Baker, Colin. A Parents' and Teachers' Guide to Bilingualism. 2nd edition. Clevedon, Boston, Toronto, Sydney: Multilingual Matters LTD, 2000. Print. In pages 105 through 145 in the book, A Parent’ and Teachers’ Guide to Bilingualism, Colin Baker discusses whether bilingual education is a benefit to bilingual students or not. She discusses the different forms of bilingual education that are available to students. She also talks about the benefits and disadvantages of bilingual education depending on whether the students speak a majority or minority language. Ravitch, Diane. "First Teach Them English." New York Times 1997, Web. 14 Feb. 2014. In the article “Frist Teach Them English,” Diane Ravitch discussed the amount of money that the government had put into bilingual education even though they had not seen many positive outcomes. In the article, Ravitch talked about how students need to learn English but not necessarily in school. The author concluded with the thought that all students do need to learn English if they live in America, but they should be learning it outside of school where they use their own money to pay for it. Gunderson, Lee. "The State of the Art of Secondary ESL Teaching and Learning." Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy. (2008): 184. Web. 14 Feb. 2014. The article “The State of the Art of Secondary ESL Teaching and Learning,” written by Lee Gunderson, started with talking about the history of bilingual education. Gunderson went on to discuss the statistics of dropout rates of bilingual students. In conclusion, Gunderson wondered why the United States could send people to the moon, but could not simply fix the graduation rates of bilingual students. Ceglowski, Deborah, Patricia Clark, Yongmei Li, Rebecca Robinson Query. "Hispanic Families' Perspectives on using Bilingual Vocabulary Kit to enhance their Prekindergarten Children's Vocabulary Development." Early Childhood Research & Practice. (2011): n. page. Web. 14 Feb. 2014. The article “Hispanic Families' Perspectives on using Bilingual Vocabulary Kit to enhance their Prekindergarten Children's Vocabulary Development,” by Deborah Ceglowski et al, was a research study that was done to test the effectiveness of English- Spanish vocabulary kits for Spanish speaking families. It reported the parents’ opinions of the kits and how they were helpful to their children. The research study also touched on how learning vocabulary at a young age can help later with school achievement. Calderon, Margarita, Marta Sanchez, Robert Slavin. "Effective Instruction for English Learners." Future of Children. (2011): 103. Web. 14 Feb. 2014. In the article “Effective Instruction for English Learners,” by Margarita Calderon et al, the authors wrote about the increasing amount of bilingual/ non-English speaking students in our public schools. The article discussed how half of our student our student population is not proficient in English. They ended the article by coming up with some instructional strategies to improve bilingual students education. England, Travis W. "Bilingual Education: Lessons from Abroad for America's Pending Crisis." Washington University Law Review. (2009): 1211. Web. 14 Feb. 2014. In the article “Bilingual Education: Lessons from Abroad for America’s Pending Crisis,” by Travis W. England, the author discussed the history of bilingual education and how it was formed. England discussed the politics behind bilingual education, and the impact that politics have on bilingual education. England also touched on the effectiveness of bilingual education in the United States and other countries.