies of the play. Briefly revise the plot sequence and discuss what happens in scene i. Read the scene as a class. Shakespearean insults can be found at http://www.wardell.org/jotd/shake spearean_insults.htm Discuss how the fight erupted between the servants. Introduce some of the insults used in Shakespeare’s time and encourage students to experiment with insulting each other in Shakespearean English. (Go to the web site referred to in the resources column for an easy sheet on constructing a Shakespearean insult. There are many other examples on the web). Create a mindmap of the kinds of topics and actions that were considered insulting in Shakespeare’s time. Compare this to the topics and actions that are considered insulting today. (e.g. insult to employer, family, etc.) 4.6g Show awareness that different cultures may have different interpretations of text (in class discussion about a character’s action in NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate Act I, scene i: Focus on the fight November 2004 Page 10 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources a story). 1.6 Students learn to respond to and compose texts that use inference and figurative language, such as symbolism and illusion, in complex and subtle ways. 5.9 Students learn about the selection, organisation and coherence of information and ideas in texts. 4.9f Reconstruct a text (using notes or through discussion). 7.10g Mimic or parody particular styles (write a fairy story written in modern times). 6.6j 9.2 Students learn to relate the content and ideas in texts to the world beyond the texts Demonstrate understanding of some literary devices such as metaphors and similes in context (sour grapes). Discuss Romeo’s behaviour in this scene. He seems to be separated from the events of this scene. Why? What do students think of Romeo’s behaviour? Handout 8: Courtly love Introduce idea of courtly love. Explain what a dictagloss is and ask students to take notes in pairs as you read the conventions of courtly love from Handout 8. Key words need to be provided and explained before listening: Courtly love, social class, advances, perform deeds, consumed, jealous. Follow-up Students complete the discussion questions from Handout 8 in groups. Ask students to brainstorm a set of modern rules for love from either the perspective of the man (as in the handout) or of a young woman. 9.7 Students learn about the ways personal perspective is shaped by social, cultural and historical influences Note: Question 1 on Handout 8 can be completed after the work on oxymoron. Questions 2 and 3 will need to be completed at the appropriate time as students read the play. 4.4c Use language NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate Courtly love Place students in pairs to reconstruct the conventions and rules focusing on the main ideas. 9.6 Students learn about the ways different and changing views of the world shape meaning 9.9 Students learn about aspects of their own context that influence Act I, scene i: Focus on Romeo Oxymoron: Taking a closer look at the language used by Romeo in this scene. November 2004 OHT 3: Shakespeare’s language Page 11 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content their responses and compositions 4.10 Students learn about the metalanguage for describing, explaining and justifying the composer’s choices of language forms and features and structures of texts in terms of purpose, audience and context. ESL Scales acquired from new sources or experiences (excursions, performances, conversations, English-speaking peers). Teaching and learning activities Resources Explain to students what an oxymoron is. Ask them to complete the table in OHT 2 trying to explain the meaning and effect of the language in this scene. Discuss and jointly, or independently write a paragraph responding to the following question: How does the use of oxymoron help to shape the audience’s view of Romeo’s character at this stage in the play? 4.11 Students learn about the influence of purpose, audience and context on the use of particular language forms and features and structures of texts. NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 12 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content 7.3 Students learn to infer from and interpret texts ESL Scales 6 (b) Close analysis of the play Copies of the play Act I, scene ii 6.5b Participate in class /group discussions of text interpretations. Discuss the servant in this scene. 4.2 Students learn to describe, explain and evaluate the composer’s choices of language forms and features and structures of texts in terms of purposes, audience and context. 6.6b 4.8 6.10b Use and sustain a register appropriate to subject content, purpose and audience. Infer the purpose, audience and context of particular texts. 6.12d Plan with particular audiences in mind. 5.10h Sustain an appropriate tone throughout a text. 6.12e Monitor writing to ensure that register has been NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate Resources 4.1e Contribute information and express ideas in group tasks and classroom discussions. 6.5c Give own opinion of a text and compare it with Students learn about the ways in which spoken, written and visual texts are shaped according to personal, historical, cultural, social, technological and workplace contexts Teaching and learning activities Briefly revise the plot sequence and discuss what happens in scene ii. Read the scene as a class. What problem does the servant have? How does he solve the problem? This scene is quite humorous. Who is Shakespeare making fun of in this scene? Is this an important scene in the context of the whole story? Why? Creating an invitation to the ball (Recommended for Year 9) Look at some examples of modern invitations, e.g. compare a text message with a child’s party invitation and an invitation to a wedding. In what ways are the invitations different and why? Ask students to label the language structures and features of each text. Discuss as a class how the invitation to the ball in Romeo and Juliet might be similar or different from these invitations. What information, language and layout would be suitable for the invitation to the ball? Teacher-selected resources: 3 examples of invitations. Students should also be encouraged to bring in an invitation they have sent or received to compare invitations across cultures. Teacher created labels for the language structures and features of invitations. As a class jointly compose the opening lines of an invitation to the ball. Students use this to create their own invitation to the Capulet Feast. Marking criteria: November 2004 Page 13 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales maintained. Teaching and learning activities 4.10 Students learn about the metalanguage for describing, explaining and justifying the composer’s choices of language forms and features and structures of texts in terms of purpose, audience and context. 6.5b Participate in class and group discussions of text interpretations. 4.3 Students learn to use appropriate language forms and features and structures of texts in their own compositions and describe, explain and justify their choices in terms of purpose, audience and context. Resources use of appropriate language for the period and for the context of the ball use of appropriate layout and decoration for the social purpose and historical context use of appropriate Shakespearean terms of address effective layout and appealing choice of colour and decoration. 6 (c) Close analysis of the play Read Act 1, scene v What is the significance of this scene in terms of the whole play? Discuss the tradition of the mask ball. Who participated in it? Why might this tradition have been fashionable in Shakespeare’s time? What would the audiences’ reaction or attitude be to a masked ball? 6.2 Students learn to respond imaginatively and interpretively to an increasingly demanding range of literary and nonliterary texts. NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 14 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources Year 10 only Zeffirelli film version of Romeo and Juliet. 7.3 Students learn to infer from and interpret texts. 6.8 Students learn about ways in which film-makers transform concepts into film, including consideration of script, story lines, sustained perspective, and visual and aural components of filmmaking and their interaction View the ball section in both the Zeffirelli and Baz Luhrmann (M rated) versions of the film*. Students take notes on the way colour has been used for the masks and costumes of different characters in this scene. Please note: The Baz Luhrmann film version is rated M. Students should be 15 years and over to view this film and must have a signed parental permission form. The Baz Luhrmann version of Romeo and Juliet is M rated. Students should be 15 years and over and must have a signed parental permission form. * See suggestions for other scenes to compare on the next page. 2.9 Students learn about processes of representation including use of symbols, images, icons, stereotypes, connotations, inference, and particular visual and aural techniques including those of camera, design and sound, to create cohesive texts. 4.6g Show awareness that different cultures may have different interpretations of text (in class discussion about a character’s actions in a story). Ask students to complete the table in Handout 9 comparing the use of symbolism across cultures and use the table format to identify the use of colour and other symbolism in each film to suggest aspects of character, e.g. red for Tybalt. Handout 9: Symbolism Discuss the findings from each film and write a paragraph describing how colour has been used in each film to portray the personalities of different characters. 10.1 Students learn to identify cultural elements expressed in the language, NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 15 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources structure and content of texts drawn from popular culture, cultural heritages and the workplace. 10.9 Students learn about the ways in which particular texts relate to their cultural experiences and the cultures of others. 4.2 A student learns to describe, explain, and evaluate the composer’s choices of language forms and features and structures of texts in terms of purpose, audience and context. 4.3 Students learn to use appropriate language forms and features and structures of texts in their own compositions and describe, explain and justify their choices in terms of purpose, audience and context. 4.10 Students learn about the metalanguage for describing, explaining NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 16 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources 6.1g Organise and present ideas in a short talk to an audience. Ask students to create a mask for themselves to attend the ball. Liaise with the art staff to explore the possibility of a joint project to produce the masks. Materials to create masks. Liaise with the creative arts faculty if possible. and justifying the composer’s choice of language forms and features and structures of texts in terms of purpose, audience and context. 6.5 Students learn to experiment with ways of representing the real world imaginatively 6.2f Use suitable language to engage listeners when beginning to speak. Students prepare a 1–2 minute talk explaining the ideas that they wanted to convey about themselves through their mask and how they attempted to convey these ideas. 6.4f Evaluate their own communication against given criteria. 8.1 Students learn to identify and describe the similarities and differences between and among ore demanding texts. 8.9 Students learn about similarities of approach, attitude, intent, point of view, perspective and style in texts by different composers. NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate Suggested additional viewing tasks Compare the two film interpretations of: the balcony scene the fight scene the tomb scene. November 2004 Page 17 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources 4.2 Students learn to describe, explain and evaluate the composer’s choices of language forms and features and structures of texts in terms of purpose, audience and context. 6.6j Demonstrate understanding of some literary devices such a metaphors and similes in context (sour grapes). 7. Metaphor and other imagery in Act 1, scene v Reread Act I, scene v from … ‘O She doth teach the torches to burn bright.’ Students complete Handout 10 focusing on the sonnet, similes and metaphor in the play Return to Handout 8: Courtly love and complete question 2. 4.10 Students learn about the metalanguage for describing, explaining and justifying the composer’s choice of language forms and features and structures of texts in terms of purpose, audience and context. 4.13 Students learn about codes and conventions, including emotive, evocative and impersonal language and signs, used to signal tone, mood and atmosphere in spoken, written and visual texts. 11.9 Students learn to adapt current skills, knowledge and understandings to new situations. 5.2a Identify when intonation, volume, stress, pacing and repetition in English support and convey NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate Complete the questions for the first song as a class. Ask students to suggest or bring a modern love song of their own and students answer the same questions independently. November 2004 Page 18 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content 8.1 Students learn to identify and describe the similarities and differences between and among more demanding texts. 8.4 Students learn to track and explain the treatment of a common theme or idea in a range of texts in different modes and media. ESL Scales meaning. 5.9g Maintain an appropriate balance between general ideas and supporting detail in texts. 4.3 Students learn to use appropriate language forms and features and structures of texts in their own compositions and describe, explain and Note: Students will need a metalanguage to analyse the songs both in terms of the sound and the language of the lyrics. This song task will need to be preceded by a vocabulary task covering terms, such as: pitch, pace, stress, tone, pausing; and poetic terms, such as rhyme, alliteration, repetition, and so on. Romeo and Juliet soundtrack: Young Hearts 6.5b Participate in class/group discussions of text interpretations. 6.5c Give own opinion of a text and compare it with others’ opinions. 5.8g Incorporate new vocabulary from texts into personal vocabulary (specialised terminology). NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate Resources Suggested songs: Roberta Flack: The first time ever I saw your face Shania Twain: From this moment Jeff Buckley: Last Goodbye Nick Cave: Ship Song 8.9 Students learn about similarities of approach, attitude, intent, points of view, perspective and style in texts by different composers. 7.1 Students learns to ask perceptive and relevant questions, make logical predictions, draw analogies and challenge ideas and information in texts. Teaching and learning activities Taped examples of live news reports. 8. Responding to the fight scene Read the fight scene Act III, scene i. Year 10 only Consider: What choice did Romeo have in this scene? Baz Lurhmann’s version of the film. Were the events the result of human choice or the unavoidable forces of fate? Ensure permission notes have been obtained. Could Romeo alone have changed the outcome of this scene? November 2004 Page 19 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content justify their choices in terms of purpose, audience and context. ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities 6.6c Identify how parts of a narrative engage the reader’s (or viewer’s) attention. Discuss how these events would be reported in the news. 4.9 A student learns about appropriate language forms and features and structures of texts to use in an increasingly wide range of contexts. Resources What sort of angle would a television station take? What kind of footage would journalists want to use? View this scene in Baz Luhrmann’s version of film if student permission forms have been obtained. 4.11 A student learns about the influence of purpose, audience and context on the use of particular language forms and features and structures of texts. 3.1 Students learn to respond to and compose increasingly complex texts in different technologies considering the effects of the technology including layout and design on meaning. 6.1c Contribute to group activities by clarifying task goals and time limits, requesting or accepting opinions, negotiating roles and suggesting procedures 3.2 Students learn to identify and critically evaluate the ways information, ideas and issues are shaped by and presented through NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate Introduce the language of film and analyse the filmic techniques used in this scene. Handout 11: Bloodshed on Verona’s streets The DET CD-ROM Take One is very useful to explore the language of film. View 2 or 3 examples of live news reports and discuss how each report creates a sense of drama and captures the audience interest. Compare to the news report style used in the Luhrmann film. Read Handout 11 on how to create your own news report. Ask students to create a news report about the fight for television. November 2004 Page 20 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources 5.4c Use circumlocution – talk around a topic – to compensate for vocabulary inadequacies. ESL Scales 9. Read Act IV, scene i: Friar Lawrence’s cell and Act V, scene ii Handout 12: Terms to describe the themes and characters. technology. 3.5 Students learn about different techniques used to compose multimedia texts. 3.6 Students learn about the ways in which modern technologies of communication are used to inform, persuade and entertain. 3.7 Students learn about the ways in which modern technologies of communication are used to shape, adapt and re-present past and present cultures, including popular cultures and youth cultures, for particular audiences. 1.1 Students learn to respond to and compose a range of imaginative, factual and critical texts which are increasingly demanding in terms of their linguistic, structural, cognitive, emotional and moral complexity. 1.3 Students learn to 6.1c Contribute to group activities by clarifying task goals and time limits, requesting or accepting opinions, negotiating roles NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate As a class construct a series of questions that you would like to ask Friar Lawrence about his part in the tragedy. Students can take turns to be in the hot seat and do their best to defend their actions from the point of view of Friar Lawrence. Handouts 13a and 13b: Themes in Romeo and Juliet Read Act v, scene iii What are the lessons of the play? November 2004 Page 21 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content analyse the effectiveness and impact of texts on responders in terms of ideas, perspective and originality. 1.7 Students learn about the ideas, information, perspectives and ideologies presented in increasingly demanding imaginative, factual and critical texts and the ways they are presented. ESL Scales and suggesting procedures. 6.5d Discuss characters and their motivations in a story. 6.6c Identify how parts of a narrative engage the reader’s (or viewer’s) attention. Teaching and learning activities Resources Introduce the idea of theme. This can be done effectively through a short story such as “The Last Spin”. This is a suitable short story to explore themes and connects well with the idea of gang violence and the feuding in Romeo and Juliet. This story can be found in Making Connections in English 4, p.31 Give students Handout 13: Themes in Romeo and Juliet to start to explore the themes of the play and link them to evidence from the text 1.8 Students learn about the features of increasingly complex imaginative, factual and critical texts including the cognitive, emotional and moral dimensions of the text and its linguistic and structural features. Content 11.4 Students learn to choose learning processes, resources and technologies appropriate for particular tasks and situations NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 22 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content 11.6 Students learn to establish and adopt roles and responsibilities, negotiate and implement strategies and meet deadlines. 11.9 A student learns to adapt current skills, knowledge and understanding to new situations. ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources 11.13 Students learn about management strategies including drawing up schedules, timing, delegation and sharing in group work 11.15 Students learn about ways in which skills, knowledge and understanding can be connected to new information and situations 10. Performing a scene from the play Place students into groups of four. Allocate students one of the scenes studied in class (or a key scene that has not been studied) and ask students to prepare the scene to perform. Each group will also prepare a brief talk explaining: NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 23 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities Resources what their scene is about what emotions and atmosphere is conveyed in their scene how their scene links to the story of Romeo and Juliet as a whole. 7.6 Students learn to propose, support and elaborate points in an argument and draw conclusions. 7.7 Students learn to explore and develop arguments in a range of modes and media and in imaginative, interpretive and critical compositions. 7.9 Students learn about the ways bias, stereotypes, perspectives and ideologies are constructed in texts, including the codes and phrasings that signal them. 7.6 Students learn to propose, support and elaborate points in an argument and draw conclusions. 7.7 Students learn to explore and develop arguments in a range 5.11d Use a range of conjunction to relate ideas across sentences or paragraphs in a text (although, yet, however). 5.11f Use topic sentences within as well as at the beginning of paragraphs to unify ideas within a paragraph. 6.11a Develop some sub-topics in a text (by picking up points made in previous sentences or paragraphs). 6.9f Write a relevant response to an essay topic. 6.12a Monitor own writing for irrelevant sentences, phrases or ideas. NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate Jointly-constructed model essay 11. Responding critically (Recommended for Year 10) Writing an essay Write a model essay on the topic: “Romeo and Juliet still popular today. Why?” Brainstorm reasons that could be used in response to this question. Essay labels of language structures and features - teacher to create. Place students in groups to write a paragraph on each point. Draw the class arguments together to construct a complete essay and write the introduction and conclusion at the end. Examine the structure of information in an essay, how to use evidence from the play in a critical response and appropriate language for a critical response. Ask students to label the different parts of the essay. Students respond to another essay question individually. ESL students who have recently arrived may be given the first sentence in each paragraph as support for their essay. Possible essay questions: Handout 14: Sample essay and plan “The real message of Romeo and Juliet is that you should never disobey authority or it can have terrible results.” Do you agree? Assessment task description and marking criteria and guidelines “We have a different view of love today than we used to November 2004 Page 24 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au Content of modes and media and in imaginative, interpretive and critical compositions. 7.10 Students learn about sequence and hierarchy of ideas. ESL Scales Teaching and learning activities 6.12f Proofread for ways to improve flow of ideas (revise words, phrases or sentences that lack clarity or are ambiguous). Resources have in the past.” Discuss in relation to the play and at least one other text of your own choosing. In your answer include how these views of love are communicated not just what they are. “Shakespeare’s plays are still relevant today because they deal with universal themes and issues that are still relevant to people today.” Discuss in relation to the themes and events of Romeo and Juliet. The tragic ending to Romeo and Juliet is a result of human actions, not fate as the Prologue suggests.” Discuss. NSW Department of Education and Training Curriculum K-12 Directorate November 2004 Page 25 of 25 http://www.curriculumsupport.education.nsw.gov.au