Investigating How Tidal Changes Affect the Chemical Composition of Water in Zones 1, 3, and 5 of the Ala Wai Canal Calvin Chan, Emily Cockey, Shayne Rasay, Janine Yim AP Biology – Shimamoto Period 2 January 14, 2011 Abstract: The project investigated the effect of tidal changes on the chemical composition of water (pH, salinity, turbidity, total dissolved solids, dissolved nitrate and oxygen concentration, and conductivity) in zones 1, 3, and 5 of the Ala Wai Canal in Honolulu, Hawaii. A YSI sonde collected data every 0.5 second for one minute at each of the zones over a period of three days, once at low tide and once at high tide on every day. The experiment showed that pH and total dissolved solids were unaffected by tidal changes. On the other hand, levels of dissolved oxygen and nitrogen and salinity were higher at high tide whereas turbidity was higher at low tide. Levels of salinity and oxygen were also found to be related as salinity levels rose at a higher rate than the levels of dissolved oxygen. Turbidity was found to be inversely related to the dissolved oxygen measurements in all three sites. 2 I. Introduction & Research The Ala Wai Canal is a small drainage estuary in Honolulu, Hawaii located at the western entrance to Waikiki. It is a narrow artificial waterway created in the 1920s in order to to trap the “combined drainage” of the Manoa and Palolo Streams (Glenn CR, 1995). In general, the canal is a “class A” saltwedge estuary, the most stratified of all types of estuaries, affected by tidal flushing (De Carlo EH, 1995). In a saltwedge estuary, fresh water floats on a layer of salt water that thins seaward and the denser saltwater moves along the bottom of the estuary as it thickens landward (Mann, 2011). For the purposes of this investigation the Ala Wai has been divided into five approximately equal sites, with site five nearest to the mouth of the Ala Wai where the salt water flows into the fresh water. One of the chemical properties of water calculated is pH and how it changes at different tides. pH measures the hydrogen ion (H+) concentration on a logarithmic scale from one to fourteen. The pH of a solution is neutral at seven indicating that the H+ concentration is equivalent to the hydroxide (OH-) concentration. When pH is below seven, a solution is acidic because the concentration of H+ is greater than the OH- concentration. Vice versa, when pH is above seven, the solution is basic as the OH- concentration is greater than the H+ concentration. Each step on the pH scale is ten times 3 more intense than its predecessor. In other words, a pH three solution is ten times more acidic than a pH four solution (Senese, 2010). The optimum pH differs in all bodies of water. Depending on the pH, different organisms live in certain areas. Most waters have a pH range from 6.5 to 8.0 The range of pH can however vary due to certain conditions such as acid rain (lower pH) and waste dumped into the water, which can potentially harm the organisms that are used to living with a certain pH. Organisms function best at a constant pH so buffers that prevent variation in pH are important in all bodies of water. The property that indicates a body of water’s ability to maintain a stable pH is called alkalinity. A high alkalinity is beneficial to organisms and can be produced by certain rocks and salts that aid in the buffering process (Addy, 2003). Another water property observed is salinity. Salinity, or the measure of salt concentration, varies in estuaries due to geographic location, tides, and weather (National Ocean Service, 2008). In general, salinity varies according to one’s position near the ends of the estuary. By convention, sea water has a rather consistent salinity of approximately 32 - 35 ppt, or parts per thousand and fresh water has a salinity closer to 0 ppt (Richard Stockton College, 2010). Thus, the source of ocean water at the mouth of the estuary has the highest salinity while the source of fresh water found further inland has the lowest salinity. Tides also affect the salinity. During ebb tides, in which river water flows towards the mouth of the estuary, salinity decreases inland. In flood tides, in which sea water flows inland, 4 salinity increase near the mouth of the estuary (Richard Stockton College, 2010). Hence, the distribution of salinity regions fluctuate with tides. Weather also changes salinity. During seasons of high precipitation, excess water dilutes the concentration of salt in the water, thus causing salinity to decrease. When temperatures rise, evaporation of water increases, which leaves more solute in the water and thereby increases salinity. Hence, wetter seasons typically decrease salinity and warmer seasons increase salinity. Salinity has a variety of effects on organisms and the solubility of solutes. One determinant of an organism’s survival in an environment is its ability to osmoregulate. In estuaries, salinity changes frequently and spontaneously with environmental shifts. If the ecosystem is hypertonic to the organism in salt concentration, water will flow out of the organism through osmosis. However, if too much water flows out of the organism, the organism’s cells may shrivel and die. If the ecosystem is hypotonic to the organism in salt concentration, water will flow into the organism. When too much water enters the organism, the organism's cells may become turgid for plants or lyse. While fluctuations in salinity have little effect on organisms that have adapted to salinity changes via, for instance, contractile vacuoles or active transport, changes in salinity may adversely affect the survival of organisms with low tolerances to salt changes. A limited amount of solute can dissolve in a given solvent. When additional solute molecules are added to a saturated solution, which contains the maximum amount of dissolved solute, the molecules will not dissolve but crystallize. Hence, higher concentrations of dissolved salt, leads to lower concentrations of dissolved solutes such as oxygen and vice versa. The third property investigated in the project was turbidity. Turbidity measures the cloudiness of water due to suspended matter such as “clay, silt, finely divided organic matter, 5 microscopic organisms, and similar material” (American Public Health Association, 1917). Measured in nephelometric turbidity units (NTU), turbidity is a measure of the amount of light scattered by particles while traveling through water. As the amount of suspended substances increase, the scattering of light and thereby turbidity increases accordingly (Murphy, 2007). Bodies of water that appear relatively clear to the naked eye can have maximum turbidity measure of 25 NTU while muddy water has a minimum turbidity measure of 100 NTU (Myre, 2006). Mainly due to its primary contributor, the Manoa drainage basin, turbidity levels in the Ala Wai Canal are high (Lau, 2006). High flow rates, soil erosion, urban runoff, waste water discharge, decaying organisms, bottom-feeding fish, algal blooms, and flooding are all factors that affect turbidity. Hence, total dissolved solids (TDS) values are closely related to turbidity. When a body of water has a high flow rate (fast running water), the current is able to carry more organic particles and sediments, which increases the amount of suspended substances on the surface of the water. Similarly, eroded soil particles and other substances carried downstream from industrial, commercial, and industrial communities by way of flooding increases the turbidity of the water. Water discharge that contains solids and organic materials from waste water treatment plants has the same effect. Within the water system itself, particles of decaying organisms, algal production, and the presence of bottom-feeding fish that stir up sediments from the bottom all contribute to turbidity (Murphy, 2007). Another important chemical property of water researched was the total dissolved solids of the estuary. The total dissolved solids (TDS) in water are directly related to the conductivity of the water. The solids that are present in the water can be natural or man-made and can be organic or inorganic. TDS is usually measure by evaporating a known value of the water and 6 massing the remaining solute, but conductivity is also a viable, if not less accurate, measure of TDS. Conductivity is the ability of a substance to carry a charge, and water’s conductivity increases as more solids are dissolved in it to help carry the charge. The polar nature of water makes it naturally conductive, but as the amount of solids increases the natural conductivity of water increases due to an increase of ions (FM River, 2004). Furthermore, the nitric oxide concentration of the canal was also investigated. Nitric oxide, or specifically nitrogen monoxide, is a byproduct gas of industrial combustion as well as the decay of organic materials. Nitrogen monoxide is a key molecule in many biological processes ranging from signaling to organ protection, but can also cause death in higher levels. The dawn of the industrial age and wide use of combustion led to an increase in atmospheric nitrogen monoxide from the burning of nitrogen gas and oxygen. Beside the toxic properties of the gas itself, the molecule can react with more oxygen to form nitrogen dioxide, which in turn dissolves in water to make nitric acid (Sam Houston State University, 2010). The concentration of nitrogen oxides can be an indicator of acidity of the water as wells as the amount of organic matter that decays in water depending on the tide. Finally, the oxygen and carbon dioxide concentrations were also observed. Dissolved gases in the water are indicators of the biological processes that occur in the water. Saturation of the water by dissolved gases can be increased by a decrease in temperature, decrease in salinity, and increase in depth (Hurst, 2002). Carbon dioxide is a byproduct gas of cellular respiration as well as an ingredient for photosynthesis and the reverse is true for oxygen gas. These two gases are usually balanced in the water due to the photosynthesizing organisms that either consume the oxygen present or have other organisms consume it. An increase in oxygen leads to an increase of respiration in order to generate energy while an increase in carbon dioxide leads to an increase 7 of photosynthesis. Dissolved carbon dioxide also plays an important role in regulating sea water and the atmosphere due to carbon dioxide’s reactions that control pH, rapid changes in carbon dioxide concentration, and distribution of sediments (Hurst, 2002). II.Materials and Methods YSI multi-parameter probe (Sonde Model 6920 V2) Data Display / Logger (YSI 650 MDS) 7.5 hp Zodiac Boat 6-foot aluminum rod to which YSI sonde is attached 1. The 7.5 hp Zodiac Boat was used to access the different zones. 2. The YSI sonde was secured to a 6-foot aluminum rod to place the probe at approximately one meter in zones 1, 3, and 5. 3. The hand-held data logger stored data files at 0.5 second intervals for one minute in each zone. 4. The experiment was performed over three days—twice a day during high tide and low tide III.Data See the last page IV. Discussion According to the investigation, pH was not significantly affected by tidal changes. While it fluctuates in a range from 0.0115 to 0.637 on November 13, 2010, in which there was outlying data as found in standard deviation, there is no apparent pattern to this fluctuation in reference to changes in the tide. Except for one outlying piece of data, pH of 4.92 in site one on November 13, 2010, which may have been attributed to faulty readings from the YSI or human error, the pH remains at an average of 7.396, a pH that is well within the optimal pH for estuaries of 6.5 to 8.0, regardless of day, tide, or weather. This is beneficial for the animal and plant life living in the Ala Wai because it allows them to live in a stable environment. The stability of pH shows that the Ala Wai has a high level of alkalinity and can support the constant lifestyle needed by organisms such as those that live in the Ala Wai Canal. 8 The salinity of the water did not follow a precise trend based on the sites’ positions from the mouth of the estuary. The average salinity for all the data taken during high tide was 31.41 ppt deviating by only 5.42, while the low tide was 22.79 deviating by 16.33. On October 21, 2010, during low tide, site 1 recorded a salinity of 0.46 ppt, site 3 a salinity of 1.22 ppt, and site 5 a salinity of 1.66 ppt. During high tide, site 1 recorded a salinity of 16.33 ppt, site 3 a salinity of 29.23 ppt, and site 5 a salinity of 37.35 ppt. Data from sites during low tide on October 30 also followed this trend. Since sea water has a higher salinity (between 32 – 35 ppt) than fresh water (about 0 ppt), the closer a site to the mouth of the estuary, the higher that site’s salinity. However, data collected on October 30, 2010 during high tide and November 13, 2010 did not follow this trend. Data from October 30, 2010 and November 13, 2010 showed that salinity was slightly higher in sites during high tide (with the exception of site one on November 13). This data confirmed that during high tides more sea water enters from the mouth of the estuary causing salinity in the estuary to rise. On November 13, 2010, the YSI multi-parameter probe recorded a salinity of 0 ppt at site 1 at a tide of 0.52 m. High precipitation on the 14th caused an ebb tide in which water from the Manoa and Palolo Streams flowed towards the mouth of the Ala Wai Estuary. The increase in fresh water at site 1 caused this extremely low salinity. The salinities at the sites during high tide on October 30 and November 13 were all very close to 35 ppt (with the exception of site 1 on November 13). Although the Ala Wai is stratified between freshwater and saltwater, it also contains areas in which the two waters mix. The higher the tidal current is, the more mixing occurs. Hence, during high tide, the waters mixed producing a nearly uniform mixture in salinity. 9 Discrepancies arose because groups measured salinity at differing depths when data was collected. Salinity at sites 1 and 3 during low tide on October 21 were significantly lower than salinity at low tides on October 30 and December 11. Perhaps since tidal currents were low during low tide, water at this time and at such a shallow depth (.46 m) was highly stratified with fresh water floating on top the salt water. When compared to the data on the other days, the salinity measured at the sites on October 21 during high tide was extremely low. While such low salinity may have resulted from a mistake on the YSI multi-parameter (since it was the group’s first time using the device), it may have also resulted due to the high presence of dissolved oxygen. The higher the salinity, the lower the percent of dissolved oxygen and vice versa. Hence, a limited solute can dissolve in a given amount of solvent. According to the data from October 30, 2010 and November 13, 2010 turbidity measurements were higher during low tide for all sites. On Oct. 30, 2010 the biggest difference between high tide and low tide measurements of turbidity was in Site 3 at 2.65 NTU; the smallest difference was in Site 5 at 0.65 NTU. However, on Nov. 13, 2010 the biggest difference between high tide and low tide measurements of turbidity was in Site 1 at 5.26 NTU; however, the smallest difference remained in Site 5 at only 0.02 NTU. In contrast, the data from Oct. 02, 2010 shows that turbidity measurements were higher at high tide for Sites 1 and 5 while higher at low tide in Site 3. Furthermore, the data set supports the Oct. 30, 2010 data which shows that turbidity difference between tides was the highest in Site 3 at 8.16 NTU. However, the data deviates from the other two because its smallest turbidity difference was in Site 1 at 3.56 NTU. Overall, the data demonstrates that the tidal changes most affect the turbidity of Site 3 and least affects Site 5. 10 A high turbidity value indicates that the water is murky or brackish. Turbidity increases during low tide for all sites because a lower water volume is disproportionately combined with the suspended solids in the canal. In other words, a combination of less water and more sediment leads to a high turbidity. Turbidity is especially high in Site 3 because of its location in the middle of the estuary. The total amount of suspended solids from the Manoa-Palolo Valley in Site 1 and the sea in Site 5 is heavily concentrated where they meet in the middle. Thus, turbidity is at its highest in the center of the estuary. On the other hand, low turbidity value indicates that the water is less murky and is closer to clear water. Turbidity is lowest in Site 5 because sediment and suspended solids collected from the drainage in Site 1 is significantly less in Site 5 because it is farther away. Sea water carries fewer solids and therefore contributes to a low turbidity value. The turbidity levels also showed a recurrent pattern of inverse relationship with the level of dissolved oxygen in the water. The data from Oct. 30, 2010 had the highest turbidity level at 6.88 NTU in Site 3 during low tide. At the same time, the dissolved oxygen concentration was at its lowest at 50.75%. Likewise, in the Nov. 13, 2010 data, the highest turbidity level was at 5.38 NTU while the dissolved oxygen concentration was at its lowest at 56.71%. The relationship between the two chemical properties shows that turbidity can impact the level of dissolved oxygen in water in many ways. Turbidity is the measure of how much light is absorbed by the particles in the water. When the sun’s rays are absorbed by the particles, energy is released as heat. Hence, water with a high turbidity value can be heated more rapidly by the sun, which causes the water to lose its ability to retain dissolved oxygen. This also gives insight to another inverse relationship between water temperature and levels of dissolved oxygen. Furthermore, soil particles and runoff from the Manoa-Palolo drainage may have carried with it nutrients that can 11 cause an outgrowth of algae. The decomposition of algae involves the consumption of significant quantities of oxygen, thereby decreasing the overall level of dissolved oxygen in the water. Thus, the algal blooms caused by high turbidity levels can cause a decrease in the amount of dissolved oxygen. Finally, the runoff can also have carried microorganisms and particles that have a high biological oxygen demand, which can again decrease the overall level of dissolved oxygen in the water. The low standard deviation values, ranging from approximately 0.25 to 1.0, for high tide turbidity measurements on Oct. 30, 2010 and on Nov. 13, 2010 indicate that the values were very consistent because they were relatively close to the average value. Hence, deviation from high turbidity value in all sites especially Site 3 during low tide and deviation from a low turbidity value in Site 5 may be due to the weather. The week of Nov. 13, 2010 included some rainy days, which may have added to the runoff from Manoa-Palolo Valley, thereby contributing to the amount of suspended solids in the estuary. Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) in the estuary do not seem to show any dominant trend in the data. Out of the days sampled, high tide shows a slightly higher concentration in some of the sites on certain days, but the amount of average TDS during low tide was dramatically higher than the high tide. The varying heights of the TDS on some days in some sites represent a lack of correlation between TDS and tide. There is a drop of TDS in a site during high tide, but an increase in tide also increases the TDS amount to levels similar to lower tide conditions. The average amount of TDS measured in the estuary is 26.96 g/L. The only conclusion drawn from the TDS data is the lack of correlation between tide and TDS. Since the Ala Wai estuary contains a vast amount of sediments from fresh and salt-water environments, the estuary tends to contain a constant amount of dissolved solids in the 12 water. Water can only dissolve so much sediment before it enters a state of saturation, or dissolved as much solid as the water can hold. Due to the lack of knowledge around the exact nature of the solids, the saturation level of the estuary is unknown and could easily be the levels measured. Whatever the height of the tide, the water in the estuary will maintain a constant amount of dissolved solids by depositing sediments on the bed of the canal to adjust for oversaturation (more solids dissolved in the water than the water can hold) or dissolving more solids to adjust for under-saturation (a state where water hold less dissolved solids than it can hold). The feature of the estuary to maintain a constant amount of dissolved solids allows a variety of plankton and other microorganisms to exist in its waters. For the first couple of moments during the tide change, fresh water and salt-water pockets could indicate an amount of dissolved sediments different from the actual amount, but overall the TDS is relatively unaffected by the nature of the tides. Hence, the Ala Wai estuary maintains a constant TDS that can dissolve in the water during any given tide. The nitrate data consistently shows a higher concentration of nitric oxide during high tide than during low tide. Besides showing a trend of higher amounts of nitrate during high tide, the data shows some days where the amount of nitrate was significantly higher than on the other days. Although the data for October 2, 2010 is significantly higher than the other days, the data collected from the low tide is proportionally higher than the other days as well. There are a few days where the low tide data drops significantly despite the proximity of the time the tides and data were measured. The average nitrate concentration during the days of high tide is 5.723mg/L deviating by 7.663 mg/L and the average concentration during low tide is 1.003 mg/L deviating by 1.0705. 13 The data shows a correlation between higher tides and higher amounts of nitric oxide in the water of the estuary. Since the tide goes up due to the inflow of seawater into the estuary, the increase of nitric oxide likely came from the main canal. The difference between the low tide and high tide amount of nitrate is smaller in site 5 than site 1. The fresh water flowing from upstream makes up a large amount of the estuary water during low tide and has small amounts of organic matter. The salty seawater that flows in from the ocean during low tide carries organisms, decaying organic matter, and human waste that contributes to the higher nitrate of the estuary during high tide. The higher concentration of nitrate generally means a higher amount of present organic substances are brought in during high tides and pushed out during low tides. Hence, as an abundance of nitrate moves in the estuary during high tide, the estuary naturally flushes back out that nitrate during low tide preventing the nitrate levels from becoming too inhospitable for life. In terms of dissolved oxygen, the low tide data shows a higher average percent across all three zones than the low tide data. The data from October 2, 2010 shows the most dramatic difference between the averages of dissolved oxygen. Due to the similarity of height of the tides at the time of measuring the October 30, 2010 and November 13, 2010 data, the difference between the high tide data than the low tide data is less noticeable, but the high tide still shows a higher percent of dissolved oxygen. The percent of dissolved oxygen consistently maintains a concentration of an average of 67.67% with a standard deviation of 29.94 during periods of high tide and 49.91% deviating by 26.67 during low tide. From the data, the Ala Wai estuary has a higher concentration of dissolved oxygen in the high tide period than in the low tide period. By interpreting the dissolved oxygen data, the concentration of dissolved carbon dioxide concludes to be higher during low tide and lower 14 during high tide. Since the data shows the highest concentration difference occurring during days when the difference between the high tide height and the low tide height was greatest, it can be reasonably concluded that tide affects the temperature, sediments, or metabolic processes or local organisms in a way that increases the concentration of carbon dioxide. A higher tide could correlate with the time of most sun that allows photosynthetic organisms to photosynthesize energy at a faster rate. An increase of cool, salty seawater into the estuary can decrease the concentration of gases of the water and adversely selects the carbon dioxide produced closer to the surface of the water to exit the water. The salinity of the water can inversely affect the percentage of dissolved oxygen since the higher the salinity of the water, the lower the percentage of dissolved oxygen. The data from the salinity measurements demonstrate an inverse relationship with the concentration of oxygen. By maintaining an environment with a high concentration of oxygen, the estuary can support a large amount of aerobic organisms when they come in during high tide. Error in this investigation may be due to faulty YSI readings, the weather, computer errors, or human errors. Faulty YSI readings may have been due the inconsistent location at which measurements were taken. Because the canal is a salt-wedge estuary, the salt water meets the fresh water at different depths. Hence, at some points along the canal, the YSI may have been gathering measurements from fresh water, salt water or both. The weather may have also played a role, especially when the rain caused heavy runoff from the Manoa-Palolo Valley to enter the canal. Also, in some areas the water was not deep enough for measurements to be taken at a depth of one meter. 15 V. Conclusions Tide changes in the Ala Wai Canal do not affect either the pH or the total dissolved solids of the water. This allows for a stable habitat and shows the high alkalinity of the Ala Wai. Dissolved oxygen is higher at high tide than at low tide and allows aerobic organisms to enter the estuary that can correlate to the increase of nitrates in the water. Salinity is also greater at high tide due to the influx of seawater at that time and is inversely related to dissolved oxygen levels. Turbidity increases at lower tides, making the water more brackish than at high tides. The high turbidity levels during low tide correlates to the low level of dissolved oxygen during low tide. This experiment could be expanded by investigating these chemical properties at different depths to see the effects of the change between salt and fresh water in the saltwedge estuary. Also, the animal life, or what is living in different sites at different tides could be investigated to find the correlation between tide, chemicals, and life. This investigation of chemical changes is important to life as it shows both how habitats can stabilize themselves, such as with a high alkalinity so living organisms can be constantly suited to their environment, and also how the chemicals can fluctuate to show differing amounts of living organisms residing in the estuary at any particular tide. 16 VI. Works Cited Addy, Kelley , et al. 2003. pH and Alkalinity. Retrieved Oct. 30, 2010, from University of Rhode Island Web site: http://www.uri.edu/ce/wq/ww/Publications/pH&alkalinity.pdf. American Public Health Association. 1917. Standard methods for the examination of water and sewage. Boston. *book De Carlo EH, Spencer KJ. 1995. Records of lead and other heavy metal inputs to sediments of the Ala Wai Canal, O’ahu, Hawai’i. Pac Sci 49(4): 471-491. *academic journal FM River. (2004). Water quality. Retrieved October 30, 2010 from FM River site: http://www.eerc.und.nodak.edu/watman/FMRiver/PPTV/factsheets.asp Glenn, CR, McMurtry, GM. 1995. Scientific studies and history of the Ala Wai Canal, an artificial tropical estuary in Honolulu. Pac Sci 49(4): 307-318. *academic journal Hurst, Steve. (2002). Dissolved gases in sea water. Retrieved October 3, 2010 from Geology 117: The Oceans site: http://ijolite.geology.uiuc.edu/02SprgClass/geo117/ lectures/Lect18.html. Lau, Stephen L. and John Francis Mink. 2006. Hydrology of the Hawaiian Islands. University of Hawai’i Press. Mann, Kenneth and William Mitsch. 2011. Boundary Ecosystem. Retrieved January 09, 2011 from Encyclopedia Britannica Online: http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/ 75627/boundary-ecosystem/70746/Boundary-systems-between-waters?anchor=ref588710. Murphy, Sheila. (2007). BASIN: Information on Water Quality Parameters. Retrieved Oct. 31, 2010 from City of Boulder / USGS Water Quality Monitoring site: http://bcn.boulder.co.us/basin/data/NEW/info/Turb.html 17 Myre, Elizabeth, and Ryan Shaw. (2006). The Turbidity Tube: Simple and Accurate Measurement of Turbidity in the Field. Retrieved from Michigan Technological University site: http://www.cee.mtu.edu/sustainable_engineering. National Ocean Service. (2008). Salinity. Retrieved Oct. 31, 2010 from NOAA’s National Ocean Service Education site: http://oceanservice.noaa.gov/education/kits/estuaries/ media/supp_estuar10c_salinity.html. Richard Stockton College. (2010). Seawater Properties. Retrieved Oct. 31, 2010 from The Richard Stockton College of New Jersey site: http://intraweb.stockton.edu/eyos/ page.cfm?siteID=105&pageID=65. Sam Houston State University. (2010). Atmospheric chemistry glossary. Retrieved October 3, 2010 from Sam Houston State University site: http://www.shsu.edu/~chemistry/ Glossary/lmn.html Senese, Fred. (2010). What is pH? Retrieved Oct. 30, 2010, from General Chemistry Online! site: http://antoine.frostburg.edu/chem/senese/101/acidbase/faq/what-is-pH.shtml 18 III. Data Chemical Composition of Water in Sites 1, 3, and 5 of the Ala Wai Canal Chemical Composition pH Salinity Turbidity Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) Dissolved Nitrate Concentration Dissolved Oxygen Concentration Chemical Composition pH Salinity Turbidity Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) Dissolved Nitrate Concentration Dissolved Oxygen Concentration Chemical Composition pH Salinity Turbidity Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) Dissolved Nitrate Concentration Dissolved Oxygen Concentration October 02, 2010 High Tide (0.55 m) Site 1 Site 3 Site 5 7.81 7.67 7.62 0.46 1.22 1.66 9 8.7 8.8 0.67 1.53 2.3 20.49 15.89 15.48 95.8 89.5 88.4 Low Tide (0.43 m) Site 1 Site 3 Site 5 7.31 7.4 7.69 16.33 29.23 37.35 5.44 16.86 1.05 17.29 29.4 36.35 2.78 2.41 2.64 46.53 22 27.87 October 30, 2010 High Tide (0.58 – 0.61 m) Site 1 Site 3 Site 5 7.7 7.5 7.36 35.29 35.14 35.15 4.92 3.74 2.93 34.8 34.66 34.67 11 1.9 0.71 60.64 68.88 80.39 Low Tide (0.55 – 0.43 m) Site 1 Site 3 Site 5 7.6 7.55 7.57 30.67 35.33 34.20 6.88 6.39 3.58 30.68 34.84 33.83 0.23 0.22 0.18 50.75 62.24 81.35 November 13, 2010 High Tide (0.52m) Site 1 Site 3 Site 5 4.92 7.15 7.29 0 35.06 35.19 -0.18 3.13 1.94 0 34.57 34.68 0 0.24 0.27 99.54 75.77 82.38 Low Tide (0.27 m) Site 1 Site 3 Site 5 7.76 7.58 7.65 34.85 37.01 34.05 5.29 5.38 1.96 34.44 36.32 33.71 0.05 0.05 0.06 71.42 56.71 92.87 19 Tide Levels Time Tide (m) October 02, 2010 0.46 0.55 0.61 0.64 0.61 0.52 0.43 0.431 October 30, 2010 0.58 0.61 0.55 0.43 0.31 November 13, 2010 0.52 0.49 0.46 0.37 0.27 0.18 9:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 1:00 2:00 3:00 4:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 1:00 2:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 1:00 2:00 3:00 Standard Deviation Values pH Salinity Turbidity TDS Nitrate Oxygen S1 0.075 0.085 0.248 0.075 3.569 8.488 October 30, 2010 S2 S3 S4 0.012 0.012 0.008 0.108 0.049 0.132 0.339 0.138 0.446 0.094 0.045 0.117 0.025 0.035 0.010 2.191 2.618 0.844 S5 0.03 0.113 1.025 0.097 0.043 3.368 November 13, 2010 S1 S2 S3 S4 0.637 0.132 0.097 0.101 0 6.836 1.411 0.537 0.562 0.159 0.256 0.344 2.265e-19 6.378 1.251 0.474 0 0.144 0.022 0.027 0.138 3.066 2.303 20.56 S5 0.035 0.366 0.423 0.320 0.019 3.444 20 9 Comparing the pH Measurements of Water from the Ala Wai Canal during High Tide and Low Tide 8 7 6 pH 5 High Tide Low Tide 4 3 2 1 0 Site 1 Site 3 Site 5 Site 1 10/2/2010 40 Site 3 Site 5 10/30/2010 Site 1 Site 3 Site 5 11/13/2010 Comparing the Salinity Measurements of Water from the Ala Wai Canal during High Tide and Low Tide 35 30 Salinity (ppt) 25 20 High Tide Low Tide 15 10 5 0 Site 1 Site 3 10/21/2010 Site 5 Site 1 Site 3 10/30/2010 Site 5 Site 1 Site 3 11/13/2010 Site 5 21 Comparing the Turbidity Measurements of Water from the Ala Wai Canal during High Tide and Low Tide 18 16 14 12 Turbidity (NTU) 10 High Tide Low Tide 8 6 4 2 0 Site 1 -2 Site 3 Site 5 Site 1 10/2/2010 Site 3 Site 5 Site 1 10/30/2010 Site 3 Site 5 11/13/2010 Comparing the Total Dissolved Solids Measurements of Water from the Ala Wai Canal during High Tide and Low Tide 40 35 30 TDS (g/L) 25 20 High Tide Low Tide 15 10 5 0 Site 1 Site 3 10/2/2010 Site 5 Site 1 Site 3 10/30/2010 Site 5 Site 1 Site 3 11/13/2010 Site 5 22 Comparing the Dissolved Nitrate Measurements of Water from the Ala Wai Canal during High Tide and Low Tide 25 20 NO3 (mg/L) 15 High Tide Low Tide 10 5 0 Site 1 Site 3 Site 5 Site 1 10/2/2010 Site 3 Site 5 Site 1 10/30/2010 Site 3 Site 5 11/13/2010 Comparing the Dissolved Oxygen Measurements of Water from the Ala Wai Canal during High Tide and Low Tide 120 100 DO (%) 80 60 High Tide Low Tide 40 20 0 Site 1 Site 3 10/2/2010 Site 5 Site 1 Site 3 10/30/2010 Site 5 Site 1 Site 3 11/13/2010 Site 5