Cadastral and Land Administration Activities in Eritrea 1. Introduction The Department of Cadastral Office and the Department of Land are two separate departments in the Ministry of Land, Water and Environment (MLWE). The MLWE comprising of the Departments of Land, Water and Environment was established in March 1997 during the second restructuring phase of the civil service. The Cadastral Office, which was under the Ministry of Justice, was reconstituted under the MLWE during August 1999, initially as a Division in the Department of Land and later during the third quarter of 2003 upgraded to the level of a Department. The Cadastral Office (CO), that is, the office for the registration of land and other immovable property erected over land was first established in Eritrea at the end of the 19th century, during the Italian colonial period with the main purpose of guaranteeing security of property ownership for Italian settlers. The Office existed for more than a century, but without any qualitative change in its procedures. The Macro- Policy of the State of Eritrea (1994) outlined the land policy with the objectives of encouraging long-term investments in agriculture and sustainable use of land resources, and assuring women’s right to land on equal basis with men. Subsequently, Land Law (No. 58/1994) was issued with the objective of reforming the land tenure system, determining the manner of expropriating land for development purposes, and the declaration of powers and duties of the Land Commission. The enhancement of economic development, social justice and equity, securing tenure and political stability are the most pronounced objectives of the land policy. The main motives for the issuance of the Land Law were: Former systems of land tenure and laws were too obsolete and incompatible with the development strategies of the government; Land disputes were increasingly resurging; Land degradation: diminished land productivity, depletion of forests and vegetation was becoming paramount. Hence, in order to meet contemporary demands and pave the ways for the progress of the country’s socio-economic situation, the Eritrean land tenure system had to undergo reforms that: Assure agricultural and industrial development; Promote initiative and motivation among beneficiaries and producers; Encourage private investment and initiative; _________________________________________________________________________________ Cadastral and Land Administration Activities in Eritrea Habtemicael WELDEGIORGIS, Eritrea FIG Commission 7 Annual Meeting & International Open Symposium Karlovy Vary, Czech Republic, 6-10 September 2010 1 Avoid land contradiction, friction and dispute; Ascertain access rights of all citizens to improve their living standards; Make it standard and applicable throughout the nation. The main features of the land law (NO.58/1994) include the following: All land is owned by the state; Eritrean citizens (>18 years) have equal right to tiesha land (residence plot in village); Farm land is allotted on usufruct basis for those who earn their living by farming; Usufruct rights are given for life-time of the individual. Offspring are given priority in the reallocation after the death of the usufruct holder; Leaseholds are provided for housing, commercial and other social services; Women have equal rights to land as men. However, effective implementation of the Land Law necessitated the introduction of an efficient, simple and modern system for the registration of land and other immovable property, and thus the Registration Law (No. 95/1997) was issued declaring the registration mandatory. The main mandate of the Cadastral Office (NO.95/1997) can be summarized as follows: Register all land, rights over land, duties that emanate from such rights, and the transfer of immovable property through sale, donation, inheritance or other manner; As necessary register all tiesha land, agricultural usufruct, leasehold, land utilized and unutilized by the state; Give information on transfer of immovable property for any encumbrances; Charge appropriate fees for the services it provides to clients; Register right holders of land together with property erected over it; Designate Eritrea as one registration district or, as may be necessary, establish registration districts to open and consolidate registries, issue directives pertaining to the administration and monitoring of the registration districts. 2. Cadastral and Land Administration Activities in Eritrea Cadastral and land administration activities in Eritrea are carried out by two different departments in the MLWE, respectively by the departments of the Cadastral Office and the Land Department. The CO is mandated with the registration of land and other immovable property erected over land, issuance of certificate of right/ownership, etc. On the other hand the Department of Land is mandated mainly with land use planning, allocation of land parcels, and monitoring whether allocated land is utilized for _________________________________________________________________________________ Cadastral and Land Administration Activities in Eritrea Habtemicael WELDEGIORGIS, Eritrea FIG Commission 7 Annual Meeting & International Open Symposium Karlovy Vary, Czech Republic, 6-10 September 2010 2 the designated purpose. Both departments have prepared their Five- Year Strategic Plan (2011-2015), during July- August 2010 in collaboration with the Eritrean Centre of Organizational Excellence (ERCOE). The process involved undertaking SWOT analysis and identifying major gaps, clarified key tasks (KTs) and key result areas (KRAs), and set goals, objectives and main activities with the purpose of accomplishing their core missions. The main missions are respectively, ‘to protect and guarantee security of immovable property ownership and use rights over land’, and ‘to ensure the implementation of sustainable land management and guarantee optimum use and fair distribution of land’. To properly implement their distinctive missions, each department is carrying out activities particular to its mandate. 2.1 Cadastral Activities Cadastre is an up-to-date land information system based on a division of land into parcels, having records and maps. The CO registers land rights and ownership of immovable property erected over land, transactions of property (through sale, donation, inheritance and exchange); provides information of rights (ownership, usufruct, and lease), mortgages, pledges, etc. Although a cadastre system should cover a definite geographical area or whole country to provide the necessary benefits, historically the Eritrean CO had neither of the two requirements and the registration system largely remained of sporadic nature. Currently, the CO has two divisions – Registration Division and Cadastral MIS Division, two Regional Units (under the Regional Branch Offices of the MLWE), and units of Monitoring and Evaluation and Human Resources Development (HRD). By 2011, it has plans to implement mandatory registration system and hence to open regional registration offices at the three seats of regional administration and major towns (in total nine offices). To this effect it has submitted its human and material requirements for approval by higher authorities. As noted above the CO registers land and property erected over it. The requirements for registration of land provided for commercial agriculture on lease basis are certificate of lease and certified surveyed plan. On the other hand, a building is qualified for registration if it satisfies the following requirements: Certificate of land lease contract Building permit Approved building plan Building/habitation license certifying that the construction of the building is done according to approved plan. Similarly, transfer of immovable property needs primarily clearance from debt or pledge, availability of basic registration documents, and legal processing by the Notary Public. _________________________________________________________________________________ Cadastral and Land Administration Activities in Eritrea Habtemicael WELDEGIORGIS, Eritrea FIG Commission 7 Annual Meeting & International Open Symposium Karlovy Vary, Czech Republic, 6-10 September 2010 3 However, there are no public notary offices other than the one in the national capital city (Asmara). The key tasks (KTs) and key result areas (KRAs) of the CO are the following: Key tasks Key result areas Issue certificate of right/ownership Right/ownership assured Customer satisfaction Provide information on registered immovable Property status informed property Secure property ownership transfer Loan through mortgaging property Customer satisfaction Provide authenticated documents of registered Right/ownership assured immovable property Customer satisfaction Provide capacity development Verify documents immovable property upon Institution strengthened registration Improve work system of Legality and correctness of documents verified Propose improvement of procedures Better performance and harmony Effectiveness and efficiency As indicated above, a cadastre system should cover the whole country or a definite geographical area in order to provide the necessary information and benefits. But, our cadastral system unlike many others lacks this. Besides, there are other constraints that need serious considerations: Inadequate institutional capacities to discharge its duties and responsibilities fully; Low technical and professional competence to run and develop the system; and Absence of Notary Public or ‘ real estate agents’ in the remaining five regions for authentication of agreement and facilitating fast transactions of property. 2.2 Land Administration Activities Land administration, which is defined as the process of determining, recording and disseminating information about ownership/right, value, and the use of land and its associated resources, includes functions concerning regulating the development and use of land, gathering income and resolving land disputes. On the other hand, land management involves the implementation of basic policy decisions about the nature and _________________________________________________________________________________ Cadastral and Land Administration Activities in Eritrea Habtemicael WELDEGIORGIS, Eritrea FIG Commission 7 Annual Meeting & International Open Symposium Karlovy Vary, Czech Republic, 6-10 September 2010 4 extent of investments in land (UN-ECE, 1996, p.47). It covers activities related with the management of land as a resource from environmental and economic perspectives. The Department of land is mandated with the duty to study on land capability and land use planning. So far, land capability studies of two Zobas/ regions (Zoba Maekel and Zoba Debub) are complete. It uses different cadastral surveying instruments such as GPS, total Station, etc. Due to inadequate institutional capacities, generally land use planning is carried out on demand basis. The key tasks and key result areas of the LD follows: Key tasks Key result areas Develop and review land related directives, Proper implementation of land law standards, guidelines, manuals, etc. Conduct Land Use Planning at all levels Sustainable use of land promote socio-economic development Conduct land use studies, delineation and Land use maps and documents map preparation based on demand for different purposes Develop integrated reliable information Data base of land and users system Better informed decisions Better access to information Increased efficiency for land related activities Conduct research, monitoring and Increased knowledge for better decisions evaluation of land related activities (land Ensure proper implementation of land law use, allocation and right holders etc) versus land law. Provide institutional capacity building Competent human resource Efficient work system Improve work system Better performance and harmony Effectiveness and efficiency _________________________________________________________________________________ Cadastral and Land Administration Activities in Eritrea Habtemicael WELDEGIORGIS, Eritrea FIG Commission 7 Annual Meeting & International Open Symposium Karlovy Vary, Czech Republic, 6-10 September 2010 5 The main constraints of the Department of Land include: Weak enforcement of existing laws; Inadequate representation in all Zobas; Overlap of laws; Inadequate professional skills; 3. Global Land Administration Perspective Land governance, which includes decisions on access to land, land rights, land use and land development, is about policies, processes and institutions through which land, property and natural resources are managed in sustainable way (FIG Publication NO. 45, p. 10). It is fundamentally about determining and implementing sustainable land policies that ensures continuity Both land administration and management systems deal with the social, legal, economic and technical framework in which land managers and administrators should operate (UNECE, 1996). This global approach to land administration systems (as shown in Figure 1 below) include an extensive range of systems and processes to administer: land tenure, land value and land use (Enemark, 1996, p. 5). Many developing countries, like Eritrea lack coherent land administration and cadastral systems. Land administration systems and their core cadastral components are essential infrastructure that facilitates the implementation of land policies both in developed and developing countries. Such systems are concerned with the administration of land as a resource in order to ensure sustainable development. In such systems the cadastral parcels through land administration and management systems give the basic infrastructure for running the interrelated systems within the areas of land tenure, land value and land use (Enemark, 2003, p.6). But, many countries tend to separate land tenure rights from land use opportunities, undermining their capacity to link planning and land use controls with land values and the operation of land market leading to ‘the failure to treat land and its resources as a coherent whole’ ( FIG Publication NO. 45, p.10). To appropriately respond to the new global challenges-climate change, food shortage, environmental degradation and natural disasters integrating land administration systems with their cadastral components looks _________________________________________________________________________________ 6 Cadastral and Land Administration Activities in Eritrea Habtemicael WELDEGIORGIS, Eritrea FIG Commission 7 Annual Meeting & International Open Symposium Karlovy Vary, Czech Republic, 6-10 September 2010 imperative. However, in many poor developing countries, such perspective will require a long time to develop. Modern land administration system is concerned with detailed information of land parcel. From its application benefits of guaranteeing of property ownership and security of tenure and credit; facilitation of efficient land transfers and land markets where land is privately owned; support of asset management; giving basic information on physical planning processes, land development and environmental control (Ibid, p. 6) are secured. Land administration cannot be accomplished without cadastral and land registration, valuation and taxation and planning control systems; and processes of core tasks. This demands capacity buildings efforts at societal, organizational and individual levels. Land use Land tenure Economic-Social-Environmental SUSTAINABLE DVELOPMENT Cadastre Land value Cadastre Land use Land tenure Land value Effective land use management Efficient land market LAND TENURE LAND VALUE LAND USE LAND DEVELOPMENT Titles Mortgages Easements Secure legal rights Assessment of Land value Policies and Spatial planning Construction Planning permits Collection of property tax Control of Land use Regulation and implementation Cadastre Identification of land parcels Register and maps Fig. 1: A Global Land Administration Perspective (Enemark, 2001) _________________________________________________________________________________ Cadastral and Land Administration Activities in Eritrea Habtemicael WELDEGIORGIS, Eritrea FIG Commission 7 Annual Meeting & International Open Symposium Karlovy Vary, Czech Republic, 6-10 September 2010 7 4. Concluding Remarks Eritrea is still a young developing country with many resource constraints: professional human resource and material. The cadastral system should sooner than later need to develop so that it would play vital role in land administration and management systems. This is not a choice to be made but a must to be done by a country to properly manage land and its resources and fit within the global economy competitively. Capacity building efforts are imperative in order to meet the medium and long-term needs. Hence, this conceptual understanding needs to develop to serve as a basis for analytical framework and methodological guidelines. 5. References Cadastral Office (2010) Five-Year Strategic Plan (2011-2015), Cadastral Office, Asmara, Eritrea Enemark, S. (2003) Capacity Building for developing sustainable Land Administration Infrastructures, Paper presented at WPLA/FIG Workshop Athens, 28 -31 May 2003 Economic Commission for Europe (ECE) (1996) Land Administration Guidelines, United Nations, New York and Geneva Government of Eritrea (GoE) (1994) Macro Policy, Asmara, Eritrea GoE (1994) Proclamation NO. 58/94: A Proclamation to reform the system of Land Tenure in Eritrea, Asmara, Eritrea GoE (1997) Proclamation NO. 95/1997: A Proclamation to Provide for the Registration of Land and Other Immovable Property, Asmara, Eritrea The World Bank and the International Federation of Surveyors (2010) Land Governance in Support of the Millennium Development Goals, Copenhagen, Denmark, ISBN 978-8790907-72-3 Larsson, G. (1996) Land Registration and Cadastral Systems, Longman Malaysia, CLP Economic Commission for Europe (1996) Ministry of Land, Water and Environment (MLWE) (2010) Five-Year Strategic Plan of the MLWE (2011-2015), MLWE, Asmara, Eritrea _________________________________________________________________________________ Cadastral and Land Administration Activities in Eritrea Habtemicael WELDEGIORGIS, Eritrea FIG Commission 7 Annual Meeting & International Open Symposium Karlovy Vary, Czech Republic, 6-10 September 2010 8 CONTACTS: Habtemicael Weldegiorgis Director General Cadastral Office Ministry of Land, Water & Env’t P. O. BOX – 976 Asmara, Eritrea Email: habtemicael_weldegiorgis@yahoo.com Tel. +291 1 124253 (Off)/ 202414 (Home) Fax: +291 1 116381 (Off) Mobile: + 291 1 07 238497 _________________________________________________________________________________ Cadastral and Land Administration Activities in Eritrea Habtemicael WELDEGIORGIS, Eritrea FIG Commission 7 Annual Meeting & International Open Symposium Karlovy Vary, Czech Republic, 6-10 September 2010 9