CR A Ap plication Form for MOC Appro val Approval of Accredited Group Learning Activities: Section 1 of the Framework of CPD Options of the Maintenance of Certification Program Program Title: Location of Event/Program: City Province Program/Event Dates: Start Date End Date PART #1: ORGANIZATION REQUESTING APPROVAL Activities submitted for approval under Section 1 must meet the requirements for either Option 1 or 2. Option 1: We are a physician organization that is planning this educational event alone or in conjunction with another physician organization. Option 2: We are a physician organization that is co-developing this educational event with a non-physician organization. We (the physician organization) have been involved in planning this event and accept accountability for its entire program. If you do not meet the criteria in Option 1 or 2, we will not be able to consider your application; the program is ineligible for Section 1 credits. Other options for obtaining credit exist for CPD activities that have not been reviewed or approved; please refer to the General Maintenance of Certification Information on the Royal College website. Co-Development: If you wish CRA to consider a co-development program, please call the CRA Accreditation Office for more information regarding the process. The first step prior to submitting an application will be to provide a “Letter of Intent” outlining the project. The CRA needs to be involved in the planning process from the beginning. This includes planning, the needs assessment, development of learning objectives, speaker selection, program design, implementation and evaluation. This constitutes educational co-development. For co-development, CRA must be contacted before any planning commences. Note that a sponsor cannot take part in the planning process, be on the planning committee, select speakers nor be involved in the development of learning objectives. Physician Organization: A not-for-profit group of health professionals with a formal governance structure, accountable to and serving, among others, its specialist physician members through: Continuing professional development Provision of health care; and/or Research This definition includes (but is not limited to) the following groups: Faculties of medicine CRA MOC Section 1 Application Form Page 1 of 7 Hospital departments or divisions Medical (specialty) societies Medical associations Medical academies Physician research organizations Health authorities not linked to government agencies Canadian Provincial Medical Regulatory Authorities (MRAs) This definition excludes pharmaceutical companies or their advisory groups, medical supply and surgical supply companies, communication companies or other for-profit organizations and ventures/activities. Types of organizations that are not considered Physician Organizations: Disease-oriented patient advocacy organizations (e.g. Canadian Diabetes Association) Government departments or agencies (e.g. Health Canada, Public health Agency of Canada) Industry (e.g. pharmaceutical companies, medical device companies, etc.) Medical education or communications (MEC) companies (e.g. CME Inc.) For-profit online educators, publishing companies or simulation companies (e.g. Medscape, CAE) Small number of physicians working together to develop educational programming Is the program sponsored by a physician organization: Yes No If yes: Name of the physician organization: Name of any non-physician organizations involved in planning this program/event: Chair of the Planning Committee Requesting Approval: Address: E-mail: Fax: ( ) Phone: ( ) Contact person and email to copy correspondence: Is this event on-line only? Yes Is this a recurring activity: Yes No No Number of times this activity will reoccur within one year from date of accreditation: (A recurring event refers to one event occurring several times in the same year, with the same content, program, faculty, objectives, etc. for each occurrence. If there is any variation, each event must be accredited separately.) NOTE: if a program is covering travel, accommodation or other personal expenses to participants, the program is not eligible for Section 1 credits. For further information, please refer to Section 32 of the CMA Guidelines for Physicians in Interactions with Industry (2007) and the Royal College interpretation which states: “All accredited group CME/CPD events cannot provide funding for physicians or their families to travel to attend events or to pay for their lodging or other related costs.” PART #2: MANDATORY EDUCATIONAL REQUIREMENTS Criteria 1: The activity must be planned to address the identified needs of the target audience. Please provide an explanation or supporting documentation for each of the following questions: 1. Who is the target audience for this activity? Please indicate specific specialties and, if applicable, indicate other health professionals for whom the activity is intended. CRA MOC Section 1 Application Form Page 2 of 7 2. List all members of the planning committee, their medical specialty or health profession, and indicate which are representing the physician organization? 3. What sources of information were selected by the planning committee to define the content of this activity? For example, reviews of the scientific or education literature; clinical practice guidelines; surveys or focus groups conducted by the sponsoring organization. Optional 4. What gaps in knowledge, attitudes, skills, or performance did the planning committee identify for this event? For example, physician performance information from hospitals or provincial / national databases; self-assessment tests; case scenarios; quality improvement activities or audits of practice. Criteria 2: The activity must create learning objectives to address identified needs. The learning objectives must be printed in the program brochure/materials or in the online information. Objectives should clearly state what a participant will know or be able to do as a result of attending an event or session. Click here for information on creating learning objectives. Please provide an explanation and supporting documentation for the following issues or questions: 1. What learning objectives were developed for this activity? a) The overall event? b) Specific sessions? 2. How were the identified needs of the target audience utilized in the creation/development of the learning objectives? 3. Do the learning objectives express what the participants will know or achieve by participating in the activity? Yes No 4. How are the learning objectives linked to the evaluation strategies for the activity? For example does the evaluation form list the learning objectives or pose questions to participants about whether the learning objectives were met? Criteria 3: At least 25% of the total education time must be devoted to interactive learning strategies. Please send the proposed course schedule, with times, indicating discussion periods, workshops, small group sessions etc., and provide an explanation or supporting documentation for the following issues or questions: 1. What learning methods have been incorporated to promote interactive learning? For example, discussion periods, small group, workshops or seminars, audience response system? Criteria 4: The activity must include an evaluation of the event’s established learning objectives and the learning outcomes identified by the participants. CRA MOC Section 1 Application Form Page 3 of 7 The evaluation strategies for events approved under Section 1 must include an assessment of the achievement of the identified learning objectives and provide opportunities for participants to identify what they have learned and its potential impact for their practice. Please provide a copy of the evaluation tools developed for this activity. The evaluation form should include opportunities for the participant to identify what they have learned and its potential impact on stimulating further learning or for their practice (i.e. Personal Leardning Projects (PLPs); commitment to change). For information on evaluation, please click here. Please provide a copy of the evaluation form and respond to the following questions: 1. Do you provide an opportunity for participants to identify if the stated learning objectives were achieved? Yes: No: (If no, please revise accordingly before you submit) 2. Are there opportunities for participants to identify and/or reflect on what they have learned? (One example of this would be a questions asking what the participants learned or plan to integrate into their practice) Yes: No: The Royal College offers a toolkit on writing learning objectives: to view, please click here. Optional (3, 4 and 5) 3. Does the evaluation strategy intend to evaluate enhanced participant performance? Yes No If yes, please describe the tools or strategies used: 4. Does the evaluation strategy intend to evaluate improved health care outcomes? Yes No If yes, please describe the tools or strategies used: 5. Will the participants receive feedback related to their learning? Yes No If yes, please describe the tools or strategies used: PART #3: MEETING ETHICAL STANDARDS FOR CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION Group CPD events approved under Section 1 must meet the Canadian Medical Association’s Guidelines for Physicians in Interactions with Industry (Update 2007) (http://policybase.cma.ca/dbtw-wpd/Policypdf/PD08-01.pdf). In the province of Québec, the Code of Ethics for Parties Involved in Continuing Medical Education (http://ww.cemcq.qc.ca/en/documents/guide_ethique.pdf) of the Conseil de l’éducation médicale continue du Québec (CEMCQ)* must be met; and the CPD event or program evaluation form must include the following question: “Did the activity comply with the Code of Ethics for Parties Involved in Continuing Medical Education?” * The CEMCQ has changed its name. While documents still refer to the CEMCQ, future documents will include the new name of the organization: Conseil québécois de développement professionnel continu des médecins (CQDPCM). Please read: Any financial assistance provided (for travel or accommodation) to reimburse physicians or their families for attending an educational event is not permitted would result in non-approval of this application. For more information on the CMA guidelines regarding financial support from industry, please see the CMA Policy: Guidelines for Physicians in Interactions with Industry (Update 2007) at the above website. Each of the following ethical standards MUST be met for this event to be approved under Section 1: 1. The physician organization must have control over the topics and content of the activity, as well as the speakers invited to present at the activity. We comply with this standard Yes No Describe the process by which the topics, content and speakers were selected for this event: CRA MOC Section 1 Application Form Page 4 of 7 2. The physician organization must assume responsibility for ensuring the scientific validity, objectivity, and completeness of the content of the activity. We comply with this standard Yes No Describe the process to ensure validity and objectivity of the content for this event: 3. The sponsoring or co-sponsoring organization must disclose to participants all financial affiliations of faculty, moderators or members of the planning committee (within the past two years) with any commercial organization(s) regardless of its connections to the topics discussed or mentioned during the event We comply with this standard Yes No Describe how conflict of interest information is collected and disclosed to participants: Note: Completed conflict disclosures from all speakers/faculty are required prior to an event. Conflicts, or lack of conflicts, are to be disclosed on the second slide of the speaker’s presentation. For a sample disclosure form, contact the CRA or click here. 4. All funds received in support of this activity must be provided in the form of an educational grant payable to the sponsoring organization.* We comply with this standard Yes No Please include a copy of the detailed budget for this program that identifies each source of revenue and each expenditure for this event. Please describe how the physician organization(s) assumes responsibility for the distribution of these funds, including the payment of honoraria to faculty. Please identify all organizations that are funding this activity. 5. No drug or product advertisement may appear on or with any of the written material for this event. We comply with this standard 6. Yes No A) Generic names should be used on all presentations and written materials. If trade names are used they should be accompanied by the generic name. We comply with this standard: Yes No B) Describe the process to advocate speakers’ adherence to using generic names of medications and/or devices included within all presentations or written materials. We comply with this standard Yes No Note: Accreditation statements cannot be located near any sponsorship recognition. Sponsorship recognition cannot be located within the scientific content. The accreditation statement is to be located within the program. Signage with sponsor recognition cannot be located within the room where the educational activity is taking place. CRA MOC Section 1 Application Form Page 5 of 7 DOCUMENTATION REQUIRED: All documentation must be included with your application. Applications are to be submitted 6 weeks before program start date. Incomplete applications will delay the review process. Completed application form emailed to accreditation@rheum.ca Yes Detailed program/course outline Yes No No If applicable, the evaluation summary of this program from last year Yes Learning objectives for each presentation Yes No NA No Detailed budget (Revenue sources and expenses need to be itemized) and sponsorship information (please contact us for a sample budget template) Yes No A copy of the evaluation form (each presentation is to be evaluated) Yes No Completed conflict disclosures for all faculty/speakers/planning committee members Yes Copy of the certificate of attendance/participation Yes Application Fee Yes No No No For online programs, I have reviewed the document Criteria for Approval of Online CPD Events Yes For co-developed applications only: a copy of the minutes of the planning committee Yes and a copy of the needs assessment Yes No No No DECLARATION: As Chair of the Planning Committee, I accept the responsibility for the accuracy of the information provided in response to the questions listed on this application and, to the best of my knowledge, certify that the CMA’s guidelines, entitled “Physicians and the Pharmaceutical Industry (2007) (sections 21-40) have been met in preparing for this CPD event. I confirm that the required documentation is complete and attached. If this event is held in Québec, we are aware that it is mandatory to adhere to the Conseil québécois de développement professionnel continu des médecins (CQDPCM) (CQDPCM), Code of Ethics for parties involved in Continuing Medical Education. Chair of the Planning Committee: Print name: Signature: Date of application: NOTE: The date of review commences on the date the completed application is received. The application fee is nonrefundable even in the event the application is declined. If the application is approved, this fee will be applied to the full accreditation fee. In order to give the CRA the opportunity to adequately review your program and make any suggestions for improvement, please submit your application as soon as possible in advance of the event. Please allow up a minimum of six (6) weeks for Section 1 review and several months for co-development applications. Applications submitted three weeks from the start date of the program may be rejected. Upon exception, the application may be reviewed as a rush and an Expedited Accreditation Fee will be applied. If you have a rush application, please contact the CRA prior to submission of the application. Co-developed programs are not eligible for expedited review. CRA MOC Section 1 Application Form Page 6 of 7 FEE STRUCTURE PROVIDER ACCREDITATION PROCESS FEE NON-REFUNDABLE APPLICATION FEE* Physician organization with no private sector funding Section 1 Approval $500 (plus HST) $100 (plus HST) Physician organization with funding from private sector Section 1 Approval $1,000 (plus HST) $200 (plus HST) Physician organization Section 3 Approval $1,000 (plus HST) $200 (plus HST) $7,500 $750 (plus HST) Non-physician organization Educational co-development where CRA would be represented on the planning committee from the onset of planning. (Section 1 and 3) Plus a $1,500 Administration fee Plus a $250 Maintenance Fee per each recurring event five and more (taxes apply to all fees) * Non-refundable application fee must accompany the application (if approved, this fee will be applied to the full accreditation fee) APPLICATIONS FOR CO-DEVELOPMENT CONSIDERATION: Please include a non-refundable application fee of $750 plus HST for consideration of co-development applications. Should your application be approved, the application fee will be applied to the accreditation fee. In the event that a co-developed program does not take place or is declined, the nonrefundable application fee and the administration fee will not be refunded. The applicant should keep an electronic copy of the completed application form and submitted documentation. The non–accredited provider has the responsibility for maintaining and documenting an ethical relationship with industry supporters; maintaining records of the evaluations and participation rests with the non-accredited provider. GENERAL INFORMATION Applications may NOT be submitted after an event. Section 1 approval is valid for 12 months. Applicants should keep a list of their attendees for record purposes for a period of five (5) years. The non-accredited provider is to maintain records of CPD activity (materials, attendance) and submit information to the Validation Program on request by the Royal College. General Maintenance of Certification information can be found on the Royal College website. Notice of approval of this activity will be forwarded to the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada in order to list your event on the Royal College web site. The College will also be notified of applications that are declined. Click here for the Royal College Accreditation Tool Kit. Guidelines for Accredited Providers of CPD Activities The Notification of Review of a Group Learning Activity will be completed by the Accredited Provider upon approval of your program/workshop and the information will be forwarded to the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. The information provided on the notification form will be used to list your event on the Royal College web site. Email completed application form with documentation to: CRA Accreditation Office 421 Gilmour Street, Suite 300 Ottawa ON K2P 0R5 Tel: 613-986-2746 / accreditation@rheum.ca Please advise the CRA Accreditation Office promptly if you do not receive a Notice of Receipt of Submission within 72 hours of submission. It is the applicant's responsibility to ensure the completed application is received. May 2015 CRA MOC Section 1 Application Form Page 7 of 7