State of Israel Ministry of Education English Inspectorate Thinking Skills Comprehending Lower Order Thinking Skills (LOTS) Organizing Skills Comparing/ Contrasting Description These skills are used to clarify the basic meaning of the text before any analysis. Who? What? Where? When? Do you know? Can you identify…? LOTS include understanding vocabulary, and identifying setting, people involved, events, conflict/problem /solution and relationships. Sample Questions Description A variety of graphic organizers can be used for the organizing skills. This thinking skill is used to compare and contrast at least two things. We learn something new by identifying the similar and the dissimilar. Classifying Sample Questions This thinking skill is used to create categories or places something in an existing category. It should include a justification of the classification. For example, this is useful for classifying characters (successful persona, heroic persona); classifying imagery (metaphor, simile) etc. Compare and contrast the conflicts (e.g. problems / dilemmas) in two texts / poems. Compare and contrast the cultural conventions in the text with your own cultural background. Compare and contrast two of the persona Classify different relationships between the people in the text. To what genre does this text belong? Organizing Skills Making Connections Sample Questions Description Organizing skills may be supported by graphic organizers This thinking skill is used to promote thinking in multiple dimensions. For example, making connections between the fictional situation and real life. Parts and Whole Different Perspectives This thinking skill is used to explain how the parts function within the whole and how the whole is a unity despite the fact that the parts are not all connected to each other. For example, this thinking skill is used to consider how the scenes of a play are part of an act. Another example is how the rhyme, rhythm and imagery of a poem reinforce each other to create a sense of unity. This thinking skill is used either to distinguish different perspectives in the text or to distinguish different perspectives of the readers of the text. 2 Connect what the person says or does at this point in the text with what we already know about him/her. Connect a recent event in the text with an earlier one. Connect the text with its context (historical, social, and cultural). Connect this text with other texts. Describe how one part/ different parts of the text contribute to your understanding of the whole. Identify a conflict in the text and show how it is portrayed in different parts. How does the title reflect the details of the text/poem? (whole/part) In view of your knowledge of the text, explain the significance of the title (part/whole). Describe the writer’s point of view. How does the writer’s attitude shape the way the events are presented? Identify how different characters respond to a specific central event in the text. How does your understanding of the text differ from someone else’s in the class? How does your understanding of the events/characters’ actions change with the development of the text? Organizing Skills Sequencing Sample Questions Description Organizing skills may be supported by graphic organizers This thinking skill is used specifically for recreating the chronology of a story that is presented in a nonchronological way. For example, recreating the chronology of a text that switches back and forth between the present and the past. Or recreating the chronology of a mystery story in which a significant action, or series of actions, need/s to be discovered in order to understand what has happened. 3 Sequence the events in their chronological order. How does the sequence of events in this text help you understand the eventual outcomes? How does the use of tenses help you understand the sequence of events? How does the sequence of the events in the text help make the incident/account more interesting? Analysis Skills Uncovering Motives Description Sample Questions This thinking skill is used to uncover motives which are the underlying psychological reasons that explain the action, inaction and/or attitudes of the people involved. Causal Explanations This thinking skill is used to explain the cause and effect relationship between actions and events in a text. One cause may have several effects. Similarly one effect may have many causes. Prediction This thinking skill is used to predict both the content and the outcome of the narrative. Prediction is used as a pre-reading and/or a while reading thinking skill. What can you find out from the text that explains what causes _____ to (do) ______? What does the story tell you about ______ that explains why______? What are the most significant cause and effect events in the text? What are the effects of _________’s actions? What was _____ trying to convince _____ to do? What argument was used? What was the result? Predict whether_______? What reasons do you have for your prediction? What did ______ predict would happen? What reasons did ______ have for this prediction? Are your expectations fulfilled or not? 4 What explicit motives are mentioned for_____ actions? How did these affect the decisions the person makes? Infer the motives for the person’s actions. What reasons did ____ give _____? Were these reasons well founded? Generation Description Sample Questions Skills Generating Possibilities This thinking skill is used to generate possibilities for solving problems, for possible outcomes, and for creative responses based on the text. Problem Solving This thinking skill is used to identify a problem and either identify its solution or suggest a possible solution, taking into account the constraints and the options present in the text. Integrating Skills Synthesis Application Skills Application Description What options does _______ have for resolving the dilemma? Create a new character for the story. Explain how this will affect the story. Brainstorm possible different endings for the story. What book/TV program/food would this character like? Explain why. Define the problem facing the protagonist. How should ______decide what to do? What should ______take/ have taken into account? How might _______ prevent____? What might you have done in the same situation? Sample Questions This thinking skill is used to integrate all aspects of one’s understanding of the text and one’s insight into a text, through a comprehensive statement and explanation. Description Write a summary of the story in no more than one paragraph. How does information we learn later in the text change the way we understand a character (an issue/a conflict)? Sample Questions This thinking skill is used to apply the other thinking skills to new contexts, either literary or non-literary. This can include the implication the text has for us on a personal or communal level or the implication the text has for other texts. 5 Apply a thinking skill to a new text. Apply a thinking skill to a personal experience. Apply thinking skills to other subjects studied at school. Apply a literary term to another text