North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Notes: This document is updated every 2 to 3 months; please check our website www.cancernorth.nhs.uk for latest version. This document does not all contain Interim Cancer Drugs Fund Decisions, i.e. decisions made as part of setting up Interim cancer drug fund are not included, only new decision for CDF funding from April 2011. These can be found at:: http://www.cancernorth.nhs.uk/hpSite/groups/networkgroups/necdag/northeastcancerdrugfund/fundingpolicyprioritylists This contains a record of all decisions made by NECDAG since May 2006. It must be viewed in conjunction with the Network list of approved cancer medicines and recent decisions by NICE. Section 2 of the document contains a summary of all NICE decisions implemented by NECDAG. Drug(s) Glucarpidase (Varoxase®) Indication Methotrexate toxicity Date considered 28 Nov 2012 Decision Approved Estimated Cost Impact (NECN) Comments £36,000 per pt - Rituximab in combination with a standard NHL induction regimen Document1 DLBCL 28 Nov 2012 Page 1 of 27 Approved Approx 10 patients, costing £120K For the treatment of toxic plasma methotrexate concentrations (>1 micromole per litre) in patients with delayed methotrexate clearance due to impaired renal function, in the following situations: Delayed elimination of methotrexate Impaired renal function Significant methotrexate toxicity Gold standard chemotherapy for patients with DLBCL is R-CHOP.. Rituximab with other chemotherapy regimens is an alternative treatment option e.g. DECC, CVP for this group of patients, as part of their first line therapy last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 . Additionally Rituximab would be added to the MACOP-B regimen for the small number of young patients with DLBCL, subtype Primary Mediastinal B cell Lymphoma Rituximab Bendamustine with rituximab PEG Asparginase Document1 Hairy Cell Leukemia Low Grade Non Hodgkins Lymphoma Adult patients with ALL 28 Nov 2012 26 Sept 2012 26 Sept 2012 Page 2 of 27 Approved Approved Approved Approx. 3 patients £27,000 £13,000 per patient 5 patients per annum, costing £99,300 An unlicensed indication – For the treatment of patients with hairy Cell Leukaemia (HCL) or Hairy cell Leukaemia varian (HCL-v) who: - Relapse early after purine analogue therapy (< 2 years post treatment) - Are refractory to purine analogues. In combination with bendamustine for patients with either first line or relapsed Low Grade Non Hodgkins Lymphoma Current practice in the region for adult patients with ALL is for them to be entered in the UKALL 14 protocol. In one arm of this protocol, patients are administered Lasparginase. However, not all patients are able to be entered into this study, and it is for these patients that last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 PEGasparginase will be used. It is common practice for paediatric patients as it is less immunogenic than Lasparginase, and has more prolonged activity Gemcitabine Rituximab Ovarian cancer patients experiencing progressive disease within 6 months of platinum-based chemotherapy ( platinum-resistant ovarian cancer). Gemcitabine is licensed for ovarian cancer (in combination with carboplatin) Post Transplant Lymphoproliferative disorders 26 Sept 2012 26 Sept 2012 Approved Approved (PTLD) Rituximab with salvage chemotherapy Document1 Patients relapsing > 12 months post 1st line therapy with R-CHOP 26 Sept 2012 Page 3 of 27 Approved 60 patients per annum, costing 0.5million Approx. 5 patients per annum, costing £29,340 There is a global shortage of pegylated liposomal doxorubicin (Caelyx). Caelyx is the NICE recommended second line treatment for women with partially platinum-sensitive, platinumresistant or platinumrefractory advanced ovarian cancer An unlicensed indication – For rising EBV viral copy numbers in patients after allogenic bone marrow transplant to pre-empt development of Post Transplant Lymphoproliferative disorders (PTLD). This is an unlicensed indication for rituximab. Although it is common practice in Europe and the U.S for patients to receive rituximab with salvage treatment, there has been evidence to suggest that patients with refractory disease or early progression last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 (< 12 months) will not benefit from re-exposure to rituximab, but the situation is said to be less clear for late relapsers, hence it is proposed to be only used in patients relapsing > 12 months post 1st line therapy with CHOP. Bendamustine in combination with rituximab High Grade Non Hodgkins lymphoma (NHL). Rejected There is very limited data to support its use in this setting. 26 Sept 2012 Approved Approved for use in combination with bendamustine for patients with CLL not fit for FCR chemotherapy or for patients who relapse within 2 years of FCR chemotherapy and not fit for alemtuzumab (Campath®) Rejected by NICE, prior NECDAG funding approval withdrawn 26 Sept 2012 Bendamustine in combination with rituximab Chronic Lymphocytic Leukaemia Cetuximab (Erbitux®) (colorectal 3rd line Colorectal Cancer – k-ras-wild type metastatic: THIRD line as a single agent or in combination with FOLFIRI / Irinotecan (Note single agent previously PCT funded) 30.5.12 Rituximab + CHOP as Induction Chemotherapy forr Mantle cell NHL and 25.01.12 Ritixumab (mabthera®) Document1 APPROVED from CDF Page 4 of 27 Approved See CDF Funding Priority List (web link above) £335,250 For use in patients in Patients unsuitable for NORDIC last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Erlotinib (Tarceva) Bevacizumab* Avastin Imatinib (Glivec) Vinorelbine (Navelbine) and Capecitabine (Xeloda) Document1 Rituximab as Maintenance Therapy chemotherapy Schedule. Note Not approved for use with FC chemotherapy regimen) 1st line treatment advanced or metastatic non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) with EGFR activating mutations. Cost Neutral There is a degree of uncertainty regarding average drug costs; what is apparent is that there will be a very low additional budget impact as erlotinib would be used instead of existing Gefitnib (Iressa) treatment. Approved £533,084 The dosing schedule NECDAG agreed was the 7.5mg/kg IV three weekly dose from the ICON-7 Trial. Given until disease progression, unacceptable toxicity or a maximum of 12 months. This is administered with carboplatin and paclitaxel for 5-6 courses and then a further 12 course as monotherapy. (total doses=18). Approved £157,320 year 1, £534,888 year 2 rising to £755,136 For patients only with a significant risk of relapse, NECDAG considered it likely that the Cost per ICER QALY for this indication lies in the region of £20-30k. Cost Neutral Combination instead of sequentially for selected patients where a higher chance of response than with the individual drugs important. (Ovarian) In combination with carboplatin and paclitaxel for up to 6 cycles, then single agent Adjuvant treatment of adult patients with GIST Treatment at 400mg daily for 3 years. Metastatic Breast Cancer 25.01.12 25.01.12 30.11.11 30.11.11 Page 5 of 27 Approved Approved last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Weekly Carboplatin and paclitaxel Heavily pretreated platinum-resistant recurrent ovarian cancer, good performance status(0-1) Cisplatin and Vinorelbine (chemoradiation) Non Small Cell Lung Cancer. 30.11.11 FOLFIRINOX Oxaliplatin, Leucovorin, Irinotecan, 5FU Management of selected patients with inoperable pancreatic cancer 2.11.11 Gemcitabine and Capecitabine Management of advanced pancreatic cancer 2.11.11 Degarelix (Firmagon) 1st line advanced hormone-dependent prostate cancer at with a PSA > 20ng/l 2.11.11 Lenalidomide (Revlimid) for Myelodysplastic syndrome with the 5q minus cytogenetic abnormality 2.11.11 & 25.2.12 Dexrazoxane (Savene TM) Treatment of extravasation Dasatinib (Sprycel) and 1st line Chronic Myeloid Leukaemia (CML) Document1 Cost Neutral Weekly dose dense paclitaxel and carboplatin regime has been reported to have high response rate & tolerable toxicity. Approved Cost Neutral Change to Concurrent Chemo with RTx as standard treatment to appropriately selected patients, instead of sequential treatment. Approved £148,500 First line for inoperable pancreatic cancer in patients with performance status 0-1. REJECTED £206,250 The committee was of the view that the clinical evidence was weak, with 3 RCT trials, two of which did not show any statistically significant benefit for the combination vs. gemcitabine. Approved Cost Neutral This expands a previous restricted approval (see decision below on 17.2.10 REJECTED £250,000 The committee considered and appeal (for CDF) as there was a lack of haematology expertise to advise the committee at original meeting. On appeal there were still safety concerns and lack of evidence. 13.7.11 Agreed to add to NECN Guidance See comments Considered part of Tariff by NECN commissioners 25.5.11 REJECTED See comments NECDAG’S view is there is already an effective 1st line treatment and these 30.11.11 Approved Page 6 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 drugs as yet offer no long term survival advantage over imatinib. These agents are approved 2nd line in NHS North East, first line approval would remove the option of 2nd line treatment Nilotinib (Tasigna) Sorafenib (Nexavar) Bendamustine (Levact®) Thyroid Cancer 1st line treatment of chronic lymphocytic leukemia (Binet stage B or C) in patients for whom Fludarabine combination chemotherapy is not appropriate. Currently unlicensed and a clinical trial was noted as being available. 25.5.11 REJECTED 19.1.11 Approved £132,380 None Following 1st line chemotherapy, given as maintenance therapy every 8 weeks for 2 years (12 doses) First-line maintenance in follicular non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma 19.1.11 Approved Year 1 £712,913 rising to £1,425,827 year 2 onwards Ritixumab (mabthera®) Newly diagnosed mantle cell NHL in fit patients aged <60years old 6.10.10 Approved Maximum £98K None Lapatinib (Tyverb®) plus an Aromatase Inhibitor (AI) (HER2) positive postmenopausal women with hormone receptor positive (HR+) metastatic breast cancer Rejected None As not being implemented The committee concluded that Lapatinib+ AI did not meet the current NICE criteria for cost effectiveness. Net cost of £73 to £147K NECDAG recognises that standard docetaxel and paclitaxel remain the first choice taxanes for metastatic breast cancer, however Abraxane will offer significant advantages for those patients who clinicians feel are unable to tolerate Ritixumab (mabthera®) Nab-paclitaxel (Abraxane) Document1 'Paclitaxel albumin (Abraxane) is accepted for restricted use within its current license for metastatic breast cancer patients who cannot 6.10.10 14.07.10 Approved with restrictions Page 7 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 tolerate standard taxanes Faslodex (Fulvestrant®) solution for injections Ritixumab (mabthera®) Drug(s) Traztusumab (herceptin®) with cisplatin and fluorouracil/capecitabine Degarelix (Firmagon) Capecitabine + irinotecan Document1 Post-menopausal and ER+ve , with Advanced/Metastatic Breast Cancer Patients: Nodular lymphocytepredominant Hodgkin lymphoma (NLPHL) Indication 1st line metastatic or locally advanced inoperable gastric cancers which over express HER-II (IHC +++ or IHC +++ FISH 1st line advanced hormonedependent prostate cancer with: PSA > 50ng/l or urether obstruction or symptoms of spinal cord compression Metastatic colorectal the taxanes treatment regimens or for patients that experience an adverse reaction to a standard taxane 14.07.10 Update of decision of April 2009 Approved with restrictions 14.07.10 Approved Date considered Decision 12th May 2010 Approved Additional expenditure of £150k. Previously approved 29.04.09, the licensed dose has now changed from 250mg monthly to 500mg monthly, with a 50% increase in costs. The new dose and costs were acceptable to NECDAG £98K to £293K per anum NECDAG concluded whilst there was no robust clinical evidence, e.g. phase III RCTs, there are technical and biological reasons to support its use for a limited number of patients rather than clinicians using Exceptional Circumstance Estimated Cost Impact (NECN) Comments £468,432 per anum NECDAG found the cost per QALY to be in the region of £52-66k per QALY gained. The treatment was thought likely to meet the NICE end of life criteria. NECDAG noted that trastuzumab is available for treatment of metastatic breast cancer with similar survival improvements and costs. 17.2.10 Approved Cost neutral Approved for restricted patients on the condition that the manufacturer either discounts or rebates the cost to be equivalent to the cost of gosarelin. 2.12.09 Approved Cost neutral As an alternative to FOLFIRI (Modified Page 8 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 (CAPIRI) Cetuximab (Erbitux®) cancer 3rd Line single agent in KRAS wild-type metastatic colorectal cancer patients. de Gramont + irinotecan). CAPIRI has comparable efficacy and tolerability to FOLFIRI, however, CAPIRI is more patient-friendly in that it does not require a central line and reduces visits to hospital. 17.11.09 Gemcitabine Adjuvant treatment for pancreatic cancer Gateway Sub Group 9.9.09 Gemcitabine and Cisplatin Palliative treatment for biliary tract cancers Gateway Sub Group 9.9.09 Document1 Approved £260,884 to £489,158 The committee felt that the strong evidence of improved survival (4.7months) for 3rd line single agent combined with a PAS scheme to reduce costs (the same pas NICE approved for 1st line cetuximab) allowed the drug to be approved under the NICE end of life ruling. Approved Max cost to NECN £187,000 per anum Trials confirm survival advantage for adjuvant Gem compared to observation in patients who had had their pancreatic cancer treated surgically. Approved Cost neutral, potentially cost saving This regimen would involve adding cisplatin to gemcitabine which is already approved in upper GI cancers or replacing existing ECX. Page 9 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Capecitabine and streptozocin Indication Neuroendocrine tumours (NET) Aprepitant (EMEND) and Palonosetron (Aloxi®) Chemotherapy induced nausea & vomiting (CINV) Rituximab in combination with Fludarabine & Cyclophosphamide For patients with CLL – Binet stage B or C, as treatment of relapsed disease Lapatinib (Tyverb) Breast cancer Plerixafor (Mozobil®) Stem cell mobilisation in the management of patients failing first mobilisation with multiple myeloma & lymphoma Bevacizumab (Avastin®) Metastatic colorectal cancer patients with unresectable liver only metastases with mutated KRAS Document1 Date considered Gateway Sub Group 9.9.09 Gateway Sub Group 9.9.09 September 09 September 09 September 09 1st July 2009 Decision Estimated Cost Impact (NECN) Comments Cost neutral Strepotozocin is already in use in an alternative schedule at centres treating NET. The approval allows replacement of 5FU/ Folinic Acid with Capecitabine. Included in tariff Palonosetron as an option for prevention of chemotherapy induced nausea & vomiting (CINV) in selected patients receiving moderate (ME) or highly emetogenic (HE) chemotherapy. Aprepitant as an option for prevention CINV in selected patients receiving HE chemotherapy £181,600 NECDAG has previously approved the use of FCR as first line treatment of CLL .However, this additional approval allows access for those patients who are at a later stage of treatment. Not Approved None In comparison with trastuzumab after progression lapatinib could be cost effective, however, NICE does not recommend trastuzumab be continued beyond progression. In comparison with standard chemotherapy the QALY is above the limits set by NICE hence the committee were unable to approve Approved £78,128 to £117,192 The use of plerixafor appears to significantly improve the chance of successful stem cell transplant (Tx) in a small number of patients who fail conventional transplant conditioning regimens. Rejected None As not being implemented. The committee concluded that the clinical evidence was not of the level of benefit normally required for acceptance into clinical practice and noted the suggestion that a randomised trial was needed to confirm benefit. Approved Approved Approved Page 10 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication yttrium-90 radiolabelled ibritumomab tiuxetan (Zevalin®) Consolidation therapy after remission induction in previously untreated patients with follicular lymphoma Gateway Sub Group 10th June 2009 Deferasirox (Exjade®) Iron Chelation for patients with Myelodysplastic Syndrome (MDS) Gateway Sub Group 10th June 2009 Cisplatin and Etoposide For induction concurrent Chemoradiotherapy To Superior Sulcus carcinomas of lung Gateway Sub Group 10th June 2009 Bortezomib (Velcade) First line therapy for multiple myeloma patients who have renal failure requiring haemodialysis or in whom use of ‘melphalan’ is prohibited Gateway Sub Group 10th June 2009 Approved Ritixumab (CLL) with Fludarabine and Cyclophosphamide First Line treatment of Chronic Lymphocytic Leukaemia in combination with FC Chemotherapy. 29th April 2009 Approved with restrictions Azacitidine (Vidaza®) Document1 Myelodysplastic Syndrome (MDS) Date considered 29th April 2009 Decision Estimated Cost Impact (NECN) Comments Rejected None As not being implemented. The committee did not feel there was currently sufficient clinical evidence to support use in the previously untreated setting, as patients locally would have received rituximab as part of their indication therapy. Approved with restrictions Net Cost to NECN = £10,000 The committee approved the recommendation to use defarasirox rather than less evidence based approaches such as transfusion of chelating agents immediately following transfusion. Approved Drug costs maximum £200 per patient. The committee felt that a 10% five year survival benefit off-set a very small financial cost. Rejected Page 11 of 27 Expected to be cost neutral The committee considered that any additional costs from re-sequencing the treatment would be offset by reducing dialysis costs. Net Cost of adding Rituximab to FC (with VAT) £271,170 Review decision on publication of final NICE Guidance None As not being implemented. The committee concluded the health economic case resulted in a QALY greater than the normal NICE threshold. This treatment fits the NICE End of Life Treatment criteria, however, the committee were concerned that the economic uncertainties and higher than normally acceptable QALY would result in a negative opinion from NICE. last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Bevacizumab (Avastin®) Faslodex (Fulvestrant®) solution for injections Oral Topotecan (Hycamtin®) Docetaxel (Taxotere®) with carboplatin Indication Metastatic Breast Cancer Post-menopausal and ER+ve , with Advanced/Metastatic Breast Cancer Patients: Relapsed Small Cell Lung Cancer (SCLC) in patients for whom re-treatment with 1st-line regime is not considered appropriate. Ovarian cancer: for patients that have demonstrated an allergic reaction to paclitaxel (CTC grade 3 or above hypersensitivity Date considered 29th April 2009 Gateway Sub Group 1st April 2009 4th February 2009 4th February 2009 Decision Document1 First Line Non Small Cell – Non Squamous Histology- Lung Cancer (2nd line see comments) 3 December 2008 & 4th February 2009 Comments Rejected None As not being implemented. The committee were unable to approve at this time because the limited overall survival advantage, and limited evidence of a difference in utility between the control arm and treatment arms of the trial meant it impossible to develop a health economic model which could produce a QALY value under the normal limits approved by NICE. Approved with restrictions Net Cost to NECN = £62,688 to £83,584 Treatment to be administered in primary after administration of the first cycle in secondary care. Restricted to patients who/with: 1. Relapsed on AI therapy in advanced disease 2. Severe joint pains exacerbated by AI therapy. 3. Compliance issues Approved Net Cost £55,008 for the Network. The committee concluded that oral topotecan is at least as effective as VAC with the added benefit of improved symptom control and significant benefits in terms of quality of life and ease of administration. Approved Net Cost to NECN = £91,863 to £137,794 The committee considered if the reported paclitaxel hypersensitivity reaction was an issue that could be resolved by switching from generic paclitaxel to the non-contract branded equivalent. The safest approach for patients was to switch to docetaxel. Approved First line £341,334 for the Network. (2nd line cost neutral with refund scheme) Replacement of 1st line Gemcitabine +Cisplatin or Carboplatin with Pemetrexed+Cisplatin or Carboplatin for patients with Non-Squamous Histology (Large Cell and Adenocarcinoma) adds 2 months to median survival. 2nd line use allowed only for patients who started 1st line prior to 3.12.09 to allow equity of access. rd Pemetrexed (Altimta®) with Platinum Estimated Cost Impact (NECN) Page 12 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication Date considered Decision Estimated Cost Impact (NECN) Comments Lenalidomide (Revlimid) Relapsed/ Refractory Multiple Myeloma 24th September 2008 Rejected None – as not being implemented. The committee were unable to approve at this time as the economic case had not been demonstrated, but noted that NICE was due to review the treatment. Lenalidomide is the most expensive cancer medicine on the market, it would cost an average of £48,268 per patient for 11 months treatment and potentially £2,461,668 for network. Sorafinib (Nexavar®) Treatment of hepatocellular cancer 24th September 2008 Rejected None – as not being implemented. The committee were unable to approve as the economic case had not been demonstrated. Docetaxel (Taxotere® ) and Cyclophosphamide (TC) Adjuvant node positive Breast cancer unsuitable for anthracyline 24th September 2008 Approved £5,000 to £15,000 per PCT As an option for the adjuvant treatment of women with early operable node positive breast cancer (stages 1-3) who have a history of cardiac disease making them unsuitable for standard anthracycline based adjuvant chemotherapy MP-T (Thalidomide in combination with Melphalan and Prednisolone) First line therapy for multiple myeloma patients Gateway Sub Group 9th September 2008 Approved Cost Neutral Negligible impact as systems are already in place to provide Thalidomide on a ‘Third Line’ therapeutic basis. EOX Epiribicin, oxaliplatin, capecitabine Inoperable oesophagogastric cancer. Gateway Sub Group 9th September 2008 Approved Max cost across NECN will be £126,053. To replace ECX and EcarboX in suitable patients. Dasatinib (Sprycel) Chronic Myeloid Leukaemia with resistance or intolerance to prior therapy including imatinib 24th September 2008 Approved with restrictions See nilotinib costs Following nilotinib’s approval dasatinib was accepted as an alternative for patients intolerant to nilotinib. Dasatinib must not be used after failure on nilotinib. (Clinicians have freedom to choose most appropriate agent nilotinib or dasatinib) Document1 Page 13 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Date considered Decision Estimated Cost Impact (NECN) Comments Patients with Imatinibresistant or intolerant Chronic Phase Chronic Myeloid Leukaemia (CML) 9th July 2008 Approved with restrictions £265,422 for the Network. Nilotinib will replace higher doses of imatinib in patients who are resistant to imatinib, and be used as an alternative treatment for patients unable to tolerate imatinib Cisplatin and 5FU: Neoadjuvant setting in head and neck cancer. Gateway Sub Group 18th June 2008 Approved Cost neutral This treatment is currently offered after radiotherapy this is simply a switch in sequencing. TIP: (Paclitaxel, Ifosfamide Cisplatin) Second-line (post-BEP) salvage chemotherapy for patients with metastatic germ cell cancer. Gateway Sub Group 18th June 2008 Approved Cost neutral Accepted as standard practice. Thyrotropin Alpha (Thyrogen diagnostic tool for serum thyroglobulin testing in tracking patients with thyroid cancer. Gateway Sub Group 18th June 2008 £232 per dose Has been available as standard practice some parts of Network but not others. Gateway agreed it is accepted as standard practice and should be available across network Irinotecan Advanced colorectal cancer 23 January 2008 Approved Cost Neutral Addition of weekly single agent irinotecan as option for treatment of advanced colorectal cancer, for those patients not suitable for NICE approved 3 weekly regimen Topotecan (Hycamtin) (in combination with cisplatin) Carcinoma of the cervix recurrent after radiotherapy and for patients with Stage IVB disease. 23 January 2008 Approved with restrictions £37,500 for the Network. Restricted to patients who have been cisplatin free for a period of at least 12 months. Use without GCSF Support 2nd line Sunitinib (Sutent®) for GIST Gastrointestinal Stromal Tumours (GIST) after Imatinib Failure 23 January 2008 Approved £130,163 for the Network. Approved using reduced costs from Sunitinib risk share scheme to achieve cost effectiveness. Drug(s) Indication Nilotinib (Tasigna) Document1 Approve Page 14 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication Date considered Decision Estimated Cost Impact (NECN) Comments 2nd Line FOLFIRI (Irinotecan Modified DeGramont) Advanced colorectal cancer 7 November 2007 Approved £38,400 for the Network. FOLFIRI is approved as 2nd line therapy following 1st line treatment with FOLFOX. £4,931 per patient (125 days treatment) In theory implementation is cost neutral since patients who would have received docetaxel will receive erlotinib at equivalent price. The committee acknowledged the convenience of the oral dose form and favourable side effect profile may mean that patients eligible for docetaxel who will received erlotinib who would not have tolerated docetaxel. Approved £12,420 Restricted to patients unsuitable for standard therapy with ECF or ECX regimens due to potential toxicity with fluoropyrimidine based chemotherapy. Certain Trusts in NECN purchase Neulasta via a price deal with Amgen based on replacing existing GCSF usage with Neulasta® (pegfilgrastim). NECN asked the manufacturers to provide the same offer of price deal to all Trusts in the Network. (Not for use in patients with the CML & MDS) Approved as an alternative to 2nd line docetaxel (Taxotere). Erlotinib (Tarceva®) Non Small Cell Lung Cancer 2nd Liner as an alternative to docetaxel (Taxotere) 7 November 2007 Cisplatin & Docetaxel (Taxotere® ) Advanced Oesophago-gastric Cancer for patients unsuitable for ECX/ECF 7 November 2007 Neulasta® (pegfilgrastim) 6mg solution for injection Reduction in the duration of neutrophenia and the incidence of febrile neutropenia (FN) in chemotherapy patients 7 November 2007 Approved Up to £502,634 (However potentially cost neutral dependant on current GCSF usage) Oral Vinorelbine (Navelbine) A single agent or in combination for the treatment of advanced breast cancer 7 November 2007 Approved £165,000 Used for patients with stage 3 and 4 relapsing after or refractory or anthracycline containing regimen. Aprepitant (Emend®) Prevention of Chemo Induced Nausea & Vomiting in patients receiving high dose cisplatin & patients who fail standard antiemetic Clinical Approval* 1 cycle of treatment costs £47.42. Typical cost per patient around £280. *To be funded by Trusts as commissioners view is costs for supportive care are covered within tariff individual costs per PCT or Trust have not been calculated Document1 23 July 2007 Page 15 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication Date considered Decision Estimated Cost Impact (NECN) Comments Ritixumab (Follicular Lymphoma) Relapsed/ refractory follicular lymphoma responding to induction chemotherapy with or without Rituximab. 23 July 2007 Approved Year 1 - £268,514 Year 2 - £537,028 Further work ongoing defining the patient pathway for follicular lymphoma. Approved £674,600 per year + (a non-recurrent cost of £202,620*) *NE NHS Chief Executives agreed the small number of patients who have already received first line treatment with interferon prior to this decision may be able to receive Sunitinib if clinically appropriate. (Approx 12). This is not approval for 2nd line use but recognition that there are some patients who may benefit. Rejected £10,356.30 per patient per year. None – as not being implemented. Reject upon review in March 2007. Decision will be subject reviewed in September 2008 Likely to be £45K per year as a number of patients already treated Sunitinib (Sutent®) First line for Renal Cell Carcinoma Zevaline® (Yttrium-90 labelled Ibritumomab tiuxetan) The treatment of adult patients with CD20+ follicular B-cell nonHodgkin’s lymphoma (NHL) resistant to/ relapsed after Rituximab. Dasatinib (Sprycel®) for Chronic Myeloid Leukaemia Adults with chronic, accelerated or blast phase chronic myeloid leukaemia (CML) with resistance or intolerance to prior therapy including imatinib (Gilvec). 7 March 2007 Rejected £31,714 per patient per year. None – as not being implemented. Bexarotene (Targretin®) Skin manifestations of advanced stage (CTCL) cutaneous T-cell lymphoma patients refractory to at least one systemic therapy 7 March 2007 Approved with restrictions £90,000 per year maximum. Document1 23 July 2007 7 March 2007 Page 16 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication Date considered Decision Estimated Cost Impact (NECN) Comments Sorafenib (Nexavar®) and Sunitinib (Sutent®) Second line for Renal Cell Carcinoma 7 February 2007 Rejected None -not being implemented. No published cost effectiveness data was available PegylatedCytarabine (Depocyte®) Intrathecal treatment of lymphomatous meningitis 7 February 2007 Approved £29,275 Centre only treatment Oral Uftoral® (tegafur/uracil) Advanced Colorectal Cancer 1 November 2006 Approved £3,500 for both Oral Uftoral & Folinic Acid. Previously NICE approved. Unable to estimate uptake, likely to be small and instead of existing treatment option. Temozolomide (Temodal® ) Concomitant & adjuvant temozomide with radiotherapy at presentation malignant glioma (brain tumour) and good performance status 1 November 2006 Approved £564,960 per year. Subsequently NICE approved Approved Drug costs per patient would be around £5.3K plus £3K for additional costs giving totals of £169,600 and £96,000 NICE approved NICE estimates that 32 patients per million population will be eligible for treatment with this regimen. Cost Neutral Delivery cost should be neutral and capacity from nursing and pharmacy time being freed would be able to be redeployed for delivery of NICE Adjuvant Colon Guidance. Docetaxel (Taxotere® ) FEC-T Adjuvant use in patients with Node Positive Breast Cancer Capecitabine GI Cancers (ECX regimen etc) Document1 1 November 2006 5 July 2006 Approved Page 17 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication Date considered Decision Estimated Cost Impact (NECN) Alemtuzumab (MabCampath®) Chronic Lymphocytic Leukaemia with disease less than 5 cm (Third Line) 5 July 2006 Approved Approximately 15 patients per year costing £65,000 Erlotinib (Tarceva®) Non Small Cell Lung (Second or Third Line) Oral Vinorelbine (Navelbine) Non Small Cell Lung (First Line) NSCLC Cetuximab (Erbitux®) Colorectal cancer metastatic Document1 5 July 2006 3 May 2006 Comments Rejected The Committee noted that no published cost effectiveness data was available. An estimate Cost per Life Year Gained and QALY had been made. The Committee concluded that the economic case had not been demonstrated. SUPERCEDED by 7.11.07 DECISION Approved Equalising practice between CCA and NCN (previously approved in NCN) Rejected Rejected due to lack of clinical evidence of improvement in survival vs. standard treatment (best supportive care) and High cost per QALY. Decision superceded by nice TA118 Page 18 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Section 2: NICE Implementation This section contains a summary of all positive NICE decisions discussed by NECDAG Drug(s) Indication Date of NICE Guidance Decision Reference Comments Vemurafenib As a possible treatment for unresectable or metastatic melanoma with the BRAF V600 mutation. Dec 2012 Approved TA269 Currently funded by CDF. Will be funded from CDF until 31st March 2013, (90 day post NICE decision) at which time funding will switch to NHS commissioners (PCT/CCGs) Ipilimumab A possible treatment for people with previously treated advanced (unresectable or metastatic) melanoma. Dec 2012 Approved TA268 Currently funded by CDF. Will be funded from CDF until 31st March 2013, (90 day post NICE decision) at which time funding will switch to NHS commissioners (PCT/CCGs) Abiraterone (Zytiga) Prostate cancer (metastatic, castration resistant) - (following cytotoxic therapy) June 2012 APPROVED TA258 Currently funded by CDF. Will be funded from CDF until 27 September 2012, (90 day post NICE decision) at which time funding will switch to NHS commissioners (PCT/CCGs) Erlotinib (Tarceva) Lung cancer (non small cell, EGFR-TK mutation positive) - 1st line June 2012 APPROVED TA258 Previously Approved by NECDAG March 2012 Nilotinib (Tasigna) Nilotinib and standarddose imatinib for the firstline treatment of chronic myeloid leukaemia ( April 2012 APPROVED TA251 Nilotinib has been added to approval for 1st line therapy as part of review of NICE guidance TA70 due to manufacturer discounting drug to match price of imatinib. However this has not yet been implemented due to availability of Nilotinib in an ongoing clinical trial Nilotinib (Tasigna) 2nd line therapy after standard dose imatinib in Jan 2012 APPROVED TA241 NICE did not recommend high-dose imatinib or Dasatinib for people with Philadelphia- Document1 Page 19 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 CML chronic myeloid leukaemia Rituximab (MabThera®) Document1 Follicular lymphoma chromosome-positive chronic myeloid leukaemia in the chronic, accelerated or blast-crisis phase that has got worse after treatment with standarddose imatinib Jan 2012 APPROVED Page 20 of 27 TA243 Rituximab for the first-line treatment of stage IIIIV follicular lymphoma is recommended in combination with certain chemotherapies as a possible treatment for people with stage III–IV follicular lymphoma ( (review of NICE TA110) last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication Date of NICE Guidance Decision Reference Comments Mifamurtide (Mepact) Osteosarcoma Oct 2011 APPROVED TA235 Mifamurtide is made available at a reduced cost to the NHS under the patient access scheme. bortezomib and thalidomide Multiple myeloma (first line) - July 2011 APPROVED TA228 NECN Haematology NSSG asked to produce treatment algorithm for MM Rituximab (MabThera®) Follicular non-Hodgkins lymphoma (maintenance treatment following response to first-line chemotherapy) June 2011 APPROVED TA226 Previously approved by NECDAG Jan 2011 Bendamustine (Levact®) Chronic lymphocytic leukaemia February 2011 APPROVED TA216 Previously approved by NECDAG Jan 2011 Pazopanib Traztusumab (herceptin®) Document1 Renal cell carcinoma (first line metastatic) HER2-positive metastatic gastric cancer February 2011 APPROVED TA215 NICE approval is on the basis of the average cost of treatment being the same as sunitinib, with similar clinical efficacy. However if average treatment duration is generally shorter then the cost of pazopanib is higher than sunitinib, as both drugs have PASs which operate in different ways. Current audit data in the North East suggest the duration of treatment is shorter than seen in trials. Trusts to assure themselves November 2010 APPROVED TA208 Previously approved by NECDAG May 2010 Page 21 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication Gefitinib (Iressa) Advanced/ metastatic non-small-cell lung cancer 1st line Date of NICE Guidance Decision Reference Comments August 2010 APPROVED TA191 Implemented in October 2010 after consideration of issues surrounding EGFR testing and the PAS scheme for prescribing the drug. Pemetrexed (Alimita) Maintenance treatment of non-squamous nonsmall-cell lung cancer June 2010 APPROVED TA190 NICE does not allow use of maintenance therapy for patients who have received 1st line pemetrexed. It is anticipated that the majority of non-squamous histology patients in NECN will have already received pemetrexed as first line combination, therefore use as maintenance treatment in NECN will be limited Sorafenib (Nexavar) 1st line treatement of advanced and metastatic Hepatocellular carcinoma May 2010 Not recommended TA189 Previously reviewed and rejected by NECDAG. Trabectedin (Yondelis) Advanced soft tissue sarcoma February 2010 APPROVED TA186 Estimated very small numbers of patients who would be treated at cancer centres. TA184 NICE recommend use of topotecan is restrcited to patients in whom re-treatment with the previous treatment is not appropriate and there is a medical reason why they cannot take (CAV) cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin and vincristine. NECDAG Previously approved for use as an alternative to CAV due to decreased toxicity. Clinicians are advised to use clinical judgement on patients suitability to receive CAV. Topotecan Document1 Relapsed small cell lung cancer November 2009 APPROVED Page 22 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication Pemetrexed first-line treatment of non-small-cell lung cancer Sunitinib Decision Reference Comments September 2009 APPROVED TA181 Previously Approved by NECDAG ( Dec 2008) gastrointestinal stromal tumours (GIST) September 2009 APPROVED TA179 Previously Approved by NECDAG ( Jan 2008) Cetuximab (Erbitux®) Combination with 5-FU, folinic acid & oxaliplatin (FOLFOX) for first line colorectal cancer with potentially operable liver metastases August 2009 Approved TA176 The manufacturer rebates 16% of the amount of cetuximab used on a per patient basis by means of a Patient Access Scheme (PAS). Lenalidomide (Revlimid) Relapsed/ Refractory Multiple Myeloma Sunitinib (Sutent®) First line for Renal Cell Carcinoma Erlotinib (Tarceva®) Document1 Non Small Cell Lung Cancer Date of NICE Guidance June 2009 Approved TA171 NICE allowed use for patients who have received at least one prior therapy and where a Risk Share Scheme is in place to provide free drug for patients who continue on treatment after 2 years. March 2009 Approved for patients suitable for interferon with performance status 0 or 1. TA169 Already implemented in NECN. TA162 NICE state. Erlotinib should be used only when the manufacturer provides the drug at the same overall treatment cost as docetaxel. In practice NICE have accepted a scheme similar to one approved by NECDAG in Nov 2007. Trusts should not a slight increase in costs (from £1,182 to £1,394 per month) as NICE did not obtain as favourable a discount as NECDAG November 2008 Approved as an alternative to 2nd line docetaxel (Taxotere). Page 23 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication Date of NICE Guidance Decision Reference Comments TA145 The possible patient group is very restricted. Most patients would be suitable for platinum based chemotherapy in combination with radiotherapy and there is currently no evidence of superiority of cetuximab for this patient population. Cetuximab (Erbitux®) (in combination with radiotherapy) Treatment of Head and Neck Cancer June 2008 Restricted approval for locally advanced squamous cell head and neck cancer with Karnofsky PS 90% not suitable for platinum chemo Cetuximab (Erbitux®) Metastatic colorectal cancer following failure of oxaliplatin-containing chemotherapy June 2008 Not recommended (Non-submission) TA150 NICE was unable to recommend the use in the NHS because no evidence submission was received from the manufacturer. Carmustine implants (Gliadel) treatment of recurrent glioblastoma multiforme June 2008 Not recommended (Non-submission) TA149 NICE was unable to recommend the use in the NHS because no evidence submission was received from the manufacturer Bevacizumab (Avastin®) non-small-cell lung cancer June 2008 Not recommended (Non-submission) TA148 NICE was unable to recommend the use in the NHS because no evidence submission was received from the manufacturer Bevacizumab (Avastin®) in combination with paclitaxel first-line treatment of metastatic breast cancer June 2008 Not recommended (Non-submission) TA147 NICE was unable to recommend the use in the NHS because no evidence submission was received from the manufacturer. Document1 Page 24 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication Erythropoietin analogues; epoetin alfa & beta (Eprex & NeoRecormon) and darbepoetin alfa (Aranesp) Treatment of symptomatic anaemia in adults who are receiving chemotherapy Date of NICE Guidance Decision Reference Comments TA142 There was some use of Erythropoietin analogues currently in NECN, Trusts should disinvest as appropriate. The NCN had previously produced guidance on the use of Erythropoietin analogues, this has now been officially withdrawn. May 2008 Not recommended for routine use. (Small use in ovarian/ patients unable to receive transfusions) Rituximab (MabThera®) Relapsed or refractory stage III or IV follicular non-Hodgkin's lymphoma February 2008 Recommended for 1st line in combination, maintenance and last line monotherapy TA137 Rituximab is an option in combination with chemotherapy to induce remission or alone as maintenance therapy during remission. Rituximab monotherapy is an option for relapsed or refractory disease when all alternative treatment options have been exhausted. Pemetrexed (Altimta®) Mesothelioma January 2008 Approved for PS 0 or 1 patients TA135 NICE guidance matches prior approval by NE Cancer Networks Bortezomib (Velcade) Monotherapy for relapsed multiple myeloma October 2007 Approved for patients who relapse for the first time after having one treatment, TA129 Approved following adoption of VRS scheme. Patients tested for response after not more than four cycles. If non responders then stopped and NHS gets refunded. Pemetrexed (Altimta®) 2nd line locally advanced or metastatic non-smallcell lung cancer August 2007 Not recommended TA124 Carmustine (Gliadel®) Implants and temozolomide (Temodal® ) Glioma (newly diagnosed and high grade) Document1 June 2007 Recommended with restrictions Page 25 of 27 TA121 Temozolomide for newly diagnosed glioblastoma multiforme with PS 0 or 1 Carmustine implants for newly diagnosed high-grade glioma only if 90% or more of their tumour has been removed, only at specialist centres/ James Cook and Newcastle . last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication Date of NICE Guidance Decision Reference Comments Fludarabine Phosphate (Fludara®) first-line treatment of chronic lymphocytic leukaemia February 2007 Not recommended TA119 The manufacturer’s NICE submission included fludarabine monotherapy and fludarabine plus cyclophosphamide compared with chlorambucil based on the results of the CLL4 trial. However the combination regimen is unlicensed in the UK therefore NICE declined to comment on it. NICE only commented on the single agent Fludarabine which is not as effective as combination. Gemcitabine and Paclitaxel Metastatic breast cancer January 2007 Recommended with restrictions TA116 Recommended as where two other treatments could also be used as alternatives. TA118 Bevacizumab with 5-fluorouracil plus folinic acid, with or without irinotecan not recommended for first line. Cetuximab with irinotecan not recommended for patients who had previous treatment that also included irinotecan. TA112 NICE recommend all three drugs and state ‘there is insufficient evidence to conclude that any one aromatase inhibitor or treatment strategy is more clinically effective than another’ NECN has produced guidance on use of adjuvant AI’s. Bevacizumab (Avastin®) & cetuximab (Erbitux®) Colorectal cancer metastatic Anastrozole (Arimidex), exemestane (Aromasin) and letrozole (Femara) Hormonal therapies for the adjuvant treatment of early oestrogenreceptor-+ve breast cancer Document1 January 2007 Nov 2006 Not recommended Recommended Page 26 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016 North of England Cancer Drugs Approval Group (NECDAG) – Cumulative Table of Decisions Jan 2013 Drug(s) Indication Rituximab (MabThera®) R- CHOP Stage III or IV follicular lymphoma Docetaxel (Taxotere® ) Paclitaxel Adjuvant use in patients with Node Positive Breast Cancer Adjuvant use in patients with Node Positive Breast Cancer Date of NICE Guidance Decision Reference Comments R CHOP regimen, ritxumab plus cyclophosphamide, vincristine and prednisolone. Sep 2006 Recommended TA110 Sep 2006 Recommended TA109 NICE recommend use of licensed FAC regimen NECDAG have considered and approved alternative FEC-T regimen Sep 2006 Not recommended TA108 Not found to be cost effective, docetaxel approved as adjuvant taxanes. Aug 2006 Recommended TA107 Previously implemented in NECN area. June 2006 Recommended TA101 Trastuzumab (Herceptin® ) Adjuvant use in patients with HER2 Positive Breast Cancer Docetaxel (Taxotere® ) hormone refractory prostate cancer Capecitabine and oxaliplatin adjuvant treatment of stage III (Dukes' C) colon cancer April 2006 Recommended TA100 Capecitabine on its own and oxaliplatin together with 5-fluorouracil and folinic acid are recommended as possible adjuvant treatments after surgery for stage III (Dukes’ C) colon cancer, when used in the following ways: Denosumab Prevention of skeletalrelated events in adults with bone metastases from solid tumours Oct 2012 Recommended TA265 Previously available via CDF Document1 Page 27 of 27 last Updated 09/02/2016