Botswana climate change policy & strategy and action plan development process Thematic working group background paper 7 November 2013 Ecosystem Services and Wildlife, Tourism Given the variable nature of Botswana’s rainfall, and aridity, the country has a very fragile ecosystem and is very vulnerable to the impacts of climate change. Ecosystem services are made up of four categories, namely (Shackleton et al, 2008); Supporting services –services necessary for the production of all other ecosystems e.g. biodiversity and nutrient dispersal Provisioning services- products obtained from ecosystem e.g. fodder and water Regulating services - benefits obtained from ecosystem e.g. soil fertility and water purification Cultural services – non material benefits from ecosystem e.g. spirituality and culture Tourism in Botswana does contribute significantly to the country’s GDP and has a potential in job creation and poverty alleviation in rural areas. Wildlife contributes considerably to the country’s GDP in a form of wildlife-based tourism. This practice is considered as the most appealing form of land use in the country (Moswete and Dube,n.d). Wildlife is also the major attraction for tourism in the country. drivers, pressure, state, impact and response Impacts and responses to climate change The impact of global warming and climate change on Botswana results in multiple pressure on key sectors such as wildlife, tourism and biodiversity. ecosystems A further generally, refinement of and the (DPSIR) of global warming and climate on Botswana will need to be undertaken. The assessment(s) must include current and future impacts of human activities on the capacity of ecosystems to meet present and future needs. Such an assessment must also include a systematic refinement of indicators. Table: Possible activities to further refine the DPSIR for climate change on Botswana ecosystems, wildlife and tourism Possible indicators Drivers: Possible activities Land use change; climate change; Develop scenarios of major drivers of change (changes in rainfall/temperature) Pressure Pressures (on major land cover Define major drivers of environmental change at catchment types & uses, forcing factors, population projections) State and sub-catchment levels Identify regional level ecosystem contributions to livelihood systems Condition/state (land cover, Analyze the interrelationships between the ecological, forest and soil carbon, water supply & quality, climate data, climate and socio-economic systems in the basin, including current and future climate adverse impacts of land degradation and climatic extremes (through integrated assessment and modeling) variability and characteristics) Build capacities of southern African individuals and Impact Impacts of land use change Responses Responses and policy options organizations in ecosystem assessments (with stakeholder groups The Government of Botswana is putting in Overall, the number of warm spells is place deliberate efforts to intensify education likely to increase in the region, with a and awareness on tourism and to accelerate decrease in the extremely cold days. the sector’s contribution in the diversification Climate scenarios point to drying in of the economy. Total investment projects in western parts of southern Africa, with this in greater drying of the range of 30 to 2009/10 and 2010/11 financial years on sector amounted to P22 million 40% throughout the winter season, several projects including access roads; land June to August, has particularly been bank; ecotourism and other. noted. Wildlife resources and the wetland The Okavango delta, which is the and major source of surface water in the rangeland ecosystems that support them are country and supports a variety of life, threatened by conflict arising from pressure from livestock grazing, arable agriculture and has been reported to be drying up During the rainfall seasons, it is human settlements, wildlife causing damage to expected that there will be a 10–20 % livestock, property, crops or people (NDP 10). increase during the peak rainfall months (December to February), while other Climate change risks Temperature increase and reduced rainfall due to climate change are the basis of arid climate of 2 degrees Celsius and changes in precipitation will range from +/-20% with a It is predicted that climate change will lead to the increased incidence of both floods and drought. The vast savannah vegetation is changing to a composition of more ‘thorny/spine’ trees and shrubs. Other risks include; fires, presence of alien invasive species, pests, fuel wood harvesting, 2010).Projected climate changes in the country Rainy seasons will be shorter and less low rates of groundwater recharge. bias towards less precipitation (World Bank, include (Omari, 2010; Moswete and Dube,n.d): reduced and low, variable rainfall will lead to temperature will increase from 0.5 degrees to over yield reliable. Projected high evaporation Botswana. Projections for Botswana are that by 2030, will rainfall. environmental problems to the already highly vulnerable months habitat destruction and rangeland destruction. wildlife species have shrunk in the past 15 years, reaching in by as much as 95% for ostrich, 90% for wildebeest, 84% for antelope tsessebe and 81% for warthogs and kudus; although others, such as elephants, zebra, remained stable while hippos increased by 6%. Wildlife species loses due to warming and drying of the Kalahari region in the southern Expected impacts and western region of the country. With increase in temperature and reduction in annual rainfall, a variety of problems are most Tourism likely to arise. This section explores the major and Tourism is an increasingly important industry tourism sector is projected to experience in Botswana, accounting for approximately 10% under prolonged impacts of climate change of GDP in 2006. One of the world's unique and are outlined below. ecosystems, the Okavango Delta, is located in impacts that the ecosystem, wildlife Botswana. The country offers excellent game Ecosystem Services viewing and birding both in the Delta and in the Chobe Game Reserve--home to one of the Global warming and climate change will affect largest herds of free-ranging elephants in the major world. tourism attractions such as the Botswana's Central Kalahari Game Okavango Delta that in turn will affect primary Reserve also offers good game viewing and and secondary land productivity and ecosystem some of the most remote and unspoiled services wilderness in southern Africa (www.gov.bw). Water depletion and drought due to reduced rainfall and high evaporation The Tourism Sector is a major contributor to rates the economy. The contribution from this sector Desertification due to overgrazing and continues to grow, making it one of the loss of vegetation important categories of international trade and Floods a Accelerated soil erosion by wind due to payments1. loss of vegetation arrivals into Botswana was about 1.5million in strong contributor The total to the balance international of tourist 2009 and this brought in receipts of more than Wildlife US$700 million (Chidumayo, 2011). Botswana land tenure is categorized into three As global warming and climate change alter main systems: State land (which includes the natural environment and the quality of national and rangeland deteriorates, this then will most wildlife management areas, and all the forest likely lead to a negative impact on wildlife as reserves) which covers 41.8% of Botswana’s the basic resource for tourism. parks, some game reserves total land area. The expected impacts of global warming and Pest outbreaks in combination with vegetation changes will lead to these areas becoming inhabitable for climate change are: Destruction of infrastructure that supports wildlife tourism activities are wild animals. projected due to an increase in extreme Shift in vegetation and loss of endemic weather events such as floods species to less palatable species Land use conflicts and migration Heat stress Invasion of pests and diseases With changes vegetation, in fodder the for composition wildlife livestock animal will be reduced Loss of income due to reduced tourism activities. of and 1UNEP, 2012. Davos Conference on Climate Change and Tourism: Tough Challenges and Major Opportunties. Press Release by UNWTO and UNEP, 01 October, p. 1. Not all change will be negative, thus society should be prepared and made aware of all Empowerment of local conservation institutions. advantages that may arise as a consequence of climate change. Example of such changes may include increase in fresh water fish that will come with an increase in the number of flood events, projected under the impacts of climate Traditional knowledge and skill could play a vital role in planning for adaptation measures, however, due to the rapid development younger generation and change. urbanisation, is Adaptation measures and skills, and there is widespread concern showing less interest in traditional knowledge Botswana has long been exposed to the impact of climate change and a number of adaptation strategies have evolved. Adaptation is necessary to prevent further damage and help communities cope and adapt to the impacts of climate change. The following strategies can help the country adapt to the impact of climate that these practices are slowly disappearing (MEWT, 2007). These changes in interests are also accompanied by changes in life style, beliefs and cultural values. Mitigation measures In Botswana, GHG emissions are negligible, change: and two-thirds of the country is a desert Ecosystem services highest emission of GHG’s in the country, thus, (Omari, 2010). The energy sector has the mitigation analysis should put more emphasis Use alternatives to trees Change composition to preferred plant species Promote the use of biodiversity products such as medicinal plants for income generation on the energy sector. Land use and forestry are largely carbon sinks and the country as a whole is assessed to be a net carbon sink (Wingqvist and Dahlberg, 2008). Mitigation strategy Sustainable use of woodlands Promote and invest in Sustainable Land Management (SLM) Rehabilitation of degraded land Incorporation of local knowledge and Building on indigenous knowledge Afforestation Improving the sustainable management of Promote the conversion of dry pastoral land to plantations, to increase carbon sink Increase carbon capture with improved grazing management of rangelands Wildlife Addressing land degradation and desertification Grazing management control Facilitation of seasonal mobility for wildlife animals. Development and protection of animal the practices into resource management include rangelands. Protection of rangelands from tillage therefore following: should genetic resources Existing coping strategies A set of regulations have been put in place by the government of Botswana in trying to alleviate the impacts of climate change. These regulations are aimed at helping communities Tourism and municipalities adapt, mitigate or eradicate Tourism plays a critical role in the formal and regulations include; informal the economy, in sustaining rural livelihoods and in food security. Enforcement of conservation policies impacts assessment of climate of change. drinking Such water, management of wastewater (reuse and recycling) Integration of environmental issues into national development plans Implementation of Environmental Assessment (SEA) for development in the water sector (Wingqvist and Dahlberg, 2008). References& additional readings 1. Omphile, U.J., Nsoso, S.J., Aganga, A.A., Malope, P., Aganga, A.O., Gopolang, P. (2007). Vulnerability Assessment and Adaptation in the Livestock and Rangelands Sector.United Nations Education training and public awareness Project – Second National Communication to the Research and systematic observation United Nations Framework Conservation on Technology transfer Capacity building Climate Change.Unpublished manuscript. 2. Wingqvist, G. Ö., and Dahlberg, E., (2008). Botswana Environmental and Climate Change Key Questions Analysis. School of business, economics and Identify key relevant policy instruments law.University of Gothenburg. Retrieved from related to this sector? http://www.sida.se/Global/Countries%20and%2 What are the current capacities for climate risk management in this sector? List weaknesses, gaps, and what is missing in terms of CRM in this sector? List the desired capacities for CRM? Which initiatives involved? institutions and and projects existing should be 0regions/Africa/Botswana/Environmental%20pol icy%20brief%20Botswana.pdf 3. MEWT. (2011)Second National Communication to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC).Ministry of Environment, Wildlife and Tourism. Gaborone, Botswana 4. World Bank. (2010). Botswana Climate Variability and Change: Understanding the Risks. Draft Policy Note 5. Omari, K. (2010).Climate Change Vulnerability and Adaptation Preparedness in Southern Africa –A Case Study of Botswana.HeinrichBöllStiftung Southern Africa (HBS). Retrieved from http://www.za.boell.org/downloads/HBF_web_B ots.pdf 6. MEWT, (2007). Botswana biodiversity strategy and action plan. Ministry of Environment, Wildlife and Tourism. Botswana. Retrieved from http://www.cbd.int/doc/world/bw/bw-nbsapv2-p1-en.pdf 7. Moswete, N. N. and Dube, P. O., (No Date). Wildlife-based Tourism and Climate: Potential Opportunities and Challenges for Botswana. Department of Environmental Sciences, University of Botswana. Retrieved from http://www.iipt.org/IIPT%20Book/articles/updat ed_articles/Naomi%20Moswete.Botswana2.pdf 8. Shackleton, C., Shackleton, S., &Gambiza, J. (2008). Links between Ecosystem Services and Poverty Alleviation: Situation analysis for arid and semi-arid lands in southern Africa.