1 Supplementary Information: Māori cloaks Museum development in New Zealand In the opening decades of the 19th century, European contact with the indigenous Māori people in New Zealand was limited to interactions with whalers, sealers and early missionaries. Māori were tribally based traders, hunters, farmers, fishers, skilful carvers and weavers, linked by genealogy, trade and sporadic warfare (Waitangi Tribunal 2011). In 1840 the Māori population of approximately 80,000 outnumbered the 2000 or so permanent European settlers (Pool 1991). These demographics quickly changed with a massive influx of European migrants and diseases which decimated the Māori population. The establishment of museums, archives and libraries in New Zealand was aligned with the development of new settler communities and new settlements. This increase in European settlement led to the establishment of a national museum in 1865, with at least 10 museums operating by 1874: Nelson (1841), Wellington (1865), Napier (1865), New Plymouth (1865), Auckland (1867), Dunedin (1868), Christchurch (1870), Invercargill (1872), Marlborough (circa 1873) and Hokitika (circa 1874) (Henare 2005). These museums focused on building a rich repository of geological, natural history and ethnographic artefacts from New Zealand and Oceania. Collections were organised and presented according to the collector or curator’s values and view of the world (Townsend 2008). Museum curators built up collections by networking extensively with colleagues, and exchanging and purchasing artefacts and specimens between museums, societies and dealers (Hooper-Greenhill 2000; McLean 2000; McCarthy 2004; Day 2005; Henare 2005; Townsend 2008). Curators also travelled throughout the country to buy museum specimens of fauna and flora and cultural artefacts, although it was apparently often difficult to obtain “articles of 2 historical value” from the Māori tribes (e.g. The Star, 26 August 1908). These collections thus included many examples of Māori art, including the prestigious kiwi feather cloaks (kahukiwi) that are analysed in the research under scrutiny (Hartnup et al. 2011). An example of collection development: Te Papa Tongarewa The largest sample of kahukiwi in the paper under scrutiny (n = 27, Hartnup et al. 2011) are from the collections at Te Papa Tongarewa (Table 1 suppl.). Te Papa was initially called the Colonial Museum, and opened behind Parliament Buildings shortly after Parliament moved to Wellington in 1865. It became known as the Dominion Museum in 1907 and later Te Papa Tongarewa when the museum and National Art Gallery were united in 1998. The Colonial Museum was led by Sir James Hector, a Scottish geologist, naturalist and surgeon, until 1903, when Augustus Hamilton, an English ethnologist and biologist, became the Director (see Dell 1965; McCarthy 2004). The Colonial Museum’s first collections included more than 500 rock, fossil and mineral duplicates from Hector’s 1862 geological survey of central Otago (Nathan & Varham 2008) as well as other materials such as the collections of the New Zealand Society (also known as the New Zealand Institute and now the Royal Society of New Zealand), Walter Mantell’s collection, private donor collections and a number of Māori artefacts. By September 1866, Hector had acquired “9,297 specimens of rocks, minerals and fossils, 2,846 specimens of shells and 1,811 specimens of natural history including woods, fishes, wools, native implements, weapons, dresses, etc” (Dell 1965). The museum acquired and re-erected Te Hau ki Tūranga, a large carved meeting house built in the 1840s by leading Rongowhakaata chief and master carver Raharuhi Rukupō (McCarthy 2004). Like many, entangled objects “of that time, the acquisition was “embroiled in a conflict is almost impossible to unravel” (McCarthy 2004). Te Hau ki Tūranga became a renowned attraction which set precedence for other 3 regional museums to procure their own meeting houses (e.g. Canterbury museum and Samuel Locke acquired Hau-te-ana-nui-o-Tangaroa for £290 from the Ngāti Porou tribe of the East Coast of the North Island of New Zealand) (Henare 2005). There was some criticism that Hector had however neglected ethnological collecting in favour of natural science (Henare 2005). A number of significant collections of Māori artefacts had passed into foreign institution ownership (e.g. ethnographer John White sold a large and important collection of Maori jade artefacts to an English buyer) and as a result the Maori Antiquities Act was passed in 1901 to “restrict the export of . . . [Maori] artefacts and a proposal was soon made for the establishment of a National Maori Museum” (Henare 2005). Hector was replaced, and Hamilton appointed Director. Augustus Hamilton was a member of the New Zealand Institute and an avid collector of Māori artefacts. He had been part of the Hawke's Bay Philosophical Institute, where he exhibited items of interest at meetings and assisted in the establishment of the institute's museum (Dell 2010). On his arrival at the Colonial Museum, Hamilton set about collecting “a representative series of specimens of Maori art and workmanship” (Dell 1965). One of his first duties as Director was reporting on two collections of Māori material, the Butterworth and Hammond collections, which were purchased by the Government. James Butterworth, a dealer of Māori, curios in the Taranaki region was perhaps the largest dealer in Māori artefacts in New Zealand from 1890-1903 (Day 2005). Butterworth produced at least three sales catalogues, including feather cloaks such as a muka and peacock feather cloak (Lot 70, 1895, 1901, 1905 catalogues; Day 2005). A number of other dealers also operated during this period (for example, Eric Craig (Auckland), Edward Spencer (Auckland), Sygvard Dannefaerd (Auckland and Rotorua), and David Bowman (Christchurch); Day 2005). Day notes that collectors used a wide range means and a number of networks to could obtain items for their collections: finding them by 4 curio-hunting over former Māori occupation sites, looting burial grounds (such as James Robieson in the Rotorua region (Watt 1990)), and obtaining artefacts directly from Māori, either by purchase or in lieu of cash payment for services. On Hamilton’s sudden death in 1913, his private collection was bought by the museum and this, together with the material he had collected during his comparatively short time as Director, “laid the foundations for a valuable ethnological collection”. By this time the museum had been renamed the Dominion Museum in 1907 and employed Elsdon Best as a ‘temporary clerical assistant’ from 1910 until his death in 1931. The new Director was Dr. J. A. Thomson, who apparently revitalised the museum, improving its organisation and instituting effective policies for improved curatorial practices and active research (Hornibrook 2010). Important contributors to museum collections in New Zealand Here, we focus on some of the main contributors to museums where many feather cloaks have been deposited, and in particular those museums represented in the research on kahukiwi (Hartnup et al. 2011). We show that considerable background knowledge exists about collectors, and in many cases knowledge of these collectors could be expanded with historical scholarship, particularly with regard to specific artefacts. Elsdon Best (1856 – 1931) was a farm worker, soldier, sawmiller, health inspector, ethnographer and writer who spent much of his time researching pre-European Māori. Best was a foundation member of the Polynesian Society (a society that promoted the study and recording of Polynesian history and culture) and interviewed Māori elders, collecting and researching Māori tribal history and lore. Best joined the road-making team in Urewera district 1895 where he combined anthropological and ethnographical work with those of paymaster and storeman. While in the Urewera, he formed a close working partnership with his key informants Tutakangahau and Paitini Wi 5 Tapeka of Maungapohatu while maintaining his relationship with the Polynesian Society and the national museum (Sissons 2010). His links with the national museum were officially recognised, after intense lobbying by Walter Gudgeon, Percy Smith, Edward Tregear and Te Rangi Hiroa (Peter Buck), with the establishment of a position specifically for Best at the Dominion Museum, Wellington in 1910. Best spent the next 20 years producing works on a range of Māori subjects (Sissons 2010). Historical records provide evidence that while in the Urewera, he obtained Māori artefacts, including kahukiwi, for the museum collection (see, for example, Evening Post, 29 May 1899). Letters between Best and Hamilton from 1905-1906 similarly contain specific orders for Maori items (Tamarapa 2011). Gilbert Mair was associated with the Te Arawa tribe in the eastern North Island for much of his life (his collection of 236 Māori artefacts was deposited in and later purchased by Auckland Museum). As an agent for Alexander Turnbull, Sir Walter Buller and the Auckland and Dominion museums, Mair assisted in the purchase and removal of many valuable carvings from the Rotorua district, and was described as “a keen and not always completely ethical collector of Maori artefacts” (Savage 2010). Alexander Turnbull (1868-1918) was another early collector who amassed a substantial collection of Māori, Pacific and New Zealand material. In 1913 he made an anonymous donation of some 500 items of Māori and Pacific Islands artefacts to the Dominion Museum. “As a colonial collector, sensitive to the nationalism of the 1890s, he committed himself to the creation of a national collection of everything relating to New Zealand and its environs, to document the creation of a new society in the south-west Pacific, and to serve the first generation of indigenous scholars, his colleagues and friends” (Traue 2010). Walter Buller (1838-1906) is regarded as New Zealand’s best known ornithologist of the 19th century and one of New Zealand’s most controversial science figures. Widely regarded for his monumental bird books (e.g. A history of the birds of New Zealand, the first edition in 6 1872–73 and the second in 1887–88), Buller’s reputation as a bird collector has overshadowed his scientific achievements (Bartle & Tennyson 2009). Buller collected birds for more than 50 years (1852–1903). Buller’s three main collections document a period which coincides with a major phase of New Zealand bird extinction associated with European settlement and the introduction of mammals (Nathan & Varham 2008). The first of collection, which contained 310 specimens, was purchased by the New Zealand government for the Colonial Museum in 1871. The second collection of 728 specimens was sold to the Hon. Walter Rothschild for the Tring Museum, London and the third collection of 588 specimens was sold to the Carnegie Museum, Pittsburgh, U.S.A (Bartle & Tennyson 2009). Provenance of specimens and artefacts The failure of the Colonial Museum, and many of New Zealand’s early museums, to document and care for natural history collections can be seen in the early work on birds during the nineteenth century (Bartle & Tennyson 2009); work that is primarily associated with Walter Buller and his colleagues. The lack of field expertise was compounded by poor curatorial practices, inadequate premises, limited storage facilities and ad hoc record-keeping (Tennyson & Martinson 2009). There was frequently poor matching of historical and reference datasets by collectors, curators and New Zealand museums in the colonial period, including Buller’s collections (Bartle & Tennyson 2009). Nonetheless, alternative avenues of research or verification are possible when examining provenance where little or no original data are available (Bartle & Tennyson 2009). For example, Buller did not catalogue his specimens, or label them except for sale when he removed all collectors‟ labels. Specimens in the first collection carried only numbered tags (Bartle & Tennyson 2009). Bartle and Tennyson note that a vital first step in the identification of Buller collection specimens was to match the distinctive numbered tags attached to the birds with the system used in his sale 7 lists. Most of Buller’s first collection was lost and very likely destroyed at the Colonial Museum in the late nineteenth century owing to a shortage of resources and neglect. Analysis of specimen collection dates for Buller’s collections indicate that the prime purpose of their acquisition was for sale not research. It seems likely that Rothschild’s interest in New Zealand birds was important in motivating Buller during the main period of his collecting from 1886 to 1896. Hawke’s Bay Museum – the McLean family More than 850 items were donated to the Hawke’s Bay museum in the early and mid 20th century by members of the McLean (also written MacLean) family. Sir Donald McLean (1820-1877) was a dominant figure in Māori and Government relations in the mid-19th century, and an avid collector of Māori artefacts during this tumultuous period. McLean arrived in New Zealand in 1840: by 1844 he was working in Taranaki for the Aboriginal Protectorate Department. As Chief Native Land Purchase Commissioner for the government, he drove major land purchase activities in Taranaki and Hawke’s Bay and was appointed the head of the Native Affairs Department in 1856. However, his support of the disputed Waitara land purchase led to the outbreak of war in Taranaki in the early 1860s. McLean then retreated from central government to the Hawke’s Bay in 1861, and built up his large and profitable estates. He was elected Superintendent of the Hawke's Bay Province in 1863 and returned to Wellington as an elected politician in 1866 (Ward 2010). Through the later 1860s McLean was in charge of the campaign against the Māori prophet Te Kooti on the East Coast and from 1869 until just before his death in early 1877 he was the Minister in charge of Native Affairs (Alexander Turnbull library n.d.). McLean amassed a significant collection of Māori artefacts from different parts of the country. However, the collection was given to the Hawke’s Bay museum on the proviso that the collection remained in the Napier area because 8 of the large number of local Māori artefacts (provenance notes received from T. Cracknell, Hawke’s Bay museum). Examining provenance and historical information in old newspapers Our examination of provenance notes provided by the Wanganui Museum indicate that for the 22 accession numbers we were able to trace from Hartnup et al.’s study (2011), only two cloaks were lent by the same donor. Yet 12 of these cloaks have donor or location details strongly suggestive of local, west coast origins, in contrast to one other that originates from Rotorua. It would therefore be possible to explore hypotheses about cloak making origins and feather trading further, by matching individual provenance data and DNA haplotypes and using historical evidence, to reach more revealing conclusions than those presented. In order to build a possible profile for the provenance and historical evidence we briefly investigated potential locations for feather cloakmaking identified in newspapers of the time. This revealed three further sites where kahukiwi were probably woven during the period in question (the upper Wanganui, Daily Southern Cross, 26 August 1856; Taupo, The Star, 21 April 1873 and Otago Daily Times, 30 August 1898; and Taranaki, Wanganui Herald, 7 December 1909) in addition to the eastern North Island weaving stronghold suggested by Hartnup et al. Our search also identified a range of specific details about cloak weaving; for example, identifying an accomplished feather cloak weaver (Thames Star 22 May 1914). Other newspaper archives recorded the London auction of a distinctive kiwi cloak with two panels of albino feathers (mentioned in at least eight English language newspapers in New Zealand e.g. Otago Daily Times, 20 March 1899). This cloak was apparently destined for the Natural History Museum London, and is superficially similar to one recorded in the British Museum that was sampled in the study of Hartnup et al. We conclude that newspapers, letters and other historical records, as well as other forms of contemporary evidence, can provide 9 detailed information on provenance. 10 References Alexander Turnbull Library (nd) Scope and contents of the Donald McLean papers. http://mp.natlib.govt.nz/static/introduction-mclean-scope?l=en. Bartle JA, Tennyson AJD (2009) History of Walter Buller’s collections of New Zealand birds. Tuhinga, 20, 81-136. Day K (2005) James Butterworth and the Old Curiosity Shop, New Plymouth, Taranaki. Tuhinga, 16, 93-126. Dell RK (1965) Dominion Museum 1865-1965. Dominion Museum, Wellington. Dell RK (2010) 'Hamilton, Augustus - Biography', from the Dictionary of New Zealand Biography. Te Ara - the Encyclopedia of New Zealand. http://www.TeAra.govt.nz/en/biographies/2h8/1. Hartnup, K., et al. (2011) Ancient DNA recovers the origins of Māori feather cloaks. Molecular Biology and Evolution 28, 2741-2750. Henare AJM (2005) Museums, Anthropology and Imperial Exchange. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Hooper-Greenhill E (2000) Museums and the interpretation of visual culture. Routledge, London. Hornibrook NDB (2010) 'Thomson, James Allan - Biography', from the Dictionary of New Zealand Biography. Te Ara - the Encyclopedia of New Zealand. http://www.TeAra.govt.nz/en/biographies/3t33/1. McCarthy C (2004) From curio to taonga: A genealogy of display at New Zealand’s National Museum 1965-2001. PhD thesis, Victoria University of Wellington, NZ. McLean G (2000) Where sheep may not safely graze. A brief history of New Zealand’s heritage movement 1890-2000. In: Common ground? Heritage and public places in New Zealand. (Trapeznik A, ed), pp. 25-44, Otago University Press, Dunedin. 11 Nathan S, Varham M eds (2008) The amazing world of James Hector. Awa Press, Wellington. Pool, D.I. (1991) Te iwi Maori: A New Zealand population, past, present & projected. Auckland University Press, Auckland. Savage P (2010) ‘Mair, Gilbert – Biography’, from the Dictionary of New Zealand Biography. Te Ara - the Encyclopedia of New Zealand. http://www.TeAra.govt.nz/en/biographies/1m4/1. Sissons J (2010) ‘Best, Elsdon – Biography’, from the Dictionary of New Zealand Biography. Te Ara - the Encyclopedia of New Zealand. http://www.TeAra.govt.nz/en/biographies/2b20/1. Starecka DC,Neich R, Pendergrast M (2010) Taonga Māori in the British Museum Te Papa Press, Wellington. Tamarapa A (2011) The cloaks of Te Papa. In: Whatu Kakahu Maori Cloaks, pp. 95-175.Te Papa Press, Wellington. Townsend LM (2008) Seen But Not Heard? Collecting the History of New Zealand Childhood. MA thesis, Victoria University of Wellington, NZ. Traue JE (2010) 'Turnbull, Alexander Horsburgh - Biography', from the Dictionary of New Zealand Biography. Te Ara - the Encyclopedia of New Zealand. http://www.TeAra.govt.nz/en/biographies/2t53/1. Tennyson AJD, Martinson P (2007) Extinct birds of New Zealand. Te Papa Press, Wellington. Waitangi Tribunal (2011) Ko Aotearoa tēnei: A report into claims concerning law and policy affecting Māori culture and identity. Te taumata tuatahi - Vol 1: Wai 262 Waitangi Tribunal Report 2011. Legislation Direct. 12 Ward A (2010) 'McLean, Donald - Biography', from the Dictionary of New Zealand Biography. Te Ara - the Encyclopedia of New Zealand. http://www.TeAra.govt.nz/en/biographies/1m38/1 Watt RJ (1990) The fake Maori artefacts of James Edward Little and James Frank Robieson. Victoria University of Wellington, NZ. 13 Table 1 Online supplement. Kahukiwi accession numbers used in this research (based on accession numbers from previous molecular kiwi data (Hartnup et al. 2011)), along with accompanying records from the museums (including provenance where known). Details provided by T. Cracknell, Kaitiaki Taonga Māori, Hawke’s Bay Museum and Art Gallery; A. Holloway, Collection Manager, Horniman Museum; D. Pike, Collection Manager, Waikato Museum; and P. Nugent-Lyne, Collection Manager, Wanganui Regional Museum. Details of the British Museum kahukiwi were taken from Starecka et al. (2010). No information was received from Auckland Museum and Canterbury Museum. Kahukiwi in the Te Papa collection do not have any associated provenance data (R. Te Kanawa, pers. comm.). Museum Sample Museum identifier accession Haplotype Accompanying information 3, 4 & 8 Donated by C.H. Waterlow number British Kahukiwi/ 1913.6-12.2 Feather cloak British Kahukiwi/ Rotorua c.1890 1914.12-15.1 8 1933.10-17.1 None Donated by Mrs H.J Tozer Feather cloak British Kahukiwi/ Donated by Mrs A.E. Long. Collected by donor’s father in Feather cloak 1878 British Kahukiwi/ 1938.11-14.1 None Donated by Mrs E. CareyHill. Presented to donor’s Feather cloak husband c.1875 British Kahukiwi/ Q19820C.704 8 Unknown acquisition source Feather cloak British Kahukiwi Oc82726 Accession number not found ie that recorded by Hartnup et al. does not match any records British Kahukiwi/ Q19820C.736 8 & 10 Unknown acquisition source 14 Feather cloak British Kahukiwi/ Q19820C.737 8, 9 & 10 Feather cloak British Kahukiwi/ Unknown acquisition source. Wanganui c.1890 Q19950C.4 10 & 8 Unknown acquisition source 2554 8&9 Donated by Lady Florence Feather cloak Hawke’s Bay Hawke’s Bay Kahukiwi MacLean Kahukiwi/ 2567 8 Feather cloak Donated by Mrs G. Chapman (Havelock North). Number 2657 updated to 2567 on Hawkes’ Bay System Id. Hawke’s Bay Hawke’s Bay Kahukiwi 26077 8, 9 & 13 MacLean Kahukiwi/ 2624 8 & 11 Feather cloak Hawke’s Bay Donated by Lady Florence Kahukiwi /cloak Donated by Mrs M.L. Smith (Napier) 2633 5 Donated by Misses Grant (Napier) 15 Hawke’s Bay Hawke’s Bay Hawke’s Bay Hawke’s Bay Hawke’s Bay Hawke’s Bay Hawke’s Kahukiwi/ Kahukiwi/ Kahukiwi/ 2641 3&5 Donated by Mrs P.S. MacLean (Napier) 2642 8 & 11 Donated by Mrs E.W. Navin (Hawke’s Bay) Feather cloak Kahukiwi/ Donated by Lady Florence MacLean Feather cloak 2643 8, 9 & 10 Donated by J. Kelly Feather cloak Kahukiwi/ 264 8, 10 & Feather cloak 4 11(Hastings) Kahukiwi/ 264 Feather cloak 6 Kahukiwi 264 8 Kahukiwi 264 Donated by Mr A.R. Wilkie Donated by Lady Florence MacLean 3&8 7 Unknown acquisition source none 9 Bay Hawke’s Bay 7 Feather cloak Bay Hawke’s 2637 Donated by Mrs G. Chapman (Havelock North) Kahukiwi 2653 8 Donated by Lady Florence MacLean Hawke’s Bay Kahukiwi 2654 8 & 11 Donated by Lady Florence MacLean Hawke’s Bay Kahukiwi 4909 8&9 Donated by Lady Florence MacLean. Purchased from Masterton/North Island. Number 4009 updated to 4909 on Hawkes’ Bay System Id. Horniman 37.82 3&5 Gift by Mr A A Allen NN907 8 & 10 No additional information Public Horniman Public 16 Horniman 1974.11 5 Mrs C Curle Waikato L2004/17/7 3&5 Late 20th century in origin Waikato L2004/10/1 3 Late 20th century in origin Waikato L2004/6/1 3 Late 20th century in origin Waikato L2004/17/30 Did not Late 20th century in origin Public amplify Wanganui Kahukiwi 1977.1.1 5&7 Regional Wanganui Huna Kahu huruhuru 1970.4 5&3 Regional Wanganui Donated by Mrs Jury Te kiwi and weka feather cloak. Donated by Mr Pargeter Kahukiwi 1953.26 8 Regional kiwi and mixed feathers. Donated by Mrs Gwen Campbell Wanganui W_SHENTO Accession number not found Regional N_COLL ie that recorded by Hartnup et al. does not match any records Wanganui Kahukiwi/ 1980.70 2 Donated by Mrs Vivien Regional Korowai Boyd. Lilian May Day whakahekeheke (1883-1949) was given/purchased cloak by/from Guide Rangi after the Duke and Duchess of Windsor visited in the 1920s. Wanganui Kahukiwi 1957.146 5 Regional Wanganui Donated by Mrs Tape Tahana Kahukiwi 1992.29.1 3, 5 & 8 Donated by Mrs Ina Handley Kahukiwi 2001.46.1 8&9 Donated by Mrs Koria Regional Wanganui Regional Wanganui Davidson W1802.700 Accession number not found 17 Regional ie that recorded by Hartnup et al. does not match any records Wanganui Kahukiwi 2002.110 3, 5, 8 & 13 Regional Donated by Mrs Carolyn Cook. Purchased in Wanganui between 18891914 by Robert MacKenzie Gatenby Wanganui Kahukiwi / Regional Kahu huruhuru 1948.64.3 8 & 10 kiwi, kakapo, tui, kereru feathers. Donated by Mr A R Harris Wanganui Kahukiwi 1802.29 8 Unknown acquisition source Kahukiwi 1968.100.2 8, 9 & 10 Donated by Mrs Patohe Regional Wanganui Regional Stephens. Made by Tarahira Kereti I. Wanganui Kahukiwi 1802.24 5 Unknown acquisition source Regional Wanganui W1802.21 Accession number not found Regional ie that recorded by Hartnup et al. does not match any records Wanganui W_R_STEAD Accession number not found Regional MAN ie that recorded by Hartnup et al. does not match any records Wanganui Kahukiwi 1936.33.1 9, 10 & 11 Regional Wanganui Purchased from Te Mutu 1936 Kahukiwi 1802.25 3, 6 & 7 Unknown acquisition source Kahukiwi 1977.4 5, 8 & 10 Donated by Mr & Mrs Regional Wanganui Regional Gerald Caccia-Birch Presented to W.J. Birch of 18 Oruamatua and later Erewhon Station, Inland Patea by a Maori Chief between 1867-1900 Wanganui Kahukiwi/ 1802.26 5 kereru, kaka, kiwi feathers. Regional Kahu huruhuru Wanganui Kahukiwi 1953.22 8 & 10 Donated by Mrs H Cowper Kahukiwi 1959.125.1 3&5 Donated by Mr Garry Craig Kahukiwi 1957.14 None Donated by Misses M & R Donated by Mrs JW Garner Regional Wanganui Regional Wanganui Regional Beckett