GSP – Spelling & Vocabulary Academic Reporting Verbs Why think about your use of reporting verbs? We use reporting verbs all the time – it’s that he said X..., she told me about Y... We often relate to another person, what someone else has said. The problem happens with our approach to academic written work. - Degree work is supposed to be reasoned, critical, intellectual, informed, and, above all, logical. - Your choice of language gives your reader (your marker) a clear impression of whether you are achieving this. What types of verbs should be avoided in academic written work? What this means in practice is that unless you know the rules of academic style so thoroughly, and have sufficient mastery and experience to be allowed to ‘break’ these rules, it’s just not logical to claim that a source, text or scholar can actively instruct us from the page. So verbs or verb phrases such as to see, to look at, to talk about, to show, to say, to tell, to think, to move on are rather redundant – unless you are actually conveying what someone said during a speech, for example. What can you use instead? When referring to what your paper’s argument or the sources or their authors are conveying here are some verbs you might try using: to describe to dispute to comment to observe to discuss to state to argue to evaluate to predict to suggest to define to proceed to illustrate to believe to assert to conclude to recognise to purport to investigate to estimate Academic Skills Advice service www.brad.ac.uk/academic-skills/ to criticise to demonstrate to concede to report to indicate to highlight to confirm to examine to advance to imply to hypothesise to theorise to posit to challenge to postulate to defend How are they used? They can be used in an active sentence in the present tense: Henson (2010) implies here that should further research be commissioned its focus should... The researchers assert that their findings were conclusive, not merely suggestive (Fenwick et al., 2008). They can be used in an active sentence in the past tense: Peshan’s study of the previous decade investigated the effect of blood glucose on perceived concentration levels (2010). Cross hypothesised that over-exposure to ‘sanitised violence’ could lead to propensity for aggressive response (2002). They can be used in passive constructions in the present tense: It is argued in this essay that in certain cases there is little evidence to support... The worsening situation within this sector is demonstrated in the report which follows. Likewise, they can be easily used in passive constructions in the past tense: It has been suggested by two recent studies that... 2 Academic Skills Advice service www.brad.ac.uk/academic-skills/ Discrepancies in the data have been criticised by current studies and these criticisms form the basis of this paper’s argument. They can also be used in active, personal pronoun sentences when reflective writing is being used, in either present or past tense: In the following reflection, I argue that it was appropriate to defer to my mentor in this case due to my clinical experience being limited. I assert that neither theory is adequate in its totality; however, a combination of the effective elements of both is more effective and directly applicable. When are they used? Deciding the ‘expressive strength’ of reporting verbs. - Fairly neutral reporting verbs become less neutral if they are taken as the key point of somebody’s hypothesis or theory. If an experimental paper set out to ‘describe’ features of something, then this becomes the author’s main focus – not just something used to explain a scenario or situation, for instance. - Some reporting verbs feel obvious when compared with one another: purporting is ‘weaker’ than claiming something; arguing is ‘stronger’ than suggesting; challenging is ‘weaker’ than disputing something. - What it is important to remember is that once you know what all the verbs mean then they can be used appropriately as you like with varying degrees of ‘expressive strength’. - Don’t forget, the list above is not exhaustive – there are many more you are likely to come across within your reading. 3 Academic Skills Advice service www.brad.ac.uk/academic-skills/