GENDER MARKER TIP SHEET PROTECTION SECTOR Gender Equality in the Project Sheet There are five entry points for the Protection Sector to address gender equality; the needs analysis, beneficiaries, project objective, activities and outcomes. This chart is designed to give examples of how to bring gender into each entry point. Following these steps will assist in improving projects that code 0-1 so they merit a code 2. The steps can also help teams to more fully mainstream gender in their code 2 projects. Project Objective If the project is making efforts to advance gender equality, the project objective should reflect this. A protection project objective that features gender quality signals to implementers the high priority your agency/organisation places on ensuring each woman, girl, boy, and man can access their human rights including the right to personal security. Here are some examples of how the gender-responsiveness of Protection projects can be profiled in the objective: the original project objective has been strengthened by the additions in italics. Protection Example 1: Contribute to preventing and reducing statelessness equally for women, girls, boys and men through an improved identification process Protection Example 2: Assure that all populations affected by the conflict have access to protection mechanisms in line with their traditional networks which allow males and females full and equal exercise of their human rights Protection Example 3: Ensure that emergency-affected children (replace ‘children’ with ‘girls and boys’) have equal access to mechanisms that protect them from risks of increased exposure to violence, abuse, trafficking, neglect and exploitation, and their rights are fully monitored according to humanitarian, human rights and child rights law. Logically, objectives that include a gender perspective will be supported by all subsequent elements of the project sheet – main activities, key outcomes and beneficiary profile. Beneficiaries Protection projects need to specifically identify their beneficiaries by group and within each group by sex and age. Avoid using generic groups that hide sex and/or age, i.e. ‘IDPs’ ‘community leaders’ or ‘victims‘, ‘IDPs’ or ‘families’. Needs Assessments Women, girls, boys and men often do not have the same choices. They may face different hurdles in fulfilling their rights, dignity or personal safety. Gender-based violence (GBV1) is an example: GBV is especially problematic in the context of complex emergencies and natural disasters, where civilian women, girls and boys are often targeted for abuse. They are the most vulnerable to exploitation, violence and abuse 1 GBV is any harmful act that is perpetrated against a person’s will and that is based on social ascribed (gender) differences between males and females. 1 simply because of their sex, age and status in society. In addition to GBV, women, girls, boys and men face struggles in the other pillars of protection: housing, land and property rights; child protection; mine action and the Rule of Law/Access to Justice. Therefore, a gender analysis is vital in the needs assessment that informs any protection project. Here are examples of questions that can enrich the design of protection projects: What are the demographics of our target group? (# of households and family members disaggregated by sex and age; # of single heads of household who are women, girls, boys and men; # of unaccompanied children, elderly persons, persons with disabilities, the chronically ill, pregnant and lactating women) What personal security risks did women, girls, boys and men face before the emergency (including in accessing food, water and fuel; in access to land and markets; access to and participation in school; participation in paid work; access to health services and facilities; and, access and participation in cultural, community and social networks? What has changed: what concerns do women, girls, boys and men now have about their personal safety? What actions do women, girls, boys and men want to be taken to increase their personal security? Do cultural norms enable women and men to participate equally in decisionmaking in their homes and communities? If not, what affirmative action is needed so both can participate in a meaningful way in IDP/refugee/returnee communities? Access to personal security and other rights is often blocked if a woman, girl, boy or man either cannot speak up or no-one listens. Are there discriminatory practices (or laws) that disadvantage either men/boys or women/girls, or vulnerable subgroups of either sex, and prevent them from exercising their rights to: food, water and NFIs; information; justice and legal rights; health and education services; land? What knowledge do women, girls, boys and men have about their legal rights, sexual and gender-based violence, STIs, recruitment, mine action, etc.? Who are the most effective messengers and what are the most effective methods to bring rights education to women, girls, boys and men? Are gender and protection issues being systematically addressed/monitored in: Governance: An active multi-sectoral mechanism to prevent and respond to gender-based violence within the disaster-affected population and a pro-active mechanism to prevent humanitarian actors from committing sexual exploitation and abuse (PSEA)2. Facility design: Privacy in shelters; separate, lit, well-located toilets/ showers/water-points for males and females; safe and accessible common-use areas for females and males; safe spaces for breastfeeding, peer discussions and psycho-social counselling for M/F children, adolescents and adults. NFIs. Appropriate locally-preferred sanitary supplies and contraceptives; culturally appropriate clothing for males and females of different ages. See the IASC Guidelines for Gender-based Violence Interventions in Humanitarian Settings. 2 UN policy stipulates ‘zero tolerance’ for sexual exploitation and abuse. Sexual violence in armed conflict is a crime against humanity. 2 Activities The gender analysis in your needs assessment will identify gender gaps that need to be addressed. These should be integrated into activities. Examples: Gap: During the needs assessment women reported two young girls had been left pregnant by the de-mining teams who set up camp near the returnee village during their 12 weeks of demining. Responsive activity: Orient all private contractors, including de-miners, in the standards the UN requires of contractors. These include compliance with the SG’s Bulletin on Special Measures for Protection from Sexual Exploitation and Sexual Abuse. All contractors and sub-contractors should be required in their contracts to comply with the SG’s Bulletin. Rigorous monitoring should ensure violations result in immediately cancelled contracts and trigger responsive services for the victims. Gap: To get valid data on the affected population, humanitarian actors were doing regular sunrise counts of the ‘night dwellers’- people, largely women, girls and boys- who walk to the town each night for protection from rebel abduction. They sleep in any secure area, whether in public works yards or school grounds, that is not on the town fringe and where there is fencing, water and light. Most men stay on their subsistence farms protecting their remaining possessions. It soon became apparent that counting ‘children’ night dwellers and ‘children’ attending school was hiding how many girls compared to how many boys were being abducted or pulled out of school for other reasons. Responsive activity: Ensure the project collects data on the affected population by sex and age routinely. In conflict and disaster-affected areas, the protection issues for women, girls, boys and men can not only be different at the onset of the emergency but change with emerging circumstances. In the situation above, identifying that the ratio of girls to boys is changing prompts project teams to explore why and what can be done. Gap: As government officials advised that it would be difficult to get female data collectors for the host community assessment, an all-male team was recruited. This team interviewed primarily male leaders. They raised no personal protection issues but did raise property protection issues. Responsive activities: Pro-actively seek equal numbers of men and women as data collectors and information sources – there are always ways of supporting women to participate; provide gender orientation to all data collectors to ensure they understand why it is important to explore the differences between the realities of women/girls and men/boys and know how to listen and record this information accurately; ensure analysis explores the ‘root causes’ of fears and threats. These can be an early warning of violence to come. In many environments sexual and gender-based violence, in its many paid and unpaid forms, is seldom discussed: signals like those in this case warrant investigation, then action, facilitated by people with GBV expertise. Projects for these target IDP-host populations would benefit from a conflict resolution mechanism that involves equal numbers of respected males and females, including adolescent girls and boys. Outcomes Outcomes should capture gender change: the change experienced by the males and females who are the identified beneficiaries. Outcome statements should, wherever possible, be worded so that any difference in outcome for males and females or in 3 male-female relations is visible. Avoid outcome statements that focus on ‘IDPs’ ‘police officers’ ‘survivors’ that hide whether, or not, males and females equally benefit. Examples of gender outcomes in protection projects: the importance of the words in italics is explained. Child-friendly learning spaces established in order to secure the return to school of 5,000 displaced school-aged children, including near equal numbers of girls and boys, in Area ABC Signals that boys and girls have an equal right to education. If near-equal numbers are not being achieved, the reasons need to be explored and inform follow-up projects. Protection issues that are distinct for girls and boys may explain the gap Improved and continued GBV coordination Reflects that creating a culture of protection for women, girls, boys and men involves many disciplines, all sectors, government and non-government actors. Relevant sex and age disaggregated data on extremely vulnerable individuals is gathered, reported and integrated into a referral system. Recognises that the sex and age of a person can affect personal security and access to rights All local partners now have near-equal numbers of male and female trainers with capacity to train others in protection, human rights and other relevant issues Acknowledges that training roles are leadership roles and should be shared equally by women and men. Also, male-to-male and female-to-female discussion and facilitation may be required in some situations or, if not required, adds another valuable dimension to male-female learning environments. X% increase in the number of property titles in the joint name of husband and wife or the name of a female head of household. Advances equality before the law in land ownership and recognises that without equal land ownership a woman’s choices may be severely restricted: without land as collateral, there is often little access to credit. 4 Gender Code* Description Note: The essential starting point for any humanitarian project is to identify the number of women, girls, boys and men who are the target beneficiaries. This information is required in all project sheets. Gender Code 3 Targeted Actions Contributes significantly to gender equality The project’s principal purpose is to advance gender equality The gender analysis in the needs assessment justifies this project in which all activities and all outcomes advance gender equality. All targeted actions are based on gender analysis. In humanitarian settings, targeted actions are usually of these two types: 1. The project assists women, girls, boys or men who suffer discrimination. The project needs analysis identifies the women, girls, boys and men who are acutely disadvantaged, discriminated against or lacking power and voice to make the most of their lives. Targeted actions aim to reduce the barriers so all women, girls, boys and men are able to exercise and access their rights, responsibilities and opportunities. Because the primary purpose of this targeted action is to advance gender equality, the code is 3. 2. The project focuses all activities on building gender-specific services or more equal relations between women and men. The analysis identifies rifts or imbalances in male-female relations that generate violence; undermine harmony or wellbeing within affected populations, or between them and others; or prevent humanitarian aid from reaching everyone in need. As the primary purpose of this type of targeted action is to address these rifts or imbalances in order to advance gender equality, the code is 3. Targeted actions are often designed as interim measures: they address gender gaps and create a level playing field. Code 3 projects use targeted actions solely to address gender gaps & create greater equality between women and men. Gender Code 2 Gender Mainstreaming Contributes significantly to gender equality A gender analysis is included in the project’s needs assessment and is reflected in a number of the project’s activities and project outcomes. Gender mainstreaming in project design is about making the concerns and experiences of women, girls, boys and men an integral dimension of the core elements of the project: gender analysis in the needs assessment leads to gender-responsive activities and related gender outcomes. This careful gender mainstreaming in project design facilitates gender equality then flowing into implementation, monitoring and evaluation. This intention, and a design that plans for measurement of gendered outcomes, is clearly articulated throughout the project sheet Most humanitarian projects should aim for code 2. In a perfect world, targeted actions would not be needed and the highest quality project, from a gender perspective, would be a project that fully mainstreams gender. Today, both gender targeted and mainstreamed projects are needed. Gender Code 1 Contributes in some limited way to gender equality Gender Code 0 May not contribute to gender equality The project includes gender equality in the needs assessment, in an activity or in an outcome. However, there is no clear indication that gender analysis flows from the needs assessment into activities or their related outcomes. These projects have pieces, like the pieces of a jigsaw puzzle, but not enough pieces to fit together ensuring male and female beneficiaries’ needs are both addressed. The project design does not guarantee that the project will have a positive impact on gender inequality. Gender is not reflected anywhere in the project sheet. There is risk that the project will unintentionally nurture existing gender inequalities or deepen them. 5