Periodic Table Unit Plan Inclusive Curriculum Planning/602A Sophie Wilson Spring 2014 Introduction This unit plan is about the Periodic Table of Elements. It is a tabular arrangement of chemical elements based on the configuration of valence electrons, which are the electrons in the outer most shell, and based on chemical properties that periods and groups of elements have in common. There is a plethora of information that can be acquired through the study of the periodic table, and that information is invaluable in the study of Chemistry. This unit would take place in a mid-level Chemistry course that has approximately 50 minute long classes. It would be taking place in a high school setting for 11th grade students. These students have had Physical Science and Biology in the past, and have seen the Periodic Table but do not know how to ‘read it.’ This unit is not only important for the study of Chemistry, but it also is what got me interested in Chemistry. I chose this unit because I think this is the unit where a student can start to really understand the impact elements have on the world, since they make up everything. Stage One – Desired Results Established Goals/Standards HS-PS 1-1. Use the periodic table as a model to predict the relative properties of elements based on the patterns of electrons in the outermost energy level of atoms. RST.9-10.7 Translate quantitative or technical information expressed in a text into visual form (e.g. a table or chart) and translate information expressed visually or mathematically (e.g., in an equation) into words. Student Understandings The organization of the Periodic Table is intentional and much can be learned from the arrangement of elements. Families of elements have characteristic properties based on their atomic structures. The reactivity and stability of elements are related to their atomic structure including alkali metals, halogens, and noble gases. Many elements have isotopes and the existence of isotopes affect the atomic mass of that element. Electronegativity of an atom is determined by valence shell electrons. Essential Questions How are the trends seen in the Periodic Table evident in day to day life? How does the reactivity of elements affect our environment? What influence has the Periodic Table had on history and technology? Students Know… The atomic number is used to find the number of electrons, protons, and neutrons an atom of an element has. The reactivity and stability trends when going top to bottom and left to right on the Periodic Table. The reasons behind the structure of the Periodic Table. That an isotope is a different form of an element, and they are the reason atomic masses aren’t whole numbers. The valence shell of electrons determines the reactivity, stability, and electronegativity of an atom. Students Can… Determine an element based on the number of neutrons or protons given. Name the first elements based on their atomic symbol. Discuss the reactivity, stability, and electronegativity of a given element based off information about its valence shell electrons. Determine if an element is an alkali metal, halogen, or noble gas and name some characteristics of elements in these families by looking at the Periodic Table. Stage Two: Performance Task (Explanation and Interpretation): You have been working as a chemist for years and you have discovered a new element. Your discovery has become big news in the scientific community and all your fellow scientists are waiting to learn more details about this new element. You are attending a conference in two weeks to present your new element to your professional peers. Your job is to make sure the other scientists attending understand not only what your element is, but also the importance of your element. You will be presenting your element to your fellow scientists in a 3-5 minute presentation, which must include a visual component (PowerPoint, Prezi, physical model, interpretive dance, etc.). This presentation is to prove to your fellow scientists that your discovery is the most important to the scientific community. By including accurate, interesting, and relevant facts your presentation will shine above all others. Your presentation must include the following information: Number of electrons, and their configuration o What do the valence electrons imply for the electronegativity of your element? Number of protons and neutrons Atomic mass o Are there isotopes for your element? What are they? Reactivity of your element Stability of your element The family your element falls into Where your element belongs on the Periodic Table as well as the reasons behind the placement. Evidence of how elements are used in the body, medicine, or healthcare. Description of what your element looks like o What is its natural state (liquid, gas, solid)? GRASPS: G: Your job is to make sure the other scientists attending understand not only what your element is, but also the importance of your element. R: You have been working as a chemist for years and you have discovered a new element. Your discovery has become big news in the scientific community and all your fellow scientists are waiting to learn more details about this new element. You are attending a conference in two weeks to present your new element to your professional peers. A: Your fellow scientists at a scientific conference. S: This presentation is to prove to your fellow scientists that your discovery is the most important to the scientific community. By including accurate, interesting, and relevant facts your presentation will shine above all others. P: A 3-5 minute presentation, which must include a visual component (PowerPoint, Prezi, physical model, interpretive dance, etc.). S: Your presentation must include the following information: Number of electrons, and their configuration o What do the valence electrons imply for the electronegativity of your element? Number of protons and neutrons Atomic mass o Are there isotopes for your element? What are they? Reactivity of your element Stability of your element The family your element falls into Where your element belongs on the Periodic Table as well as the reasons behind the placement. Evidence of how elements are used in the body, medicine, or healthcare. Description of what your element looks like o What is its natural state (liquid, gas, solid)? Other Evidence: End of unit short answer test Entry tickets at the beginning of every day’s class. “But…what is it?” Lab o Students are provided with beakers with multiple samples of elements. They must determine what each element is using their senses and approved lab procedures. Popcorn games o Focusing on atomic symbols Quick write about the essential questions at the end of the unit. Rubric: Excellent All of the required information is present. All facts are accurate and demonstrate a strong understanding of the Periodic Table. The visual component enhances the presentation and is engaging. Good Most required information is present. Adequate Some required information is present Insufficient Little required information is present. All facts are accurate and demonstrate some understanding of the Periodic Table. The visual component enhances the presentation but is not engaging. A number of facts are inaccurate and do not demonstrate an understanding of the Periodic Table. No visual component is present. Presentation Presentation is 35 minutes long and portrays all the information. Presentation is 35 minutes long and portrays most information. Proof of Importance A convincing argument is made as to the importance of this element. A good argument is made as to the importance of the element. Most facts are accurate and demonstrate some understanding of the Periodic Table. The visual component is present but does not enhance the presentation and is not engaging. Presentation is 12 minutes long or more than 5 minutes and portrays some information. An argument is made as to the importance of the element. Required Information Information Accuracy Visual Component Presentation is less than 1 minute and very little information is portrayed. No argument is made as to the importance of the element. Stage Three: Learning Plan Monday (A) Tuesday (A) Wednesday (A) Thursday (M) Friday (M) 1. Do now activity: Students list 5 things that are periodic and what property causes them to be periodic. 2. Discuss answers 3. Periodic Table of Humanity: Students choose 5 characteristics that describe themselves (eyes, hair, height, noses, dress, weight, etc.). Then I will group them together and they will collect information regarding the other students based on their 5 characteristics. Then they will construct a chart/table to arrange students based on similarities/differences. 4. Discuss class charts 5. Creating a Periodic Table activity (see attached) 1. Do now activity: What do you know about the Periodic Table? 2. History Lecture about the Periodic Table and the problems surrounding its creation. 3. Teach Chemical Symbols for the 55 elements that they will need to know by the end of the unit. Also give them mnemonics to help remember some of the tough ones (‘A U want some gold?’, ‘PB and Lead’, ‘Tin Snips’). 1. Do now activity: Why is the Periodic Table laid out the way it is? 2. Give students their copies of the Periodic Table. 3. Walk students through the different groups/families in the Periodic Table, having them color in the correct row/column as I lecture about them. 4. In small groups have students list ways in which elements are used in our lives, follow with class discussion. 5. Lecture about metals, non-metals, and metalloids. 7. Introduce Chemical Element project. 1. Do now activity: Thinkpair-share about uses of Al, Cl, and Si and then share their ideas with a partner. 2. But…What is it? Lab: Students have a variety of samples of elements (including, Al, Ni,Si, S, and Zn) and will be attempting to determine what each sample is through testing their physical and chemical properties. 3. Come back together as a class and discuss what was observed. 1. Do now activity: Quiz 2. Watch “Atoms and their Electrons” video. Structured notes handout will be given to students and will be checked at the end of the video. 3. Throughout the video, stop it and have students identify which elements belong in the family being discussed. Monday (M, T) 1. Do now activity: What would happen if Carbon disappeared from the universe tomorrow? What would happen if Francium disappeared from the universe tomorrow? 2. Student time in computer lab to work on presentations. Tuesday (A) 1. Do now activity: Have the students sketch the trends they predict for reactivity/stability on a picture of the Periodic Table. 2. Reactivity and Stability Lecture 3. Reactivity videos Wednesday (T) Thursday (M) 1. Do now activity: What chemical element do you think is the most important, and why? 2. Chemical Element Presentations 3. Exit Ticket: After all the presentations, what chemical element do you think is the most important, and why? 1. Do now activity: Students will write down at least one question/topic they still have questions about. 2. Test Review using Popcorn Game 3. Will give students a fillin-the-blank study guide which will be scaffolded based on student-need. Friday (T) 1. Do now activity: quick write answering essential questions 2. Short answer test. Lesson Overview Title of Unit Subject area Grade level Duration of unit Unit Description Unit goals (Standards) Knowledge & Skills Periodic Table Chemistry High School (10th-11th grade most likely) 2 weeks This unit plan is about the Periodic Table of Elements. It is a tabular arrangement of chemical elements based on the configuration of valence electrons, which are the electrons in the outer most shell, and based on chemical properties that periods and groups of elements have in common. There is a plethora of information that can be acquired through the study of the periodic table, and that information is invaluable in the study of Chemistry. HS-PS 1-1. Use the periodic table as a model to predict the relative properties of elements based on the patterns of electrons in the outermost energy level of atoms. RST.9-10.7 Translate quantitative or technical information expressed in a text into visual form (e.g. a table or chart) and translate information expressed visually or mathematically (e.g., in an equation) into words. Students Know… The atomic number is used to find the number of electrons, protons, and neutrons an atom of an element has. The reactivity and stability trends when going top to bottom and left to right on the Periodic Table. The reasons behind the structure of the Periodic Table. That an isotope is a different form of an element, and they are the reason atomic masses aren’t whole numbers. The valence shell of electrons determines the reactivity, stability, and electronegativity of an atom. Students Can… Determine an element based on the number of neutrons or protons given. Name the first elements based on their atomic symbol. Discuss the reactivity, stability, and electronegativity of a given element based off information about its valence shell electrons. Determine if an element is an alkali metal, halogen, or noble gas and name some characteristics of elements in these families by looking at the Periodic Table. Lesson Third day of the unit where students will be learning about the groups and families on a Periodic Table, and Description/Overview the relationships between elements in these groups/families. for the Day Pre-lesson Assumptions These students have had Physical Science and Biology in the past, and have seen the Periodic Table but do not know how to ‘read it.’ They have also had lessons so far to learn about periodicity, what it is and how it can be used to create a table of related items. They have also had a lesson on the history of how the Periodic Table was created. They have also been introduced to a number of elements, but do not have much information past what a Chemical Symbol is. Goals Daily Lesson Targets Targeted disability area and key features of disability for UDL application(s) ELL considerations Extension considerations for high achieving students Students will be able to explain, using a Periodic Table, what a group and family are. They will also be able to name the important groups/families as well as their most important common characteristics. Emotional Disability (7.1, 8.3, and 9.1) Students with an inability to develop relationships, have a tendency to isolate themselves, may show pervasive unhappiness, aggression, or fear. These students will need to be given choice, chances for feedback when working towards clear goals, and have them work in groups with responsibilities for each member of the group. There will be a lot of new vocabulary being used during this lesson, the majority of which will be new to all students. Together the class will create a word wall of the new words that come up throughout the lesson. This will be helpful throughout the year, as many of these terms will be used in future units so this word wall will be displayed throughout the rest of the course. Challenge the students to predict which groups/families I am discussing during the first lecture portion before I tell the rest of the students which part of their Periodic Tables to color in. Also, encourage them to pick one of the lesser known elements which will provide more of a challenge to find in-depth research about. Method Lesson Section Description Do Now Activity (3 minutes) Students will answer the question “Why is the Periodic Table laid out the way it is?” This is a review question from the day before. Hook (7 minutes) Give students their own copies of the Periodic Table. Listen to Tom Lehrer’s The Element Song and ASAPScience’s The Periodic Table Song. Lecture about Periodic Table structure (15 minutes) Walk students through the different groups/families in the Periodic Table, having them color in the correct row/column as I lecture about them. Small Group Discussion (10 minutes) In small groups have students list ways in which elements are used in our lives, come back together or a full class discussion POTENTIAL BARRIER FOR LEARNING: The student has challenges with… UDL Principles & Guidelines addressed including rationale for selection Multiple means of Representation Action and Expression Engagement ELL Provide Multiple Means of Representation – 2.1 Clarify vocabulary and symbols Emotional Disability – student has challenges incorporating The vocabulary will be new for all students, as a class we will be creating a word wall that will be posted in the class for the rest of the year. It will be available for students to refer to throughout the subsequent lessons. Provide Multiple Means of Engagement – 8.3 Foster collaboration and community During this exercise, students will each themselves into the class Lecture about metals, non-metals, and metalloids. (10 minutes) Introduce Chemical Element Project (10 minutes) Discuss the differences between metals, non-metals, and metalloids on the Periodic Table. Introduce the project. Walk through the directions and the rubric. Let students pick which element they are interested in researching. ELL be given a role to play in the group. By giving the students responsibility, it will encourage their participation in the activity and will help garner a sense of belonging with their peers. Provide Multiple Means of Representation – 2.1 Clarify vocabulary and symbols The vocabulary will be new for all students, as a class we will be creating a word wall that will be posted in the class for the rest of the year. It will be available for students to refer to throughout the subsequent lessons. Provide Multiple Means of Engagement – 7.1 Optimize individual choice and autonomy By giving the students a choice for which element they will be researching the students will feel more involved and will have a higher chance at really diving deep into the project. Provide Multiple Means of Engagement – 9.1 Promote expectations and beliefs that optimize motivation I will be providing the students work time the following Monday after assigning this project to work on their presentations in class. I will take this time to give them actionable feedback, both positive and constructive, so they can make any adjustments before receiving their final grade. I will discuss this opportunity for feedback when I introduce the project. Assessment Description Formative/on-going assessment method Summative assessment/closure activity/exit pass I will ask questions throughout the lectures to ensure they class is processing the material. At the end of the class I will point to each group and family on the Periodic Table and have the class tell me what each one is called, I will pay attention to how many students are responding and adjust my plans for the next day accordingly. POTENTIAL BARRIER FOR LEARNING: The student has challenges with… UDL Principles & Guidelines addressed including rationale for selection Multiple means of Representation Action and Expression Engagement Co-Teaching Structure to be used and rationale Structure One Teach and one model Rationale During the first lecture about periods and families, the co-teacher will model which elements will be colored in as we discuss each one. The co-teacher will then lead the metals, non-metals, and metalloids lecture and I will keep an eye out for students who seem confused so we can adjust as necessary the next day. Materials (adaptations and regular materials): Attach Creating a Periodic Table Materials: Prep: For each group of students, assemble a collection of 20 objects (Five sets of four objects) in a bag. Provide a bag containing 19 of these objects. A collection of objects includes sets of coins (penny, nickel, dime, quarter), sets of buttons that are similar but vary in diameter, and washers that vary in diameter. Other objects, such as nuts, bolts, and paper circles will work and are easily obtainable. The difference in masses should be large enough for a beam balance to detect. Ideally, each set (one column on the table) should be of the same material and thickness and vary only in diameter. Each group of students receive: bag of objects 20 squares of paper, each 3x3cm metric balance metric ruler 2 sheets of graph paper Procedure: In this lab students will develop their own classification system for a collection of ordinary objects. They will analyze trends in their system and compare their system with the Periodic Table. 1. Groups will receive a bag of objects. Each bag is missing one item. 2. Instruct the students to examine the items carefully, and identify the missing object. Students will describe the missing object and explain why they believe the object has these characteristics. 3. Lay the paper squares out on the table so that you have a grid of five rows of four squares each. 4. Arrange objects on the grid in a logical order, students will be determining what is logical to them. There will be a blank square for the missing object in the location in the grid where it belongs. In lab journals, students will write a justification to explain their arrangement. 5. 6. Measure the mass (g) and the diameter (mm) of each object, and record results in the appropriate square. Each square (except the empty one) should have one object and two written measurements. 7. Examine arrangement; does the arrangement still make sense? Explain. 8. Rearrange the squares and their objects, if necessary, to improve arrangement. Describe the basis for the new arrangement in lab journals. Working across the rows, number the squares 1 to 20. 9. 10. Copy grid onto a piece of paper. In each square, be sure to list the type of object and label all measurements with appropriate units. 11. Make a graph of mass (y-axis) versus object number (x-axis). Label each axis, and put a title on the graph. 12. Discuss the graph with classmates. Try to identify any important features of the graph. For example, does the graph form a line or a curve? Is there anything unusual about the graph? What do these features tell you? Write answers down 13. Now make a graph of diameter (y-axis) versus object number (x- axis). Repeat step 11. 14. Draw conclusions: How is your arrangement of objects similar to the periodic table provided? How is your arrangement different from that periodic table? Look back at your prediction about the missing object. Do you think it is still accurate? Try to improve your description by estimating the mass and diameter of the missing object. Record your estimates. Reflection When I finish writing a unit plan using backwards design I look back and say to myself ‘well, that wasn’t as bad as I thought it was going to be.’ Then I start another unit plan, and say to myself, ‘what was I thinking? I’m never going to finish this!’ But, I eventually finish it, look back on my finished product and am really happy with what I have ended up with. This way of finishing a unit plan makes the most sense to me. Although I can see the temptation to begin planning a lesson based around an activity and trying to make the unit fit around that activity, it just doesn’t make sense for ensuring students walk away with the essential learnings for a lesson or unit. As a whole, this process is one that I want to take the time to walk through with each unit, but that might take me a couple of years. Hopefully the process will become smoother with practice, but until then, I still will be walking through the process step-by-step. The most difficult part of the process is Stage One. It feels like I’m trying to get a boulder rolling, but that bolder is more of a cube than a sphere. I can get it to go, but in big chunks, it doesn’t go smoothly. Unpacking the standards alone could cause me to get tripped up. I start to read too much into the standard, making more work for myself. Once I have unpacked the standards the process through Stage One goes a bit smoother. Having learned the beginning statements for each section (students can do, students will know, etc.) helps me to categorize where each statement belongs. I really enjoy coming up with the essential questions, and am aspiring at this moment to always incorporate essential questions into at least every unit, if not every day’s lesson. I think another reason I have trouble slogging through completing Stage One is that I know it will shape what the rest of my unit will look like. Since it is the all-mighty foundation of the rest of my plan, I want to get it right. I know I can go back and revise it later if I need to, but somehow I still feel like that’s cheating somehow. I thoroughly enjoyed writing Stage Two. I feel like I got a glimpse of the fun-side of teaching, the creative side, and the innovative side. I could really dive deeply into coming up with a performance task that would hit all of my goals of what I was trying to teach the students, but also incorporate some fun into the task as well. Honestly, before learning about the performance task I assumed that most (if not all) of my summative assessments would be tests. That’s usually the procedure for Science classes, lecture, problem sets, test, and repeat. By thinking about how else to summarize my unit, I think I came up with a pretty good summative assessment, but I found myself still thinking I need a test to verify that every student understands the material. I hesitate from using it as the one and only summative assessment for a unit. Stage Three felt like it took forever, but I think that was due to the unit I chose, and not the process itself. For this unit I didn’t have a good idea of how each day would progress. For the previous unit plan I had an idea of what I wanted to do every day before I started working on the learning plan, but for this one I started from scratch. Because of that it felt a little sluggish going through each day’s activities and trying to come up with a cohesive-seeming product. Then, once I finished my learning plan, picking a single day to do my lesson plan focusing on took me a long time. I kept switching which day I wanted to focus on, but I believe the one I ended up with was the most appropriate to work on. Overall, I enjoy working through unit plans using this process, but it still feels cumbersome. I think this will improve with practice, but until then it is still a bit of a tedious process.