Returned & Services League of Australia (South Australia Branch) Policy for Management of Veterans’ Graves The sobriquet “We will remember them - Lest We Forget” is synonymous with the Returned & Services League (RSL) and is the baseline tenet of the RSL’s views in respect of veteran graves and memorials. Deceased Australian veterans’ remains are in locations as diverse as the fortunes of war and, for those who survived, the subsequent peace. The resting place of many is unknown; lost at sea or over land as a result of naval and air and military operations where their remains have been consumed by the environment in which they were lost. Known war dead are interred in designated places under the control of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission (CWGC) or the Australian Office of War Graves (AOWG). Designated Commonwealth War Graves Commission sites, and those administered by the Office of Australian War Graves, are sites sacred to our national heritage and must be respected as such. They are typified by the Western Front cemeteries in France and Belgium, located on land ceded by the respective governments in perpetuity. Where established War Graves (such as CWGC and AOWG) sites exist in Australia, such sites should be retained in perpetuity and exempted from tenured lease arrangements by legislation or regulation, if necessary. Veterans who are deceased subsequent to their service in conflict may be commemorated in a number of ways: a. AIF Cemetery. The AIF Cemetery at West Terrace in Adelaide, comprising some 4,000 graves of AIF veterans who died post World War I has inherent historical significance. It is exempted by the Adelaide Cemeteries Authority from tenured re-use because of its heritage status. Consideration should be given to formalising this by regulation / legislation from any re-use provision. b. Services Cemeteries Trust. This Trust is administered by the RSL in collaboration with metropolitan and country cemetery authorities. Sites may be full burial or cremation. Sites in SA include: AIF Cemetery, West Terrace, Adelaide (Heritage listed) Derrick Garden of Remembrance at Centennial Park Cemetery, Daw Park Rev 0.1, 29/4/15 Kibby Garden of Remembrance at Enfield Memorial Park, Enfield Pt Lincoln Garden of Remembrance, Pt Lincoln Pt Pirie Garden of Remembrance, Pt Pirie Upper Murray Garden of Remembrance, Renmark RSL Graves - Currency Creek Cemetery, Goolwa Service Cemeteries Trust sites are marked with commemorative plaques. RSL should obtain an indication from the authorities of each of the above to ascertain the situation at each in respect of tenured re-use. Where a site may be subject to tenured re-use, the preservation and conservation of the commemorative plaques should be required of the cemetery authority such that they are photographed, documented and uploaded to the RSL Virtual War Memorial website, and retained so as to allow easy physical access, in for example, a commemorative wall. c. General interments. Many veterans are interred and or commemorated as part of a family plot or similar arrangement, or as a single burial in the general section of suburban or town cemeteries. Suburban sites will generally be subject to tenured leases. Where it is recorded that a veteran is interred or commemorated, the Cemetery Authority should be required to ensure that any headstone / plaque is to be physically preserved, recorded and documented by the Cemetery Authority. The RSL advocates that upload of pertinent information to the RSL Virtual War Memorial website be required. Where no disclosure of service is made or is evident in cemetery records or on headstones / plaques, the RSL is not in a position, nor is it appropriate for it to advocate for any requirement or onus being placed on the Cemetery Authority. Disclosure or otherwise is a family decision taken at the time of interment. It is not the place of the RSL to retrospectively second guess family intentions or wishes. Tens of thousands of our war dead have no known grave. Contemporary practices such as scattering the ashes of cremated deceased persons are an increasing trend. These facts underline the contention that physical remains are arguably less critical than the memorialisation of the person. Where the remains of war dead are recovered on a battlefield, an established process exists to ensure all reasonable efforts are made to identify any such remains and effect an appropriate re-interment. Rev 0.1, 29/4/15 However, once graves have been established, their future needs to be clearly understood. Where established War Graves (such as CWGC and AOWG) sites exist, such sites should be retained in perpetuity and exempted from tenured lease arrangements by legislation. The AIF Cemetery on West Terrace has unique heritage and historical significance and is to be exempted for any re-use provision in the same way as specified historical precincts in the rest of West Terrace Cemetery. Heritage cemeteries exist in various locations. They are generally not subject to tenured re-use. RSL contends that this is entirely appropriate and supports the application of heritage status in accordance with current practice. What remains unresolved is how this might apply in the future. The issue in regional locations is less clear; this is perhaps an issue for consideration by the Local Government Association. The RSL administers the Services Cemeteries Trust. Graves covered by the Service Cemeteries Trust are located in a number of sites as per the RSL website. In addition graves may exist elsewhere marked with Commemorative Plaques made available through the Trust. Whether or not these graves are subject to tenured re-use is a function of the policy of individual Cemetery Authorities. Some of these are tenured. Others, such as Kibby Gardens at Enfield Cemetery, are not because to do so would disrupt the nature of the site. The Services Cemeteries Trust does not have the capacity to renew tenured sites. The RSL-SA requests that Cemetery Authorities consider following the approach of the Adelaide Cemeteries Authority at Kibby Gardens in exempting grouped veteran graves from tenured re-use arrangements. Where veteran graves that are so-identified are located in a cemetery such that it may be subject to tenured re-use, the preservation and conservation of commemorative plaques and memorial headstones should be required of the cemetery authority such that they are photographed, documented and retained so as to allow easy physical access. A commemorative wall or similar would be an appropriate means of achieving this without compromising available space to any great degree. Rev 0.1, 29/4/15 General interments. Many veterans are interred and or commemorated as part of a family plot or similar arrangement, or as a single burial in the general section of suburban cemeteries. These sites will generally be subject to tenured leases. o Where it is recorded that a veteran is interred or commemorated, the Cemetery Authority should be required to ensure that any headstone / plaque is to physically preserved, recorded and documented by the Cemetery Authority. It is proposed that this process would include upload to the RSL Virtual War Memorial website as a standard operating procedure. o Where no disclosure of service is made, is evident in cemetery records or on headstones / plaques, the RSL is not in a position, nor is it appropriate, for it to advocate for any requirement or onus being placed on the Cemetery Authority. Disclosure or otherwise of service history is a family decision taken at the time of interment. It is not the place of the RSL to retrospectively second-guess family intentions or wishes where there is no overt evidence. o The RSL-SA, the Services Cemeteries Trust and related agencies are not in any position to pay for lease renewal. o There may be scope for the Services Cemeteries Trust to provide a plaque for the service person at the family’s request, for inclusion in some kind of perpetual memorialisation such as on a commemorative wall. Funding mechanisms would need to be resolved because the Trust does not have the capacity to do so. Justification The handling / interment of the physical remains of deceased persons varies significantly across cultures. Methods include: Below ground burial – generally with a memorial / commemorative headstone. Above-ground repositories such as family mausoleums and ‘necropolis(i?)’; literally, ‘cities of the dead’. These are popular in Continental European cultures. Cremation, with or without repositories for the ashes Ossaries are repositories of skeletal remains – common in Europe where they are often described as ‘catacombs’ dating back centuries. In places like Verdun and Caporetto (Italy) they are used to house the remains of war dead. For hygiene and sanitation reasons, the management of burials sites is subject to strict controls. Rev 0.1, 29/4/15 All of the methods above require real estate, with cremation requiring the least. Some forms of cremation, where the subject’s ashes are scattered, do not require any. T.J Hanna State President 28 April 2015 Rev 0.1, 29/4/15