London Borough of Waltham Forest Community Ward Forum LEA BRIDGE WARD COMMUNITY WARD FORUM MEETING MINUTES Meeting date: Wednesday 2nd September 2015 Meeting time: 6.30pm-8pm Location: Lea Bridge Library, 382 Lea Bridge Road, Leyton E10 7HU Councillors in attendance: Cllr Masood Ahmad (Chair) Cllr Mohammed Asghar Cllr Yemi Osho Apologies:Lea Bridge SNT Clerk to the Meeting: Amanda Butler 38 Attendees No Item 1. Welcome & Introductions Minutes Cllr Ahmad welcomed residents and introduced Ward Councillors Actions from Carried Forward to next meeting 2nd December 2015. previous minutes 2. Lea Bridge Station Cllr Ahmad gave residents the following update on Lea Bridge Station: Work has started in Lea Bridge Station and it is on target for completion in May 2016 Question: Resident Why will the Station not be completed in November 2015? Answer: Cllr Ahmad There were technical problems which have now been 1 resolved. However, work has now started. Question: Resident Where will the route start and finish? Answer: Cllr Ahmad There will be links from Stratford to Stanstead, including routes from Stratford and Tottenham Question: Resident How much freight will it hold? Answer: Cllr Ahmad I don’t know. However, you are welcome to ask questions at the next Transport Liaison Consultative Committee Meeting which will be held at 7.30pm on 17th November 2015. 3. Lea Valley Regional Park Authority (LVPRA) Alex Farris- Open Spaces Manager and Stephen Wilkinson- Head of Planning and Strategic Partnerships for Lea Valley Regional Park Authority gave the following update for the last 6 months to residents: The LVPRA was established via parliament in 1966. It has been around for 50 years. The LVPRA offers the public different sport facilities and open space In the last year it has been involved with projects at the Olympic venue in Broxbourne The LVPRA has formed a Leisure Trust in October 2014 which has become effective from 1st April 2015.. The main purpose of the Leisure Trust is to manage each of their venues and consists of 50 staff. 320 staff remain with the Authority. This has been a significant change in the way the LVPRA functions. The LVPRA has 14 venues including the Ice Rink 2 and Water Centre Question: Claire Weiss What effect have these changes made on the democratic roles? If the purpose of the Leisure Trust is now income generation, what role does the democratic representative play? Answer: Alex Farris Cllr Gerry Lyons is still Waltham Forest’s representative on the LVRPA and he is still accountable to residents. However the ‘Leisure Trust’ is managed by Trustees. Any improvements have to be funded by LVRPA. The Trustees include individuals who are Councillors or have a Management background. There is a contractual relationship between the Leisure Trust and LVRPA, which includes performance indicators. Question: Claire Weiss Will the LVRPA become completely privatised? Answer: Alex Farris There is a 3 year contractual relationship between the Leisure Trust and the LVRPA, (with a possibility of a 2 year extension). Question: Sheenagh Joseph Does the LVPRA own properties on the Argall Estate? Answer: Alex Farris You are talking about Lea Valley Estate which is different from the LVRPA. We have no relationship with them. Question: Cllr Ahmad Who manages the Horse Riding School? 3 Answer: Stephen Wilkinson The Leisure Trust. Stephen Wilkinson gave the following update on Walthamstow Marshes There have been 2 serious safety issues in the summer relating to Walthamstow Marshes LVRPA have been working in partnership with Police on incidents. There have been no arrests regarding these incidents, to date. However there have been no incidents reported since. LVRPA are in discussions with Police about long term solutions. There is a risk linked with open spaces which has to be managed effectively and within the nature conservation parameters. It is important to get that balance. However, the LVRPA has been pro-active in this regard and have conducted extra patrols Question: Resident What will be the long term solutions in relation to Walthamstow Marshes? Answer: Stephen Wilkinson We are working on it Question: Resident There was a reported death on Walthamstow Marsh Answer: Stephen Wilkinson That was an unrelated to any use of the Marsh. There was no criminal element to it. Question: Resident What about cyclist’s muggings? Answer: Stephen Wilkinson I am not aware of that issue. However, the Police should be aware of that 4 Question: Resident Can you tell us the Leisure Trust’s programme? Answer: Stephen Wilkinson They are based at the Waterworks Centre on Lammas Road. Residents can contact the following e-mail address to make enquiries about programme of events:ghoddinott@leevalleypark.org.uk Ice Rink Alex Farris gave an update to residents on the Lea Valley Ice Rink The Ice Rink has been in Waltham Forest for 30 years There are 300,000 people who use the ice rink It is opened for 19 hours a day The LVRPA is conducting a project to look at the following options for the ice rink:- 1. Expanding and improving the Ice Rink 2. Build an additional Ice Rink 3. Find a new venue for the Ice Rink around the LVRPA other locations The project will involve looking at planning and transport issues A feasibility study will be conducted and the recommendations will be put forward in the next phase, which involves consulting with the community It is a big project for the LVRPA 5 Question: Claire Weiss Can you tell us the timescale of the project? There are also the following issues to consider: Impact on the existing Traffic on Lea Bridge Road If you opt to build an additional ice rink, this will take up part of the Greenspace. It should remain open land The best option would be to find a location in the Olympic Park because it already has a car park Question: Resident Can the document containing the LVRPA options be sent to the Friends of Walthamstow? Answer: Stephen Wilkinson Yes Question: Resident Will it be kept as a sports facility, regardless? Answer: Alex Farris I can’t answer that. It will be looked at Question: Cllr Ahmad We don’t want to lose a sports facility Question: Shabaz Hussain-Young Advisor I think that the Ice Rink is brilliant. Waltham Forest does not have many facilities available for young people. If we lose our Ice Rink, it will only deter people from coming to the Borough. Building an additional ice rink is a brilliant idea Answer: Alex Farris The Project Team will be discussing the options Question: Rev Maria Holmden Is it possible to consult residents during your feasibility study? 6 Answer: Alex Farris We need to scope it as a viable idea and explore the funding possibilities. There will be nothing to consult at that stage Question: Rev Maria Holmden You have already heard the views expressed at this meeting. I think it would be useful to consult during the feasibility study Answer: Alex Farris There will be ample opportunity to consult after the feasibility study Question: Claire Weiss Can you feedback and ask your Project Team to conduct a local consultation during the feasibility study? Answer: Alex Farris There will not be anything to consult on until a decision is made as to whether the option is viable or not Answer: Cllr Osho Who are your core customers? Residents use the Ice Rink. Can I suggest that a copy of the minutes be sent to the LVRPA via Cllr Gerry Lyons in order for the suggestions to be used in your feasibility study Comment: Resident Members of the public can attend LVRPA public meetings. If a member of the public wants to speak about an item on the Agenda, then they can arrange this with the LVRPA beforehand. 7 Answer: Alex Farris Yes that is correct. The meetings are held at Middleton House in North Enfield and some are held at the Water Works Centre in Lammas Rd. There are 2 planning Committees. Action: Clerk to refer to Community Development Team Lead Team: Community Development Team Copy of minutes to be sent via Cllr Gerry Lyons to LVRPA in order for suggestions to be considered in feasibility study 4. Mini-Holland Project Ian Killingbeck gave the following update on the MiniHolland Project:Public Consultation has been conducted in the following areas of Lea Bridge Road:Section A- Borough boundary with Hackney to the Lammas Road Junction The consultation period was conducted between June to July 2015 and has now been completed Section H- Whipps Cross Roundabout The consultation period was conducted between June to July 2015 and has now been completed Results Overall, the results for Section A and H have shown a great deal of support for the proposals for public space and road improvements in both areas, which will now be implemented 8 Concerns There were concerns raised regarding on-going maintenance in Pubic Space Question: Resident I am concerned with the Whipps Cross and Wood Street junction Answer: Ian Killingbeck The Council will be sending out 30,000 consultation letters to households and feedback will be going to Cabinet The Remaining Areas on Lea Bridge Road We are working on the detail for the remaining areas on Lea Bridge Road. The consultation will be conducted mid October/November 2015. We will be running a number of drop in sessions, which will provide residents with an opportunity to have their say. We will also be offering ‘walk and talk tours’ which will provide residents with an opportunity to accompany architects on these tours and suggest improvements on Public Realm. The dates of the ‘walk and talk tours’ are 19th & 20th September 2015. Church Road The consultation for this area has already been completed Results There were great support for the plans Concerns Residents suggested improving the safety along the Road. The results and concerns will be fed back to residents Question: Sylvia Sullivan You say you have received support, how much support was received? Answer: Ian Killingbeck 9 Over 50%. There were 13,000 consultations delivered of which we received 250 responses. Of the 250 responses, over 50% were in favour of the plans Question: Resident I have to park my car miles away because of the safety issues on Lea Bridge Road. There is a safety hazard when crossing Lea Bridge Road because of the closed side Roads. Answer: Ian Killingbeck We want to manage that Question: Cllr Ahmad There are traffic issues on Lea Bridge Road Question: Resident How are you going to address it? Question: Cllr Ahmad Ian, can I suggest that you attend our next meeting on 2 nd December 2015 and show a presentation to residents on the plans and proposals Question: Resident You need to look at our concerns Answer: Ian Killingbeck We want to encourage people to cycle and walk Question: Sheenagh Joseph What’s happening to the Markhouse/Lea Bridge Road junction Answer: Ian Killingbeck The Markhouse Road junction is terrible. The Mini-Holland Project aims to make it safe. Improvements will be made for pedestrians 10 Question: Resident You need to look for alternative Roads which would be available to run parallel to Lea Bridge Road Answer: Cllr Ahmad Any concerns regarding the Mini Holland Project, please email miniholland@walthamforest.gov.uk Answer: Ian Killingbeck Please feed into the consultations Question: Cllr Ahmad How will the Bus lane space on Lea Bridge Road be improved? There are some patches of Lea Bridge Road where there is NO bus lane or cycle lane Answer: Ian Killingbeck We are working on it Answer: Cllr Ahmad We will invite you to speak some more about the Mini Holland Project at the next CWF meeting on 2nd December 2015 5. CPZ Iain Hastings-Traffic Manager gave the following update on CPZs to residents: The will be CPZ Zones implemented in the Theydon Street E17 Area. The Theydon St area includes Wetherden St , Sybourn Rd and Hibbert Rd The Council distributed 570 households in the area ,with consultation leaflets on the CPZ plans Results:-130 responses. 76% were in favour of CPZ zones Based on the results, the Council agreed to proceed with the proposals 11 Residents will be notified shortly with the results of the consultation The CPZ zones will be implemented in December 2015 Question: Resident Is there a need for a second consultation because of the shortfall of responses? Answer: Cllr Ahmad No Question: Resident Residents who live in Lea Bridge Road was told that they could not buy permits because they do not reside in the CPZ area Question: Resident Two shops on Lea Bridge Road (who were outside of the CPZ area) were able to buy permits for the side roads which were in the CPZ zone. Question: Resident The common theme that is being discussed is consultation. The Council have a list of every resident who is registered to vote. Why is this information not utilised for sending out consultations? Answer: Cllr Ahmad Consultations are based on households Question: Resident Are the consultations in other languages apart from English? Answer: Iain Hastings They are in English 12 Question: Rev Maria Holmden Why can’t there be a ticket machine available for motorists to buy parking tickets (for a restricted period of time) and display in their vehicles? This could bring revenue into the Council. A similar scheme operates in Redbridge where motorists are allowed to park free for 30 minutes. This would assist residents and businesses. Answer: Iain Hastings Residents do not want people to park in their roads. It depends on the length of the roads Answer: Rev Maria Holmden It would only be for a short period of time Question: Resident Do you have any plans to implement CPZ zones in Vicarage Rd, Manor Rd and Malta Rd areas? I have to park on other Roads. There is a petition to the Council to implement CPZ zones in these areas Answer: Iain Hastings The CPZ programme is based on the requests from resident’s complaints from the previous year. If a petition has been submitted, an Officer will look into it 6. Youth Engagement Action: Ian Hastings to Lead Team: Highways look into implementing ticket machines Jane Brueseke- Project Officer for Youth Engagement was accompanied by the Council’s Young Advisors:- Shabaz Hussain, Xhavit Hoxhaj, Danyal Adam Hussain, Luke and Salma Jane Brueseke gave the following update on Youth Engagement to residents: Jane Brueseke manages two Youth Engagement Groups :-The Young Advisors Group and the Youth Independent Advisory Group The groups consist of 60 young people who all live in the Borough and include young people who are able bodied and who have disabilities 13 They work in partnership with the Youth Offending Service The Home Office has cited Waltham Forest as having strong Youth Engagement The groups remit involves Peer training, being positive role models and educating young people on stop and search rights The Young People are all trained when recruited Young Advisors have worked with the following organisations to contribute the voice of young people:- 1. Accident & Emergency Department at Whipps Cross 2. William Morris Gallery 3. Libraries 4. MP Stella Creasy in relation to promoting Sexual Education in schools 5. Helping and advising on transport and health issues 6. Sit on interview panels e.g. The recruitment of the Director of Children and Families 7. Mystery Shopping in Pharmacies selling condoms to young people The Young Advisors have won lots of awards. Last week, they won 3 awards including 1 Award for the Best Young Advisor of the Year! Cllr Osho approached the Youth Engagement Service and asked how they can contribute to the Lea Bridge Ward. She attended a Young Advisors meeting and suggestions were made for the Young Advisors to focus on Careers and Employment for young people The residents and attendees were asked if Lea Bridge CWF were willing to commission the Young Advisors to conduct a project into schools within the Lea Bridge Ward by engaging with young people on Career Opportunities in the Health Service and connecting local people to local jobs Young Advisor- Shabaz Hussain suggested an additional project (from any under spend of the 14 CWF funding). The suggested project is a Gardening Club in the gardens of Lea Bridge Library. The Gardening Club would contribute to Community Cohesion and the well being of the Local Community Question: Resident Could they attend Church Youth Groups Answer: Jane Brueseke They would have to be Commissioned Question: Resident Have you visited schools in the ward? Answer: Shabaz Hussain Yes, Kelmscott School and Lammas School Question: Cllr Osho Youth Advisors are asking the CWF if they would support the suggested Project in Schools. They would be engaging with schools in the Lea Bridge Ward. I think it is a fantastic opportunity. Also the suggestion of a Gardening Club at the gardens behind Lea Bridge Library would be a good opportunity to attract support from the National Garden scheme and show case our Garden. Do residents support the funding ideas? Question: Resident How much would it cost? Answer: Jane Brueseke It depends on the project you would like to support Answer: Cllr Osho If you decide on the Project in Schools within the ward, it will involve going into schools and conducting a Career Development Project. They will organise focus groups and work experience for students 15 Question: Resident How many schools do we have in our ward? Answer: Shabaz Hussain 3 Question: Resident I think community engagement is a good idea Question: Resident I think it is a great idea Answer: Cllr Ahmad We will support the project 7. 8. Safer Neighbourhood Team Update Primary Care Update Lea Bridge SNT sent their apologies Carl Edmonds , CCG (Clinical Commission Group) representative attended the meeting. The CCG’s remit includes the following: Planning Element Hospital Services Mental Health Primary Care/GP Access-(from April 2015) Carl Edmonds gave the following responses to questions posed by attendees at the last Community Ward Forum meeting held on 3rd June 2015: Question How much are the CCG spending on the Polyclinic? How many patients are being treated at the 16 Responses/Comments The polyclinic isn’t commissioned as an entity and doesn’t have a contract as such, therefore the CCG has inherited a building called a polyclinic rather than a service which delivers what polyclinics were supposed to deliver. The Walk in Centre service provided at Orient Practice is a financial value of over £400k and sees 13,000 people each year. It is Polyclinic? open 8-8pm 7 days a week. Transport access to the Polyclinic is restricted and problematic. It is not open at weekends or evenings why? The Walk In Centre is open 7 days a week, 8-8pm 7 days a week. Patients can use the extended service outside of these hours (see below). Can there be alternative GP access available in the Lea Bridge ward? Extended GP Service - For extended opening hours information please contact 0208 519 3999. Service is open at weekends In LL service is based in: Staff will not do dressing for patients at polyclinic why? District nurses are refusing to conduct care in the community why? How many GP’s are employed in Waltham Forest? How many locums are employed in Waltham Forest? How are you ensuring that there are enough good doctors with 17 Triangle House, Harrow Rd GP Practice 2-8 Harrow Road, Leytonstone E11 3QF In Walthamstow: The St James Practice, 47 St James Street, Walthamstow E17 7NH Information is also available on NHS choices Practices can do some routine dressing. For specialist support or home service, the GP can refer to the community wound care service. District Nurses work in the community, they will assess whether or not someone needs a home visit or a clinic visit at times, and we would support that as commissioners. 118 GPs 164 SL (Salaried, Locums, Trainees etc.) We are developing a quality dashboard that will measure how well practices are performing on important measures such as the growing population? Good doctors GP’s are full- what is the alternative? What is the action plan for patients who cancel appointments? Why are GPs not open at weekends and evenings? How will GPs use nurses and other health workers to share the workload? immunisations and Friends and Family Test (FFT). We currently don’t deal with GPs as individual performers (NHSE do this). We are keen to hear from patients to help us improve services. FFT is monitored monthly, we are piloting Kiosks and commissioning National Patient Association to help develop Practice Participation Groups. Booking and cancelling appointments should be available on line. Text reminders from practices – 2way response available for patients from 1st October 2015. Video conferencing consultations to be available for a cohort of patients (pilot underway for Diabetes) We don’t have a policy for addressing people who ‘continually’ DNA but I have fed this into the Regional strategy development team. We now have an extended hours service which is provided from 3 locations in WF. This provides all core primary medical care to all patients registered with a WF GP. The service will also be able to provide practice nurse appointments over a phased period We have a strategy going to our Governing Body in October that focuses on how we will improve the way we work with Nurses 1) Recruitment 2) Retention and 3) Development. We will identify incentives (eg career development pathways and financial. We will involve nurses more in clinical leadership. Medical Records GPs have access to patient’s summary records- not full records. GPs need to ask if it is ok to access records 18 Question: Resident Can you change GPs? Answer: Carl Edmonds Yes. We are developing score cards for GPs. We monitor GP’s by asking residents if they would recommend their GPs to friends and family. There are also Computer Kiosks available to patients to gather patient’s experience of their GP’s The Waltham Forest Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) is holding their Annual General Meeting on Thursday 10th September 2015 at Walthamstow Assembly Hall. Residents are welcome to attend Question: Claire Weiss What is the CCG’s approach on ghost practices? The GP at the Vicarage Road Practice has been absent for a long period of time. Patients are receiving a service from a Locum Answer: Carl Edmonds The CCG do not deal with individual Practices. NHS England would look into that. The CCG looks into the quality of care delivered by Practices. We want to phase out single handed GP Practices Question: Cllr Ahmad When Boundary Rd Practice closed down, there was no information on the door informing residents Answer: Carl Edmonds The Boundary Rd Practice was closed because the CQC (Care Quality Commission) took action because of a breach of quality care. This happened in 24 hours. I thought there was information provided on the door of the premises. Question: Resident Practices are now providing a texting and text back service 19 to patients. This will come into effect in October 2015 Answer: Carl Edmonds The Primary Care Strategy is being developed and includes improvements in: Booking Appointments by phone and online from April 2015 3 GP Practices being piloted for weekend Service Communication by Practices via text Will be conducting a Skype pilot to patients Question: Resident Can we have a Clinic situated in Lea Bridge Road? Answer: Carl Edmond We will look into it Question: Cllr Ahmad The Lea Bridge Ward is the most deprived ward in Waltham Forest. We need more Health Services Question:Cllr Osho With the Lea Bridge Station due to open, there will be more people in the area. There are also plans for more property development in the area which will also have an impact on the need for more Health Services. Question: Resident What are your plans for maternity provision in Waltham Forest? Answer: Carl Edmonds The CCG are looking into having more community midwives We want each Practice to implement Patients Participation Group and we are working with the National Patients Association in relation to this 20 Healthwatch leaflets are also available at this evening’s meeting 9. Any Other Business Comment: Claire Weiss You are invited to celebrate the life of Katy Andrews who was an Activist for Walthamstow & Leyton Marshes and attended many CWF meetings. Katy sadly passed away recently. She will be very much missed. The Celebration of her life will be held on Wednesday 23rd September 2015 at 6.30pm on the boundary of Walthamstow and Leyton Marshes Question: Resident Can we have reduce the items on the Agenda to 2 topics in the future because of time constraints Comment: Resident There is a Facebook page for Lea Bridge and Markhouse residents. Please visit the page. Details of Community Ward Forum meetings are posted on the page Question: Resident When will the SNT attend a meeting? Answer: Cllr Ahmad The Ward Panel Meeting will be held on 9th September at 7pm at Lea Bridge Library. The meeting will be focused on SNT issues. Meeting Ends: 8.35pm Date of Next CWF meeting: Wednesday 2nd December 2015 at 6.30pm to 8.30pm at Lea Bridge Library, 382 Lea Bridge Rd E10 7HU 21