C-1 CULT 413 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY IN CULTURAL STUDIES Full Course Title: Research Methodology in Cultural Studies Istraživačka metodologija u kulturološkim studijama Course Code: Course Level/BiH cycle: CULT 413 1st Cycle (Bachelor of Arts) ECTS credit value: 6 Student work-load: (Table with hours for: Lectures; Exercise; Other; Individual learning) For the whole semester: Length: Faculty/School/Department: Lectures Tutorial / Practical training e.g. Project Individual learning TOTAL 45 15 30 60 150 One semester FASS; Cultural Studies (CULT) Course leader: Assist. Prof. Dr Tuba Boz Contact details: Office: e-mail: Office hours: Phone: Site: IUS main campus building Host Study Program: Cultural Studies (CULT) tboz@ius.edu.ba Course status: Pre-requisites: None Access restrictions: None Assessment: Presentations, group activities, consultations, quizzes, exams and take-home exams. 1 C-1 Date validated: Course aims: Learning outcomes: Indicative syllabus content: February 2012 The aims of this course are to: 1. To introduce students to ethnographic research; 2. To ensure that students are given proper knowledge of various quantitative and qualitative data collection methods; 3. To introduce students to different ways of viewing the world; 4. To introduce students to the significance and techniques of interdisciplinary research; 5. To enrich student critical thinking, interpreting and understanding cultural symbols; 6. To introduce students to the importance of ethics in research. On successful completion of this course IUS student will be able to: 1. To conduct ethnographic research; 2. To use various and appropriate quantitative qualitative data collection methods; 3. To think and discuss about culture critically and creatively; 4. To employ interdisciplinary approached when conducting research; 5. To recognize and design their research with ethical considerations. This course is designed to introduce and equip Cultural Studies students with the fundamentals of ethnographic and qualitative research methods. The main themes to be dealt with may include: Lives and Lived Experiences; Investigating Cultural Producers and Cultural Consumers; Quantitative Research; Qualitative Research, Ethnography, Interviewing, Analyzing Discourse, Text and Pictures, Engaging with History and Engaging, Engaging with Memory and Ethics in Research. Teaching occurs via lectures, seminars and tutorials, individual and team- work in-class activities. Learning delivery: Assessment Rationale: Assessment Weighting: Essential Reading: Recommended readings: In order to provide solid undergraduate foundation in Cultural Studies Program and to enable students to develop a critical and evaluative understanding of culture with the socio-political environment, and to demonstrate commitment and diligence at any time, different assessment methods are proposed for this module. Therefore, appropriate and diverse assessment methods include field-work project, presentations, group activities, consultations, exams and take-home exams with the aim to help students to stay focused and active, and fully benefit from the module. Attendance and participation 5% Field-work project 20% Midterm exam 25% Presentation 10% Final exam 40% 1. Pickering, Michael (ed.) Research Methods for Cultural Studies. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2008. 2. Brewer, D. John. Ethnography. Buckingham: Open University Press, 2000. 3. Messenger D. Maire and Mosdell, Nick. Practical research methods for media and cultural studies: making people count. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2006. 4. Stokes, C. Jane. How to do media & cultural studies. London: Sage Publications, 2003. 5. Bouma, Gary. & Ling, Rod. The research process. Fifth ed. New York: Oxford, 2004. Additional/recommended reading: 1. Clough, P. and Nutbrown, C. (2007) A Student’s Guide to Methodology, 2nd edition, London: Sage. 2. Creswell, J.W. (2008) Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches, 3rd edition, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage 3. Hollway, W. and Jefferson, T. (2000) Doing Qualitative Research Differently: Free Association, Narrative and the Interview Method, London: Sage. 4. Dadds, M. and Hart, S. (eds) (2001) Doing Practitioner Research Differently, London: Routledge Falmer. 5. McNiff, J. (2000) Action Research in Organisations, London: Routledge. 6. Schmuch, R. (ed.) (2008) Practical Action Research: A Collection of Articles, 2nd edition, Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press. 7. De Vaus, D.A. (2001) Surveys in Social Research, 5th edition, London: Routledge. 2 C-1 8. Lance, C.E. and Vandenberg, R.J. (eds) (2008) Statistical and Methodological Myths and Urban Legends, New York: Routledge Academic. 9. Letherby, G. (2003) Feminist Research in Theory and Practice, Buckingham: Open University Press. 10. Atkinson, P. (1992) The Ethnographic Imagination, London: Routledge. 11. Dey, I. (1998) Grounding Grounded Theory: Guidelines for Qualitative Inquiry, San Diego: Academic Press. 12. Strauss, A. and Corbin, J. (1990) Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques, Newbury Park, CA: Sage. Intranet web reference: Important notes: Students have to make sure to avoid plagiarism or even the vague possibility of plagiarism. Note that copying from the internet or even taking ideas from internet sources without proper citation is also a form of plagiarism, not only copying from paper based texts. Students are expected to paraphrase the arguments whenever possible and add proper citations from the original text. Each final essay will be checked against anti-plagiarism software. Failing to gain at least 30% from each assignment results in failing the course (that is students are expected to undergo each of the four assignment forms (class participation, position paper, oral presentation, final essay). Absence from class is allowed only with strong reason. Students are allowed one “free miss” but more than one absence without documentation will negatively affect the grade. Quality Assurance: At the study program Cultural Studies and the Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences special attention is paid to quality assurance. A prerequisite for the application of quality assurance policy is to develop awareness among academic staff, but also among students about the importance of monitoring and improving the quality of teaching. It also implies an understanding that quality monitoring is an evaluation of work, but the establishment of an institutional system with its full implementation at all levels. Since the internal quality monitoring mission of the University or Faculty within the University, this track will be given special attention, as follows: Continuous improvement of policies and procedures for quality assurance due to the specificity of the program, Clearly established procedures and application of procedures in adoption of study program in accordance with the guidelines. These procedures are established and there is a need for further work on them, Establishment of procedures for student evaluation and there is a need for its verbatim and transparent application, Selection of qualified and competent teaching staff, Evaluation of efficiency of use of premises and equipment, Regular information about the programs is done through the written and printed materials, Openness to external quality monitoring procedures established by the relevant domestic and foreign institutions. In addition to the above areas of quality assurance, students of IUS or a study program Cultural Studies internally evaluate the quality of teaching and teachers in all courses at the end of each semester. The evaluation is done electronically and anonymously. In addition, and evaluate the quality of textbooks and instruments in the laboratory and used in practice. Academic staff submitted an annual report on recent activities of the Vice-Rector for Education at the latest two weeks after the final exam. The independent evaluator who is not a member of the academic staff of Universities, administered evaluation questionnaire, and a member of the study program (for each program separately) and Dean of the Faculty discusses the research findings as well as student evaluations and together carried revising the plan for improving professional work. Semesterally, the members of each program of study reviewed the sufficiency and adequacy of available facilities, textbooks and teaching aids (instruments, technical equipment ...) and, according to the findings of the report sent to the Dean, which contains proposals for the 3 C-1 purchase or repair of existing equipment/aids. Program members also reviewed the adequacy of program information available on the website of the University, and send their proposals and suggestions in the form of a letter to the Dean. Course Schedule: 4 C-1 Week 1 Lesson / Date Topics to be covered How to define your project How to choose a research method What personal characteristics do the students have which might help them complete their research What skills and experience do the students have which might help them in their research Summarizing your research The “5 W’s” of your research – What is my research? – Why do I want to do the research? – Who are my research participants? – Where am I going to do the research? Class activities Problems/ Assignments (Homework) Readings Learning objectives (After this lesson student will be able to:) Introduction to 1. Plan, define and Research summarize their project. Methods – A 2. Choose and utilize a practical Defining the 5 research method. W’s of a project guide for 3. Learn how to utilize anyone Summing up the undertaking a their personal skills, project in one experience and Research sentence characteristics which Project might help them in their Discussing the Pages 1-14 research. sentence with the tutor to revise if there is any confusion Students will learn how to plan and summarize Planning and their project. summarizing a Different research methods will be discussed. project – When am I going to do the research? 5 C-1 2 How to decide upon a methodology Understanding the methodological debate (qualitative vs. quantitative methodology) Choosing a methodology Examples of qualitative research methodologies Matching methodology with topic Action research Ethnography Feminist research Grounded theory Choosing a methodology and research methods for a project Pages 15 - 26 1. Define various research methods and methodologies 2. Know the differences between qualitative and quantitative methodology, their strengths and weaknesses Choosing upon qualitative or quantitative research methodology 3. Decide upon a methodology when conducting a research Defining why and how the research methodology is chosen 4. Match methodology with the topic of research Matching methodology with the topic of the project / research 5. Use own intuition as a pointer in conducting a research Using triangulation as a combination of qualitative and quantitative inquiry 3 How to choose your research Conducting an example of a Pages 27 – 1. Choose a research method according to 6 C-1 methods Semi-structured interviews Structured interviews Conducting focus groups Group interviews Advantages and disadvantages of the focus group method Using questionnaires Undertaking participant observation Choosing your methods Defining needs and means Thinking about purpose structured or semi-structured interview 39 Conducting an example of a group interview; defining advantages and disadvantages of the group method 2. Conduct focus groups and group interviews 3. Define advantages and disadvantages of the group method 4. Use questionnaires Conducting participant observation 5. Undertake participant observation Defining end and means of the research 6. Define ends and means 7. Summarize the purpose of the research Summarizing the purpose of the project 4 Student presentations 5 How to conduct background research Using university websites in conducting research Defining research topics, methods and needs personality, likes, dislikes, strengths and weaknesses Student presentations Conducting background research for a project Defining research topics, methods and Pages 40 - 47 1. Conduct background research 2. Use websites in research 3. Define research topics, methods and needs 7 C-1 Using interlibrary loans needs Primary research Conducting primary and secondary research for a project Secondary research Filing and labeling notes from secondary sources Noting details for bibliography 4. Use interlibrary loans 5. Define primary and secondary research 6. Conduct primary and secondary research 7. Assess information from secondary sources for relevance and accuracy 8. File and label notes from secondary sources so that the source can be found again if required 9. Note details for bibliography in the final report 6 Midterm exam 7 Choosing participants for a research Using sampling procedures Probability samples and purposive samples Sampling techniques Midterm exam 1. Choose participants for Choosing a Pages 48 - 56 a research group of participants for a 2. Use sampling research procedures Using various 3. Define and utilize sampling purposive and procedures and probability sampling 8 C-1 Choosing sample size techniques Utilizing purposive and probability sampling in research Choosing appropriate sample size 8 How to prepare a research proposal The contents of a proposal Aims and objectives of a research proposal Survey timetable Research budget What makes a good proposal? Reasons why research proposals fail Preparing a research proposal Defining why a particular method/ methodology was chosen Working out timetable and budget Conducting a background research Defining research aims and objectives techniques 4. Choose sample size 5. Use a mixture of sampling techniques within one project to overcome disadvantages of a single technique Pages 57 - 66 1. Prepare a research proposal 2. Clearly define the title, objectives and aims of a research proposal 3. Conduct a unique research or offer a new insight / development 4.Conduct comprehensive and thorough background research and literature review 4. Work out a survey timetable, resources and budget 5. Define useful policy and practice implications 6. Demonstrate relevant background knowledge 9 C-1 and experience 9 How to conduct interviews Recording methods – advantages and disadvantages Using audio recording equipment Taking notes How to develop an interview schedule Establishing rapport Asking questions and probing for information Completing the interview Practicing with recording equipment Conducting a pilot interview Developing an interview schedule Establishing rapport Asking open question and probe for information Pages 66-78 1. Conduct interviews 2. Utilize various recording methods (audio recording, visual recording, note-taking, box-ticking) 3. Define advantages and disadvantages of each recording methods 4. Record sensitive topics 5. Prepare for an interview; overcome nerves and focus the mind 6. Develop an interview schedule 7. Establish rapport 8. Ask questions and probe for information 9. Complete the interview 10 C-1 10 How to conduct focus groups Asking questions Seeking responses Finishing the focus group Recording equipment Strategies for dealing with awkward situations Using audio recording equipment 11 Conducting a Pages 79-89 pilot focus group Preparing questions 1. Conduct focus groups 2. Ask questions and seek responses 3. Obtain and use recording equipment Practice using audio equipment 4. Deal with awkward situations Practice recruiting participants 5.Choose a venue Choosing a venue 6.Recruit participants Recruiting your participants 7. Prepare for the focus group interview How to construct questionnaires Open and closed questions: advantages and disadvantages Wording of questions Using closed-ended questions Avoiding leading questions Length and ordering of questions Collecting personal Constructing a pilot questionnaire Using examples of both open and closed questions Avoiding leading questions Paying attention to wording, length and order of questions Pages 90-104 1. Construct questionnaires 2. Use open and closed questions in questionnaires 3. Define advantages and disadvantages of open and closed questions 4. Define wording, length and ordering of questions 11 C-1 information Piloting the questionnaire 5.Collect personal information Obtaining a high response Questionnaire design 6. Pilot the questionnaire 7.Obtain a high response 8. Design a questionnaire 9. Avoid leading questions 10.Collect personal information 12 C-1 12 How to carry out participant observation Gaining access Practicing participant observation Using gatekeepers Creating a good impression Acting ethically Personal considerations when entering the field Collecting and analyzing information Field notes IT equipment Withdrawing from the field Practicing collecting, analyzing and organizing information Practicing using IT equipment in research Pages 105114 1. Gain access to the community of research 2. Create a good impression 3. Act ethically within the community 4. Prepare to interact with different kinds of people 6. Collect and analyze information 7. Chose a method of taking field notes 8. Develop organizational skills; systematically record and store transcripts, diagrams, plans, tapes and recordings 9. Use IT equipment 10. Withdraw from the field after finishing research 13 C-1 13 How to analyze your data When to analyze data Analyzing qualitative data Formats for analysis The qualitative continuum Thematic analysis Comparative analysis Content analysis Discourse analysis The proves of qualitative data analysis Analyzing quantitative data Computing software Using computers for qualitative data analysis ; advantages and disadvantages Statistical techniques Finding a connection Measuring data: nominal scales, ordinal scales, interval scales, arithmetic mean Producing a pilot Pages 115format for 133 analysis Practicing various methods of analysis – thematic, content, comparative and discourse analysis Practicing data measuring using nominal scales, ordinal scales, interval scales and arithmetic mean Practicing the use of various statistical techniques and data analysis methods 1. Analyze qualitative and quantitative data 2. Produce formats for analysis 3. Define and use various methods of analysis – thematic, content, comparative and discourse analysis 4. Use computing software for data analysis 5. Define various methods of measuring data 6. Measure data using nominal scales, ordinal scales, interval scales and arithmetic mean 7. Define and utilize statistical techniques 8. Define and use bivariate and multivariate analysis 14 C-1 14 How to report your findings Remember the audience Structuring reports Reasons why reports fail Writing journal articles Making presentations : dos and don’ts Producing a Pages 133structured report 148 according to the guidelines set forth in the textbook Producing an example of a journal article Producing oral presentations 15 How to be an ethical researcher Producing a pilot Pages 151 code of ethics 159 Anonymity and confidentiality Recognizing overt and covert research Producing a code of ethics Right to comment The final report Data protection Producing a pilot final report 1. Report findings 2. Structure reports 3. Write journal articles 4. Define the dos and don’ts of presentations 5. Produce oral presentations 1. Be an ethical researcher 2. Respect anonymity and confidentiality 3. Recognize and define overt and covert research 4. Produce a code of ethics 5. Produce a final report 6. Protect data 16 Final exam Final exam 15 C-1 16