Faculty of Graduate Studies & Research University of Alberta 2-29 Killam Centre for Advanced Studies Graduate Interdisciplinary Studies The Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research acknowledges a number of types of interdisciplinary graduate programs A. Established Dual Degree Programs MBA/LLB; MBA/MAg; MBA/MEng; MBA/MF; and MBA/PhD B. Established Interdisciplinary Programs Neuroscience Division: MSc (thesis-based); PhD Centre for Health Promotion Studies: MSc (thesis-based); MSc (course-based); and Postgraduate Diploma Campus St-Jean: MA (avec thèse) C. Interdisciplinary Graduate Program Proposals for Individuals Purposes and Objectives Although many graduate programs are already interdisciplinary to some extent and include the flexibility for students to meet their objectives within the existing program, it may be that a proposed area of study for an individual student cannot be effectively accommodated within a single department. When a student’s knowledge base is at the interstices of two or more disciplines an individual interdisciplinary graduate program may be an appropriate response. In her landmark book, Interdisciplinary: History, Theory, and Practice (1990), Julie Thompson Klein notes that “educators, researchers, and practitioners have all turned to interdisciplinary work in order to accomplish a range of objectives: to answer complex questions; to address broad issues; to explore disciplinary and professional relations; and to achieve unity of knowledge, whether on a limited or grand scale.”1 Between Disciplines, a 1993 report on “The UBC Joint-Faculties Symposium on Interdisciplinarity,” distinguishes between interdisciplinary, multidisciplinary, and transdisciplinary research: Multidisciplinary research: participants do their own disciplinary ‘thing’; each acts as a disciplinary expert; knowledge claims are based on the authority of that expertise; the final product does not integrate the disciplinary contributions. Interdisciplinary research: individuals may choose research problems, which require extensive insights from several disciplines; they must have a full and colloquial understanding of the major portion of the second discipline. Success is measured, in part, by their ability to publish in the journals of disciplines other than their own. Transdisciplinary research: research held together by a common ideological framework such as structuralism, semiotics, post-structuralism, post-modernism, general systems theory, etc.2 The Interdisciplinary Graduate Program Proposal for Individuals form is designed to streamline the application process and ensure that adequate academic standards of supervision, facilities, and other resources necessary to offer such a program are in place. [Graduate Program Manual, Individual Interdisciplinary Studies, page 46] ______________________ 1 Julie Thompson Klein, Interdisciplinarity: History, Theory, and Practice (Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1990: 11. (From Jo-Ann Wallace, A Report on Interdisciplinary Studies in the Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research, 1998). 2 Between Disciplines: A Report on the UBC-Joint Faculties Symposium on Interdisciplinarity, 5-6 March 1993 (August 1993), p.4 These definitions are drawn from Jill Vickers, “Where is the Discipline in Interdisciplinarity” in Interdisciplinarity/L’Interdisciplinarite, Association for Canadian Studies/Association d’etudes canadiennes (September 1992). (From Jo-Ann Wallace, A Report on Interdisciplinary Studies in the Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research, 1998). Page 1 January 2008 Note: Students and supervisors are encouraged to consider interdisciplinary graduate program proposals for individuals as early in their program as possible. Any transfer normally should be made at least six months prior to candidacy for doctoral students and within the first six months of the program for a master’s candidate. [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 1.3.b] Applicants to an interdisciplinary graduate program for individuals should have a superior academic record with substantial background in at least one of the proposed disciplines [Graduate Program Manual, Eligibility and Admission Requirements] Interdisciplinary graduate programs for individuals are restricted to thesis degree programs, master’s and doctoral, and are not applicable to probationary or qualifying students. [Graduate Program Manual, Eligibility and Admission Requirements] Students transferring from a graduate program either in the home or conjoint department will require a Recommendation for a Change of Category form rather than an Application for Graduate Admission form. [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 1.3.b] To access the Graduate Program Manual on the web go to www.ualberta.ca/gradstudies How to Proceed 1. The Interdisciplinary Graduate Program Proposal for Individuals application has two parts. The first part should be completed and signed by the applicant and delivered to the Supervisor. It is the responsibility of the applicant to develop a preliminary research proposal that both defines the focus of the research and interdisciplinary approach. Application is made through the home department/faculty. [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 1] 2. The second part should be completed and signed by the supervisor in the home department/ faculty and the co-supervisor in the conjoint department/faculty. (Determination of the home vs conjoint department/faculty is a decision made by the chairs and/or graduate coordinators of the departments/faculties in consultation with the student. The department of the co-supervisor will be designated as the conjoint department. [Graduate Program Manual, Role of the Home and Conjoint Departments] 3. The department chairs/graduate coordinators from both departments should also review and sign the application. [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 2] 4. The home department forwards the Interdisciplinary Graduate Program Proposal for Individuals along with appropriate documentation (either Graduate Application for Admission and official transcripts, etc or Recommendation for Change of Category form) to the Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research. 5. FGSR reviews the proposal and informs the departments and the student of the outcome. Page 2 January 2008 Interdisciplinary Graduate Program Proposal for Individuals The following application reflects information required according to the Graduate Program Manual. [Admissions, Individual Interdisciplinary Studies pages 46- 48]. [Approved by FGSR Council, 1994/05/27] Name of Applicant: _________________________________________________ Applicant’s U of A ID #: ______________ Degree: [Graduate Program Manual, Designation of the Degree, page 46] MA (thesis-based) MBA (thesis-based) MDes (thesis-based) MEd (thesis-based) MFA (thesis-based) MLIS (thesis-based) MMus (thesis-based) MN (thesis-based) MPH (thesis-based) MSc (thesis-based) LLM (thesis-based) EdD DMus PhD Proposed Start Date of Interdisciplinary Program: Fall Term 20__ Winter Term 20__ Spring Term 20__ Summer Term 20__ Proposed Home Department: Proposed Conjoint Department Page 3 January 2008 Applicant’s Proposed Research Statement (To be completed by the applicant) It is the responsibility of the applicant to develop a preliminary research proposal that both defines the focus of the research and the interdisciplinary approach. Apply through the home department. [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 1] Academic area in which you have substantial background______________________ [Graduate Manual Eligibility and Admission Requirements] Secondary academic area ____________________________ Proposed Research Statement (see page 5 for guidelines to completing this section) Please attach additional pages if required. ________________________________________ Signature of Applicant _____________________________ Date Page 4 January 2008 Guidelines for Completing the Applicant’s Proposed Research Statement Each research project and its related definition require different framing. Addressing the following questions should prove advantageous. 1. Define your research interest. 2. Why does this research require an interdisciplinary approach? 3. What are the conceptual and practical reasons for your choice of knowledge areas (disciplines) and methodologies? 4. State any relevant issues including your professional or other experience qualifications to undertake interdisciplinary research. Page 5 January 2008 Departmental Expectations of the Interdisciplinary Graduate Program Proposal for Individuals (To be completed by the Supervisor and Co-supervisor) a) Suitability of Applicant Please comment on the applicant’s ability to complete an individual interdisciplinary studies program (ie superior academic record, areas in which a substantial background exists, etc.) [Graduate Manual, Eligibility and Admission Requirements page 46, Proposal 2.b, page 46] b) Rationale for Interdisciplinary program. Please build on the applicant’s proposed research statement to provide a rationale for the need or advantage of this as an interdisciplinary program. Please attach additional pages if required. [Graduate Manual, Proposal 2.a & d, page 46] Page 6 January 2008 d) Proposed Program Structure To ensure that the applicant meets the requirements of both the home and conjoint departments, please complete PART 1 (for Master’s applicants) or PART 2 (for Doctoral applicants) [Graduate Program Manual Proposal 2.d, page 46] PART 1. For Master’s Degree Course Content Usual Requirements of Home Department Usual Requirements of Conjoint Department Proposed Requirements for this Application Required course(s) Research methods course(s) Thesis requirements Other Page 7 January 2008 PART 2. For Doctoral Degree Course Content Usual Requirements of Home Department Usual Requirements of Conjoint Department Proposed Requirements for this Application Required course(s) Research methods course(s) Written comprehensive examination, if required Candidacy requirements Supervisory meetings required Thesis defense requirements Other Page 8 January 2008 e) Supervision [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 2.c page 46, Supervision and Examinations page 47] Proposed Supervisor: __________________________________ (from Home department/faculty) Proposed Co-Supervisor: ___________________________________ (from Conjoint department/faculty) Proposed Supervisory Committee: (check one of the following) Master’s: will be named prior to defense Doctoral: will be named within the first year of the start of the interdisciplinary program Supervisory Committee member names follow: f) Examinations [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 2.c, page 46, Supervision and Examinations, page 47] Which department’s/faculty’s procedures will be followed for the Candidacy Examination (if Doctoral proposal)? _________________________________ Which department’s/faculty’s procedures will be followed for the Final Oral Examination? ___________________________________________ Note: The chair of the candidacy examination and final oral examination must be from the department/faculty whose procedures are being followed. g) Timelines [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 2.d, page 46] When will the student begin the individual interdisciplinary studies program? When do you expect the student to complete the coursework? When do you expect the student to complete the written comprehensive examination, if required? When do you expect the student to complete the candidacy examination (if a doctoral student)? When do you expect the student to complete the final oral examination? h) Funding Arrangements [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 2.e, page 46] What funding arrangements has the home department made? How is the conjoint department assisting in funding the applicant? Page 9 January 2008 i) Other Related Information (if required) [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 2.d, page 46] j) Is the applicant a new admission? Yes No If yes, please include a completed Application for Graduate Admission form and required admission documents. [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 3.a page 46] Is the applicant currently actively enrolled in the home or conjoint department? Yes No If yes, please state which one ____________________ and attach a Recommendation for Change of Category form signed by the Chair or the Graduate Program Coordinator for the home department and the conjoint department. [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 3.b pages 46-47] Page 10 January 2008 Signatures of Approval [Graduate Program Manual, Proposal 2. Page 46] Home Department: Conjoint Department: Name of Supervisor Name of Co-supervisor Signature of Supervisor Signature of Co-supervisor Name of Chair/Graduate Coordinator Name of Chair/Graduate Coordinator Signature of Chair/Graduate Coordinator Signature of Chair/Graduate Coordinator Date signed Date signed Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research Approval Approved Refused Comments/Clarification required: Approved for Academic Term ______________ (Fall/Winter/Spring/Summer & year) Signature of Associate Dean, FGSR Date Signed Page 11 January 2008