KENNESAW STATE UNIVERSITY GRADUATE COURSE PROPOSAL OR REVISION, Cover Sheet (10/02/2002) Course Number/Program Name SW 8702 / Social Work Department Social Work and Human Services Degree Title (if applicable) Master of Social Work Proposed Effective Date August, 2012 Check one or more of the following and complete the appropriate sections: New Course Proposal Course Title Change Course Number Change Course Credit Change XXCourse Prerequisite Change XX Course Description Change Sections to be Completed II, III, IV, V, VII I, II, III I, II, III I, II, III I, II, III I, II, III Notes: If proposed changes to an existing course are substantial (credit hours, title, and description), a new course with a new number should be proposed. A new Course Proposal (Sections II, III, IV, V, VII) is required for each new course proposed as part of a new program. Current catalog information (Section I) is required for each existing course incorporated into the program. Minor changes to a course can use the simplified E-Z Course Change Form. Submitted by: _____ Faculty Member Approved Date Not Approved Department Curriculum Committee Date Approved Approved Approved Approved Approved Approved Not Approved Department Chair Date College Curriculum Committee Date College Dean Date GPCC Chair Date Dean, Graduate College Date Not Approved Not Approved Not Approved Not Approved Not Approved Vice President for Academic Affairs Date Approved Not Approved President Date KENNESAW STATE UNIVERSITY GRADUATE COURSE/CONCENTRATION/PROGRAM CHANGE I. Current Information (Fill in for changes) Page Number in Current Catalog ___ Course Prefix and Number SW 8702 ___ Course Title Advanced Clinical Practice I: Working With Individuals ___ Class Hours 3 ____Laboratory Hours_____0__Credit Hours____3____ Prerequisites Admission to the MSW Program Description (or Current Degree Requirements) ___ This advanced practice course will build upon basic skills covered in the foundational year practice sequence. It is designed to increase knowledge and understanding essential for effective therapeutic interventions in psychological and behavioral disorders. This course builds upon the foundation year courses by expanding the conceptual dynamics of the ecological perspective related to individuals. Topics will include advanced clinical interventions with individuals using multiple theoretical orientations and models. Formulation of intervention strategies will employ multiple research-based techniques. Assessment of intervention effectiveness is central to this course. II. Proposed Information (Fill in for changes and new courses) Course Prefix and Number ___________________________________ Course Title _________________ ___________ Class Hours ____Laboratory Hours_______CreditHours________ Prerequisites All MSW Foundation Level Courses Description (or Proposed Degree Requirements) This Advanced Clinical Practice I: Working with Individuals course builds upon basic skills covered in the first year foundation practice, human behavior and the social environment, policy, research courses and field experiences. The course will assist students with specializations in Child and Family Services, Mental Health and the subspecialty, Substance Abuse, in their assessment and intervention with individuals III. Justification Course Updated to be in compliance with the accreditation standards. IV. Additional Information (for New Courses only) Instructor: Text: Prerequisites: Objectives: Instructional Method Method of Evaluation - V. Resources and Funding Required (New Courses only) Resource Amount Faculty Other Personnel Equipment Supplies Travel New Books New Journals Other (Specify) TOTAL Funding Required Beyond Normal Departmental Growth VI. COURSE MASTER FORM This form will be completed by the requesting department and will be sent to the Office of the Registrar once the course has been approved by the Office of the President. The form is required for all new courses. DISCIPLINE COURSE NUMBER COURSE TITLE FOR LABEL (Note: Limit 30 spaces) CLASS-LAB-CREDIT HOURS Approval, Effective Term Grades Allowed (Regular or S/U) If course used to satisfy CPC, what areas? Learning Support Programs courses which are required as prerequisites APPROVED: ______________________________________________ __ Vice President for Academic Affairs or Designee __ Current Syllabus MASTER OF SOCIAL WORK PROGRAM SW 8702: Advanced Clinical Practice I: Working with Individuals Professor: Dorcas D. Bowles Meeting Time: TBA Semester Credits: 3 hrs. Email Address: dbowles3@kennesaw.edu or dorcasbowles@bellsouth.net Phone Number: 678-797-2453 Office: Room 3323 Prillaman Hall Office Hours: Mondays: 10:00am – 12 Noon and 1:00pm – 3:00pm Tuesdays 9:00am-1:00pm or by appointment COURSE DESCRIPTION This advanced practice course will build upon basic skills covered in the foundational year practice sequence. It is designed to increase knowledge and understanding essential for effective therapeutic interventions in psychological and behavioral disorders. This course builds upon the foundation year courses by expanding the conceptual dynamics of the ecological perspective related to individuals. Topics will include advanced clinical interventions with individuals using multiple theoretical orientations and models. Formulation of intervention strategies will employ multiple research-based techniques. Assessment of intervention effectiveness is central to this course. COURSE OVERVIEW Social Work 8702: Advanced Clinical Practice I: Working with Individuals will begin with a discussion of the meaning of theory and the history of clinical social work. The course will then cover the major clinical practice theories that social workers commonly use in their assessment, planning, and intervention with individuals in either of the two specializations- Children and Family Services or Mental Health and the subspecialty, Substance Abuse. The practice theories covered include: psychodynamic theories, including object relations and ego psychology; behavioral; cognitive; interpersonal; structural family; narrative; time limited dynamic; and motivational. Additionally, there will be a discussion of personality disorders, also known as character disorders, with a special emphasis on borderline and narcissistic personalities. Spirituality and social justice issues, as defined by each of these theories, will be infused as the various theories are discussed. The course is designed to increase knowledge and understanding essential for effective therapeutic interventions in psychological and behavioral disorders. Other topics will include: ethics and values, the importance of the therapeutic relationship, diversity and cultural factors, and the issues involved in terminating with clients. Formulation of intervention strategies will employ multiple research techniques based on the theories addressed. Assessment of intervention effectiveness is central to this course. Prerequisites: All first year foundation courses including first year field internship. Required Textbooks Walsh, J. (2006). Theories for Direct Social Work Practice. Belmont, CA: Brooks/Cole. Berzoff, J., Flanagan, Laura M., and Hertz, P. (2008). Inside Out and Outside In (2nd Ed. New York: Jason Aronson. Handouts: Handouts and additional readings will be distributed throughout the term and/or placed on reserve in the library. Students who are absent from a particular class are responsible for obtaining the handouts and additional readings from the instructor. COURSE RATIONALE RELATIVE TO THE MISSION OF THE MSW PROGRAM The Master of Social Work Program at Kennesaw State University was established to address increasing problems in the following specialization areas: Children and Family Services and Mental Health Services including a subspecialty in Substance Abuse. The Department is committed to making a positive difference in the community in these areas. SW 8702 is related to and consistent with the mission of the Masters of Social Work. Course Objectives Upon completion of the course, the student in specializations Children and Family Services, Mental Health Services and the subspecialty Substance Abuse will be able to: SW 8702: Advanced Clinical Practice I: Working with Individuals Knowledge Objectives: Upon Completion of this course students will: 1. Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of various theories and models utilized in the clinical treatment of individuals and how to differentially apply them to diverse populations; EP 2.1.3 2. Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of the importance of diversity in one’s work with clients; EP 2.1.4 3. Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of how oppression and discrimination impact clients; EP 2.1.5 4. Demonstrate knowledge of culturally responsive relationships; EP 2.1.10a Engagement 5. Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of the bio-psychosocial-spiritual factors that influence clinical interventions; EP 2.1.10b Assessment 6. Demonstrate a theoretically informed knowledge base to ensure effective practice interventions with individuals; EP 2.1.10c Intervention 7. Demonstrate knowledge that will allow for the evaluation of one’s work with clients. EP 2.1.10d Skills Objectives 1. Demonstrate solid professional identity as a social worker; EP 2.1.1 2. Demonstrate ability to apply ethical decision making skills to specific issues as they relate to clients served while recognizing and managing one’s personal biases; EP 2.1.2 3. Demonstrate ability to assess the strengths and weaknesses of a range of theories and differentially apply them to diverse client situations; EP 2.1.3 4. Demonstrate ability to communicate professional judgments and collaborate with professionals from various disciplines in coordinating treatment interventions in one’s work with clients from diverse backgrounds; EP 2.1.3 5. Demonstrate ability to differentially apply theories of human behavior and the social environment to guide one’s clinical assessments, interventions and terminations with clients; EP 2.1.7 6. Demonstrate ability to engage, assess, intervene, and evaluate individuals from diverse backgrounds based on an understanding of their strengths and resources; EP 2.1.10 a-d Values Objectives 1. Appreciate and understand one’s personal and professional values, ethical principles, and legal mandates pertinent to one’s clinical practice with individuals; EP 2.1.2 2. Engage in self-reflection in the interest of clients served from diverse backgrounds; EP 2.1.3 3. Recognize client strengths, coping strategies, vulnerabilities and spirituality in making assessments and interventions EP 2.1.10 b, c Practice Behaviors that correspond with the course objectives and the ten advanced competencies 1. Readily identify as a social work professional EP 2.1.1 2. Demonstrate professional use of self with client/s; EP 2.1.1 3. Apply ethical decision-making skills to issues specific to clinical social work EP 2.1.2 4. Engage in reflective practice EP 2.1.3 5. Identify and articulate clients’ strengths and vulnerabilities EP 2.1.3 6. Research and apply knowledge of diverse populations to enhance client well-being EP 2.1.4 7. Use knowledge of the effects of oppression, discrimination, and historical trauma on client and client systems to guide treatment planning and intervention EP 2.1.5 8. Synthesize and differentially apply theories of human behavior and social environment to guide clinical practice EP 2.1.7 9. Assess the quality of clients’ interactions within their social contexts EP 2.1.9 10. Develop a culturally responsive therapeutic relationship EP 2.1.10a Engagement 11. Use multi-dimensional bio-psychosocial spiritual assessment tools EP 2.1.10b Assessment 12. Collaborate with other professionals to coordinate treatment interventions EP 2.1.10c 13. Use clinical evaluation of the process and/or outcomes to develop best practice interventions for a range of bio-psychosocial spiritual conditions EP 2.1.10d COURSE METHOD Didactic presentations/discussions, analysis of videotapes, case discussions, and role playing, will be used throughout the semester. Students are expected to have read assignments and cases prior to a given class and should be prepared to participate in classroom discussions and role plays. Students will not be able to participate in experiential exercises and class discussions unless they are present in class. Therefore, class attendance and participation are imperative. COURSE EXPECTATIONS Attendance Policy: Students are expected to attend each and every class and to arrive on time,. Roll will be taken regularly. Students are allowed to miss two classes without penalty. Three (3) points will be deducted from the final score if one misses 3-5 classes and 5 points will be deducted if one misses 6 or more classes. Students do not need to notify the professor regarding the reason for their absence(s). Be aware that tardiness will also affect your final grade Phones/Pagers: . Phones and pagers disrupt the class. Phones and pagers must be turned off during class. Make-up Policy: Make-up exams or extension dates on papers, as a rule, will not be permitted. Only in extraordinary circumstances may this be considered ((hospitalizations, death of a family member, etc.). The professor reserves the right to determine the format of any make-up exam or extension dates on papers. Incomplete Grades: The grade of “I” will be given only under emergency situations that prohibit a student from completing specific assignments or class projects. The student must contact the instructor and receive approval in writing that an assignment cannot be completed by the designated date so that the grade of “I” can be given for incomplete work. A designated time will be given by the professor for when the work must be completed by the student. If the deadline is not met, the student will receive a grade based upon work completed for the course excluding a grade for the specific assignment. Assignments Policy: All papers must be completed using APA 6th edition (see www.apastyle.org). That includes, but is not limited to, using double-spacing, as well as standard fonts (Times New Roman 12) and margins (1 inch on all sides). Page number requirements do not include the cover page, reference pages or appendices. While references can be used from a number of sources, references counted as “required” include only peer reviewed journal articles or book chapters published from a scholarly press (Columbia University Press, Jason Aronson Press, Allyn Bacon , etc. ). Other references may be used, however they do not count as a required references. Late assignments will be penalized as follows: 2 days late – 5 points ; 3-4 days late 10 points; 5 – 7 days late 15 points. Papers will not be accepted after 7 days. Communication with Students: All communication with students will be through KSU e-mail address so that you should check your e-mail regularly. ACADEMIC INTEGRITY STATEMENT http://catalog.kennesaw.edu/content.php?catoid=11&navoid=489&returnto=search #stud_code_cond Criteria for Student Evaluation Progress will be evaluated utilizing the following criteria: Class attendance and participation Three (3) points will be deducted from the final score if one misses 3-5 classes and 5 points will be deducted if one misses 6 or more classes. Assignment Assignment 1: Assignment 2: Assignment 3: Assignment 4: Total = 100% Topic Ethical Dilemma Antwone Fisher Psycho. Application Case of Susan CBT, Psycho-Dynamic, or Interpersonal Application Case of Alice Due 9/6/2011 9/27/2011 10/18/2011 11/22/2011 Points 100 points 100 points 100 points 100 points Course grades will be assigned as follows: Percentages for Final Grade 92 – 100% A 91 - 80% B 79 - 70% C 69 and Below F Course Outline and Readings Weekly Topics and Readings: 1. Week 1: August 23, 2011 Setting the Stage: Definition & History of Clinical Social Work; Practice Theory What is Theory? The Relationship between Theory and Intervention The value of theory in Clinical Practice The Curative Factors in all Practice Theories Strengths Oriented Clinical Practice; Spirituality Evidence-based Practice Ecological Systems Theory (ecosystems) Becoming a Therapist DVD: Becoming a Therapist: Inside the Learning Curve from Psychotherapy. Net Required Reading: *Walsh, J. Chapter 2, pp. 17 – 31. (Strengths Oriented Clinical Practice, pp 19-21; Incorporating Spirituality into Direct Practice – pp. 29-30). *Cowger, Charles D. and Snively, Carol A., “Assessing Client Strengths” (On Reserve in Library) *Borden, W. (2009). Evidence-Based Practice, Science and Social Work: An Overview. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 1115-1120. Oxford Press. (On reserve in Library.) *Borden, W. (2009). The Life Model/Ecological Perspective. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 231 – 235.. Oxford Press. (On reserve in Library) Rothery, Michael ( ) “Ecological Systems Theory. (On Reserve in Library) Optional Reading: • Goldstein, H. (1990). The knowledge base of social work practice: Theory, wisdom, analogue, or art? Families in Society, 71, 32-43. • Saleebey, D. (2000). Power in the people: Strengths and hope. Advances in Social Work, 1(2), 127-136. 2. Week 2: August 30, 2011 Ethics and Values in Clinical Social Work Clinical Vignettes of Ethical Issues Provided by Professor for Class Discussion. Assignment I: Ethical Dilemma Assignment Due Week 3: September 6, 2011 1. Describe an ethical dilemma you have experienced or know about from your social work experience (25 points). 2. What action did you take regarding the ethical dilemma? (25 points) 3. Identify and discuss the relevant ethical guidelines as described in the NASW Code of Ethics. (25 points) 4. Given the ethical guideline(s) discussed, did you take the appropriate action or would you, in hindsight, take a different action? (25 points) Required Reading: NASW Code of Ethics Reamer, F.G. (1998). The evolution of social work ethics. Social Work, 43, 488-500. ( In Library or can be obtained from University of Georgia SSW or Georgia State U. SSW) Borden, W. (2009). Ethical Issues in Social Work.. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 115 - 121. Oxford Press. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles 3. Week 3: September 6, 2011: View Movie: Antwone Fisher: Assignment 2 Due Week 6: September 27, 2011 Assignment 1 Due: Ethical Dilemma Class will complete the required readings and view the movie, Antwone Fisher. Assignment2: Antwone Fisher ( Due Week 6: September 27, 2011) Based on your readings and viewing of the movie, Antwone Fisher, address the following questions from the movie. Each question is worth 20 points for a total of 100 points. 1. What role did Davenport play in Antwone’s life other than his therapist? What was the quality of the relationship between Davenport and Antwone? What was Antwone’s contribution to treatment and what role did hope play? 2. What role do you think Davenport’s theoretical orientation plays in Antwone’s progress? What role did Antwone’s girlfriend Cheryl play in his treatment and his life? 3. What cultural/class issues are relevant to Antwone’s treatment/therapy? Is the relationship between Antwone and Dr. Davenport cross-cultural? If so, in what ways? How are cultural and or class differences addressed? 4. In what stage of change is Antwone at the start of treatment? When and to which stage does he shift? To what do you attribute that change? 5. Is Davenport an ethical psychiatrist? Why or why not? Required readings: Walsh, Chapters 1, pp 1-16. Tseng, W.S. & Streltzer, J. (2001). Culture & Psychotherapy. Chapter 17; pp. 265-278. Washington DC: American Psychiatric Press. *Berzoff, J., Flanagan, Laura M., and Hertz, P. (2008). Inside Out and Outside In (2nd Ed. New York: Jason Aronson. Chapter 14 by Lourdes Mattei, “Coloring Development: Race and Culture in Psychodynamic Theories”, pp. 245-271. Optional readings: Harper, K.V. & Lantz, J. (1996). Cross-cultural Practice. Chicago: Lyceum. (Chapter 1: Cross-cultural curative factors.) 4. Weeks 4 & 5: September 13 & 20, 2011 Week 4: September 13, 2011: Psychodynamic Theories I: Ego Psychology Ego Psychology and Ego Functions Common Mechanisms of Defense Evaluation of Defenses Week 5: September 20, 2011; The Autonomous Ego Functions Case: The Girl in the Window Specific Ego Intervention Strategies Ego Psychology and Principles for Terminating with Clients Ego Psychology and Social Justice Issues Ego Psychology and Spirituality Role Plays: The Post Traumatic Stress Survivor, In Walsh, pp. 53-55 Psychosocial Ego Development Theory of Erik Erikson; Role Play Using Ego Psychology Strategies. CASE: : The Post Traumatic Stress Survivor, pp. 53-55 taken from Direct Social Work Practice by Joseph Walsh. You are to read the entire case. The Role Play will be based on the 4th Paragraph of the Case found on page 53, which begins: “After their fourth session, Heidi’s depression and anxiety increased.” Four ego psychology strategies are listed below and there will be four (4) role plays with 8 students. For each Role Play, one student will be the SW and the second student the client. The Role Plays will demonstrate one of the Ego Psychology Strategies listed below. 1. With the information you know, do a beginning interview that demonstrates sustainment or establishing a relationship with Heidi. 2. Do an interview that demonstrates Exploration/Description/ Ventilation and Person Situation Reflection. 3. Do an interview that demonstrates Partializing (Structuring) and Education. 4. Do an interview that demonstrates Developmental Reflection Required readings: Walsh, Chapter 3 – Ego Psychology, pp. 32 - 61 Berzoff, “Inside Out, Outside In: An Introduction, pp. 1-15 and Chapter 4, “Ego Psychology”, pp. 63-97. Berzoff, Chapter 5, “Psychosocial Ego Development: The Theory of Erik Erikson, pp. 99 – 120. Optional readings: Malick, M.D. (1991). Re-assessing assessment in clinical social work practice. Smith College Studies in Social Work, 62, 3-17. 6. Week 6: September 27, 2011 Assignment 2 Due: Antwone Fisher Psychodynamic Theories II: Object Relations Theory Object Relations Theory Early Nurturing and Attachment Theory Two Object Relations Theorists: Donald Winnicott and Margaret Mahler Margaret Mahler’s Separation/Individuation Phases Assessment and Intervention Required readings: Walsh, Chapter 4 – “Psychodynamic Theories II: Object Relations Theory”, pp. 62 – 89. Berzoff, Chapter 6, “Object Relations Theory” by Laura Melano Flanagan, pp. 121160. Berzoff, Chapter 8, “Attachment Theory” by Robert Shilkret and Cynthia Shilkret, pp. 189-204. Bowles, Dorcas (1983). Ethnicity and Race: Critical Concepts in Social Work. Washington, D.C. NASW Press. “ Development of an Ethnic Sense of Self” using Object Relations Theory (On Reserve in Library) Optional reading: Borden, W. (2009). Object relations psychology. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 305-310. Oxford Press. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) 7. Week 7: October 4, 2011 Psychodynamic Object Relations Theory and Gender Object Relations and Social Justice Object Relations and Spirituality and Principles for Terminating with Clients Diversity and Cultural Factors: Issues faced by Majority Workers with Clients of Color and by Workers of Color working with Clients of Color (Class Discussion) Case Discussion - The Wild Child (Walsh, pp. 79 – 82) Required readings: Berzoff, Chapter 10, “Psychodynamic Theory and Gender”, pp. 229-244. Berzoff, Chapter 11, “Coloring Development: Race and Culture in Psychodynamic Theory” by Lourdes Mattei, pp. 245 – 270. Optional readings: Chapter 5 – Family Emotional Systems Theory Dalzell, Heidi J. (2001). Insight at any age: Psychodynamic treatment of older adults. Psychoanalysis & Psychotherapy Vol 18(2), 241-260. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) Messer, S.B. (2002). A psychodynamic perspective on resistance in psychotherapy: Vive la resistance! Journal of Clinical Psychology, 58(2), 157-163. 8. Week 8: October 11, 2011 Personality Disorders (also known as Character Disorders) with a Special Emphasis on Borderline and Narcissistic Personalities Meaning of Term Personality Disorder or Character Disorder Borderline Personality Disorders Borderline Personality in Context of Person’s Object Relations, Ego Functions and Sense of Self Review of Object Relations Chart Case: Mary Ann F.: A Borderline Mother and her New Born Narcissistic Personality Disorder Narcissistic Personality in Context of Person’s Object Relations, Ego Functions and Sense of Self Required Reading: Berzoff, Flanagan and Hertz, Inside Out and Outside In, “Personality Disorders with a Special Emphasis on Borderline and Narcissistic Personalities. Chapter 14, pp. 311-354. Walsh, pp. The Nature of Problems and definition of “Splitting”, pp. 74-75. Borden, W. (2009). Interventions with Borderline Personality Disorder. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 305-310. Oxford Press, pp. 742 – 751. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) 9.Week 9: October 18, 2011 Assignment 3: Psychodynamic Application Paper Due: Case of Susan: Week 9, October 18, 2011 Narcissistic Personality Disorder Continued Behavioral Theory Intervention Techniques Using Behavioral Theory Social Justice Using Behavioral Theory Spirituality Using Behavioral Theory Required readings: Walsh, Chapter 6 – Behavioral Theory 10.Week 10: October 25, 2011 Behavioral Theory Continued to include Spirituality Social Justice DVD: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy with John Krumboltz Required readings: Borden, W. (2009). Cognitive-Behavioral Theory. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 305-310. Oxford Press. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) Borden, W. (2009). A Behavioral Approach to Social Work Treatment. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 288 - 294. Oxford Press. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) Rokke, P.D. & Rehm, L.P. (2001). Self-management techniques. In K. Dobson (Ed.), Handbook of Cognitive-Behavioral Therapies, pp. 242 - 247. New York: Guilford Press. 11. Week 11: November 1, 2011 Cognitive Theory Assessment Intervention Cognitive Theory and Social Justice Cognitive Theory and Spirituality DVD: Depression: A Cognitive Therapy Approach with Arthur Freeman, Ed.D Required readings: Walsh, Chapter 7 – Cognitive Theory Borden, W. (2009). Cognitive Restructuring Techniques. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 588-594. Oxford Press. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) Optional readings: Beck, J.S. (1995). Cognitive therapy: basics and beyond. New York: Guilford. (On Reserve) Interpersonal Therapy and Structural Family Theory 12. Week 12: November 8, 2011 Interpersonal Therapy and Structural Family Theory Interpersonal Therapy Interpersonal Therapy Elements of Psychodynamic Theory Elements of Cognitive and Behavioral Theory Assessment Intervention Interpersonal Therapy and Social Justice Interpersonal Therapy and Spirituality Case: The Rose from Spanish Harlem – Class Discussion (Walsh, pp. 187 -192 Structural Family Theory Major Concepts and Other Concepts The Nature of Problems and Change Assessment Interventions Ending Structural Family Therapy Structural Family Theory and Social Justice Structural Family Theory and Spirituality DVD: Structural Family Therapy with Harry Aponte, LCSW Required Readings: Walsh, Chapter 8 – “Interpersonal Therapy”, pp. 177 -198. Walsh, chapter 9 – “Structural Family Theory”, pp. 199 – 229. 13. Week 13: November 15, 2011 Structural Family Theory Contd. Narrative Therapy Narrative Theory Defined Major Concepts of Narrative Theory Assessment using Narrative Theory Interventions Using Narrative Theory Terminations and Narrative Therapy Narrative Therapy and Spirituality Narrative Therapy and Social Justice Case: Bag Lady – Walsh, pp. 289-291 and Case Examples from the Class Required readings: Walsh, Chapter 12 – Narrative Theory Optional reading: Goncalves, O.F., Machado, P. P. P. Korman, Y., Angus, L. (2002). Assessing psychopathology: A narrative approach. In: L.E. Beutler & M.L. Malik (Eds.), pp. 149-176. Rethinking the DSM: A psychological perspective. Washington DC: APA. *Borden, W. (2009). Narrative Therapy. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp.273-276. Oxford Press. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) 14. Week 14: November 22, 2011 Assignment 4 Due: Cognitive Behavioral, Psychodynamic or Interpersonal Theory- Practice Application Paper Due Case of Alice (Select one theoretical Perspective) 202 Narrative Therapy Cont’d (Fall Break – No Classes – November 23 – 27, 2011) 15. Week 15 Wednesday November 29, 2011 Time Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy Definition of Time Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy Five Essential Assumptions of TLDP Two Goals of TLDP Five Major Criteria used in Determining Clients’ ability to benefit from TLDP How the SW obtains data that will be used to show that there is a Maladaptive Pattern DVD: Time Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy by Psychotherapy Net. Dr. Hannah Levenson, Therapist. Psychotherapy. Net Questions for Class Discussion following a Review of the DVD 1. Did Mr. Johnson, the client, demonstrate the five essential assumptions of Time Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy? 2. Why does Dr. Levenson push Mr. Johnson so hard to talk about his feelings in spite of his insistence that he is unable to do so? 3. When Dr. Levenson interprets Mr. Johnson’s disclosure of his feelings of disappointment, do you agree with her linking the feelings with abandonment? 4. What was most helpful to you as a SW about the TLDP model? What perspectives did you find helpful and might use in your own work? 5. What do you think you would have done differently than Dr. Levenson, the therapist, in the video? Be specific in what different approaches and techniques you might have applied and state why you would use these different approaches. 203 Required readings: Levenson, Hanna, “Time Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy”, from The Art and Science of Brief Psychotherapies, pp. 157 -184. On Reserve in Library Walsh, Chapter 13 – Crisis Theory & Intervention Eaton, Y.M. & Roberts, A.R. (2004). Frontline crisis intervention. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 89-96. Oxford Press. (On Reserve) 16. Week 16: December 6, 2011: Final Class (Final Exam Week: December 6 12, 2011 Motivational Interviewing Definition of Motivational Interviewing Transtheoretical Stages of Change (TSOC) Model – A Major influence of Motivational Interviewing Clinical Perspective in Motivational Interviewing The Social Worker Client Relationship and Assessment in Motivational Interviewing Intervention in Motivational Interviewing Specific Techniques used by the Social Worker in Motivational Interviewing Developing a Change Plan Technique that Supports Self –Efficacy Motivational Interviewing and Spirituality Motivational Interviewing and Social Justice DVD: Client Mike by William Miller. developer of Motivational Interviewing, Psychotherapy Net Video Collection – Enhance Your Training Program Termination with Clients Professor’s Closing Comments Required readings: Walsh, Chapters 12 – Motivational Interviewing, pp. 253-272 Walsh, J. (2003). Endings in Clinical Practice. Chapters 2 & 3; pp. 22-56. Chicago: Lyceum Books. (Available on WebCT) 204 O’Leary Tevyaw, T. & Monti, P.M. (2004). Motivational enhancement and other brief interventions for adolescent substance abuse. Addiction, 99, 63-75, Supplement 2. Berzoff, Chapter 18, pp. 443-446. Optional reading: Elks, M.A., & Kirkhart, K.E. (1993). Evaluating effectiveness from the practitioner perspective. Social Work, 38(5), 554-563. Mercier, C., Landry, M., Corbiere, M. & Pereault, M. (2004). Measuring clients’ perception as outcome measurement. In Roberts & Yaeger (Eds.), EvidenceBased Practice Manual, pp. 904-909. Oxford Press. PLEASE NOTE: You will be doing one assignment on an ethical issue, one assignment based on the film, Antwone Fisher, and 2 application of practice papers. Each paper should be between 10-15 pages long, double-spaced. If the papers can be completed in fewer than 15 pages that is fine. If the paper is a page or two longer than 15 pages that is also fine. Remember: More does not mean better. They are due at the beginning of each class as follows: 205 Case of Susan Family Service Agency Case Study: Susan Identifying Information Susan is a 40 year old Caucasian woman. She identifies herself as lesbian; has never been married and has no children of her own. She has been unemployed for roughly 6 years, although she did at one time have a “high paying job” of about $45,000 a year as a locksmith. In addition to her salary, Susan often received good tips for her work as a locksmith. Susan currently collects Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) as a result of severe back problems she has had since childhood, based in part on beatings she received at the hands of her Father and beatings from her lesbian lover, Tina and Tina’s boyfriends. Susan was in a 12 year lesbian relationship with Tina who had two daughters, J and T. The two daughters were by two of Tina’s former boyfriends. Susan does not attend church regularly, but when she does, she attends a Unitarian Church. Description of Client Susan presents as a very thin woman who looks older than her 40 years. Her face and neck are scarred with slashes and discolorations and her cheeks are drawn in from a recent drastic loss in weight. She walks slowly and with a cane. She has eight teeth remaining and reports intense pain in her face because these teeth are decaying. Susan’s teeth were basically knocked out during fights with Tina and Tina’s boyfriends. She is in need of glasses and her eyes squint. She often uses her hands to cover her mouth as a way of not letting others see that most of her teeth are missing. Susan speaks in a slow pace, with very little emotional inflection and often stutters when discussing painful memories experienced from her childhood in relationship to physical abuse by her father, sexual abuse by her siblings, and adult life with her lover, Tina, and Tina’s boyfriends who also severely physically abused her. Susan often uses humor to describe some of her more painful memories. She graduated high school, but reports she can read only at about a 6th grade level. She loves working with her hands and took courses that led her to becoming a locksmith which she was good at until she was forced to give up being a locksmith because of severe back injuries. At the beginning of TX, Susan’s affect was somewhat labile, changing from angry to defensive, to sad, hopeless, and somewhat apologetic. During the initial interviews, Susan described her recent loss of a 12 year relationship with Tina, 206 a female lesbian partner, and her two female children, J and T, that Susan and Tina, raised together. Early meetings with the SW focused on Tina’s leaving/abandoning Susan and taking the two girls, J and T, that Susan had come to love and become attached to, with her. Susan felt she was a parent to the two girls and that she could see sadness in the faces of the two girls when Tina left with them. Susan experienced feeling sad, depressed and “out of sorts” when Tina took the two girls, J and T and left. In later meetings with the SW, Susan would become unable to think of anything else except her memories of childhood physical and sexual abuse by her father, two brothers and older sister. Susan lives in a private single room of a large boarding house that she rents. There are 4 other female residents in the boarding house where the 4 tenants share a bathroom and a kitchen. Susan has had this living arrangement since the breakup with her girlfriend, Tina. Near the end of TX, Tina moved into a one room apartment where she currently resides. Referral Susan was a “walk-in” client to the Family Service Agency which was about two blocks from the boarding house where she lived. One of the other female boarders had indicated that she had previously received help from the agency, and Susan decided to seek help on her own. Susan told the intake SW that she would “really appreciate someone to talk to because things are falling apart for me, and I cannot figure things out.” The Intake SW did a brief intake interview and Susan was assigned to a 2nd year SW student from a graduate school of social work. Meetings were planned for once per week with the MSW intern. Family History Susan is the youngest of five children: two older brothers and two older sisters. Susan was sexually molested for years by her two older brothers and by the older sister. Susan had a fairly good relationship with the sister who was 2 years her senior and next to her in age. Susan remembered that the sexual abuse happened to her between the ages of 8 and 13. Susan stated that the two older brothers often molested her individually and together as a team, and she does not feel that the brothers knew that the oldest sister was also sexually molesting her. The oldest sister was later hospitalized for psychiatric reasons, and later developed MS. In addition to being molested by her siblings, Susan stated that a total of 11other men had sexually abused her, some family members and others neighbors and friends of the family. Susan’s father was an alcoholic and she reported being beaten by her father as well as witnessing the Father severely physically abuse her mother. He (her father) always beat the Mo. in the kitchen. The father gave the Mo. a skull fracture in 207 the back of her head and Susan is certain that this blow led to the aneurism that subsequently killed the Mo. Susan was age 13 when her Mo. died and has been on her own pretty much since then. Treatment Sessions Susan was in a lesbian relationship for 12 years with a woman, Tina, ten years her senior. Susan was age 28, and Tina age 38, when the lesbian relationship began. Tina had two female children, J and T, by two different men, and the two children also lived in the household. Susan experienced physical and emotional abuse in the relationship with Tina. When Susan first talked about Tina, she alternated between seeing her as evil and as a “good woman with a good heart.” Although Tina had left Susan 9 months earlier when TX began, Susan felt responsible for the failed relationship. Susan could not have children and came to develop positive feelings toward the two female children, J and T, who were Tina’s children by different men prior to Susan’s and Tina’s relationship. Also, when Susan met Tina, Susan was working and making a fairly good salary, of approximately $45,000 per year, as a locksmith. Tina was unemployed and was basically being taken care of sporadically by the children’s fathers and other men with whom she had relationships. Susan supported Tina and her two children and became very emotionally attached to the two girls. As far as Susan knows, Tina was in relationships with males prior to their becoming lovers, and she is Tina’s first lesbian relationship. Tina was very physically abusive to Susan during the 12 year relationship, and Susan initially blamed herself for Tina’s abuse of her. Susan stated: “It’s my fault for bringing a straight woman out as a lesbian. Tina beat me and cheated on me and I let her. It’s my fault. I came to love Tina and her two daughters and now I have no-one. Tina is the only person who loved me other than my Mo., but my Mo. could not show her love to me, because she was physically abused by my Fa. and was depressed all the time.” Tina would punch Susan in the face, chest and stomach, and throw chairs, vases and other large objects at her, some of which hit Susan in the face and on various other parts of her body. Often the fights with Tina were about boyfriends that Tina brought to the house. Tina had boyfriends throughout the relationship with Susan and the boyfriends also physically abused Susan. More than one of Tina’s boyfriends physically beat and abused Susan. Tina would watch these fights and “egg the boyfriends on” as they physically beat and abused Susan. Susan felt the beatings from Tina and her boyfriends were her fault because she was bad and deserved the beatings. Oftentimes, the fights with Tina’s boyfriends started when Susan would yell at the boyfriends that Tina did not love them, but loved Susan. 208 One of Tina’s boyfriends had held a gun to Susan’s head and Susan had said: “Go ahead – put me out of my misery.” Another of Tina’s boyfriends, broke Susan’s cheek, knocked three of her front teeth out, and smashed her glasses. Susan stated that she has gotten hit in the head so much and tried to abuse herself so much with drugs that she wonders if her brains aren’t fried. Susan stated that sometimes it feels like there’s so much noise in her head, like a banging back and forth. She has headaches all the time. She knows that the headaches are related to the abuse she received as a child from her father and from fights with Tina and her boyfriends. During Susan’s and Tina’s relationship, Susan rented an apartment that consisted of two bedrooms; 2 baths with one bath connected to the large master bedroom and the other bath off of the 2nd bedroom; a large living room; dining room; kitchen with a large pantry; and a small Den which was used to watch TV. The apartment provided a place where Tina and her girls could live. The girls shared one bedroom and bath and Susan and Tina the master bedroom and bath. Susan was doing well health-wise, until she began to experience severe beatings at the hand of Tina and Tina’s boyfriends, which worsened a back problem she had from beatings she experienced at the hand of her father. Susan’s back problems worsened and resulted in her not being able to continue her work as a locksmith and having to receive Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI). Once Susan began receiving SSDI, she lost the apartment because it was too expensive; Tina and the girls left; and Susan was only able to afford a room in a boarding house where she currently lives. Tina would occasionally bring the two girls, J and T, to visit Susan, often accompanied by a new boyfriend. Tina was also able to get Susan to give her small sums of money for the girls which Susan could not refuse because she had become attached to the girls and wanted the best for them. Once Tina got the money from Susan, she would leave. If Susan asked if the girls could stay with her for a while longer, Tina would say No and snatch the kids and leave. Susan is sure the girls were confused as they would often turn to look at Susan as though they wanted to stay, but Tina would rush them out without Susan and the girls being able to say good-bye. Susan says that she felt overwhelmed, was not able to sleep, was more overwhelmed than she had ever been, and would be upset that if she did not do what Tina said, she would not be able to see the girls. Susan felt she had lost everything - her job, her health, the apartment, Tina, and the girls. Susan has no contact with members of her family who live in another state. Susan felt she had no one and could not live without Tina and the girls. Part of TX focused on helping Susan to see that she is separate from Tina and the girls and that she can have a life separate from them. During these sessions, Susan would cry incessantly because she felt her life was over without Tina and the girls. 209 Gradually, with the SW’s help, Susan began to see some of her strengths and that her relationship with Tina was “exploitative”; that Tina was “manipulative” and that she could live without Tina and the girls. It took several sessions for Susan to begin to internalize that she had strengths and to begin to “feel whole” and worthwhile as a person without Tina and the girls. During this time, as Susan was beginning to feel comfort with herself, she would occasionally express feeling empty without Tina and the girls in her life and she began to drink again. Susan stated that on one occasion, she drank a fifth of tequila to make the pain inside her go away. She does not want to drink because she has been through “drinking binges” before. In the past, Susan would drink heavily, especially after beatings from Tina and/or Tina’s boyfriends. The last time Susan drank tequila, following a beating by one of Tina’s boyfriends, she spent 3 days praying to the porcelain God she had in her apartment. Susan stated that she feels tired. So tired, she just wants to crawl in her shell. She wants to be alone; she’s tired; wants to go to her room and lay there. She thinks about her Mom; listens to the cars go by; does not think of anything; does not want to go out to get food or groceries. She only wants to walk around in her room by herself. Susan expressed that at these time, being alone allows “me to think about and process what we talk about during our sessions; this makes me feel stronger and allows me to think of my past and where I am in my life without Tina and the girls. I hold on to these thoughts and it gets me through these rough spots until I can speak with you again.” The SW commented that what Susan has just described represents growth on her part and that given her past, it takes time for healing to occur. Susan has done a lot of hard work to get to this place and the SW expressed that she is proud of the progress Tina has made. Tina was teary eyed and said: “I could not be at this place were it not for our time together. Thanks for all you have done to help me.” The SW explained to Tina that Tina had done the work and she should feel proud of what she has achieved. Tina thanked the SW for caring about and being there for her. “I would probably be dead if I did not have you”, Tina stated. The Family Service Agency used a psychiatrist for consultation services and the SW referred Susan to the psychiatrist for a psychiatric exam for her depression and “feelings of emptiness” and she was placed on meds for her depression. Susan stated the meds have helped her feel better and less depressed. As well, Tina had not visited Susan for several months and Susan was doing better; feeling stronger. Susan had been saving money and living frugally with the goal of moving to a small apartment. She was able to find a small apartment she could afford, was able to pay the required deposit, and was making plans to move. 210 Then, several weeks later on a Saturday, Tina brought Susan food but did not bring the girls. Susan had not seen Tina for several months and was feeling that she was getting herself together and ready to move on with her life. Susan and Tina ate some of the food Tina brought, and talked about things in general and the discussion went well. Susan told Tina that she had put a deposit on an apartment and planned to move soon. On the next day, Sunday, Tina brought the girls to see Susan. Tina knew from talking with Susan on Saturday, that Susan planned to move to an apartment. On that Sunday when Tina brought the girls to see Susan, Tina talked about the possibility of she and Susan getting back together and trying to make the relationship work. Susan was quite surprised and explained to the SW in her next session, that she did not trust Tina so she just took the information in without commenting. Tina still has her boyfriends and Susan feels that Tina wants another “free ride”, but Susan is not prepared to get involved with Tina again. Susan was finally able to see and realize that Tina had “used me so she and her two daughters could live rent free” in Susan’s apartment and have food and bills paid by Susan. The SW could see that Susan’s understanding and insight, based on their work together and the gains made in TX, were remarkable. Susan was finally able to see that her relationship with Tina was exploitative, abusive and unhealthy. Susan explained to the SW that based on the work she had done in TX with the SW, she is feeling better, feeling stronger and does not want to return to the place she was at earlier. Susan stated that she knows that Tina is not good for her and it has taken some time for her to work out her feelings regarding Tina and the abuse she experienced with her and the abuse she experienced at the hands of her father. She does not want to and does not deserve to get hurt again. Susan repeated what the SW had told her on several occasions: “As you said, I can be my own person and am worthy and deserving of a better life.” With the SW’s help, Susan was able to explain to Tina that it had taken her a long time to work through the abuse she had experienced with Tina and her boyfriends. Susan stated that she loved J and T and wanted the best for them, but felt it was in everyone’s best interest that she and Tina not get back together. Susan stated that she would miss the girls, J. and T., but needed to get on with her life and Tina and the girls needed to get on with their lives. Tina was angry and wanted to start a fight, but Susan held her ground and said she needed to move on and did not want to repeat the pain of the past. 211 Tina tried to get Susan to give her the address where she was moving, but Susan said she could not give her the address. They needed to say good bye. Tina tried to turn the cards and say that she did not want a relationship with Susan and never wanted to see Susan again. Also, she would make sure Susan never saw the girls. J and T., again. Susan attempted to give Tina a hug good bye and to tell the girls good bye and give them a hug, but Tina pulled away and took the girls’ hands and left without any goodbyes. Susan felt sad that things ended this way, but felt she had to protect herself and would not allow Tina to “manipulate” her further. (The word manipulate had been used by the SW to explain Tina’s relationship with Susan.) Susan moved to her new apartment. It is a small one bedroom apartment, and she has spent time fixing it up and is enjoying having time to herself and doing things she enjoys. She attended church last week and re-connected with a woman, Judy, she had known earlier when she attended church. She and the woman have had coffee together and gone to a few movies. These were things Susan once enjoyed but had not done when she was living with Tina. Susan feels good that she is doing things she enjoys. The woman is divorced and “straight” and Susan enjoys her company. Susan has stated that this is the first time she has ever had a “real friend” that she can talk and share her ideas with. Susan has explained to Judy that she is a lesbian and the woman has expressed that while that is not her lifestyle, she respects Susan and her lifestyle. Susan stated that Judy is okay with Susan being a lesbian and Judy being straight and respected Susan for being who she is and Susan is fine with Judy being straight and her own person. Judy has had several other church members to her house for special occasions and Susan has gone and has had a good time. Susan feels she wants an intimate female relationship, but feels that until she finds a “good, healthy” relationship that is not “exploitative and manipulative”, she is fine. The student SW left the agency to return to school and Susan was quite sad and depressed when she left. The student SW transferred Susan to another worker in the agency and Susan continued to see the other SW. The new SW explained that it was natural for Susan to feel sad at the loss of the student SW. The two of them had worked hard together and it was natural that Susan would miss her. Gradually, Susan’s sadness lessened as she got to know the new SW and felt comfortable talking with her. After several months, the new SW expressed to Susan that she felt Susan was at a place where she no longer needed to see the SW. Susan was hesitant at the idea initially but agreed to a plan where Susan would continue to be seen weekly for another month after which Susan would be scheduled to come every two weeks. Prior to the change to being seen once every two weeks, the SW and Susan talked about Susan’s feelings about the change and what Susan might feel and that they 212 would monitor Susan feelings to determine if the change in schedule was okay for Susan. This same process was followed for scheduled appointments on a once per month basis. Susan did fine with the changes and the SW introduced the idea that Susan was ready to be on her own with the understanding that Susan could call the agency should she have other issues she wanted to address. Susan accepted this final arrangement and acknowledged that the gradual reduction in visits had been good for her and had allowed her to prepare for being on her own. Susan expressed that she is indebted to the student SW and the current SW for “saving my life and helping me feel whole and complete”. Susan has been on her own now for some time. She has only called the new SW on one occasion when she was feeling sad and needed to process her feelings. The SW and Susan were able to talk on the phone and Susan felt this was adequate. Susan knows that the agency is there for her should she need to contact them. Susan has made no further calls to the agency. ASSIGNMENT 3: Due: Week 9: October 18, 2011 Psychodynamic Application of Theory: Case of Susan Application of Psychodynamic Theories (Object Relations and Ego Psychology) to Case of Susan. Answer each question. Be sure to number and state the question before each response so that I know the answer that corresponds with the question. Questions: 1. Based on the information given in the case-study, (a) what are Susan’s strengths? Where would you locate Susan developmentally and why? (b) provide the characteristics of the developmental stage with specific information from the case study that support your choice; and (c) describe treatment interventions used by the SW to support Susan in moving from the stage you have selected to a different/higher stage. (20 points) 2. The relationship between Susan, Tina, and Tina’s boyfriends was quite abusive. How do you explain Susan’s acceptance of the physical abuse from Tina and Tina’s boyfriends. (20 points) 3. Based on lectures and readings, (a) assess Susan’s ego functioning (b) What areas of ego functioning are working well? (c) What ego functions are not working well? (c) What ego defenses is Susan using? Give specific examples. (20 points) 213 4. You are assigned as Susan’s social worker: (a) are there additional interventions you would use? Why? Why not? (b) Would you refer Susan to any other professional(s)? Identify professionals; explain reason for referral(s (c) Explain how you would work with/coordinate with the other professionals? ); (If you would not refer Susan to any other professional(s), explain why. (20 points) 5. Explain the role of the student SW and give your assessment of the relationship she formed with Susan and your thoughts about her TX of Susan. Describe your thinking with regard to how the new SW handled the termination with Susan and whether the handling was clinically appropriate or clinically inappropriate. Explain your response. Be specific (20 points) Case Study: Alice Agency Setting: A Mental Health Agency Identifying Information: Alice is a 23 year old Caucasian, married female who is currently unemployed. She’s been married for six years to her first and only husband, Joe. Alice was referred by her primary care physician after no physical causes could be found for feelings of chronic depression, fatigue, anxiety, migraine headaches and stomach aches during the last three years. Approximately six months ago, Alice was fired from her job as a cashier at a drug store. Since that time, she states that she spends most of her time taking care of her pets: three dogs and two cats, and making crafts. Alice is soft-spoken and describes herself as shy, dependent, and easy to feel hurt and quick to feel guilty. In the past three weeks, she has been experiencing significant levels of sadness, depression, anxiety and low self-esteem. She denies any suicidal ideation. She states that she is very inhibited when it comes to talking about and dealing with emotionally charged and disturbing issues and avoids such topics as much as possible. Alice describes her husband as very supportive and hard-working. She states that there are no difficulties in their marriage and she is very satisfied being married to Joe. Alice reports that she and her husband have tried unsuccessfully since they have been married to have children. Alice reports that when she was four years old, her mother, grandmother, and grandfather all died in a car accident of which she was the only survivor. She claims that she has no memories of the accident itself or of her biological mother. Alice related the onset of her current symptoms to a time three years ago when she had taken a trip to Texas to visit some of her relatives on her mother’s side of the family. 214 At that time, she learned some of the details of the accident from her mother’s relatives. She stated that she had difficulty tolerating the return drive home, especially on two lane roads. Since then, she has had dreams of the accident and has been unable to drive a car herself. Alice also reported that an elderly friend of hers, Sam, who has been a father figure to her since she was a young girl, committed suicide about six months ago. Alice says that since that time the dreams of the accident, as well as dreams of Sam, have been more frequent. FAMILY HISTORY: Alice reported that her father was married once before his marriage to her mother and twice after her mother’s death. Alice has a half-sister from her father’s first marriage and two older siblings from his marriage to her mother. In addition, she has two step-siblings from her father’s last two marriages. Alice says she had a great deal of difficulty with her first step-mother when she was growing up. She described her first step-mother as alcoholic and physically abusive of one of her sisters. This step-mother also gave Alice a black eye once. Alice described her second stepmother as rejecting and not wanting to deal with Alice since this woman’s own children were already gone. Alice reported that at age 16, she began running away from home and staying out late at night and drinking and occasionally smoking marijuana with friends. She says that this lasted for about one year and that she was able to quit using alcohol and marijuana on her own. At age 17, Alice moved out of the house and lived first with an aunt, then with her best friend and family, and finally with her boyfriend (now her husband) and his family. Alice stated that her primary reason for seeking social work intervention is to try to remember and learn as much as she can about the accident that killed her mother and grandparents and remember and learn as much as she can about her mother as a person. She stated that her father had always discouraged her from talking about her deceased mother when she was growing up. Alice wants to stop feeling depressed and anxious and also start feeling better about herself. She believes that remembering and learning about her mother and the accident will help her do this. In addition, she would like to get to the point where she is able to work and drive a car again. Application of Cognitive Behavioral or Psychodynamic Theory: Case of Alice Due Week 14, November 22, 2011 215 You are the social worker assigned to work one-on-one with Alice, the young woman in the assigned case at the Mental Health Agency. You can select either the Cognitive Behavioral theoretical perspective, the Interpersonal theoretical Perspective or the Psychodynamic theoretical perspective as your frame of reference in working with Alice. Please state your choice of theories first and briefly justify your choice as it relates to the case. You are to choose only one theoretical perspective, even if in real practice, you would choose to use parts of both theories. Answer each question. Be sure to number and state the question before each response so that I know the answer that corresponds with the question. Questions: State your theoretical perspective. (0 points) Justify or state why you have chosen a particular theoretical perspective for your work with Alice. (0 points) 1. Provide an understanding of Alice’s issues that is congruent with your chosen theoretical perspective to include: (a.) a list of Alice’s strengths;(b) a description of the problem(s) as it would be explained by your practice theory; and (c) potential reasons for the problematic behavior(s) as explained by your theory. (20 points) 2. Based on the information you have provided to Question No. 1, provide: (1) a treatment plan including at a minimum two (2) treatment goals that are congruent with Alice’s strengths and the theory you selected; and (2) the approximate length of time you will need to achieve the goals selected and why. (20 points) 3. Describe at least two interventions you might use in this case based on the theory you selected and Alice’s strengths. Discuss how the interventions relate to the treatment goals and how they would be implemented. (15 points) 4. Would your conceptualization and/or intervention be different if Alice were described as a Mexican-American woman? Why or why not. If yes, describe the differences. (20 points) 5. Describe two ways in which you would evaluate Alice’s progress. What would you measure? How and when would you measure it? (15 points) 216 6. What do you anticipate would be Alice’s response to termination and how would you handle the termination including how and when you would inform Alice of the termination. (10 points) Glossary of Concepts Psychodynamic Theory: Object Relations Dorcas D. Bowles, Professor Consolidation of Individuality and Emotional Constancy The fourth sub-phase of separation individuation, which begins toward the end of the second year is open-ended. During this period, a degree of object constancy is achieved, and the separation of self and object representation is sufficiently established. Mother is clearly perceived as a separate person in the outside world, and at the same time has an existence in the internal representational world of the child. Emotional Refueling During the practicing and rapprochement sub-phases, the infant moves away from the mother, but when s/he becomes fatigued or depleted of energy, s/he seeks to reestablish bodily contact with her. This “refueling” perks the toddler up and restores his/her previous momentum to practice and explore. Mutual Cueing A circular process of interaction established very early between mother and infant by which they “empathically” read each other’s signs and signals and react to each other. For example, the mother learns the meanings of the baby’s different cries and movements: the baby learns to anticipate the mother’s ministrations: s/he also learns soon which cues the mother (unconsciously) picks up and which she does not. No mother perfectly responds to a baby’s cues, but serious mismatching of cues is an obstacle in the path of smooth development. Shadowing and Darting Away During the rapprochement sub-phase, the child, at times, follows his/her mother’s every move (“shadows” her); s/he cannot let the mother out of sight or out of his/her vicinity. At times, we observe the opposite behavior, the child darts away, and waits for and expects the mother to swoop him/her up in the mother’s arms and thus for brief moments undo the “separateness”. 217 Ambivalence Ambivalence can occur only when there is representation of a single, whole person. Separation/Individuation has to have occurred at least in its beginning stage. The person can tolerate mixed feelings occurring at the same time; can tolerate good and bad feelings being present in the same person. 218 Glossary of Concepts Psychodynamic Theory: Object Relations Dorcas D. Bowles, Professor Consolidation of Individuality and Emotional Constancy The fourth sub-phase of separation individuation, which begins toward the end of the second year is open-ended. During this period, a degree of object constancy is achieved, and the separation of self and object representation is sufficiently established. Mother is clearly perceived as a separate person in the outside world, and at the same time has an existence in the internal representational world of the child. Emotional Refueling During the practicing and rapprochement sub-phases, the infant moves away from the mother, but when s/he becomes fatigued or depleted of energy, s/he seeks to reestablish bodily contact with her. This “refueling” perks the toddler up and restores his/her previous momentum to practice and explore. Mutual Cueing A circular process of interaction established very early between mother and infant by which they “empathically” read each other’s signs and signals and react to each other. For example, the mother learns the meanings of the baby’s different cries and movements: the baby learns to anticipate the mother’s ministrations: s/he also learns soon which cues the mother (unconsciously) picks up and which she does not. No mother perfectly responds to a baby’s cues, but serious mismatching of cues is an obstacle in the path of smooth development. Shadowing and Darting Away During the rapprochement sub-phase, the child, at times, follows his/her mother’s every move (“shadows” her); s/he cannot let the mother out of sight or out of his/her vicinity. At times, we observe the opposite behavior, the child darts away, and waits for and expects the mother to swoop him/her up in the mother’s arms and thus for brief moments undo the “separateness”. Ambivalence Ambivalence can occur only when there is representation of a single, whole person. Separation/Individuation has to have occurred at least in its beginning stage. The person can tolerate mixed feelings occurring at the same time; can tolerate good and bad feelings being present in the same person. 219 Bibliography Andreas, C. 7 Andreas, S. (1990). Briefer than brief. Family Networker. March-April, 37-41. Applegate, J. (1995). The Facilitating Partnership: a Winnicottian Approach for Social Workers and Other Helping Professionals. New York: Aronson. Atkinson, B. (Sept./Oct 2004). Altered States: Why insight in itself is not enough for lasting change. Psychotherapy Networker. Atwood, J. & Ruiz, J. (1993). Social constructionist therapy with the elderly. Journal of Family Psychotherapy, 4(1), 1-33. Beck, J. S. (2011). Cognitive Behavior Therapy: Basics and Beyond. New York: Guilford Press. Beitman, B.D. (1987). The structure of individual psychotherapy. New York: Guilford Press. Berzoff, J., Flannagan, L., & Hertz, P. (2008). Inside Out and Outside In: Psychodynamic Clinical Theory and Practice in Contemporary Multicultural Contexts. Northvale, N.J.: Jason Aronson. Bowles, Dorcas. (1988). Chapter 7. Development of an Ethnic Sense of Self. In Jacobs, C. and Bowles, D. Ethnicity & Race: Criticval Concepts in Social Work. Washington, D. C. NASW Press. Braconnier, A. & Marcelli, 7/24/96. (1979). The Adolescent and His Parents: The Parental Crisis. Journal of Adolescence, 2, 325-336. Buie, D. H. (1981). Empathy: Its Nature and Limitations. Journal of the AmericanPsychoanalytic Association, 29, 281-308. Dallos, R. (2004). Narrative Therapy: Integrating ideas from narrative and attachment theory in Systemic therapy with eating disorders. Journal of Family Therapy. 26 (1), 40-66. Edwards, J., & Bess, J., (1998). Developing Effectiveness in the Therapeutic Use of Self. Clinical Social Work Journal, 26(1), 89-104. Cooper, M., & Lesser, J., (1997). How Race Affects the Helping Process: A Case of Cross Racial Therapy. Clinical Social Work Journal, 25(3), 323-334. 220 Corey, G. (2000). Case Approach to Counseling and Psychotherapy. Pacific Grove:Brooks/Cole. Dorfman, R. A. (1998). Paradigms of Clinical Social Work, Volume 2. New York: runner/Mazel. Durrant, M. & Kowalski, K. Enhancing views of competence (Ch. 5) and Selekman, M. D. Solution-oriented brief therapy with difficult adolescents (Ch. 6). In Friedman, S. (Ed.), The new language of change: Constructive collaboration in psychotherapy. New York: Guilford. Fllaskas, C. (1997). Engagement and the therapeutic relationship in systemic therapy. Journal of Family Therapy, 25(3), 189-195. Franklin, C. & Jordan, C. (1995). Clinical Assessment for Social Workers. Chicago: Lyceum. Frederickson, J. (1999). Psychodynamic Psychotherapy. Philadelphia: Brunner Mazel. Goldstein, E. G. (1995). Ego psychology and social work practice (Ch. 3,4, 7, 8). New York: Free Press. Harris, M., & Bergman, H. (1987). Case Management with the Chronically Mentally Ill. Clinical Perspective. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 57 (2), 296-301. Hartman, C., & Reynolds, D. (1987). Resistant clients: Confrontation, interpretation and alliance. Social Casework, 86(4), 205-213. Henry, W. & Strupp, H. (1994). The Therapeutic Alliance as Interpersonal Process. In The Working Alliance: theory, research, and practice. New York: John Wiley. Imber-Black, E. (1997). Developing Cultural Competence: contributions from recentfamily therapy. American Journal of Psychotherapy, 51 (4), 607-610. Jackson, L. C. (2000).The new multiculturalism and psychodynamic theory (ch. 1) & Shorter-Gooden, K. & Jackson, L. C. The interweaving of cultural and intrapsychic issues in the therapeutic relationship (Ch. 2). In L. C. Jackson & B. Greene Psychotherapy with African-American women: Innovations in psychodynamic perspectives and practice. New York: Guilford Jongsma & Peterson. (1995). The Psychotherapy Treatment Planner. New York: John Wiley and Sons. Kottler, J. A. (1993). Personal and professional lives (ch. 3). In On being a therapist. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. 221 LeCroy, C. (2000). Case Studies in Social Work Practice. Pacific Grove: Brooks/Cole. Lewis, J., Dana, R., & Blevins, G. (2000). Substance Abuse Counseling. Pacific Grove: Brooks/Cole. Mahler, M., Pine, F., and Bergman, A. (1975). The Psychological Birth of the Human Infant. New York. Basic books. McGoldrick, M., (2002). Using Genograms to Map Family Patterns. In The Social Workers’ Desk Reference. New York: Oxford University Press. Mishna, F. et al. (2002). Social work with clients contemplating suicide: Complexity and ambiguity in the clinical ethical and legal considerations. The Clinical Social Work Journal, 30 (3). Morrow, D. (2000). Coming Out to Families: Guidelines for Intervention with Gay and Lesbian Clients. Journal of Family Social Work, 5(2), 53-63 Norcross, J., & Goldfried, M. Eds. (2005). Handbook of Psychotherapy Integration (2ndEd.) New York: Oxford University Press. Proctor, K., & Davis, L. (1994). The Challenge of Racial Differences: Skills for Clinical Practice. Social Work 39, 314-323. Reid, T. (1999). A cultural perspective on resistance. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration, 9(1) 57-81. Roberts, A. & Greene, C. (2000). The Social Workers’ Desk Reference. New York:Oxford University Press. Sharf, R.S. (2000). Theories of psychotherapy and counseling. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth. Siegel, D. (1999). Chapter 1: Introduction: Mind, brain, and experience. In The Developing Mind: How relationships and the brain interact to shape who we are. Gilford Press. Singer, E. (1994). Key Concepts in Psychotherapy. Northvale: Jason Arson, Inc. Turner, F.J. (Ed.) (1996). Social Work Treatment. New York: The Free Press. Werner-Wilson, R. J. et al. (1999). Is therapeutic alliance influenced by a feminist approach to therapy. Contemporary family therapy, 21(4). Pp. 545-550. 222 Winnicott, D. W. (1975). Collected Papers: From Pediatrician to psychoanalyst. New York: Basic Books. Wolberg, L.R. (1995). The Technique of Psychotherapy. Northvale: Jason Aronson. Wolfe, J.L. & Fodor, I. G. (1996). The poverty of privilege: Therapy with women of the “upper” classes. Women and Therapy, 18, 73-89. Woods, M.E. & Hollis, F. (5th Ed.) (2000). Casework: A psychosocial Therapy. Boston: McGraw-Hill. Zimmerman, J. & Dickerson, V. (1996). If problems talked: Adventures in narrative therapy. New York: Guilford Press. 223 Revised Syllabus 224 MASTER OF SOCIAL WORK PROGRAM SW 8702: Advanced Clinical Practice I: Working With Individuals Professor: Dorcas D. Bowles Meeting Time: TBA Semester Credits: 3 hrs. Email Address: dbowles3@kennesaw.edu or dorcasbowles@bellsouth.net Phone Number: 678-797-2453 Office: Room 3323 Prillaman Hall Office Hours: Mondays: 10:00am – 12 Noon and 1:00pm – 3:00pm Tuesdays 9:00am-1:00pm or by appointment COURSE DESCRIPTION This Advanced Clinical Practice I: Working with Individuals course builds upon basic skills covered in the first year foundation practice, human behavior and the social environment, policy, research courses and field experiences. The course will assist students with specializations in Child and Family Services, Mental Health and the subspecialty, Substance Abuse, in their assessment and intervention with individuals. COURSE OVERVIEW Social Work 8702: Advanced Clinical Practice I: Working with Individuals will begin with a discussion of the meaning of theory and the history of clinical social work. The course will then cover the major clinical practice theories that social workers 225 commonly use in their assessment, planning, and intervention with individuals in either of the two specializations- Children and Family Services or Mental Health and the subspecialty, Substance Abuse. The practice theories covered include: psychodynamic theories, including object relations and ego psychology; behavioral; cognitive; interpersonal; structural family; narrative; time limited dynamic; and motivational. Additionally, there will be a discussion of personality disorders, also known as character disorders, with a special emphasis on borderline and narcissistic personalities. Spirituality and social justice issues, as defined by each of these theories, will be infused as the various theories are discussed. The course is designed to increase knowledge and understanding essential for effective therapeutic interventions in psychological and behavioral disorders. Other topics will include: ethics and values, the importance of the therapeutic relationship, diversity and cultural factors, and the issues involved in terminating with clients. Formulation of intervention strategies will employ multiple research techniques based on the theories addressed. Assessment of intervention effectiveness is central to this course. Prerequisites: All first year foundation courses including first year field internship. Required Textbooks Walsh, J. (2006). Theories for Direct Social Work Practice. Belmont, CA: Brooks/Cole. Berzoff, J., Flanagan, Laura M., and Hertz, P. (2008). Inside Out and Outside In (2nd Ed. New York: Jason Aronson. Handouts: Handouts and additional readings will be distributed throughout the term and/or placed on reserve in the library. Students who are absent from a particular class are responsible for obtaining the handouts and additional readings from the instructor. COURSE RATIONALE RELATIVE TO THE MISSION OF THE MSW PROGRAM The Master of Social Work Program at Kennesaw State University was established to address increasing problems in the following specialization areas: Children and Family Services and Mental Health Services including a subspecialty in Substance Abuse. The Department is committed to making a positive difference in the community in these areas. SW 8702 is related to and consistent with the mission of the Masters of Social Work. Course Objectives 226 Upon completion of the course, the student in specializations Children and Family Services, Mental Health Services and the subspecialty Substance Abuse will be able to: SW 8702: Advanced Clinical Practice I: Working with Individuals Knowledge Objectives: Upon Completion of this course students will: 1. Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of various theories and models utilized in the clinical treatment of individuals and how to differentially apply them to diverse populations; EP 2.1.3 2. Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of the importance of diversity in one’s work with clients; EP 2.1.4 3. Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of how oppression and discrimination impact clients; EP 2.1.5 4. Demonstrate knowledge of culturally responsive relationships; EP 2.1.10a Engagement 5. Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of the bio-psychosocial-spiritual factors that influence clinical interventions; EP 2.1.10b Assessment 6. Demonstrate a theoretically informed knowledge base to ensure effective practice interventions with individuals; EP 2.1.10c Intervention 7. Demonstrate knowledge that will allow for the evaluation of one’s work with clients. EP 2.1.10d Skills Objectives 1. Demonstrate solid professional identity as a social worker; EP 2.1.1 2. Demonstrate ability to apply ethical decision making skills to specific issues as they relate to clients served while recognizing and managing one’s personal biases; EP 2.1.2 3. Demonstrate ability to assess the strengths and weaknesses of a range of theories and differentially apply them to diverse client situations; EP 2.1.3 4. Demonstrate ability to communicate professional judgments and collaborate with professionals from various disciplines in coordinating treatment interventions in one’s work with clients from diverse backgrounds; EP 2.1.3 227 5. Demonstrate ability to differentially apply theories of human behavior and the social environment to guide one’s clinical assessments, interventions and terminations with clients; EP 2.1.7 6. Demonstrate ability to engage, assess, intervene, and evaluate individuals from diverse backgrounds based on an understanding of their strengths and resources; EP 2.1.10 a-d Values Objectives 1. Appreciate and understand one’s personal and professional values, ethical principles, and legal mandates pertinent to one’s clinical practice with individuals; EP 2.1.2 2. Engage in self-reflection in the interest of clients served from diverse backgrounds; EP 2.1.3 3. Recognize client strengths, coping strategies, vulnerabilities and spirituality in making assessments and interventions EP 2.1.10 b, c Practice Behaviors that correspond with the course objectives and the ten advanced competencies 1. Readily identify as a social work professional EP 2.1.1 2. Demonstrate professional use of self with client/s; EP 2.1.1 3. Apply ethical decision-making skills to issues specific to clinical social work EP 2.1.2 4. Engage in reflective practice EP 2.1.3 5. Identify and articulate clients’ strengths and vulnerabilities EP 2.1.3 6. Research and apply knowledge of diverse populations to enhance client well-being EP 2.1.4 7. Use knowledge of the effects of oppression, discrimination, and historical trauma on client and client systems to guide treatment planning and intervention EP 2.1.5 8. Synthesize and differentially apply theories of human behavior and social environment to guide clinical practice EP 2.1.7 228 9. Assess the quality of clients’ interactions within their social contexts EP 2.1.9 10. Develop a culturally responsive therapeutic relationship EP 2.1.10a Engagement 11. Use multi-dimensional bio-psychosocial spiritual assessment tools EP 2.1.10b Assessment 12. Collaborate with other professionals to coordinate treatment interventions EP 2.1.10c 13. Use clinical evaluation of the process and/or outcomes to develop best practice interventions for a range of bio-psychosocial spiritual conditions EP 2.1.10d COURSE METHOD Didactic presentations/discussions, analysis of videotapes, case discussions, and role playing, will be used throughout the semester. Students are expected to have read assignments and cases prior to a given class and should be prepared to participate in classroom discussions and role plays. Students will not be able to participate in experiential exercises and class discussions unless they are present in class. Therefore, class attendance and participation are imperative. COURSE EXPECTATIONS Attendance Policy: Students are expected to attend each and every class and to arrive on time,. Roll will be taken regularly. Students are allowed to miss two classes without penalty. Three (3) points will be deducted from the final score if one misses 3-5 classes and 5 points will be deducted if one misses 6 or more classes. Students do not need to notify the professor regarding the reason for their absence(s). Be aware that tardiness will also affect your final grade Phones/Pagers: . Phones and pagers disrupt the class. Phones and pagers must be turned off during class. Make-up Policy: Make-up exams or extension dates on papers, as a rule, will not be permitted. Only in extraordinary circumstances may this be considered ((hospitalizations, death of a family member, etc.). The professor reserves the right to determine the format of any make-up exam or extension dates on papers. Incomplete Grades: The grade of “I” will be given only under emergency situations that prohibit a student from completing specific assignments or class projects. The 229 student must contact the instructor and receive approval in writing that an assignment cannot be completed by the designated date so that the grade of “I” can be given for incomplete work. A designated time will be given by the professor for when the work must be completed by the student. If the deadline is not met, the student will receive a grade based upon work completed for the course excluding a grade for the specific assignment. Assignments Policy: All papers must be completed using APA 6th edition (see www.apastyle.org). That includes, but is not limited to, using double-spacing, as well as standard fonts (Times New Roman 12) and margins (1 inch on all sides). Page number requirements do not include the cover page, reference pages or appendices. While references can be used from a number of sources, references counted as “required” include only peer reviewed journal articles or book chapters published from a scholarly press (Columbia University Press, Jason Aronson Press, Allyn Bacon , etc. ). Other references may be used, however they do not count as a required references. Late assignments will be penalized as follows: 2 days late – 5 points ; 3-4 days late 10 points; 5 – 7 days late 15 points. Papers will not be accepted after 7 days. Communication with Students: All communication with students will be through KSU e-mail address so that you should check your e-mail regularly. ACADEMIC INTEGRITY STATEMENT http://catalog.kennesaw.edu/content.php?catoid=11&navoid=489&returnto=search #stud_code_cond Criteria for Student Evaluation Progress will be evaluated utilizing the following criteria: Class attendance and participation Three (3) points will be deducted from the final score if one misses 3-5 classes and 5 points will be deducted if one misses 6 or more classes. Assignment Assignment 1: Assignment 2: Assignment 3: Assignment 4: Topic Ethical Dilemma Antwone Fisher Psycho. Application Case of Susan CBT, Psycho-Dynamic, or Interpersonal Application Case of Alice Due 9/6/2011 9/27/2011 10/18/2011 11/22/2011 Points 100 points 100 points 100 points 100 points Total = 100% 230 Course grades will be assigned as follows: Percentages for Final Grade 92 – 100% A 91 - 80% B 79 - 70% C 69 and Below F 231 Course Outline and Readings Weekly Topics and Readings: 1. Week 1: August 23, 2011 Setting the Stage: Definition & History of Clinical Social Work; Practice Theory What is Theory? The Relationship between Theory and Intervention The value of theory in Clinical Practice The Curative Factors in all Practice Theories Strengths Oriented Clinical Practice; Spirituality Evidence-based Practice Ecological Systems Theory (ecosystems) Becoming a Therapist DVD: Becoming a Therapist: Inside the Learning Curve from Psychotherapy. Net Required Reading: *Walsh, J. Chapter 2, pp. 17 – 31. (Strengths Oriented Clinical Practice, pp 19-21; Incorporating Spirituality into Direct Practice – pp. 29-30). *Cowger, Charles D. and Snively, Carol A., “Assessing Client Strengths” (On Reserve in Library) *Borden, W. (2009). Evidence-Based Practice, Science and Social Work: An Overview. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 1115-1120. Oxford Press. (On reserve in Library.) *Borden, W. (2009). The Life Model/Ecological Perspective. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 231 – 235.. Oxford Press. (On reserve in Library) Rothery, Michael ( ) “Ecological Systems Theory. (On Reserve in Library) 232 Optional Reading: • Goldstein, H. (1990). The knowledge base of social work practice: Theory, wisdom, analogue, or art? Families in Society, 71, 32-43. • Saleebey, D. (2000). Power in the people: Strengths and hope. Advances in Social Work, 1(2), 127-136. 2. Week 2: August 30, 2011 Ethics and Values in Clinical Social Work Clinical Vignettes of Ethical Issues Provided by Professor for Class Discussion. Assignment I: Ethical Dilemma Assignment Due Week 3: September 6, 2011 1. Describe an ethical dilemma you have experienced or know about from your social work experience (25 points). 2. What action did you take regarding the ethical dilemma? (25 points) 3. Identify and discuss the relevant ethical guidelines as described in the NASW Code of Ethics. (25 points) 4. Given the ethical guideline(s) discussed, did you take the appropriate action or would you, in hindsight, take a different action? (25 points) Required Reading: NASW Code of Ethics Reamer, F.G. (1998). The evolution of social work ethics. Social Work, 43, 488-500. ( In Library or can be obtained from University of Georgia SSW or Georgia State U. SSW) Borden, W. (2009). Ethical Issues in Social Work.. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 115 - 121. Oxford Press. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles 3. Week 3: September 6, 2011: View Movie: Antwone Fisher: Assignment 2 Due Week 6: September 27, 2011 Assignment 1 Due: Ethical Dilemma Class will complete the required readings and view the movie, Antwone Fisher. Assignment2: Antwone Fisher ( Due Week 6: September 27, 2011) Based on 233 your readings and viewing of the movie, Antwone Fisher, address the following questions from the movie. Each question is worth 20 points for a total of 100 points. 1. What role did Davenport play in Antwone’s life other than his therapist? What was the quality of the relationship between Davenport and Antwone? What was Antwone’s contribution to treatment and what role did hope play? 2. What role do you think Davenport’s theoretical orientation plays in Antwone’s progress? What role did Antwone’s girlfriend Cheryl play in his treatment and his life? 3. What cultural/class issues are relevant to Antwone’s treatment/therapy? Is the relationship between Antwone and Dr. Davenport cross-cultural? If so, in what ways? How are cultural and or class differences addressed? 4. In what stage of change is Antwone at the start of treatment? When and to which stage does he shift? To what do you attribute that change? 5. Is Davenport an ethical psychiatrist? Why or why not? Required readings: Walsh, Chapters 1, pp 1-16. Tseng, W.S. & Streltzer, J. (2001). Culture & Psychotherapy. Chapter 17; pp. 265-278. Washington DC: American Psychiatric Press. *Berzoff, J., Flanagan, Laura M., and Hertz, P. (2008). Inside Out and Outside In (2nd Ed. New York: Jason Aronson. Chapter 14 by Lourdes Mattei, “Coloring Development: Race and Culture in Psychodynamic Theories”, pp. 245-271. 234 Optional readings: Harper, K.V. & Lantz, J. (1996). Cross-cultural Practice. Chicago: Lyceum. (Chapter 1: Cross-cultural curative factors.) 4. Weeks 4 & 5: September 13 & 20, 2011 Week 4: September 13, 2011: Psychodynamic Theories I: Ego Psychology Ego Psychology and Ego Functions Common Mechanisms of Defense Evaluation of Defenses Week 5: September 20, 2011; The Autonomous Ego Functions Case: The Girl in the Window Specific Ego Intervention Strategies Ego Psychology and Principles for Terminating with Clients Ego Psychology and Social Justice Issues Ego Psychology and Spirituality Role Plays: The Post Traumatic Stress Survivor, In Walsh, pp. 53-55 Psychosocial Ego Development Theory of Erik Erikson; Role Play Using Ego Psychology Strategies. CASE: : The Post Traumatic Stress Survivor, pp. 53-55 taken from Direct Social Work Practice by Joseph Walsh. You are to read the entire case. The Role Play will be based on the 4th Paragraph of the Case found on page 53, which begins: “After their fourth session, Heidi’s depression and anxiety increased.” Four ego psychology strategies are listed below and there will be four (4) role plays with 8 students. For each Role Play, one student will be the SW and the second student the client. The Role Plays will demonstrate one of the Ego Psychology Strategies listed below. 1. With the information you know, do a beginning interview that demonstrates sustainment or establishing a relationship with Heidi. 235 2. Do an interview that demonstrates Exploration/Description/ Ventilation and Person Situation Reflection. 3. Do an interview that demonstrates Partializing (Structuring) and Education. 4. Do an interview that demonstrates Developmental Reflection Required readings: Walsh, Chapter 3 – Ego Psychology, pp. 32 - 61 Berzoff, “Inside Out, Outside In: An Introduction, pp. 1-15 and Chapter 4, “Ego Psychology”, pp. 63-97. Berzoff, Chapter 5, “Psychosocial Ego Development: The Theory of Erik Erikson, pp. 99 – 120. Optional readings: Malick, M.D. (1991). Re-assessing assessment in clinical social work practice. Smith College Studies in Social Work, 62, 3-17. 6. Week 6: September 27, 2011 Assignment 2 Due: Antwone Fisher Psychodynamic Theories II: Object Relations Theory Object Relations Theory Early Nurturing and Attachment Theory Two Object Relations Theorists: Donald Winnicott and Margaret Mahler Margaret Mahler’s Separation/Individuation Phases Assessment and Intervention Required readings: Walsh, Chapter 4 – “Psychodynamic Theories II: Object Relations Theory”, pp. 62 – 89. Berzoff, Chapter 6, “Object Relations Theory” by Laura Melano Flanagan, pp. 121160. 236 Berzoff, Chapter 8, “Attachment Theory” by Robert Shilkret and Cynthia Shilkret, pp. 189-204. Bowles, Dorcas (1983). Ethnicity and Race: Critical Concepts in Social Work. Washington, D.C. NASW Press. “ Development of an Ethnic Sense of Self” using Object Relations Theory (On Reserve in Library) Optional reading: Borden, W. (2009). Object relations psychology. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 305-310. Oxford Press. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) 7. Week 7: October 4, 2011 Psychodynamic Object Relations Theory and Gender Object Relations and Social Justice Object Relations and Spirituality and Principles for Terminating with Clients Diversity and Cultural Factors: Issues faced by Majority Workers with Clients of Color and by Workers of Color working with Clients of Color (Class Discussion) Case Discussion - The Wild Child (Walsh, pp. 79 – 82) Required readings: Berzoff, Chapter 10, “Psychodynamic Theory and Gender”, pp. 229-244. Berzoff, Chapter 11, “Coloring Development: Race and Culture in Psychodynamic Theory” by Lourdes Mattei, pp. 245 – 270. Optional readings: Chapter 5 – Family Emotional Systems Theory Dalzell, Heidi J. (2001). Insight at any age: Psychodynamic treatment of older adults. Psychoanalysis & Psychotherapy Vol 18(2), 241-260. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) Messer, S.B. (2002). A psychodynamic perspective on resistance in psychotherapy: Vive la resistance! Journal of Clinical Psychology, 58(2), 157-163. 237 8. Week 8: October 11, 2011 Personality Disorders (also known as Character Disorders) with a Special Emphasis on Borderline and Narcissistic Personalities Meaning of Term Personality Disorder or Character Disorder Borderline Personality Disorders Borderline Personality in Context of Person’s Object Relations, Ego Functions and Sense of Self Review of Object Relations Chart Case: Mary Ann F.: A Borderline Mother and her New Born Narcissistic Personality Disorder Narcissistic Personality in Context of Person’s Object Relations, Ego Functions and Sense of Self Required Reading: Berzoff, Flanagan and Hertz, Inside Out and Outside In, “Personality Disorders with a Special Emphasis on Borderline and Narcissistic Personalities. Chapter 14, pp. 311-354. Walsh, pp. The Nature of Problems and definition of “Splitting”, pp. 74-75. Borden, W. (2009). Interventions with Borderline Personality Disorder. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 305-310. Oxford Press, pp. 742 – 751. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) 9.Week 9: October 18, 2011 Assignment 3: Psychodynamic Application Paper Due: Case of Susan: Week 9, October 18, 2011 Narcissistic Personality Disorder Continued Behavioral Theory Intervention Techniques Using Behavioral Theory Social Justice Using Behavioral Theory Spirituality Using Behavioral Theory 238 Required readings: Walsh, Chapter 6 – Behavioral Theory 10.Week 10: October 25, 2011 Behavioral Theory Continued to include Spirituality Social Justice DVD: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy with John Krumboltz Required readings: Borden, W. (2009). Cognitive-Behavioral Theory. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 305-310. Oxford Press. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) Borden, W. (2009). A Behavioral Approach to Social Work Treatment. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 288 - 294. Oxford Press. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) Rokke, P.D. & Rehm, L.P. (2001). Self-management techniques. In K. Dobson (Ed.), Handbook of Cognitive-Behavioral Therapies, pp. 242 - 247. New York: Guilford Press. 11. Week 11: November 1, 2011 Cognitive Theory Assessment Intervention Cognitive Theory and Social Justice Cognitive Theory and Spirituality DVD: Depression: A Cognitive Therapy Approach with Arthur Freeman, Ed.D Required readings: Walsh, Chapter 7 – Cognitive Theory 239 Borden, W. (2009). Cognitive Restructuring Techniques. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 588-594. Oxford Press. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) Optional readings: Beck, J.S. (1995). Cognitive therapy: basics and beyond. New York: Guilford. (On Reserve) Interpersonal Therapy and Structural Family Theory 12. Week 12: November 8, 2011 Interpersonal Therapy and Structural Family Theory Interpersonal Therapy Interpersonal Therapy Elements of Psychodynamic Theory Elements of Cognitive and Behavioral Theory Assessment Intervention Interpersonal Therapy and Social Justice Interpersonal Therapy and Spirituality Case: The Rose from Spanish Harlem – Class Discussion (Walsh, pp. 187 -192 Structural Family Theory Major Concepts and Other Concepts The Nature of Problems and Change Assessment Interventions Ending Structural Family Therapy Structural Family Theory and Social Justice Structural Family Theory and Spirituality DVD: Structural Family Therapy with Harry Aponte, LCSW 240 Required Readings: Walsh, Chapter 8 – “Interpersonal Therapy”, pp. 177 -198. Walsh, chapter 9 – “Structural Family Theory”, pp. 199 – 229. 13. Week 13: November 15, 2011 Structural Family Theory Contd. Narrative Therapy Narrative Theory Defined Major Concepts of Narrative Theory Assessment using Narrative Theory Interventions Using Narrative Theory Terminations and Narrative Therapy Narrative Therapy and Spirituality Narrative Therapy and Social Justice Case: Bag Lady – Walsh, pp. 289-291 and Case Examples from the Class Required readings: Walsh, Chapter 12 – Narrative Theory Optional reading: Goncalves, O.F., Machado, P. P. P. Korman, Y., Angus, L. (2002). Assessing psychopathology: A narrative approach. In: L.E. Beutler & M.L. Malik (Eds.), pp. 149-176. Rethinking the DSM: A psychological perspective. Washington DC: APA. *Borden, W. (2009). Narrative Therapy. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp.273-276. Oxford Press. (Available to copy from Dr. Bowles.) 14. Week 14: November 22, 2011 Assignment 4 Due: Cognitive Behavioral, Psychodynamic or Interpersonal Theory- Practice Application Paper Due Case of Alice (Select one theoretical Perspective) 202 Narrative Therapy Cont’d (Fall Break – No Classes – November 23 – 27, 2011) 15. Week 15 Wednesday November 29, 2011 Time Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy Definition of Time Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy Five Essential Assumptions of TLDP Two Goals of TLDP Five Major Criteria used in Determining Clients’ ability to benefit from TLDP How the SW obtains data that will be used to show that there is a Maladaptive Pattern DVD: Time Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy by Psychotherapy Net. Dr. Hannah Levenson, Therapist. Psychotherapy. Net Questions for Class Discussion following a Review of the DVD 1. Did Mr. Johnson, the client, demonstrate the five essential assumptions of Time Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy? 2. Why does Dr. Levenson push Mr. Johnson so hard to talk about his feelings in spite of his insistence that he is unable to do so? 3. When Dr. Levenson interprets Mr. Johnson’s disclosure of his feelings of disappointment, do you agree with her linking the feelings with abandonment? 4. What was most helpful to you as a SW about the TLDP model? What perspectives did you find helpful and might use in your own work? 5. What do you think you would have done differently than Dr. Levenson, the therapist, in the video? Be specific in what different approaches and techniques you might have applied and state why you would use these different approaches. 203 Required readings: Levenson, Hanna, “Time Limited Dynamic Psychotherapy”, from The Art and Science of Brief Psychotherapies, pp. 157 -184. On Reserve in Library Walsh, Chapter 13 – Crisis Theory & Intervention Eaton, Y.M. & Roberts, A.R. (2004). Frontline crisis intervention. In Roberts & Greene (Eds.) Social Worker’s Desk Reference, pp. 89-96. Oxford Press. (On Reserve) 16. Week 16: December 6, 2011: Final Class (Final Exam Week: December 6 12, 2011 Motivational Interviewing Definition of Motivational Interviewing Transtheoretical Stages of Change (TSOC) Model – A Major influence of Motivational Interviewing Clinical Perspective in Motivational Interviewing The Social Worker Client Relationship and Assessment in Motivational Interviewing Intervention in Motivational Interviewing Specific Techniques used by the Social Worker in Motivational Interviewing Developing a Change Plan Technique that Supports Self –Efficacy Motivational Interviewing and Spirituality Motivational Interviewing and Social Justice DVD: Client Mike by William Miller. developer of Motivational Interviewing, Psychotherapy Net Video Collection – Enhance Your Training Program Termination with Clients Professor’s Closing Comments Required readings: Walsh, Chapters 12 – Motivational Interviewing, pp. 253-272 Walsh, J. (2003). Endings in Clinical Practice. Chapters 2 & 3; pp. 22-56. Chicago: Lyceum Books. (Available on WebCT) 204 O’Leary Tevyaw, T. & Monti, P.M. (2004). Motivational enhancement and other brief interventions for adolescent substance abuse. Addiction, 99, 63-75, Supplement 2. Berzoff, Chapter 18, pp. 443-446. Optional reading: Elks, M.A., & Kirkhart, K.E. (1993). Evaluating effectiveness from the practitioner perspective. Social Work, 38(5), 554-563. Mercier, C., Landry, M., Corbiere, M. & Pereault, M. (2004). Measuring clients’ perception as outcome measurement. In Roberts & Yaeger (Eds.), EvidenceBased Practice Manual, pp. 904-909. Oxford Press. PLEASE NOTE: You will be doing one assignment on an ethical issue, one assignment based on the film, Antwone Fisher, and 2 application of practice papers. Each paper should be between 10-15 pages long, double-spaced. If the papers can be completed in fewer than 15 pages that is fine. If the paper is a page or two longer than 15 pages that is also fine. Remember: More does not mean better. They are due at the beginning of each class as follows: 205 Case of Susan Family Service Agency Case Study: Susan Identifying Information Susan is a 40 year old Caucasian woman. She identifies herself as lesbian; has never been married and has no children of her own. She has been unemployed for roughly 6 years, although she did at one time have a “high paying job” of about $45,000 a year as a locksmith. In addition to her salary, Susan often received good tips for her work as a locksmith. Susan currently collects Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) as a result of severe back problems she has had since childhood, based in part on beatings she received at the hands of her Father and beatings from her lesbian lover, Tina and Tina’s boyfriends. Susan was in a 12 year lesbian relationship with Tina who had two daughters, J and T. The two daughters were by two of Tina’s former boyfriends. Susan does not attend church regularly, but when she does, she attends a Unitarian Church. Description of Client Susan presents as a very thin woman who looks older than her 40 years. Her face and neck are scarred with slashes and discolorations and her cheeks are drawn in from a recent drastic loss in weight. She walks slowly and with a cane. She has eight teeth remaining and reports intense pain in her face because these teeth are decaying. Susan’s teeth were basically knocked out during fights with Tina and Tina’s boyfriends. She is in need of glasses and her eyes squint. She often uses her hands to cover her mouth as a way of not letting others see that most of her teeth are missing. Susan speaks in a slow pace, with very little emotional inflection and often stutters when discussing painful memories experienced from her childhood in relationship to physical abuse by her father, sexual abuse by her siblings, and adult life with her lover, Tina, and Tina’s boyfriends who also severely physically abused her. Susan often uses humor to describe some of her more painful memories. She graduated high school, but reports she can read only at about a 6th grade level. She loves working with her hands and took courses that led her to becoming a locksmith which she was good at until she was forced to give up being a locksmith because of severe back injuries. At the beginning of TX, Susan’s affect was somewhat labile, changing from angry to defensive, to sad, hopeless, and somewhat apologetic. During the initial interviews, Susan described her recent loss of a 12 year relationship with Tina, 206 a female lesbian partner, and her two female children, J and T, that Susan and Tina, raised together. Early meetings with the SW focused on Tina’s leaving/abandoning Susan and taking the two girls, J and T, that Susan had come to love and become attached to, with her. Susan felt she was a parent to the two girls and that she could see sadness in the faces of the two girls when Tina left with them. Susan experienced feeling sad, depressed and “out of sorts” when Tina took the two girls, J and T and left. In later meetings with the SW, Susan would become unable to think of anything else except her memories of childhood physical and sexual abuse by her father, two brothers and older sister. Susan lives in a private single room of a large boarding house that she rents. There are 4 other female residents in the boarding house where the 4 tenants share a bathroom and a kitchen. Susan has had this living arrangement since the breakup with her girlfriend, Tina. Near the end of TX, Tina moved into a one room apartment where she currently resides. Referral Susan was a “walk-in” client to the Family Service Agency which was about two blocks from the boarding house where she lived. One of the other female boarders had indicated that she had previously received help from the agency, and Susan decided to seek help on her own. Susan told the intake SW that she would “really appreciate someone to talk to because things are falling apart for me, and I cannot figure things out.” The Intake SW did a brief intake interview and Susan was assigned to a 2nd year SW student from a graduate school of social work. Meetings were planned for once per week with the MSW intern. Family History Susan is the youngest of five children: two older brothers and two older sisters. Susan was sexually molested for years by her two older brothers and by the older sister. Susan had a fairly good relationship with the sister who was 2 years her senior and next to her in age. Susan remembered that the sexual abuse happened to her between the ages of 8 and 13. Susan stated that the two older brothers often molested her individually and together as a team, and she does not feel that the brothers knew that the oldest sister was also sexually molesting her. The oldest sister was later hospitalized for psychiatric reasons, and later developed MS. In addition to being molested by her siblings, Susan stated that a total of 11other men had sexually abused her, some family members and others neighbors and friends of the family. Susan’s father was an alcoholic and she reported being beaten by her father as well as witnessing the Father severely physically abuse her mother. He (her father) always beat the Mo. in the kitchen. The father gave the Mo. a skull fracture in 207 the back of her head and Susan is certain that this blow led to the aneurism that subsequently killed the Mo. Susan was age 13 when her Mo. died and has been on her own pretty much since then. Treatment Sessions Susan was in a lesbian relationship for 12 years with a woman, Tina, ten years her senior. Susan was age 28, and Tina age 38, when the lesbian relationship began. Tina had two female children, J and T, by two different men, and the two children also lived in the household. Susan experienced physical and emotional abuse in the relationship with Tina. When Susan first talked about Tina, she alternated between seeing her as evil and as a “good woman with a good heart.” Although Tina had left Susan 9 months earlier when TX began, Susan felt responsible for the failed relationship. Susan could not have children and came to develop positive feelings toward the two female children, J and T, who were Tina’s children by different men prior to Susan’s and Tina’s relationship. Also, when Susan met Tina, Susan was working and making a fairly good salary, of approximately $45,000 per year, as a locksmith. Tina was unemployed and was basically being taken care of sporadically by the children’s fathers and other men with whom she had relationships. Susan supported Tina and her two children and became very emotionally attached to the two girls. As far as Susan knows, Tina was in relationships with males prior to their becoming lovers, and she is Tina’s first lesbian relationship. Tina was very physically abusive to Susan during the 12 year relationship, and Susan initially blamed herself for Tina’s abuse of her. Susan stated: “It’s my fault for bringing a straight woman out as a lesbian. Tina beat me and cheated on me and I let her. It’s my fault. I came to love Tina and her two daughters and now I have no-one. Tina is the only person who loved me other than my Mo., but my Mo. could not show her love to me, because she was physically abused by my Fa. and was depressed all the time.” Tina would punch Susan in the face, chest and stomach, and throw chairs, vases and other large objects at her, some of which hit Susan in the face and on various other parts of her body. Often the fights with Tina were about boyfriends that Tina brought to the house. Tina had boyfriends throughout the relationship with Susan and the boyfriends also physically abused Susan. More than one of Tina’s boyfriends physically beat and abused Susan. Tina would watch these fights and “egg the boyfriends on” as they physically beat and abused Susan. Susan felt the beatings from Tina and her boyfriends were her fault because she was bad and deserved the beatings. Oftentimes, the fights with Tina’s boyfriends started when Susan would yell at the boyfriends that Tina did not love them, but loved Susan. 208 One of Tina’s boyfriends had held a gun to Susan’s head and Susan had said: “Go ahead – put me out of my misery.” Another of Tina’s boyfriends, broke Susan’s cheek, knocked three of her front teeth out, and smashed her glasses. Susan stated that she has gotten hit in the head so much and tried to abuse herself so much with drugs that she wonders if her brains aren’t fried. Susan stated that sometimes it feels like there’s so much noise in her head, like a banging back and forth. She has headaches all the time. She knows that the headaches are related to the abuse she received as a child from her father and from fights with Tina and her boyfriends. During Susan’s and Tina’s relationship, Susan rented an apartment that consisted of two bedrooms; 2 baths with one bath connected to the large master bedroom and the other bath off of the 2nd bedroom; a large living room; dining room; kitchen with a large pantry; and a small Den which was used to watch TV. The apartment provided a place where Tina and her girls could live. The girls shared one bedroom and bath and Susan and Tina the master bedroom and bath. Susan was doing well health-wise, until she began to experience severe beatings at the hand of Tina and Tina’s boyfriends, which worsened a back problem she had from beatings she experienced at the hand of her father. Susan’s back problems worsened and resulted in her not being able to continue her work as a locksmith and having to receive Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI). Once Susan began receiving SSDI, she lost the apartment because it was too expensive; Tina and the girls left; and Susan was only able to afford a room in a boarding house where she currently lives. Tina would occasionally bring the two girls, J and T, to visit Susan, often accompanied by a new boyfriend. Tina was also able to get Susan to give her small sums of money for the girls which Susan could not refuse because she had become attached to the girls and wanted the best for them. Once Tina got the money from Susan, she would leave. If Susan asked if the girls could stay with her for a while longer, Tina would say No and snatch the kids and leave. Susan is sure the girls were confused as they would often turn to look at Susan as though they wanted to stay, but Tina would rush them out without Susan and the girls being able to say good-bye. Susan says that she felt overwhelmed, was not able to sleep, was more overwhelmed than she had ever been, and would be upset that if she did not do what Tina said, she would not be able to see the girls. Susan felt she had lost everything - her job, her health, the apartment, Tina, and the girls. Susan has no contact with members of her family who live in another state. Susan felt she had no one and could not live without Tina and the girls. Part of TX focused on helping Susan to see that she is separate from Tina and the girls and that she can have a life separate from them. During these sessions, Susan would cry incessantly because she felt her life was over without Tina and the girls. 209 Gradually, with the SW’s help, Susan began to see some of her strengths and that her relationship with Tina was “exploitative”; that Tina was “manipulative” and that she could live without Tina and the girls. It took several sessions for Susan to begin to internalize that she had strengths and to begin to “feel whole” and worthwhile as a person without Tina and the girls. During this time, as Susan was beginning to feel comfort with herself, she would occasionally express feeling empty without Tina and the girls in her life and she began to drink again. Susan stated that on one occasion, she drank a fifth of tequila to make the pain inside her go away. She does not want to drink because she has been through “drinking binges” before. In the past, Susan would drink heavily, especially after beatings from Tina and/or Tina’s boyfriends. The last time Susan drank tequila, following a beating by one of Tina’s boyfriends, she spent 3 days praying to the porcelain God she had in her apartment. Susan stated that she feels tired. So tired, she just wants to crawl in her shell. She wants to be alone; she’s tired; wants to go to her room and lay there. She thinks about her Mom; listens to the cars go by; does not think of anything; does not want to go out to get food or groceries. She only wants to walk around in her room by herself. Susan expressed that at these time, being alone allows “me to think about and process what we talk about during our sessions; this makes me feel stronger and allows me to think of my past and where I am in my life without Tina and the girls. I hold on to these thoughts and it gets me through these rough spots until I can speak with you again.” The SW commented that what Susan has just described represents growth on her part and that given her past, it takes time for healing to occur. Susan has done a lot of hard work to get to this place and the SW expressed that she is proud of the progress Tina has made. Tina was teary eyed and said: “I could not be at this place were it not for our time together. Thanks for all you have done to help me.” The SW explained to Tina that Tina had done the work and she should feel proud of what she has achieved. Tina thanked the SW for caring about and being there for her. “I would probably be dead if I did not have you”, Tina stated. The Family Service Agency used a psychiatrist for consultation services and the SW referred Susan to the psychiatrist for a psychiatric exam for her depression and “feelings of emptiness” and she was placed on meds for her depression. Susan stated the meds have helped her feel better and less depressed. As well, Tina had not visited Susan for several months and Susan was doing better; feeling stronger. Susan had been saving money and living frugally with the goal of moving to a small apartment. She was able to find a small apartment she could afford, was able to pay the required deposit, and was making plans to move. 210 Then, several weeks later on a Saturday, Tina brought Susan food but did not bring the girls. Susan had not seen Tina for several months and was feeling that she was getting herself together and ready to move on with her life. Susan and Tina ate some of the food Tina brought, and talked about things in general and the discussion went well. Susan told Tina that she had put a deposit on an apartment and planned to move soon. On the next day, Sunday, Tina brought the girls to see Susan. Tina knew from talking with Susan on Saturday, that Susan planned to move to an apartment. On that Sunday when Tina brought the girls to see Susan, Tina talked about the possibility of she and Susan getting back together and trying to make the relationship work. Susan was quite surprised and explained to the SW in her next session, that she did not trust Tina so she just took the information in without commenting. Tina still has her boyfriends and Susan feels that Tina wants another “free ride”, but Susan is not prepared to get involved with Tina again. Susan was finally able to see and realize that Tina had “used me so she and her two daughters could live rent free” in Susan’s apartment and have food and bills paid by Susan. The SW could see that Susan’s understanding and insight, based on their work together and the gains made in TX, were remarkable. Susan was finally able to see that her relationship with Tina was exploitative, abusive and unhealthy. Susan explained to the SW that based on the work she had done in TX with the SW, she is feeling better, feeling stronger and does not want to return to the place she was at earlier. Susan stated that she knows that Tina is not good for her and it has taken some time for her to work out her feelings regarding Tina and the abuse she experienced with her and the abuse she experienced at the hands of her father. She does not want to and does not deserve to get hurt again. Susan repeated what the SW had told her on several occasions: “As you said, I can be my own person and am worthy and deserving of a better life.” With the SW’s help, Susan was able to explain to Tina that it had taken her a long time to work through the abuse she had experienced with Tina and her boyfriends. Susan stated that she loved J and T and wanted the best for them, but felt it was in everyone’s best interest that she and Tina not get back together. Susan stated that she would miss the girls, J. and T., but needed to get on with her life and Tina and the girls needed to get on with their lives. Tina was angry and wanted to start a fight, but Susan held her ground and said she needed to move on and did not want to repeat the pain of the past. 211 Tina tried to get Susan to give her the address where she was moving, but Susan said she could not give her the address. They needed to say good bye. Tina tried to turn the cards and say that she did not want a relationship with Susan and never wanted to see Susan again. Also, she would make sure Susan never saw the girls. J and T., again. Susan attempted to give Tina a hug good bye and to tell the girls good bye and give them a hug, but Tina pulled away and took the girls’ hands and left without any goodbyes. Susan felt sad that things ended this way, but felt she had to protect herself and would not allow Tina to “manipulate” her further. (The word manipulate had been used by the SW to explain Tina’s relationship with Susan.) Susan moved to her new apartment. It is a small one bedroom apartment, and she has spent time fixing it up and is enjoying having time to herself and doing things she enjoys. She attended church last week and re-connected with a woman, Judy, she had known earlier when she attended church. She and the woman have had coffee together and gone to a few movies. These were things Susan once enjoyed but had not done when she was living with Tina. Susan feels good that she is doing things she enjoys. The woman is divorced and “straight” and Susan enjoys her company. Susan has stated that this is the first time she has ever had a “real friend” that she can talk and share her ideas with. Susan has explained to Judy that she is a lesbian and the woman has expressed that while that is not her lifestyle, she respects Susan and her lifestyle. Susan stated that Judy is okay with Susan being a lesbian and Judy being straight and respected Susan for being who she is and Susan is fine with Judy being straight and her own person. Judy has had several other church members to her house for special occasions and Susan has gone and has had a good time. Susan feels she wants an intimate female relationship, but feels that until she finds a “good, healthy” relationship that is not “exploitative and manipulative”, she is fine. The student SW left the agency to return to school and Susan was quite sad and depressed when she left. The student SW transferred Susan to another worker in the agency and Susan continued to see the other SW. The new SW explained that it was natural for Susan to feel sad at the loss of the student SW. The two of them had worked hard together and it was natural that Susan would miss her. Gradually, Susan’s sadness lessened as she got to know the new SW and felt comfortable talking with her. After several months, the new SW expressed to Susan that she felt Susan was at a place where she no longer needed to see the SW. Susan was hesitant at the idea initially but agreed to a plan where Susan would continue to be seen weekly for another month after which Susan would be scheduled to come every two weeks. Prior to the change to being seen once every two weeks, the SW and Susan talked about Susan’s feelings about the change and what Susan might feel and that they 212 would monitor Susan feelings to determine if the change in schedule was okay for Susan. This same process was followed for scheduled appointments on a once per month basis. Susan did fine with the changes and the SW introduced the idea that Susan was ready to be on her own with the understanding that Susan could call the agency should she have other issues she wanted to address. Susan accepted this final arrangement and acknowledged that the gradual reduction in visits had been good for her and had allowed her to prepare for being on her own. Susan expressed that she is indebted to the student SW and the current SW for “saving my life and helping me feel whole and complete”. Susan has been on her own now for some time. She has only called the new SW on one occasion when she was feeling sad and needed to process her feelings. The SW and Susan were able to talk on the phone and Susan felt this was adequate. Susan knows that the agency is there for her should she need to contact them. Susan has made no further calls to the agency. ASSIGNMENT 3: Due: Week 9: October 18, 2011 Psychodynamic Application of Theory: Case of Susan Application of Psychodynamic Theories (Object Relations and Ego Psychology) to Case of Susan. Answer each question. Be sure to number and state the question before each response so that I know the answer that corresponds with the question. Questions: 1. Based on the information given in the case-study, (a) what are Susan’s strengths? Where would you locate Susan developmentally and why? (b) provide the characteristics of the developmental stage with specific information from the case study that support your choice; and (c) describe treatment interventions used by the SW to support Susan in moving from the stage you have selected to a different/higher stage. (20 points) 2. The relationship between Susan, Tina, and Tina’s boyfriends was quite abusive. How do you explain Susan’s acceptance of the physical abuse from Tina and Tina’s boyfriends. (20 points) 3. Based on lectures and readings, (a) assess Susan’s ego functioning (b) What areas of ego functioning are working well? (c) What ego functions are not working well? (c) What ego defenses is Susan using? Give specific examples. (20 points) 213 4. You are assigned as Susan’s social worker: (a) are there additional interventions you would use? Why? Why not? (b) Would you refer Susan to any other professional(s)? Identify professionals; explain reason for referral(s (c) Explain how you would work with/coordinate with the other professionals? ); (If you would not refer Susan to any other professional(s), explain why. (20 points) 5. Explain the role of the student SW and give your assessment of the relationship she formed with Susan and your thoughts about her TX of Susan. Describe your thinking with regard to how the new SW handled the termination with Susan and whether the handling was clinically appropriate or clinically inappropriate. Explain your response. Be specific (20 points) Case Study: Alice Agency Setting: A Mental Health Agency Identifying Information: Alice is a 23 year old Caucasian, married female who is currently unemployed. She’s been married for six years to her first and only husband, Joe. Alice was referred by her primary care physician after no physical causes could be found for feelings of chronic depression, fatigue, anxiety, migraine headaches and stomach aches during the last three years. Approximately six months ago, Alice was fired from her job as a cashier at a drug store. Since that time, she states that she spends most of her time taking care of her pets: three dogs and two cats, and making crafts. Alice is soft-spoken and describes herself as shy, dependent, and easy to feel hurt and quick to feel guilty. In the past three weeks, she has been experiencing significant levels of sadness, depression, anxiety and low self-esteem. She denies any suicidal ideation. She states that she is very inhibited when it comes to talking about and dealing with emotionally charged and disturbing issues and avoids such topics as much as possible. Alice describes her husband as very supportive and hard-working. She states that there are no difficulties in their marriage and she is very satisfied being married to Joe. Alice reports that she and her husband have tried unsuccessfully since they have been married to have children. Alice reports that when she was four years old, her mother, grandmother, and grandfather all died in a car accident of which she was the only survivor. She claims that she has no memories of the accident itself or of her biological mother. Alice related the onset of her current symptoms to a time three years ago when she had taken a trip to Texas to visit some of her relatives on her mother’s side of the family. 214 At that time, she learned some of the details of the accident from her mother’s relatives. She stated that she had difficulty tolerating the return drive home, especially on two lane roads. Since then, she has had dreams of the accident and has been unable to drive a car herself. Alice also reported that an elderly friend of hers, Sam, who has been a father figure to her since she was a young girl, committed suicide about six months ago. Alice says that since that time the dreams of the accident, as well as dreams of Sam, have been more frequent. FAMILY HISTORY: Alice reported that her father was married once before his marriage to her mother and twice after her mother’s death. Alice has a half-sister from her father’s first marriage and two older siblings from his marriage to her mother. In addition, she has two step-siblings from her father’s last two marriages. Alice says she had a great deal of difficulty with her first step-mother when she was growing up. She described her first step-mother as alcoholic and physically abusive of one of her sisters. This step-mother also gave Alice a black eye once. Alice described her second stepmother as rejecting and not wanting to deal with Alice since this woman’s own children were already gone. Alice reported that at age 16, she began running away from home and staying out late at night and drinking and occasionally smoking marijuana with friends. She says that this lasted for about one year and that she was able to quit using alcohol and marijuana on her own. At age 17, Alice moved out of the house and lived first with an aunt, then with her best friend and family, and finally with her boyfriend (now her husband) and his family. Alice stated that her primary reason for seeking social work intervention is to try to remember and learn as much as she can about the accident that killed her mother and grandparents and remember and learn as much as she can about her mother as a person. She stated that her father had always discouraged her from talking about her deceased mother when she was growing up. Alice wants to stop feeling depressed and anxious and also start feeling better about herself. She believes that remembering and learning about her mother and the accident will help her do this. In addition, she would like to get to the point where she is able to work and drive a car again. Application of Cognitive Behavioral or Psychodynamic Theory: Case of Alice Due Week 14, November 22, 2011 215 You are the social worker assigned to work one-on-one with Alice, the young woman in the assigned case at the Mental Health Agency. You can select either the Cognitive Behavioral theoretical perspective, the Interpersonal theoretical Perspective or the Psychodynamic theoretical perspective as your frame of reference in working with Alice. Please state your choice of theories first and briefly justify your choice as it relates to the case. You are to choose only one theoretical perspective, even if in real practice, you would choose to use parts of both theories. Answer each question. Be sure to number and state the question before each response so that I know the answer that corresponds with the question. Questions: State your theoretical perspective. (0 points) Justify or state why you have chosen a particular theoretical perspective for your work with Alice. (0 points) 1. Provide an understanding of Alice’s issues that is congruent with your chosen theoretical perspective to include: (a.) a list of Alice’s strengths;(b) a description of the problem(s) as it would be explained by your practice theory; and (c) potential reasons for the problematic behavior(s) as explained by your theory. (20 points) 2. Based on the information you have provided to Question No. 1, provide: (1) a treatment plan including at a minimum two (2) treatment goals that are congruent with Alice’s strengths and the theory you selected; and (2) the approximate length of time you will need to achieve the goals selected and why. (20 points) 3. Describe at least two interventions you might use in this case based on the theory you selected and Alice’s strengths. Discuss how the interventions relate to the treatment goals and how they would be implemented. (15 points) 4. Would your conceptualization and/or intervention be different if Alice were described as a Mexican-American woman? Why or why not. If yes, describe the differences. (20 points) 5. Describe two ways in which you would evaluate Alice’s progress. What would you measure? How and when would you measure it? (15 points) 216 6. What do you anticipate would be Alice’s response to termination and how would you handle the termination including how and when you would inform Alice of the termination. (10 points) Glossary of Concepts Psychodynamic Theory: Object Relations Dorcas D. Bowles, Professor Consolidation of Individuality and Emotional Constancy The fourth sub-phase of separation individuation, which begins toward the end of the second year is open-ended. During this period, a degree of object constancy is achieved, and the separation of self and object representation is sufficiently established. Mother is clearly perceived as a separate person in the outside world, and at the same time has an existence in the internal representational world of the child. Emotional Refueling During the practicing and rapprochement sub-phases, the infant moves away from the mother, but when s/he becomes fatigued or depleted of energy, s/he seeks to reestablish bodily contact with her. This “refueling” perks the toddler up and restores his/her previous momentum to practice and explore. Mutual Cueing A circular process of interaction established very early between mother and infant by which they “empathically” read each other’s signs and signals and react to each other. For example, the mother learns the meanings of the baby’s different cries and movements: the baby learns to anticipate the mother’s ministrations: s/he also learns soon which cues the mother (unconsciously) picks up and which she does not. No mother perfectly responds to a baby’s cues, but serious mismatching of cues is an obstacle in the path of smooth development. Shadowing and Darting Away During the rapprochement sub-phase, the child, at times, follows his/her mother’s every move (“shadows” her); s/he cannot let the mother out of sight or out of his/her vicinity. At times, we observe the opposite behavior, the child darts away, and waits for and expects the mother to swoop him/her up in the mother’s arms and thus for brief moments undo the “separateness”. 217 Ambivalence Ambivalence can occur only when there is representation of a single, whole person. Separation/Individuation has to have occurred at least in its beginning stage. The person can tolerate mixed feelings occurring at the same time; can tolerate good and bad feelings being present in the same person. 218 Glossary of Concepts Psychodynamic Theory: Object Relations Dorcas D. Bowles, Professor Consolidation of Individuality and Emotional Constancy The fourth sub-phase of separation individuation, which begins toward the end of the second year is open-ended. During this period, a degree of object constancy is achieved, and the separation of self and object representation is sufficiently established. Mother is clearly perceived as a separate person in the outside world, and at the same time has an existence in the internal representational world of the child. Emotional Refueling During the practicing and rapprochement sub-phases, the infant moves away from the mother, but when s/he becomes fatigued or depleted of energy, s/he seeks to reestablish bodily contact with her. This “refueling” perks the toddler up and restores his/her previous momentum to practice and explore. Mutual Cueing A circular process of interaction established very early between mother and infant by which they “empathically” read each other’s signs and signals and react to each other. For example, the mother learns the meanings of the baby’s different cries and movements: the baby learns to anticipate the mother’s ministrations: s/he also learns soon which cues the mother (unconsciously) picks up and which she does not. No mother perfectly responds to a baby’s cues, but serious mismatching of cues is an obstacle in the path of smooth development. Shadowing and Darting Away During the rapprochement sub-phase, the child, at times, follows his/her mother’s every move (“shadows” her); s/he cannot let the mother out of sight or out of his/her vicinity. At times, we observe the opposite behavior, the child darts away, and waits for and expects the mother to swoop him/her up in the mother’s arms and thus for brief moments undo the “separateness”. Ambivalence Ambivalence can occur only when there is representation of a single, whole person. Separation/Individuation has to have occurred at least in its beginning stage. The person can tolerate mixed feelings occurring at the same time; can tolerate good and bad feelings being present in the same person. 219 Bibliography Andreas, C. 7 Andreas, S. (1990). Briefer than brief. Family Networker. March-April, 37-41. Applegate, J. (1995). The Facilitating Partnership: a Winnicottian Approach for Social Workers and Other Helping Professionals. New York: Aronson. Atkinson, B. (Sept./Oct 2004). Altered States: Why insight in itself is not enough for lasting change. Psychotherapy Networker. Atwood, J. & Ruiz, J. (1993). Social constructionist therapy with the elderly. Journal of Family Psychotherapy, 4(1), 1-33. Beck, J. S. (2011). Cognitive Behavior Therapy: Basics and Beyond. New York: Guilford Press. Beitman, B.D. (1987). The structure of individual psychotherapy. New York: Guilford Press. Berzoff, J., Flannagan, L., & Hertz, P. (2008). Inside Out and Outside In: Psychodynamic Clinical Theory and Practice in Contemporary Multicultural Contexts. Northvale, N.J.: Jason Aronson. Bowles, Dorcas. (1988). Chapter 7. Development of an Ethnic Sense of Self. In Jacobs, C. and Bowles, D. Ethnicity & Race: Criticval Concepts in Social Work. Washington, D. C. NASW Press. Braconnier, A. & Marcelli, 7/24/96. (1979). The Adolescent and His Parents: The Parental Crisis. Journal of Adolescence, 2, 325-336. Buie, D. H. (1981). Empathy: Its Nature and Limitations. Journal of the AmericanPsychoanalytic Association, 29, 281-308. Dallos, R. (2004). Narrative Therapy: Integrating ideas from narrative and attachment theory in Systemic therapy with eating disorders. Journal of Family Therapy. 26 (1), 40-66. Edwards, J., & Bess, J., (1998). Developing Effectiveness in the Therapeutic Use of Self. Clinical Social Work Journal, 26(1), 89-104. Cooper, M., & Lesser, J., (1997). How Race Affects the Helping Process: A Case of Cross Racial Therapy. Clinical Social Work Journal, 25(3), 323-334. 220 Corey, G. (2000). Case Approach to Counseling and Psychotherapy. Pacific Grove:Brooks/Cole. Dorfman, R. A. (1998). Paradigms of Clinical Social Work, Volume 2. New York: runner/Mazel. Durrant, M. & Kowalski, K. Enhancing views of competence (Ch. 5) and Selekman, M. D. Solution-oriented brief therapy with difficult adolescents (Ch. 6). In Friedman, S. (Ed.), The new language of change: Constructive collaboration in psychotherapy. New York: Guilford. Fllaskas, C. (1997). Engagement and the therapeutic relationship in systemic therapy. Journal of Family Therapy, 25(3), 189-195. Franklin, C. & Jordan, C. (1995). Clinical Assessment for Social Workers. Chicago: Lyceum. Frederickson, J. (1999). Psychodynamic Psychotherapy. Philadelphia: Brunner Mazel. Goldstein, E. G. (1995). Ego psychology and social work practice (Ch. 3,4, 7, 8). New York: Free Press. Harris, M., & Bergman, H. (1987). Case Management with the Chronically Mentally Ill. Clinical Perspective. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 57 (2), 296-301. Hartman, C., & Reynolds, D. (1987). Resistant clients: Confrontation, interpretation and alliance. Social Casework, 86(4), 205-213. Henry, W. & Strupp, H. (1994). The Therapeutic Alliance as Interpersonal Process. In The Working Alliance: theory, research, and practice. New York: John Wiley. Imber-Black, E. (1997). Developing Cultural Competence: contributions from recentfamily therapy. American Journal of Psychotherapy, 51 (4), 607-610. Jackson, L. C. (2000).The new multiculturalism and psychodynamic theory (ch. 1) & Shorter-Gooden, K. & Jackson, L. C. The interweaving of cultural and intrapsychic issues in the therapeutic relationship (Ch. 2). In L. C. Jackson & B. Greene Psychotherapy with African-American women: Innovations in psychodynamic perspectives and practice. New York: Guilford Jongsma & Peterson. (1995). The Psychotherapy Treatment Planner. New York: John Wiley and Sons. Kottler, J. A. (1993). Personal and professional lives (ch. 3). In On being a therapist. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. 221 LeCroy, C. (2000). Case Studies in Social Work Practice. Pacific Grove: Brooks/Cole. Lewis, J., Dana, R., & Blevins, G. (2000). Substance Abuse Counseling. Pacific Grove: Brooks/Cole. Mahler, M., Pine, F., and Bergman, A. (1975). The Psychological Birth of the Human Infant. New York. Basic books. McGoldrick, M., (2002). Using Genograms to Map Family Patterns. In The Social Workers’ Desk Reference. New York: Oxford University Press. Mishna, F. et al. (2002). Social work with clients contemplating suicide: Complexity and ambiguity in the clinical ethical and legal considerations. The Clinical Social Work Journal, 30 (3). Morrow, D. (2000). Coming Out to Families: Guidelines for Intervention with Gay and Lesbian Clients. Journal of Family Social Work, 5(2), 53-63 Norcross, J., & Goldfried, M. Eds. (2005). Handbook of Psychotherapy Integration (2ndEd.) New York: Oxford University Press. Proctor, K., & Davis, L. (1994). The Challenge of Racial Differences: Skills for Clinical Practice. Social Work 39, 314-323. Reid, T. (1999). A cultural perspective on resistance. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration, 9(1) 57-81. Roberts, A. & Greene, C. (2000). The Social Workers’ Desk Reference. New York:Oxford University Press. Sharf, R.S. (2000). Theories of psychotherapy and counseling. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth. Siegel, D. (1999). Chapter 1: Introduction: Mind, brain, and experience. In The Developing Mind: How relationships and the brain interact to shape who we are. Gilford Press. Singer, E. (1994). Key Concepts in Psychotherapy. Northvale: Jason Arson, Inc. Turner, F.J. (Ed.) (1996). Social Work Treatment. New York: The Free Press. Werner-Wilson, R. J. et al. (1999). Is therapeutic alliance influenced by a feminist approach to therapy. Contemporary family therapy, 21(4). Pp. 545-550. 222 Winnicott, D. W. (1975). Collected Papers: From Pediatrician to psychoanalyst. New York: Basic Books. Wolberg, L.R. (1995). The Technique of Psychotherapy. Northvale: Jason Aronson. Wolfe, J.L. & Fodor, I. G. (1996). The poverty of privilege: Therapy with women of the “upper” classes. Women and Therapy, 18, 73-89. Woods, M.E. & Hollis, F. (5th Ed.) (2000). Casework: A psychosocial Therapy. Boston: McGraw-Hill. Zimmerman, J. & Dickerson, V. (1996). If problems talked: Adventures in narrative therapy. New York: Guilford Press. 223