Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy, BA, PGCE, PGDip The greatest terror a child can have is that he is not loved, and rejection is the hell he fears. I think everyone in the world to a large or small extent has felt rejection, and with rejection comes anger, and with anger some kind of crime in revenge for the rejection, and with the crime guilt, and there is the story of mankind. One child, refused the love he craves, kicks the cat and hides his secret guilt; and another steals so that money will make him loved; and a third conquers the world – and always the guilt and revenge and more guilt. John Steinbeck (1952). In the essay, I will investigate the evidence suggesting that emotional stress and anxiety serve to reduce the efficiency of working memory. Individuals with dyslexia are likely to have the efficiency of their already weak working memory disproportionately reduced by anxiety as emotional stress is likely to be an existing symptom of their specific learning difficulty, borne of their earlier educational experiences. There exists a cycle of disadvantage for students with dyslexia, in our educational context, in that one of the likely sources of poor memory performance is their already established difficulties in phonological processing (Dockrell and McShane (1993)). Given that the working memory system includes a specialised phonological store in which verbal information is retained, children with dyslexia are highly likely to have problems learning to read from their earliest days in education. The repercussions of rejection in early learning echo throughout one’s life and repeated childhood mortification can ultimately destroy the ability to feel good about oneself, i.e. it erodes self-esteem which, in itself, is an indication of low self-efficacy. The SpLD Working Party Report on Dyslexia (2005: 6) notes that: 'Low self-esteem, often due to past humiliations, is especially apparent in mature students'. I will illustrate this further with reference to the theory of self-efficacy, which states that self-efficacy makes a difference in how people feel, think and act (Bandura, 1997). People with low self-esteem also have low self-efficacy and in terms of feelings, a low sense of self-efficacy is associated with depression, anxiety and feelings of helplessness. This provides the context for my research and I will explore in detail the effects of anxiety and how it exacerbates the difficulties that students with dyslexia have with respect to their working memory, subsequently I will explore how these difficulties affect their anxiety in a vicious cycle that can deny them the opportunity to learn from experience. I will focus specifically on students with dyslexia (who already harbour some working memory differences) and the residual effects of anxiety in early education and the means by which these can be internalised to become emotional stress resulting in concomitant problems in later life, in particular in the context of higher education. There is probably no more moving an account of this situation than Jackie Stewart (2001) who stated: ‘You will never understand what it feels like to be dyslexic. No matter how long you have worked in this area, no matter if your own children are dyslexic, you will never understand what it feels like to be humiliated your entire childhood and taught every day to believe that you will never succeed at anything’. I feel it is important to begin by defining both dyslexia and anxiety so as to specify the exact nature of my investigation and literature review. Professor John Stein, (2006) states that ‘dyslexia has an organic neurological basis and, contrary to previous strongly held beliefs, it is not 'purely psychological’’. However, one must bear in mind that reading is a learned activity. M. Wolf (2008:10) states that all ‘human behaviours are based on multiple cognitive processes, which are based on Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 2 the rapid integration of information from very specific neurological structures, which rely on billions of possible connections, which are programmed in large part by genes....reading has no direct genetic program passing it on to future generations’. In terms of human evolution the brain was never meant to read, there are neither specific genes nor biological structures specific to this task. Reading is not natural as it is a human invention which must be learned at a conscious level. A child has to learn that orthography (the sequence of letters on the page) represents the phonology. According to Shaywitz (1996), the phonological model of dyslexia defines dyslexia in terms of difficulties ‘associated with converting phonemes (smallest meaningful segments of language) into symbols (letters). The mental activity associated with reading can be divided into word identification, phonological processing and cognitive reasoning. A deficit in phonological processing will reduce a person’s ability to convert symbols into sounds (reading) and/or sounds into symbols (writing)’. There is a pyramid of reading behaviours, beginning at the most basic level, which is the genetic foundation, above this there are the neurons and circuits, subsequently the neural structures, the perceptual motor conceptual processes (where the bulk of current academic research focuses) and finally the behavioural level (reading). The penultimate level, which consists of basic perceptual, conceptual, linguistic attentional and motor processes, is where most theorists believe the difficulties underlying dyslexia can be found. Therefore, one must consider dyslexia a complex neurological condition which occurs in approximately 4% of the population (Singleton, 1999). Anxiety requires a similar definition, given that the word has entered common usage and can take a myriad of forms, being referred to as ‘stress’ or as a counterweight to depression. Humanity's effort to escape anxiety is a recurring theme in human thought and literature. Our reading of the latter leads one to believe that it can take many forms, some in connection with specific events e.g. examinations, and others that manifest themselves as fear or an ill-defined sense of malaise. There has been research undertaken on children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and anxiety (Biederman et al 1991) which ‘supports considerable comorbidity of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder with conduct disorder, oppositional defiant disorder, mood disorders, anxiety disorders...’. Willcutt and Pennington (2000) examined the emotional and psychiatric difficulties present in a cross section of twins with reading problems. They found that anxiety was associated with reading difficulties. However, they found that this was in contrast to hyperactivity and conduct disorder as the anxiety was not elevated in co-twins of children with reading disabilities, suggesting that the increased anxiety levels occur as a consequence of literacy difficulties rather than having a genetic (or environmental) origin. Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 3 Rosen et. al. (1992: 1) discuss how pathological anxiety may ‘develop from adaptive fear states. Fear responses (e.g. freezing, startle, heart rate and blood pressure changes, and increased vigilance) are functionally adaptive behavioural and perceptual responses elicited during danger to facilitate appropriate defensive responses that can reduce danger or injury (e.g., escape and avoidance)’. Fear was found to be a central motive, with the amygdala playing a central role. Pathological anxiety was conceptualized as an ‘exaggerated fear state in which hyperexcitability of fear circuits that include the amygdala and extended amygdala is expressed as hypervigilance and increased behavioural responsivity to fearful stimuli’. In turn, hyperexcitability in fear circuits was found to be expressed as pathological anxiety that is manifested in the various anxiety disorders. Against this background, anxiety can be seen as either a short term 'state' or a long term ‘trait.’ Trait anxiety reflects a stable tendency to respond with state anxiety in the anticipation of threatening situations. This tendency is likely to be invoked in any situation that the individual perceives as threatening, in the case of the individual with dyslexia such a situation is likely to include literacy and memory related tasks. Anxiety can be seen as an 'acquired reaction-sensitivity in individuals suffering from impaired self-esteem to overreact with fear to any anticipated adjustive situation that contains a further threat to self-esteem. It is the novel elements of an unfamiliar learning problem which constitute the threat to the anxious individual, and instigate a habitual, anxiety-reducing response set to avoid the improvisation necessary for successful learning’ (Ausubel et. al. 1953: 5). Most people assume that anxiety impairs the performance of most tasks, especially difficult ones. However, reality is more complicated than that. Anxiety often has surprisingly little effect on performance, even though we typically feel that anxiety is preventing us from performing well. This paradox was explained by Eysenck and Calvo (1992). They argued that anxiety has 'hidden costs'. We need to distinguish between performance effectiveness (how well we perform a task) and processing efficiency (the relationship between performance effectiveness and use of processing resources). Anxiety has more of an adverse effect on efficiency than on effectiveness because anxious individuals typically respond to reduced efficiency by using additional resources. It is not difficult to understand the stress any child will encounter entering the educational system, particularly in primary school where the focus is the acquisition of literacy skills which must be learned because, as previously observed, such skills must be learned at a conscious level rather than being inherited. Every child will undergo some degree of separation anxiety at being parted from their parent, at being asked to spend time in a new environment, at meeting new children and at being asked to perform in a social context. These feelings would apply to any individual in a learning context and invariably, enthusiasm and encouragement will Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 4 prevail to reduce these levels of stress before they become harmful. However, in the case of a student with dyslexia, particularly if the condition is undiagnosed, this anxiety can soon be compounded. Problems will soon arise with parents and teachers telling him/her to work harder or that he is not working to his/her potential and/or ability or that he/she will not amount to much. It is inevitable that this will have consequences for the child in terms of areas such as emotional development, the development of coping mechanisms and self esteem levels. This leads us to the importance of emotion in the learning environment. Wolf (2206) states that: ‘emotional engagement is often the tipping point between leaping into the reading life or remaining in a childhood bog where reading is ensured only as a means to other ends’. Emotions and memory seem to be inextricably linked as they both involve each other. Blakemore and Frith, (2006: 177) state that: ‘emotional events are better remembered than neutral events and this is especially true for negative emotional events. Research involving both animals and humans has shown that the amygdala, an important part of the brain’s emotional system (sometimes called the limbic system) is involved with ‘the formation of enhanced long-term memories associated with events that arouse fear or sadness’. They go on to stress that the amygdala is crucial for processing memories of emotionally salient events, and its activation during such events may be the root cause for them being better recalled. Their research indicates that the amygdala interacts with the hippocampus, a nearby structure (also part of the limbic system) which is crucial for non-emotional memories. Thus, they suggest that it might be the connections between the amygdala and the hippocampus that make memories of emotional events so rapidly established and long lasting. As was noted above, the amygdala is particularly involved in fear conditioning. Fear conditioning can occur after just one exposure as this is when an animal learns to avoid a particular event or stimuli. The brain via the amygdala is able to detect and respond to danger extremely quickly. The amygdala is separate from brain areas in charge of other areas responsible for conscious learning (e.g. remembering names and dates). So unconscious emotional learning, which is automatic and impulsive and higher cognitive processing, such as understanding why a situation is frightening, occur separately in the brain. One can see that intuitive and conscious emotional intelligences are two different things using different brain systems. I would argue that early educational experiences which could be classed as traumatic can fuse in the mind with the stimuli or task being remembered with fear, which in turn, results in anxiety when similar situations or tasks are likely to be encountered. According to Bandura (1995, p. 2): ‘Self-efficacy is the belief in one’s capabilities to organise and execute the courses of action required to manage prospective situations’. There are four major sources for influencing personal competence (Bandora 1977). First, self-efficacy beliefs can be enhanced through personal accomplishment or mastery as far as success is attributed internally and can be Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 5 repeated. A second source is vicarious experience. When a ‘model person’ who is similar to the individual successfully masters a difficult situation, social comparison processes can enhance self-efficacy beliefs. Third, there is symbolic experience through verbal persuasion by others (e.g. a teacher reassures a student). The last source is emotional arousal, that is the person experiences anxiety in a threatening situation and thus feels incapable of mastering the situation. In terms of feeling, a low sense of self-efficacy is associated with depression and anxiety. Persons with low self-efficacy also have low self-esteem and they harbour pessimistic thoughts about their accomplishments and personal development. Self efficacy levels can enhance or impede motivation and I would argue that the latter is the case for students with dyslexia. According to a review of studies undertaken by Chapman and Turner (2003: 1): ‘For children who experience initial and ongoing success or difficulty in reading, development of relations between reading performance and selfsystem factors occurs within the first year of schooling. Our studies also show that phonological processing ability and letter-name knowledge at the outset of schooling not only predict subsequent reading performance but also academic self-concept and reading self-efficacy. Children who are deficient in phonological processing or state a preference for using text-level cues for identifying unfamiliar words in text rather than word-level information tend to develop difficulties in reading as well as negative reading-related self-perceptions’. Dale H. Schunk is an educational psychologist who took Bandura’s theory of selfefficacy into the realm of education, cognition and learning. According to Schunk, (2003: 160): ‘Personal and environmental factors affect one another. As an example of how beliefs can affect the environment, consider students with high and low selfefficacy for learning. Those with high efficacy may view the task as a challenge and work diligently to master it, thereby creating a productive classroom environment. Those with low efficacy may attempt to avoid the task, which can disrupt the classroom’. The evidence demonstrating that individuals with literacy difficulties have increased levels of anxiety is growing. Paget and Reynolds (1984) noted that children with learning difficulties were more anxious than their peers with the anxiety being seen to affect their concentration. In a study of 16 students with dyslexia, Riddick, Sterling, Farmer and Morgan (1999) found that these students displayed more anxieties and feelings of academic incompetence than controls. A more recent research study (Caroll and Iles 2006) involved sixteen students who were asked to complete a written questionnaire concerning trait anxiety levels. The students were told that they would be given a timed reading test and their state anxiety levels were measured, subsequently their reading was assessed using the Test of Word Reading Efficiency (TOWRE). The findings ‘indicate that dyslexic university students have higher levels of trait anxiety than non-dyslexics with respect to both academic and social situations. They also show higher levels of state anxiety when faced with a situation in which their reading abilities will be tested. Increased anxiety levels in Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 6 dyslexics were not limited to academic situations. Dyslexics in higher education also show increased levels of social anxiety. It is likely that for this group, as with schoolchildren, social factors are closely bound up with academic achievements’. This would seem to substantiate the observation that for some, years of struggling with reading and related tasks will dispose them to stress, worry and anxiety when placed in a situation where accuracy or literacy is being measured. It is my understanding that a key factor in the aforementioned sequence of events e.g. the disposition of students with dyslexia to anxiety, is working memory, and its role in everyday cognitive activities as well as in the use of language. An understanding of how this working memory system operates is essential if one is to understand the correlation between anxiety and dyslexia. In this part of the essay I would like to focus on working memory and the integral role it plays in developing reading fluency. This concept of reading fluency needs to be explored further if one is to appreciate the role of working memory and its interaction with long-term memory and understanding. Wolf (2008: 130-1) states that: ‘fluency is not a matter of speed; it is a matter of being able to utilise all the special knowledge a child has about a word, its letters, letter patterns, meanings, grammatical functions, roots, and endings – fast enough to have time to think and comprehend. Everything about a word contributes to how fast it can be read’. Similarly, the cognitive scientist David Swinney (1979: 645-659) discovered that when reading: ‘the brain doesn’t find just one simple meaning for a word; instead it stimulates a veritable trove of knowledge about that word and the many words related to it’. According to Stein (2006) ‘reading requires the child to identify and order letters visually and to match them with the phonemic sound segments that they represent, whereas speech naturally segments into syllables, not phonemes’. In order for a child or any individual to be able to undertake this task they must be able to enlist key executive functions in the brain and one of these is working memory. At its most basic, working memory acts in the same way as a computer’s cache memory in that it temporarily holds information about letters and words long enough for the brain to connect it to more conceptual information held in long term memory, acting as a cognitive blackboard. According to Wolf (2008: 131) ‘as decoding readers progress, their comprehension becomes inextricably bound to these executive processes, and to what they know about words and to fluency. They are all related. Incremental increases in fluency allow for inference making, because there is added time for inferences and insights. Fluency does not ensure better comprehension; Rather, fluency gives enough time to the executive system to direct attention where it is most needed – to infer, to understand, to predict, or sometimes to repair discordant understanding and to interpret a meaning afresh’. The importance of this cannot be understated because the initial stages of learning to read are the time when children learn to go beyond the information they are being asked to digest, this is the time when the reading brain learns to take time to think and consider while Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 7 reading. Any problems at this stage are going to have a significant ripple effect which will persist throughout the child’s education thus their opportunity to learn from experience becomes more remote. The notion that memory was not one single structure was an idea that prompted a number of investigations and research papers in the mid 20th century and perhaps the most famous of these was George Miller’s seminal paper: ‘The Magic Number Seven’ which was published in 1956. His research led him to conclude that subjects can handle seven plus or minus two meaningful units of information. It was suggested that whereas long-term memory has enormous capacity for storage coupled with a relatively slow input and retrieval, short-term memory is a limited capacity store with rapid input and retrieval. Baddeley (1986: 14) states that the ‘the evidence of coding seems to associate short-term memory tasks with phonological processing and long-term memory with semantic coding’. He focussed on what he perceived as the underlying storage systems and the evidence emerging from Neuropsychological research on patients with amnesia and brain damage. In essence, the concept of working memory proposes that a dedicated system maintains and stores information in the short term, and that this system underlies human thought processes. His work led to a model of working memory which had three principal components. ‘The central executive possessed limited-capacity processing resources, which can be for particular processing information between other components of the memory system, the subsystems of the phonological loop and the visuo-spatial sketchpad. The phonological loop is capable of processing and maintaining phonological information and consists both of a phonological short-term store and a subvocal control process used both for rehearsal and recoding information into phonological form. The visuo-spatial sketchpad is involved in generating images and in retaining information with visual or spatial dimensions’ (Gathercole, Baddeley (2003)). This model was successful in providing an integrated account using data from neuropsychological, developmental and neuroimaging data as well as research on members of the public. Subsequently, questions were asked with respect to a number of phenomena that are not readily captured by the original model. This led to a fourth component to the model, the episodic buffer, being proposed. According to Baddeley (2000: 1): ‘it comprises a limited capacity system that provides temporary storage of information held in a multimodal code, which is capable of binding information from the subsidiary systems, and from long-term memory, into a unitary episodic representation. Conscious awareness is assumed to be the principal mode of retrieval from the buffer. The revised model differs from the old principally in focussing attention on the processes of integrating information, rather than on the isolation of the subsystems. In doing so, it provides a better basis for tackling the more complex aspects of executive control in working memory’. A visual Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 8 representation of this new and more comprehensive model can be seen in figure 1. Figure 1. ‘When phonological awareness and central executive function are examined with respect to their role in literacy, it does appear that working memory accounts for unique variance in reading performance’ (Pickering S (2004)). Pickering goes on to argue that some caution is required when looking for a definitive explanation for all literacy difficulties and that it should be borne in mind that a range of cognitive processes are important in the task of learning to read. Against this background, Pickering (2006: 238) listed the following in her summary: ‘Children with poor working memory skills typically make poor academic progress in the areas of literacy and mathematics. Children with working memory impairments frequently fail in classroom activities that impose significant working memory loads. The most common type of classroom failure involved forgetting instructions, losing place in complex tasks, and struggling in tasks that involved both processing and storage loads. Although children with working memory impairments had some awareness of their memory problems, their teachers did not and attributed their problems to lack of attention’. As the final part of this essay, I will investigate the correlations and interplay between dyslexia and anxiety and the way these two phenomena can intertwine with each other with, frequently, disastrous results for the individual concerned. Darke (1988) undertook two experiments to measure the comparative working capacities of highly anxious and low anxiety individuals. He used a traditional digit span measure of capacity as the first part of the experiment and in the second he required subjects to both process and store information. The digit span task entails individuals being presented with progressively longer series of digits for serial recall. Thirty two firstyear psychology students of the University of Sydney served as subjects. According to Darke (1982: 145) ‘highly anxious subjects displayed significantly smaller measures of capacity in relation to the low anxiety groups in both experiments. It is concluded that high levels of anxiety reduces both the storage and processing Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 9 capacity of working memory’. The results are consistent with Eysenck’s (1982, 1992) conclusions with respect to the tendency of high anxiety subjects to engage in task-irrelevant processing and that anxiety affects the articulatory loop component of working memory. Thus, working memory is considered to be further weakened by the effects of anxiety and intrusive thoughts on complex cognitive tasks, including those dependent on literacy skills, leading to information processing problems. One of the interesting aspects of the aforementioned research is that Shane Darke is based in the Department of Psychology, University of Sydney and his work relates also to illicit drug use and addiction as part of the National Drug and Alcohol Research Centre (Australia). The link between anxiety and addiction is well documented. Kushner et al (1990: 147) state: ‘the idea that people suffering from anxiety have a proclivity to consume alcohol to relieve their symptoms is supported by reports showing high comorbidity rates of alcohol and anxiety problems’. It is tempting to extrapolate that this would have a particular consequence for students with dyslexia and there is some evidence to suggest that this may be the case. Hinson et al (2003: 298) state that: ‘decision making that favours short-term over long-term consequences of action, defined as impulsive or temporally myopic, may be related to individual differences in the executive functions of working memory’. There has been some very recent research into the correlation between dyslexia and addiction and according to Yates (2006: 53): ‘there appears to be a clear indication that dyslexic drug users engage in a more chaotic drug using life style than their nondyslexic counterparts. They consume more drugs, they are more likely to inject and they report more health problems’. This leads back to issues with self-esteem and self-efficacy and although I have been unable to unearth any evidence of any causal link or significant correlation between dyslexia and addiction, there are sufficient parallels to warrant further investigation. As was noted above, persons with low selfefficacy also have low self-esteem and they harbour pessimistic thoughts about their accomplishments and personal development. In the case of students with dyslexia and anxiety, both of these factors affect their working memory, which can in turn, result in impulsive behaviour, notably these are some of the pre-requisites of problematic behaviour in cases where alcohol or illicit drugs are turned to for solace and self-medication. In conclusion, I would like to summarise what I regard as the interplay between dyslexia and anxiety, with the common factor being the implications for working memory. As is detailed above, dyslexia is characterised by phonological processing difficulties. The working memory system includes a specialised phonological store in which verbal information is retained. Children with poor working memory skills, typically, make poor academic progress in the areas of literacy and mathematics and can develop negative reading-related self-perceptions. These self-perceptions can, in turn, impact on their self-efficacy as negative emotional events are better remembered. Research indicates that dyslexic university students have higher Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 10 levels of trait anxiety than non-dyslexics. High levels of anxiety reduce both the storage and processing capacity of working memory. So one can see a cycle whereby the effects of dyslexia are exacerbated by anxiety, with a concomitant effect on self-efficacy which, in turn, makes the individual more prone to anxiety and so on. There appears to be a dynamic interplay between dyslexia and anxiety, with each fuelling the other, creating a cycle of disadvantage for the individual concerned. Against this background, there are a number of implications for practitioners working in the field of dyslexia. I concur with the conclusion of the research undertaken by Caroll and IIes (2006: 651) when they observe that: ‘assessment of emotional wellbeing should form part of the assessment of need for students entering higher education’. This needs to be borne in mind by assessors undertaking needs assessment under the Disabled Students Allowance scheme. Practitioners working with students with dyslexia should be aware that anxiety is not just an associated condition for their clients but one which serves to exacerbate all of their difficulties with respect to reading and coping in an academic context. Practitioners should be attuned to the more obvious symptoms of anxiety and include in their armoury strategies which can assist the student, such as relaxation techniques, breathing techniques, taking regular breaks, effective and realistic time management. The profound effect that anxiety can have on an individual’s working memory underscores our responsibility to assist the student in coming to realise the existence of the cycle of interplay and to assist them to develop strategies which will minimise this cycle’s destructive power. Finally, there are a number of areas for future research and investigation, in particular, the correlation between dyslexia and addiction. Similarly, I would like to investigate further the efficacy of a range of relaxation strategies which could be used by practitioners when working with students with dyslexia. Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 11 References Ausubel, D P, Schiff, H. Goldmann M. Qualitative characteristics in the learning process associated with anxiety, The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology. Vol 48(4), 1953, 537-547 Baddeley, A (1986). Working Memory. Oxford: Oxford University Press Baddeley, A . (2000). The episodic buffer: a new component of working memory? Trends in Cognitive Sciences. 4 (11), p417-423. Baddeley, A, Gathercole, S, (2003) Working Memory and Language, Psychology Press Bandura, A (1977), Self-efficacy: The exercise of Control. New York: Freeman. Bandura, A. (1995). Self-Efficacy in Changing Societies. Cambridge University Press. Biederman, J, Newcorn J and Sprich S. (1991) ‘Comorbidity of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder with conduct, depressive, anxiety, and other disorders’. Pediatric Psychopharmacology Unit, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston 02114. Blakemore, S, Frith U. (2006) The learning brain, lessons for education. Blackwall Publishing Oxford Carroll, J. IIles, J E, (2006) An assessment of anxiety levels in dyslexic students in higher education. British Journal of Educational Psychology 76, 651-662 Chapman, J W. Tunmer, W E. (2003) 'Reading difficulties, reading related selfperceptions, and strategies for overcoming negative self-beliefs’, Reading and Writing Quarterly, 19: 1, p5-24 Dockrell J., McShane J (1993) Children’s Learning Difficulties. Oxford: Blackwell Darke, Shane (1988) 'Anxiety and working memory capacity', Cognition & Emotion, 2: 2, 145-154 Eysenck, M. W. Calvo, M. G. 1992 Anxiety and performance: The processing efficiency theory. Cognition & emotion, 6(6), 409 - 434. Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 12 Hinson J M, Jameson T L, Whitney, P Impulsive decision making and working memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition. Vol 29(2), Mar 2003, 298-306. Kushner, M G, Sher K J and Beitman B D. (1990) The relation between alcohol problems and the anxiety disorders. Am J Psychiatry 147:p685-695 Kirby,J. Silvestri, R. Allingham, B. Parilla, R. La Fave, C.. (February 2008). ‘Learning Strategies and Study Approaches of Postsecondary Students with Dyslexia’. Journal of Learning Disabilities. 41 (1), p94-95. Pickering, S. Verbal Memory in the Learning of Literacy in Turner M, Rack J, (2004) eds) The Study of Dyslexia (London) Kluwer Academic. Pickering, S.(2006) Working Memory and Education, London, Elsevier Rosen J B, Schulkin J, From normal fear to pathological anxiety. Psychological Review. Vol 105(2), Apr 1998, 325-350 Shaywitz, S. (1996), ‘Dyslexia’, Scientific American, November 1996 Singleton, C. H. (Chair). (1999). Dyslexia in Higher Education: Policy, provision and practice (The Report of the National Working Party on Dyslexia in Higher Education). Hull, UK University of Hull Stein J. (2006). The Physiological Basis of Dyslexia. Available: http://www.physiol.ox.ac.uk/~jfs/research1.html. Last accessed 10 may 2010. Steinbeck J (1952). East of Eden. New York: Putnam Penguin, pp. 270-271 Stewart J (2001) Presentation to British Dyslexia Association, Sheffield. Swinney, D A (1979) ‘Lexical Access during Sentence Comprehension: Reconsiderations of Context effects’. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behaviour, 18, p. 645-659 Schunk, D (2003) 'Self-efficacy for reading and writing: Influence of modelling, goal setting, and self-evaluation’, Reading & Writing Quarterly, 19: 2, 159-172 SpLD Working Group 2005/DfES Guidelines can be downloaded from the PATOSS web-site: http://www.patoss-dyslexia.org/ Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 13 Willcutt, E, G, and Pennington, B. E. (2000). ‘Psychiatric comorbidity in children and adolescents with reading disability’. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 41 (8), 1039-1048 Wolf, M (2008). Proust and the Squid, the Story and Science of the Reading Brain. Houston: Icon. 1. Yates, P R (2006) ‘Bad mouthing, bad habits and bad, bad boys: an exploration of the relationship between dyslexia and drug dependence ‘ Supervised by Susan Eley, Kirsten Stalker & Alison Bowes MSc. In Applied Social Research, Dissertation submitted 31st August 2006 Department of Applied Social Science, University of Stirling Anxiety and its correlation with working memory – the implications for students with Dyslexia Patrick Mulcahy Student No: 9055478 Page 14