Labyrinth: Understanding the Baccalaureate Framework through the Experience of Place A Community Hour Activity Designed by Matt Kubik, Interior Design and Pat Ashton, Sociology, Peace & Conflict Studies Goal: To enhance students’ understanding of the IPFW Baccalaureate Framework and to apply LEAP Principles of Excellence through participation in a community hour activity. Objectives: Upon completing this community hour activity, students will be able to Identify and describe the six components of the Baccalaureate Framework. Explain how these foundational principles apply to their education. Infer how these principles will inform their lifelong learning. Experience the labyrinth as a place for reflection. The Labyrinth A labyrinth is an archetypal form in which we experience a journey through time and space. Unlike a maze, which presents a confusing array of paths, turns, and tricky dead ends, a labyrinth has only one path. There is only one way in and one way out. You cannot get lost in a labyrinth. Whereas sorting out the choices in a maze is primarily a left-brain, analytical activity, a labyrinth is more of a right-brain activity, providing space for reflection, intuition, and imagery. The goal within a maze is to get through and get out as quickly and efficiently as possible. The goal in a labyrinth is to savor the experience of the journey, and to be receptive to insights produced by reflection. The labyrinth is an ancient and near universal symbol. The seven-circuit, or classical labyrinth (so called because there are seven circuits or pathways to the center) pictured on this page has been found on artifacts dated to 3,500 years ago. The design appeared on the coins of ancient Crete, and it has been found on every inhabited continent in prehistory, from Peru to Siberia, India to Arizona, Africa to Scandinavia. We can’t be sure how they were used in prehistory, but we know that in modern times labyrinths have been used as tools for reflection and meditation. In the Middle Ages, labyrinths were built into floors of the great Gothic cathedrals of Europe. Devout Christians walked them as a substitute for, or an extension of, a pilgrimage to the Holy Land. Labyrinth patterns are also found in Hindu, Buddhist, and Islamic art. In North America labyrinth are woven by the Hopi into their basket patterns and appear in numerous petroglyphs. Today labyrinths are found around the world, in both public and private spaces. There are temporary versions in which the paths are outlined in chalk, string, rope, spray paint, gravel, birdseed, etc. and permanent versions in which paths are marked by rocks, pavers, hedges, or flowers. An example of a recent public labyrinth project can be found in Toronto, Canada. The Labyrinth Community Hour Page 1 of 14 goal of Toronto City of Labyrinths is to create a labyrinth within walking distance of every Torontonian inside the city limits. To date, some 60 plus labyrinths have been created throughout Toronto. (http://cityoflabyrinths.tyo.ca/) The classical labyrinth combines a number of important geometric forms: the circle, the spiral, the arch, and the right angle. It makes use of both symmetry and asymmetry. The labyrinth marries the idea of a journey to the center with the notion of a return to the outside world. The Labyrinth and the IPFW Baccalaureate Framework The IPFW faculty has identified six foundations of baccalaureate education. All students who earn a baccalaureate degree at this institution will have the following knowledge and skills: Acquisition of Knowledge Students will demonstrate breadth of knowledge across disciplines and depth of knowledge in their chosen discipline. In order to do so, students must demonstrate the requisite information- seeking skills and technological competencies. Application of Knowledge Students will demonstrate the ability to integrate and apply that knowledge, and, in so doing, demonstrate the skills necessary for life-long learning. Personal and Professional Values Students will demonstrate the highest levels of personal integrity and professional ethics. A Sense of Community Students will demonstrate the knowledge and skills necessary to be productive and responsible citizens and leaders in local, regional, national, and international communities. In so doing, students will demonstrate a commitment to free and open inquiry and mutual respect across multiple cultures and perspectives. Critical Thinking and Problem Solving Students will demonstrate facility and adaptability in their approach to problem solving. In so doing, students will demonstrate critical-thinking abilities and familiarity with quantitative and qualitative reasoning. Communication Students will demonstrate the written, oral, and multimedia skills necessary to communicate effectively in diverse settings. These foundations provide the framework for all baccalaureate degree programs. The foundations are interdependent, with each one contributing to the integrative and holistic education offered at IPFW. By journeying through the labyrinth, students will reflect on the role of these components in both their undergraduate education and afterwards in their lifelong learning. Labyrinth Community Hour Page 2 of 14 The Labyrinth and the LEAP Principles of Excellence The Association of American Colleges and Universities (AAC&U) has been examining the aims and outcomes of a 21st-century college education. Through the Liberal Education and America’s Promise (LEAP) program, the organization aims to go beyond standard metrics of enrollment, persistence, and graduation to define what college graduates need to know and do for success in life, work, and citizenship. Their essential learning outcomes are very similar to IPFW’s Baccalaureate Framework, encompassing knowledge of the social, physical, and natural worlds, intellectual skills such as communication and critical thinking, personal and social responsibility, and the ability to apply integrated knowledge to complex problems. In pursuit of these goals, LEAP has adopted Principles of Excellence. These principles can easily be integrated with the IPFW Baccalaureate Framework and implemented through this labyrinth exercise. 1. Aim High – and Make Excellence Inclusive The labyrinth activity allows for teamwork that includes all members of the class. It challenges students to go out of their comfort zone and engage in an alternative form of learning. 2. Give Students a Compass The labyrinth activity orients students to the Baccalaureate Framework and through kinesthetic learning teaches them that the path to their goal is not always a straight one, but rather a complex pattern of twists and turns. 3. Teach Students the Arts of Inquiry and Innovation The labyrinth activity teaches students to interrogate their experience through a nontraditional learning process. 4. Engage the Big Questions Through this activity students are encouraged to think about the goals of their education and the role of their education in their life experience. 5. Connect Knowledge with Choices and Action Through this activity students develop a framework for thinking about their educational choices in college and to connect their college knowledge and skills with life choices. 6. Foster Civic, Intercultural, and Ethical Learning Students will learn about the labyrinth as an intercultural form while they walk it and contemplate civic and ethical goals. 7. Assess Students’ Ability to Apply Learning to Complex Problems The post-activity assessments will measure students’ ability to apply the Baccalaureate Framework to their personal learning goals and reflect upon the role of this knowledge and these skills in their education and their lives. Labyrinth Community Hour Page 3 of 14 Advance Planning for the Labyrinth Activity At least one day prior to your community hour, check out the Labyrinth Kit from the FYE office. Design and duplicate pre- and post-activity assessment documents for the number of students in your community hour. With weather conditions in mind, select a location for your labyrinth activity and notify students where to meet. If you will be outside, you may want to suggest that students wear footwear that is comfortable for walking. (Depending on location and weather, they may choose to walk the labyrinth in their bare feet.) Accessing or Laying Out The Labyrinth Each instructor has 4 choices about generating or finding a labyrinth to use in this exercise: 1. Incorporate the building of the labyrinth into the community hour and recruit your students to build it with you. This is especially valuable if your community includes themes about geometry, construction, teamwork, and/or communication. Directions for an easy, relatively quick method of laying out a classical labyrinth are included in a separate document and a project video. Materials are available from the FYE office. 2. Create the labyrinth yourself in advance of the community hour. Again, materials and instructional video are available from the FYE office. You will need at least 1 other person to help you lay out the labyrinth. FYE student workers may be available to help you. Be sure to check with the FYE office well in advance. 3. If available, use an existing labyrinth on campus. At this juncture, there are no permanent labyrinths (yet!) on campus, but as various learning communities create labyrinths for this exercise, they may persist for 1 day to several weeks, depending upon the method of construction, location, use, and ambient weather conditions. 4. If the weather requires you to be indoors, have your students draw labyrinths following the seed pattern in the appendix. Alternatively, you can photocopy the labyrinth picture in the appendix. Have the students – individually or in groups – write the elements of the Baccalaureate Framework on their labyrinths. Then have them “walk” the labyrinth by tracing the path, discussing the six elements of the Framework as they go. Suggested locations for labyrinths are marked on a campus map included with the materials. When you have a completed labyrinth, place the center sign and lay out the signs or stations for each component of the Baccalaureate Framework according to the map in the appendix. Or have groups of your students place the “flags” as they walk the labyrinth. We don’t recommend that large numbers of students begin walking the labyrinth all at once. While the full-size labyrinth we recommend here can accommodate a large number of students, Labyrinth Community Hour Page 4 of 14 try to space the students somewhat (e.g., in small groups) so that each individual student can have a reflective experience. The Core Exercise: Walking The Labyrinth and Exploring the IPFW Baccalaureate Framework Read the guidelines below to students prior to starting their walks or print copies of the guidelines document found in the Appendix and pass it out to students. Guidelines for walking the labyrinth 1. Complete the pre-assessment. 2. Be open to the experience. Before beginning, clear your mind of distractions and focus on the present moment. Suggestion: close your eyes and just be aware of your breathing. You will relax and focus as you notice the movement of air into and out of your lungs. 3. As you walk the labyrinth, try to screen out distractions and concentrate on your walk. Be aware of your footsteps. You are on a journey. 4. Be respectful of the journey of others while they are in the labyrinth. Do not disturb or distract them. As people pass one another, if the path is too crowded, those on the way out should step aside and yield right of way to those on their journey into the center. Those with a physical handicap that makes it more difficult to negotiate the labyrinth should always have the right of way. 5. At each sign or station, begin to reflect on the particular listed component of the Baccalaureate Framework. Reflect on that component until you reach the sign or station where the next one is posted. On the way in to the center, you should reflect on the role of each component in your college education. On the way out, you should reflect on the role of each component in your lifelong education (career, community and civic involvement, etc.). 6. When you have finished walking the labyrinth, reflect quietly on your experience. Be respectful of those still walking the labyrinth. 7. Complete the post-assessment. Optional Suggestions for Building and Walking The Labyrinth Arrange the students in a continuous line from the entrance to the center of the labyrinth. The person closest to the entrance announces the first component of the IPFW Baccalaureate Framework. The next person says something about that component: a short description, a synonym, a short explanation of why it is important, a metaphor for thinking about it, etc. The next person says something different about that component, and so on along the line. When the sign or station for the next component is reached, the person closest to it announces that Labyrinth Community Hour Page 5 of 14 component. Proceed as above for each subsequent component. When the center of the labyrinth is reached, allow time for silent reflection. Then reverse the process, proceeding from the center out to the entrance. This time focus on another dimension of each component – e.g., how each student will use it in their career, its role in making them an educated citizen, etc. (e.g., have them complete the sentence “I will....” or “I plan to....” in relation to a particular component.) If doing this at night outdoors, each student could be given a candle. Light the one closest to the entrance, and then have each student pass the flame on to the next student’s candle as they state their contribution. When you move from the center to the exit, each student extinguishes their candle in turn. Have the final student walk away from labyrinth before extinguishing their candle, symbolizing taking the Baccalaureate Framework out into the world. Assessment Pre-activity assessments. These can be administered at the beginning of the community hour, at a previous community hour, or in a previous class period. To maximize the time available for walking the labyrinth, we recommend that you administer the pre-assessment during a prior community hour or class period. Post-activity assessments. At least one of these should be administered immediately after students have completed their labyrinth walks. Additional assessments could, at the instructor’s option, be completed during subsequent community hours or class periods. All assessments of this activity should be shared with the FYE office. Instructors are encouraged to incorporate additional assessments that are relevant to the goals of their particular learning community. Further information on assessment goals, techniques, and procedures, as well as descriptions of the techniques below may be found in Angelo and Cross, Classroom Assessment Techniques, available in the Library and from CELT. Assessment guidelines Any assessment should incorporate critical reflection as a key component. As Clayton (2010) notes, critical reflection generates, deepens, and documents learning. Specifically, Clayton suggests that this critical reflection be accomplished through a model she designates as DEAL – Describe, Examine, and Articulate Learning. Below are questions to guide reflection in each area. Describe What did I do? (i.e., how did I walk the labyrinth?) What did I feel or experience as I walked the labyrinth? How did I experience the others who were walking the labyrinth? Examine What components of the Baccalaureate Framework do I remember? What can I explain about each component? Labyrinth Community Hour Page 6 of 14 Articulate Learning As it relates to my education, what did I learn about each component of the Baccalaureate Framework? Why does/should this matter to me? As it relates to my lifelong learning, what did I learn about each component of the Baccalaureate Framework? Why does/should this matter to me? In light of this learning what will I do? Suggested assessment ideas Here are some assessment techniques, derived from Angelo and Cross’ Classroom Assessment Techniques (CATs). Knowledge probe Matching (list components and descriptions in separate columns and ask students to match) 1-minute paper (for 1 minute, write everything you know about the Framework) Electronic survey on Blackboard (true/false, multiple choice, or short answer questions) Focused listing In 2-3 minutes, list each component of the framework and words or phrases associated with each one. Empty (or nearly empty) outline Give the students a blank outline listing 6 components and ask them to fill it in with names and descriptions. Defining features matrix Ask the students to fill in a matrix of the Framework components and how they apply to their education and life. Analytic memos Write to self, advisor, friend, or potential employer about how the Framework applies to their education and/or career. One sentence summary Following the framework Who does what to Whom, When, Where, How, and Why? Have the students write one sentence about how the Baccalaureate Framework applies to their education/life. Concept maps On a labyrinth template, have the students draw a concept map of how the principles relate to them. Applications cards Give each student 6 index cards. Have them write one of the components of the Framework on the front and an application of it on the back of each separate card. Labyrinth Community Hour Page 7 of 14 Videotape Videotape the students creating and walking the labyrinth, then interview them on tape afterwards about their understanding/application of the Framework. Individual or group Each of the above assessments can be conducted as individual activities or in groups – pairs, small groups of 3-5 students, or large groups (e.g., the entire class). Meta-analysis as assessment As a deeper form of assessment, ask the students, individually or in groups to analyze their assessment results. Students could sort and/or evaluate the responses of the class as a whole, or they could examine the results of their assessments and reflect on the questions: What did we learn? About what do we want to learn more? Resources Angelo, Thomas A. and K. Patricia Cross, 1993. Classroom Assessment Techniques, 2nd ed. Jossey-Bass. Available from CELT or the Library. Clayton, Patti. 2010. “Generating, Deepening, and Documenting Learning: The Power of Critical Reflection.” Available from CELT. Labyrinthos http://www.labyrinthos.net/ A resource center for all things relating to labyrinths – history, photos, a bibliography, an academic journal on labyrinths, and links to other sites. Labyrinth Locator. http://labyrinthlocator.com/ Sponsored by Veriditas and The Labyrinth Society, you can use this site to locate labyrinths anywhere in the world. (There may be labyrinths in your local community!) Appendix to this Document Components of the FYE labyrinth kit Guidelines for walking the labyrinth Sample post-activity assessment How to draw a labyrinth Picture of a labyrinth, suitable for photocopying Labyrinth Community Hour Page 8 of 14 The FYE Labyrinth Kit (1) campus map showing possible outdoor locations to lay out a labyrinth (1) PowerPoint Presentation: Historical Overview and Geometry of the Labyrinth (1) set of laminated instructions and (1) instructional video: How to lay out a 7-circuit labyrinth, including where to place the posters for each component of the Baccalaureate Framework (1) center pole (red) (4) corner poles (white) (1) hammer (1) tape measure (1) carpenter’s square (1) 17’ blue rope (1) 50’ knotted white layout rope with attached ring (4-5) cans of white spray paint (3) marking wands to hold and apply the spray paint (1) box of paper booties to protect shoes while spray painting (6) 2-sided laminated posters with elements of the IPFW Baccalaureate Framework (1) poster for the center spot Bookmarks detailing the IPFW Baccalaureate Framework (enough for each student) Labyrinth Community Hour Page 9 of 14 The Core Exercise: Walking The Labyrinth and Exploring the IPFW Baccalaureate Framework Guidelines for walking the labyrinth 1. Complete the pre-assessment. 2. Be open to the experience. Before beginning, clear your mind of distractions and focus on the present moment. Suggestion: close your eyes and just be aware of your breathing. You will relax and focus as you notice the movement of air into and out of your lungs. 3. As you walk the labyrinth, try to screen out distractions and concentrate on your walk. Be aware of your footsteps. You are on a journey. 4. Be respectful of the journey of others while they are in the labyrinth. Do not disturb or distract them. As people pass one another, if the path is too crowded, those on the way out should step aside and yield right of way to those on their journey into the center. Those with a physical handicap that makes it more difficult to negotiate the labyrinth should always have the right of way. 5. At each sign or station, begin to reflect on the particular listed component of the Baccalaureate Framework. Reflect on that component until you reach the sign or station where the next one is posted. On the way in to the center, you should reflect on the role of each component in your college education. On the way out, you should reflect on the role of each component in your lifelong education (career, community and civic involvement, etc.). 6. When you have finished walking the labyrinth, reflect quietly on your experience. Be respectful of those still walking the labyrinth. 7. Complete the post-assessment. Sample Assessment On the next two pages you will find a sample post-activity assessment. Feel free to customize it to meet your pedagogical goals. Labyrinth Community Hour Page 10 of 14 The Labyrinth and the IPFW Baccalaureate Framework Post-Activity Assessment Did you walk the labyrinth during the Community Hour? (circle one) Yes No Did you walk the labyrinth on your own in the last week? (circle one) Yes No Directions: Strictly from memory, fill in each component of the Baccalaureate Framework. Use your own words if you can’t remember the “official” words. Below each component, briefly explain What the component means to you As you see it, how does this component relate to your education? Why does/should this matter to you? 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. [OVER PLEASE] Labyrinth Community Hour Page 11 of 14 Explain how walking the labyrinth did or did not help you understand the Baccalaureate Framework. Labyrinth Community Hour Page 12 of 14 How to draw a labyrinth Begin with the basic seed pattern. It starts with a cross, four half squares, and four points where the missing corner of each square would be. Draw an arc from the top of the cross to the adjacent half square to the right. Then draw increasingly larger arcs connecting the end of the next geometric object to the left to the next available geometric object to the right. Here is an illustration. Labyrinth Community Hour Page 13 of 14 A labyrinth to finger trace You can “walk” this labyrinth by tracing the path with your finger or an object such as a pen or pencil, marker, crayon, or stick. Labyrinth Community Hour Page 14 of 14