Winnipeg School Division Diagnostic Learning Centre Polysyllabic Word Study - Fully Analyzed A strategy to help students use reference (key) words to solve polysyllabic words January 2008 Rationale: 1. Fully analyze the key word (phonogram pattern). Gaskins’ (2005) research findings suggest that prior to applying analogy for decoding, the student must first fully analyze the key words, that is, know the pattern the key word represents. Once that is known to a level of automaticity, analogy, as one of the four decoding strategies, can be applied with likely success. 2. Teach in sequence. Presenting the key word patterns in sequence from VC, CVC, CV or open syllable, CVC- r-controlled, CVC-digraph, CVCC and an expanded version that includes long vowels (double vowels) and diphthongs ensures the student learns the patterns systematically. The sequencing is intended to lessen confusion arising from students “looking for parts” they know in a random manner. Example: student finds ‘rat’, ‘ted’ or ‘dec’ in decorated, which does not support successful decoding. 3. Teach to transfer. Teaching and practicing the strategy just prior to a period of connected reading instruction is effective in helping students to weave it back into their reading. 4. Instructional decisions regarding the order of presentation should be dependent on specific student needs. 5. Each step may be abandoned when a student demonstrates internalization of the concepts of syllabication, analogy and substitution. 6. Initial instruction works well with both individuals and small groups of students. Procedure: Show each student how to use the vowels and vowel patterns in a word to identify each syllable and solve unfamiliar words by applying the following steps: 1. find and underline each vowel from left to right to answer the question, “How many syllables are there in the word?” 2. look around each vowel to identify each syllable 3. match a reference (key) word to each syllable 4. articulate in sequence each reference (key) word chosen in order to provide a model of the unknown word 5. read the new word by articulating each syllable in sequence Student Materials: Full sets of reference (key) word cards for each student Individual whiteboard or sets of practice cards for individual student study 1 Step A - Key words: VC CVC CV Have the student begin a store of reference (key) words by writing the following on index cards: in at it up ten sad get he go Display these one-syllable word cards. Examine each reference (key) word carefully so that the student understands the VC and CV patterns. The CV pattern produces an open syllable. The CVC pattern produces a closed syllable, that is, the vowel is closed in or surrounded by consonants. The key words must be fully analyzed to be used as references for making analogies. Instruct the student that his/her job is to choose the familiar word cards that match the parts of the two-syllable word given. Once the words are appropriately matched, have the student pronounce the two matching reference (key) words and then the two-syllable words. Practice matching and pronouncing these words as quickly as possible. Substitute consonants. Example: Match: Read: Read: nomad go sad go sad no mad Practice words which might be used are: secret omen zero bitten hero fatten veto situp pinto nomad remit tincup open batten some children will initially think that a syllable is a word if students experience difficulty syllabicating an open syllable word as in ‘omen’, it is helpful to demonstrate the flexible thinking required: o use magnetic letters or letter tiles to build the word o underline the vowels o m e n o remove the ‘m’ o e n m o explain your thinking that “when there is one consonant (m) it generally belongs with the second vowel (or second syllable) o m e n o continue the procedure of matching reference (key) words: Example: omen Match: go ten Read: go ten Read: o men 2 Step B - Key words: CVC - includes digraphs and CVC r-controlled vowels Provide the student with an additional seven reference (key) word cards. Continue to examine closely the patterns within the key words. Ensure the students understand the concept. can then her car sun big is Using all reference (key) word cards, have the students match cards to these words as in Step A. sister fitter banter charter merger barber banner canter garter cancer blister ginger batter jerkin winter margin vermin render hermit latter charger charter market digger farther trigger cargo deter meter defer sober refer garter cancer bitter fitter blister jerkin center barter setter panther blunder grocer mango depart Step C - Key words: add in CVCC and other CVC digraphs Provide the student with an additional four reference (key) word cards. Continue to examine closely the patterns within the key words. Ensure the students understand the concept. went fish and end Using all reference (key) word cards, have the students match cards to these words as in Steps A and B. ferment percent tangent bandit scatter catfish secret inland disband moment recent defend serpent punish wetland scarlet garment attend misspent varnish clannish upend depend pungent finish banish repent regret dement bunker Step D - Extended practice with key words After much practice with the reference (key) words the students need to move on to using the whole store of words in their heads as words to match with syllables to solve unfamiliar words. Show the students some two-syllable words that will require the students to create their own reference words. Example: focus Match: go us Read: go us Substitute consonants. Read: fo cus . 3 Provide lots of practice with this step. Initially you may wish to draw a line or place a red dot (. ) between the two parts of the word to show the division. Placing each word in the context of a sentence gives practice in checking pronunciation and provides meaning for each word. Some words to start with: basket vermin display decide devour betray rattan trawler frozen demand blender fender recent harpoon convoy boyhood repeat cluster defend rebound retreat butler profound withstand sincere corner butter gusset relay robot resound regret binder handsome remit render refuse hinder restore sandwich order rely cutlet invade russet simmer repay remind cinder igloo retreat shimmer reply sponsor delight jasmine engage wither rampage sewer defame litter prevent tender dismiss mannish luster whisper splinter payment border defeat delay wiggler simpler pinball permit dement mister slender potter hammer matter zenith platter massive ferment member gender sordid plaster statement fritter musket devout splutter present shampoo destroy splendid permit selfish orphan splinter magnet gutter snobbish Step E - Expanded version: - add syllables exhibiting Long Vowel Patterns - CVVC and CVV words - two vowels working together- the consonant joins the team Provide students with the following reference (key) words to help them use words with vowel patterns as part of their store of key words retained in their heads. Key words that have been internalized from earlier stages need no longer be visible. nail boat feet meat prayer sailor cheater slayer sprayer neater skeeter sweeter beater powder recoat floater teamwork soapsuds say boy oil for now trailer retreat layer jailer grayer bleater teepee treatment fleeter greeter spoiler broiler Oiler enjoy beachhead however truly beanstalk toasted Step F - Extended practice without key words Once the strategy is learned, additional practice should occur using words from the students’ reading without key word cards. These words then become their own store of key words in their heads that they may draw upon as needed. 4 Step G - Three Syllable Words Use the preceding procedure with words of three or more syllables. Again, put the words in a sentence context and discuss the meaning of the word in that context. Some practice words are: engagement painkiller important informant contestant informant entertain surrender suitable dealmaker hydroplane multitude hydrofoil enrichment attentive enlistment sarcastic enjoyment amendment powerful manpower insincere hopelessly contradict thermostat signature unfailingly romantic wonderful employment apartment abdomen diplomat indignant underline steamroller influence juicemaker unpeelable nonpayment speedily expensive inactive chimpanzee fisherman disorder turpentine bruising noteworthy limousine minimal playfully unreachable Step H - Four Syllable Words and Longer unobservant extraterrestrial unimpressive entertainment laboratory veterinarian sophisticated illuminate videotron biodegradable anthropological thermodynamics autobiography magnificent automobile independent unimportant zoological aerobatic spectacular particular underpopulated inexplicability extravagant unhesitant examination graduation memorandum geography agriculture temporary aqueduct anaconda reincarnation antigravity advertisement unrepentant gymnasium stereophonic claustrophobia aquarium territory tenderhearted dramatization tempermental 5 Teach for Transfer: Goal: the student will put the strategy into practice while reading authentic text as expediently as possible Teachable moments: teacher makes and demonstrates links teacher watches and notices words presented for solving using this process need to be at a level commensurate with student instructional reading levels whiteboards, word cards, magnetic letters or letter tiles may all be use alternatively to explain and practise the strategy teacher will guide the student to make connections between this strategy and the SPLASH and TRICKY WORDS word analysis strategies (“Look for parts you know.”) Teacher will recognize when the transfer has occurred: student shows signs of internalizing the entire process and beginning to apply it when reading authentic text student demonstrates growing cognitive flexibility in applying the strategy release of responsibility will vary from student to student Adapted from Cunningham, Patricia M. (1978). Decoding Polysyllabic Words;An Alternative Strategy, Journal of Reading, (April) pp. 614-617. Other references: Gaskins, I. (2005). Success with Struggling Readers: The Benchmark School Approach (p.165-168).New York: The Guildford Press. McFarlane, L. (1998). Facilitating Communication and Literacy: Phonemic Awareness in the Clinic and Classroom. Presentation handout. October 22, 1998. Appendix C. p. 32. Richards, R. (1999). The Source for Dyslexia and Dysgraphia p.183. East Moline, IL: LinguiSystems. 6