Wind Energy Capability & Experience Risktec is an independent, specialist risk management consulting and training company wholly owned by its employees. We assist clients in major hazard industries and commercial and public sectors to manage Health, Safety, Security and Environmental [HSSE] and Business Risk. Risktec has successfully transferred lessons learned in the traditional high/major risk industries to the relatively new Wind Energy Industry including how to manage risk in an appropriate, sensible and cost-effective manner, ensuring proportionate approaches are adopted. Risktec is actively engaged with the Wind Energy Industry and is fully committed to helping it play its part in the fight against climate change in a manner which reduces risk to acceptable levels thereby protecting people, the environment, assets, reputation and financial/business stability. Engineering Risk Reduction Planning Management Systems Improvements Risk reduction “enablers” Improved Culture & Behaviours Project Lifecycle Risk We provide a range of services to the Wind Energy Industry. Case Studies of typical projects are presented below and cross-referenced to show how our services cover the entire lifecycle of a project as well as the key risk reduction “enablers”, as illustrated in the following diagram. Design Construction Operation & Maintenance Decommissioning Time Click here to see our series of articles on Risk Management or go to our ‘Knowledge Bank’ at www.risktec.co.uk www.windenergynetwork.co.uk Safety Assessment/Justification of Wind Turbines adjacent to Safety Significant Infrastructure Risktec produced the Safety Justification [SJ] for a Wind Farm adjacent to two Top Tier COMAH [Control Of Major Accident Hazards] Sites in Milford Haven, Wales. This SJ was independently peer reviewed and endorsed by the Health and Safety Laboratories. The quality of this SJ and the accompanying positive peer review was seen as the deciding factor in the wind farm developer being granted planning permission. This SJ presented the culmination of a robust Safety Assurance Process [SAP] which was integrated with project development activities including a probabilistic assessment of the threat of turbine blade “throw” to adjacent oil and gas storage tanks. This integrated SAP ensured that the wind farm design/layout evolved such that the risk posed to the neighbouring sites did not increase their existing risk profile to any significant extent, with this risk reduced As Low As Reasonably Practicable [ALARP]. Risktec has since used this tried and tested methodology to assess the risk posed by wind turbines sited in close proximity to other safety significant infrastructure including a Nuclear Power Station, a range of other Top Tier COMAH Sites, various Chemical Processing Sites, Port Facilities and Motorways. “Responsible Siting Standard” for Small Wind Turbine Manufacturer Risktec developed a “Responsible Siting Standard” [RSS] which could be used to determine whether a proposed turbine location is appropriate and safe. There was concern that installers/developers were installing turbines in unsuitable locations. The manufacturer had no control over turbine siting and, whilst they were not responsible for each installation, they were worried about the effects of an incident on their reputation and the Industry in general. To mitigate against this, Risktec developed a web application which provided the practical implementation of the RSS for use by their installers/developers to determine/demonstrate that each proposed location was safe. By making this part of their “conditions of sale”, the manufacturer would regain control over specific siting issues, ensuring that their turbines were only erected on sites where it was demonstrated that the risk was acceptable. www.risktec.co.uk Occupational Health & Safety Management System for Wind Farm Operator Risktec supported a UK onshore wind farm developer/owner/operator in developing an Occupational Health and Safety Management System [OHSMS] consistent with OHSAS 18001. An OHSMS provides a structured set of procedures, policies and controls for managing occupational health and safety within overall business operations to ensure that all reasonably practicable measures are taken to reduce the possibility of an accident, illness, injury or fatality in the workplace and limit the effects were one to occur. Assessment to determine whether Access Lifts should be retro-fitted to UK Wind Farm Using the "Safe Wind Turbine Tower Access; A Decision Making Framework" [which we helped develop for the BWEA (now RenewableUK)], Risktec completed a detailed assessment to determine whether a major UK wind farm owner/operator should retro-fit access lifts to one of their operational wind farms. This assessment comprised a detailed engineering/design review of the proposed access lift design, a detailed risk assessment of both the existing access arrangements and proposed lift system and a comprehensive "cost-benefit" analysis. Assessment of Compliance of Turbine Lift System with new Machinery Directive The latest version of the European Union Machinery Directive presents far more onerous and prescriptive requirements relevant to wind turbine lifts. These assessments considered the use of the access lift in normal and credible fault/emergency scenarios and demonstrated that, whilst a number of specific shortfalls were present, a fully compliant solution would actually compromise safety in the context of an overall Safe System Of Work [SSOW]. Risktec presented detailed justification for the current design/arrangements demonstrating that the lift system has been designed and is operated such that risk is reduced to acceptable levels and ALARP. “Bowtie” Diagrams for Offshore Cable Installation Company In support of a due diligence process for a deepwater cable installation company, Risktec produced a number of “Bowtie” diagrams to illustrate how all engineering/business risks are controlled and identify any areas of weakness that require remedial action. The “Bowtie” technique is Prevention Mitigation an extremely powerful way of communicating how risk Conseqis being managed within an operation, business etc. It Threat Hazard uence helps to ensure that risks are managed rather than just analysed, partly by going beyond the usual risk assessment ‘snapshot’ and highlighting links between risk controls and management systems. Top Event Conseq- Wind Energy Industry Health and Safety Threat uence Performance Measurement and Improvement Risktec has developed a flexible and evolutionary Conseqapproach for measuring and improving health and Threat uence safety performance for RenewableUK. Risktec undertook a very extensive review and consultation Barriers process, which resulted in strong support from members for proposals which emphasised simplicity, Safety-critical activities practicability and security of information, while demonstrably promoting health and safety improvement and being specifically tailored to this Industry sector. The developed process is based on the Safety-critical equipment collection and risk-based prioritisation of information generated from actual incidents and health and safety management surveys. This information is used to enable benchmarking, sharing of lessons learned, and the derivation of Key Safety Performance Indicators [KSPIs], as part of a structured and systematic H&S improvement cycle. By focussing the solution on an evolutionary process rather than a set of static KSPIs, the KSPIs evolve over time, directly reflecting the fast changing nature of the Industry. This approach ensures that the KSPIs will always provide an appropriate ‘snap-shot’ of current health and safety performance, remaining relevant and appropriate to the most important challenges at any given time, hence driving safety improvement across the industry. Quantitative Risk Assessment – Boat Transfer to Offshore Wind Turbines Risktec supported a client who conducts vessel crew changes to offshore wind turbines. A quantitative assessment of the risk to personnel transferring to offshore wind turbines via workboat from a mother vessel was completed. An assessment of the different transport stages was completed and Risktec compared the assessed risk against other transport methods whilst benchmarking current accident/incident data against relevant industry data to generate a detailed understanding of the relative risks of these activities. UK Offices: Warrington, Aberdeen, Edinburgh, Glasgow, London, Crawley, Bristol Overseas Offices: Dubai, Muscat, Houston, Calgary E-mail: enquiries@risktec.co.uk Phone: +44(0)1355 340200 www.risktec.co.uk