95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad Compound Adjectives in English and Arabic as a contrastive study A Research Submitted by M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad Abstract Traditionally adjective phrases are defined as phrases that consist of an adjective and any modifier such as adverbs and preposition. They are the most frequent and considered the most prototypical grammatical from that function as noun modifiers. This research ,in particular, deals with one aspect of adjectives, namely, compound. They are words, phrases and clauses that function as adjective. They named "compound adjectives". e.g. [The green-house effect]. It is important to introduce this descriptive class of words, to compare with Arabic language in order to maintain or limit the most important similarities and differences that can be found in both systems. Also we see as(an experience teacher of English language) that the students need to be aware and understand the meaning ,proper usage of this descriptive tools in order to develop their proficiency in English language. 109 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad The present research is divided into three sections. The first section has been devoted to study compound adjectives in English. It examines different kinds of compound adjectives viz., hyphen and non hyphen classified on the bases of form, meaning and function. It studies the syntactic function of compound adjectives i.e as a pre modifier of the noun phrase and their restriction use whether it is hyphenated or nonhyphenated The second section has attempted a descriptive analysis of the two types of compound adjectives in Arabic viz., actual and causal, on the basis of their references and syntactic features. It describes the restrictions uses of the two types. Finally, on the basis of the descriptive analysis of compound adjectives in English and Arabic done separately in section 1 and section 2 respectively, a contrastive study is attempted in section 3, to bring out the similarities and dissimilarities between the two systems. 110 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad Section 1 1.1 What does compound mean? According to Ryodo Ogata , English grammarians, including traditional one have dealt with compound but they seem to have failed to give a precise definition of compounds. Later, Sweet (1891) defines a compound as a "combination of two words equivalent formally and logically to a single word". He means by "formally" a single, in dividable by "logically" Sweet implies that compounds are characterized by "meaningparticularization" which can't be a criterion for compounds. But Bloomfield (1933) suggests that "The construction of compound words are most similar to the construction of syntax". So compound is a word composed of more that one free morpheme. And English compounds may be classified in several ways such as the word classes or the semantic relationships or know the rule that were supposed to hyphenate compound adjectives when they appear before a noun not after a noun. 1.2 Compound Adjectives Adjectives in compounds are inseparable from their constituent. They are modifying compounds and expressions "multi-word modifiers" like: bitter-sweet chocolate a hand-woven scarf a kind-hearted aunt Meys (1975) called compound adjectives as "condensed sentences" That is to say "meaning – particularization" mainly based on evidence presented by noun compounds. This can be readily seen when we think of compound adjectives like timeconsuming or self- built. [Meys (1975) classified compound adjectives in the frame of transformational generative grammar]. 111 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad time – consuming procedures English compound adjectives are constructed. It is a modifier of a noun. It is made of two or more morphemes of which left-hand component limits or changes the modification of the right- hand one, as in "the dark- blue eye" dark limits the "blue" that modifies "eye". So compound adjective comprises more than one word, usually hyphens are used to link the words together to show that it is one adjective. That is an all-too-common mistake. an up-to-date dictionary. 1.3 Syntactic form of compound adjectives: As it clearly to all that the study of rules of a language is called grammar which is a field of linguistics. It is the study of how words are combined together to form sentences. Adjectives in compounds (our present research ) are inseparable from their constituent. So common patterns to make a compound adjectives are as follow: adj. or number + noun + “ -ed” red- haired adj. or adv. + past part. low- paid adj. adv. Or noun + present part. good- looking v. + adj. --- feel- good. Meys (1975) classified compound adjectives in the frame of transformational generative grammar, e.g. a drowsy- looking policeman. Det L1 ( S1 ) L2 comp. Aj NP 112 S 2 N1 comP. Aj NP 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad L1- L2 are symbols refer to lexical items functioning as constituents in the compounds and their underlying structures. While S1 – S2 refer to structural elements- affixes like:[- ing ,-ed ly etc]. a drowsy- looking policeman. Compound adjective of the form “-looking” here can be used as a criterion for the presence of predicative use of the word. Similarly, The grammatically of a sentence in the predicative form “The soldier is friendly (-looking) conversely affirms the claim that compound adjectives are “condescend sentences” as Meys (1975) called. We have to note that forming the compound adjectives from nouns like: Subj. + have/ has + noun phrase subj. + be + (a) adj. noun + ed + n. The stool has three legs it is a three- legged stool. Layla has long hair She is a long-hair beauty. “have” here is used to indicate a part of the whole, not possession of something separate. So we can’t say: Layla has two cars * she is a two- carred house wife. or Mary has two sons * Mary is a two- sonned mother. However compound adjectives in the previous pattern is used to give physical or “metaphorical description”. 1.4 Kinds of compound adjectives. Compound adjective can be classified as hyphenated and non hyphenated adjectives. 1.4.1 Hyphenated compound adjectives Hyphens are usually used to link the words together to show that it is one adjective e.g. 113 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad That is an all-too- common mistake. an up-to-date dictionary. And as stated before that compound adjectives which are a combination of words that serve as a single adjective, So we should hyphenate compound adjective that appears before a noun in order to be “compound”. They need to modify each other in a “chain” for example “a dark- green box” vs. “a dark green box” i.e dark here describes the shade of green and is not describing the box. The following rules should be followed when dealing with hyphenate compound adjectives. 1- They have been formed originally by an adjective preceding a noun: round table “round- table discussion”. blue sky “blue- sky law”. four wheels “four- wheel drive” (historically the singular or root not plural is used). 2- It is also hyphenated when a verb preceding an adjective or adverb: “feel good” “feel- good factor”. “Buy now pay later" buy- now pay- later purchase. 3- Short adverbs like “well”, “fast” are often hyphenated in combination when they preceding the noun. a well-known writer fast- link connection 4- When an original verb preceding a preposition like “stick on” stick- on label “stand by” stand- by fare “walk on” walk-on part 5- When “-d” or “-ed ” has been added as a part-participle construction before noun, it is usually hyphenated: 114 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad “middle-aged lady” “rose-tinted glasses” 6- Numbers spelled out or as numeric. “seven- year itch”. “20th- century poem”. “a20-year-old man”. 7- Colures are compounds like: “a dark-blue sweater”. dark limits blue not sweater. “a reddish-orange dress”. 1.4.2Non hyphenated Compound Adjectives Hyphens are usually unneeded when come after noun if the compound adjectives used after thing or person being described ,e.g. The baby is well fed. The dictionary is up to date. But they can appear before noun in these cases: 1- There is no need to group the words together that should be written using capitalization or italicization makes grouping clear. “Old English scholar”: an old person who is English and scholar, or an old scholar who studies English. Also, “a Sunday morning walk”. 2- Hyphen is usually dropped after adverbs end in (-ly) even if they are seemingly part of compound adjective. They entered the brightly lit room. 3- A hyphen usually dropped in a compound using a comparative (er) or superlative (-est). better sounding speakers. oldest surviving member. 4- Also we don’t use a hyphen in a compound that uses letters as the second part of the adjectives. 115 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad section 9 discharge. type A personality. 5- Compound adjectives from proper nouns don’t need to hyphenate. Romeo and Juliet tickets. The words “Romeo” and “Juliet” are adjectives describing the tickets. As the capital letters of proper nouns group the words and there is no need to use a hyphen. Nigel (1997) shows the various possible combinations of compound adjectives in English with examples in the following table: End position Initial position Adj. Adv. n. n.+ ed Pres. part. Past part. Adj. bittersweet northeast hard-up deep-see old-aged nicelooking clear-cut Adv. up-tight halfyearly crosscountry n. ice-cold tax-free cat-like king-size wellmannered bowlegged Number --------- ----------- five-stars two-faced Pres. part. Past. Part. boilinghot ----------- workingclass ----------- --------- ---------- --------- brokendown cut-price brokenhearted --------- ---------- 116 everlasting oceangoing twotiming wellknown handwoven ---------- 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad Section 2 Compound Adjectives in Arabic Arab adjectives are similar to nouns in almost every aspect. They are called “ “ ”توابعfollowers” of the noun head in their syntactic function. The Arab grammarians considered the class of adjectives as a subclass of the class noun i-e. They called “ اسم غير ”الصفةas a noun which is not adjective, and “ ”اسم الصفةas a noun which is adjective. In Arabic language compound adjective comprises more than one morpheme to be one adjective and agree with it in number, gender, case and definiteness. See the following example. ُ .حفظت قصيدةً رائعا ً أسلوبها -1 I memorized a great - style poem. Here “ ”رائعاlimits the style “ ”أسلوبof the poem. So the compound adjective “ ”رائعا أسلوبهاis agree with ““ ”قصيدةpoem” in case and indefiniteness, whereas the following sentence: . العراق بلد وفير خيره-2 Iraq is very rich country. We see ““ ”وفيرenrich” agree with ““ ”بلدcountry” in case and gender. However compound adjectives in Arabic function as post modifier to the head noun. However, to make compound adjective in Arabic common patterns should be followed: sub. + predicate -----------.جاء رجل أبوه كريم adv. Prep. + n. ------------- رأيت ولدا ً على حصانه adv. Place + n. -------------- في الدار رجل أمام الكرسي ً هذا الطالب يحمل كتابا v. + n. -------------- الذي+ n. -------------أطيعوا أباكم الذي رباكم 117 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad أحمد أطول من أخيه جاء الولد الكريم أبوه Adj. + prep.-----------Def. n.+ n. ------------- 2.2 Compound Adjectives Rules in Arabic. Adjectives in Arabic classified into two kinds; actual and causal adjectives. The Arabic compound adjectives can be as well actual and casual adjectives. 2.2.1 Actual compound Adjectives. Actual compound adjectives are directly modifying the noun head. Their rules are expressed as follow: 1- They can be nominal sentence. In this case the noun head should be indefinite noun like: . جاء رجل أبوه كريم-3 comp. adj. Ind. n. The nominal sentence “ ”أبوه كريمmodifies the indefinite noun “”رجل. 2- They can be verbal sentence like: .ً حضر علي يحمل كتابا-4 The verbal sentence “ ”يحمل كتاباis the compound adjective that modifies “ ”عليand realizes the role of predicate. 3- Adverb phrase of place can be compound adjectives like: اّللِ ه ُهم د ََر َجات ِعندَ ه : قوله تعالى-5 .)361/ (آل عمران َواّللُ بَ ِصير ِب َما يَع َملُون . رأيت رجلً على حصانه-6 adv. prep. n . Compound adjectives here “ ”عند هللاand “ ”على حصانهrealizes the role of adverb of place and preposition respectively. We have to note that the compound adjective may be more than one in the noun phrase like: 118 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad ُ س َماء فِي ِه َّ ب ِ همنَ ال ظلُ َمات َو َرعد َوبَرق يَجعَلُونَ أَصابِعَهُم فِي آذَانِ ِهم َ أَو َك :قوله تعالى ٍ ص ِيه ت ه )31\ (البقرة َواّللُ ُم ِحيط ِبالكافِ ِرين ِ ق َحذَ َر ال َمو ِ ِ همنَ الص ََّوا ِع The nominal sentence “ ”فيه ظلماتand adv. of preposition “ ”من السماءare various comp. adj. to the head noun “”صيب. 4- Using “ ”ذوmeans “ ”صاحبand “ ”ذاتmeans “ ”صاحبةas a compound adjective such as: ُ ف َوالرَّ ي َح ُ َفِي َها فَا ِك َهة َوالنَّخ ُل ذ : قوله تعالى-7 ان ِ ات اْلَك َم ِام* َوالحَبُّ ذُو العَص )31-33/(الرحمن The compound adjectives “ ”ذات األكمامand “ ”ذو العصفmodify “ ”النخلand “ ”الحبrespectively. 5- The relative pronoun “ ”الذيcan be compound adjective such as: َاس اعبُدُوا َربَّ ُك ُم الَّذِي َخلَقَ ُكم َوالَّ ِذينَ ِمن قَب ِل ُكم لَعَلَّ ُكم تَتَّقُون ُ َّيَا أَيُّ َها الن : قوله تعالى-8 )31/(البقرة 6- The comparative degree usually termed the elative form (صيغة ) التفضيلhas the form “ أجمل ”افعل. It has the dual and plural number both in masculine and feminine. It modifies the noun head like: .أكبر من أخيه ُ هذا الولد-9 2.2.2 Causal Compound Adjectives Causal compound adjectives are indirectly modifying the preceding noun head, and directly the following noun, e.g. ُ .الحسن خطه جاء الرج ُل-11 Comp. n. The word “ ”الحسنexposes the meaning of the “ ”الخطnot the man “ ”الرجلbut “ ”الحسن خطهrelates to “”الرجلthe man, i.e. The “”الحسن limits the meaning of “ ”خطهand indirectly modifies the noun head. 119 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad This construction agree with the head noun in definiteness, number, gender and case, see the following examples. singular جاء الرج ُل الكري ُم أبوه-11 dual ب ِ جاء الرجلن الكريما اْل plural masculine جاء الرجا ُل الكرا ُم اْلب ُ plural feminine ب جاءت النسا ُء ِ الكريمات اْل Elative form “ ”صيغة التفضيلthat have the form أفعلin the absolute أخضر – أحمرcan be used as periphrastic construction by means of such words like أحسن – أشدwith a noun derived from adjective like أحسن وجه, - أشدُ حمرة. Also The genitive construction is used in causal compound adjective where more than two or three entities are concerned. e.g. “ ”أحلى االثنينi.e. when a noun “in contract” to another noun in the genitive. 2.3 Abstract Benefits of Compound Adjectives Adjectives in general in Arabic system have many moral benefits. Compound adjectives at the same time also can be for further extent as moral and abstract benefits such as: 1- Praising ( ) المديح " " فسبح باسم ربكَ العظيم )16 \(الواقعة This is to show Gods greatness. 2- Emphasis bad things or something." أعوذ باهلل من الشيطان اللعين " الرجيم ( )اللعين الرجيمa compound adjective emphasizes the modifier ( )الشيطانquality. 3- Object of specification ""التمييز 120 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad )4\" أني رأيت أحد عشر كوكبا ً والشمس والقمر رأيتهم لي ساجدين " )يوسف The number ) )أحدَ عشرmodifies ( )كوكباwhich is the object of specification i.e. ( )أحد عشرpreceded and not followed the noun head ( ) كوكباas usual in compound adjectives. Or if we say يضرب )َ )خص َمهُ الضربةَ الواحدةwe see ( )الواحدةemphasizes ( )الضربةand( َالضربة )الواحدةmodifies ( )خصمهas a compound adjective. 121 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad Section 3 Differences and Similarities in English and Arabic 3.0 In this section, there are a few distinction can be drawn between compound adj. in English and Arabic. The following are the major findings of this research. 3.1 Differences 1- English compound adjectives normally pre modify the head noun,”, Arabic on the other hand post modify the head like: “a blue – sky restaurant comp. adj. + n. English مطعم السماء الزرقاء n + comp. Arabic 2- Hyphen in English is almost very necessary to remove ambiguity, whereas, the Arabic system is not restricted with any hyphen but agree with the head in number, gender, case and defiantness. So a noun phrase in Arabic may be ambiguous without indicating the case explicitly e.g. U p-to-date dictionary hyphenated . قرأت كتابا ً رائعا ً أسلوبه inflected 3- Capitalization and Italicization has not followed the hyphenated compound adjective rule whether it is proper or common noun. Arabic on the other hand is not restricted with capitalization or italicization and proper noun in Arabic can’t be compound adjective or even single adjective but the noun head. e.g. Romeo and Juliet tickets comp. adj. أحمد أطو ُل من أخيه The head n. 4- Compound adjectives in English are divided according to their hyphenated, whereas in Arabic system they are divided according to their direct or indirect limitation of the head noun. 122 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad comp. adj. in English Hyphen comp. in Arabic actual non-hyphen causal 3.2 Similarities 1- In both languages English and Arabic compound adjectives modify the head noun. And they comprise more than one morpheme to be one comp. adj. the dark- blue eye ُهذا الولدُ جميل خلقه 2- Syntactically and semantically, both English and Arabic compound adjectives are directly or indirectly related to the head noun i.e. (inherent and non inherent). e.g. stick-on label direct green–land country Indirect direct أنهُ جالس عند الباب Indirect هذا رجل طوي ُل القامة 123 95 العدد/ مجلة كلية االداب M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad References in English 1- A arts , F. A arts , J (1988) English Syntactic Structures: New York, Toronto, Sydney, Tokyo, Prentice hall. 2-Adams,V.(1973):An Introduction to modern Word- formation: Longman. 3- Bloomfield, L.(1933) Language. Allen and Unwind. London. 4-Bolinger,D.(1967). Adjectives in English: Attribution and Predication, Lingua18. 5- Burton-Roberts,(1994) Analyzing Sentences. An Introduction to English Syntax: London and New York: Longman. 6- Chalkier, S. Weiner, E.ed.( 1994) The Oxford Dictionary of English Grammar: London: BCA. 7- Hawkins, Joyce(ed) (1986) The Oxford Reference Dictionary: Oxford University Press. 8- H.Sweet (1891).A new English Gammar, logical and historical, Oxford University Press. 9-Hornsby, A. S. (1977) Guide to Patterns and Usage in English: Oxford: Oxford University Press. 10-Huddleston,RodneyD.(1984) Introduction to the grammar of English: Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 11- Meys, W.J.( 1975) Compound Adjectives in English: North- Holland Publishing Company. 12-Nigel J. Ross.(1997) . "Double- Barrel led" Adjectives: Modern English Publications, Basingstoke, UK. 13-Quirk, R; Greenbaum, S., Leech, Geoffrey; & Svartvik, Jan. (1972) A Grammar of Contemporary English , Harlow: Longman. 14-Radford, A. (1992) Transformational Grammar : A First Course Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 15-Ryodo OGATA( 1976). Compound Adjectives in English. 124 مجلة كلية االداب /العدد 95 M.ed Hind Hamid Muhammad 16-Thomas Y. Crowell Co. Inc. (1975) Modern English Linguistics: A Structural and Transformational Grammar. 17-W. M. Baskerville & J. W. Sewell 1896 An English Grammar. Syntax adjectives. 18- Yoweli Y. Aziz (1989).A Contrastive Grammar of English And Arabic: Mosul. المصادر العربية -3القران الكريم . -1أوضح المسالك إلى ألفية ابن مالك ،اإلمام أبي محمد ابن هشام األنصاري المصري. حققه دكتور هادي حسن حمودي ،دار الكتاب العربي ,بيروت ط3111 4م. -1جامع الدروس العربية ،الشيخ مصطفى الغاليني .دارالغد الجديد .القاهرة\ المنصورة. ط1007 3م . -4شرح ألفية ابن مالك .ابن عقيل -القاهرة 3165م. -5شرح شذور الذهب في معرفة كالم العرب .األمام أبي محمد األنصاري المصري ت. محمد محي الدين عبد الحميد .مطبعة السعادة .مصر ط3151- 6م. -6كتاب سيبويه ،تحقيق وشرح عبد السالم محمد هارون ،عالم الكتب ،بيروت -لبنان ط3401 1هـ3181-م. -7المقرب ،ابن عصفور .تحقيق أحمد عبد الستار الجواري ،عبد هللا الجبوري – بغداد .مطبعة العاني3186 .م. -8النحو الوافي ،عباس حسن .دار المعارف بمصر .ج\ 1الطبعة الثانية . 3164 125