BIOL 1001 STUDY NOTES Test #1 Persephone Greco-Otto Nature of Science: Science = a process for understanding the world, learn about universe (understand the natural/observable world), evidence, based on critical thinking (kriticos = discerning judgment, kriterion =standards) o Developed through reasoning (inferences = logical conclusions based on observable facts), test explanations against observations of the natural world (empirical = info gained through observation or experimentation), more than 1 scientific method, question-hypothsis-procedure-data-conclusions, never proves/method is flexible Superstitions do the actions influence the outcome? Incorrect ideas, animals become superstitious (push lever and delay before food delivered, develop strange behaviours during the lag that they repeat and associate w/food, self-association/conditioning) Limitations only natural phenomena, can’t deal w/belief/faith, no moral/aesthetic Method observe phenomenon, propose explanation, test through series of explanation accurate/valid (if explanation matches what’s observed, reproduction) OR revised/alternative explanation proposed Pseudoscience = individuals make scientific-sounding claims not supported by trustworthy, methodical scientific studies (statement may be true, but relationship isn’t) Anecdotal Evidence = based on only 1/few observations, not rigorously studied, not large enough sample size Theory and Hypothesis Hypothesis = proposed explanation for a phenomenon, must clearly establish mutually exclusive alternative explanations for a phenomenon, generate testable predictions, test empirically (rational, testable, repeatable) self-correcting o Alternative Hypotheses use evidence to determine which alternatives stronger/weaker, all ideas open to scrutiny (modify ideas as new evidence appears) o Theory = hypothesis for natural phenomena that is exceptionally well-supported by the data, broad explanations for a wide range of phenomena Logical Fallacies post hoc, ergo propter hoc (it happened after, so it was caused by…), confusion of correlation/causation Evidence and Proof hypotheses and theories may be supported by evidence but not proven Believe and Accept subject to peer review/replication, science based on inferences based on evidence Function and Purpose designed tools have purposes, structures/behaviours of living things have functions Primitive/Less Evolved and Advanced/More Evolved more highly specialized seen as more advanced, but actually based on how well they’re adapted to their environment Cause and Chance chance isn’t meaningless, cause is the “why explanation” 1 Fact statements that we know to be true through direct observation Law generalization about data and is a compact way of describing what we’d expect to happen in a particular situation Observation directly made w/our own sense or indirectly through use of tools Falsifiable a conceivable test that might produce evidence proving the idea false Uncertainty uncertainty in measurement is range of values within which the true value falls Error difference between a measurement and the true value Prediction what we would expect to happen or what we expect to observe if this idea were accurate “Theory of Intelligent Design” “life is too complex for everything to have developed step by step,” became popular when “creationism” was deemed unconstitutional to be taught, all living things best explained by an intelligent cause and not an environmental cause (no evolution) since world is fantastical, statistical improbabilities o Can’t identify designer, make observations, run experiments, make predictions, make hypotheses (doesn’t fit scientific method), only end products can be observed (no hypotheses), can’t be tested (no predictions/hypothesis, not tested/can’t be falsified), isn’t iterative (either the universe was created or it wasn’t, clergy letter project Evolution, Phylogenetics, History of Evolutionary Thought Biological Evolution = doesn’t happen among individuals (only grow + change), but over generations (genetic change), different species share common ancestors Mosaic Evolution = different organisms/parts of organisms don’t evolve at the same rate Theory of Evolution: o 2 Types of Biological Evolution Microevolution = changes in genetic characteristics over time, changes in gene frequency (how common an allele is in a pop), population over several generations + changes in gene frequency in pop, thought that it leads to macroevolution, eg. genealogy Macroevolution = descent of diff species from a common ancestor, much larger scale, more generation, derivation of new species biodiversity, eg. phylogeny *if characteristic is not genetic, then it isn’t evolution (many traits environmentally and genetically determined) o Biodiversity = the richness of living systems as reflected in genetic variability within and among species, the number of species living on earth, and the variety of communities and ecosystems Biosphere = all regions of earth’s crust, waters and atm that sustain life Ecosystem = group of communities interacting w/ their shared physical environment (biotic and abiotic) Community = pop of all species that occupy the same area 2 o o Population = group of individuals of the same kind/species that occupy the same area Multicellular organism = individual consisting of independent cells Cell = smallest unit of life Unity/Diversity of Life: don’t know how many species on earth little, hard to observe/live in harsh environments that we cannot reach Opportunities for Diversification movement into new environments, eg. extinction of dinosaurs allowed for diversification (more mammals), Galapagos finches (moved into vacated island to avoid predators/more food) *Intracompetition (within a species) intercompetition (between species) 1. Large changes in environment or evolution of key adaptation 2. Release from competition or vacated niches eg. Cambrian explosion/radiation (soft bodied to hard bodied) 1st representatives of current phylum 3. Specialization different species descended from same species take advantage of environmental changes eg. cichlids have diff. feeding patterns which lead to different anatomical structures Ecological Opportunity = key adaptations that can be exploited Evolution of photosynthesis production of O2 aerobic respiration development of ozone layer organisms could live closer to water surface movement from water to land? Water-Land Originally partly aquatic/terrestrial preexisting traits beneficial for life on land (developed in organisms in water) To avoid predation? Approx. 370 mill years ago Challenges/adaptations no support (buoyancy in water) to gravity, conservation of water (skin maintains water), protection against UV, waste excretion, reproduction (external fertilization in water eggs developed a membrane/shell to keep from drying out), food (plants on earth), respiratory surfaces (gills to lungs internal to keep from drying out, fluid to allow diffusion of gas) Intermediary/transition fossil of fishapod to tetrapod (Tiktaalik) changes in structure allowed life on land (more robust joints/digits), exaggeration of already present features, flat skull like crocodile Selection pressures those better at dealing w/pressures passed on traits Modes of Nutrition: Chemoautotroph oxidize CO2, some bacteria/archaeans, no eukaryotes Chemoheterotroph oxidize organic molecule, some bacteria/archaeans, proteins, fungi, animals, plants 3 Photoautotroph light and CO2, some photosynthetic bacteria, proteins and plants Photoheterotroph lights and organic mlcs, some photosynthetic bacteria o Populations = same species, individuals, reproduction o Characteristics of Model Organisms: easy to culture/grow, small, reproduce quickly, short lifespan, mature quickly, many offspring, kept in small space, invertebrates (ethical approval) Phylogenetics (represent hypotheses of relationships): informative/practical, oomycetes, identify source pops of invasive organisms, infections (trace the source) o Systematics = branch of biology that studies the diversity of life + its evolutionary relationships o Phylogeny = classification organisms based on differences and similarities (morphology, habitat, mode of nutrition, locomotion, DNA/protein sequence, reproduction) *not to scale so can’t tell how closely related/time o Taxonomy = classification of organisms into an ordered system that indicates natural relationships o Classification = an arrangement of organisms into hierarchical groups that reflect their relatedness o Taxonomic Hierarchy: kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species o Taxon = a name designating a group of organisms included within a category in the Linnaean taxonomic hierarchy o Common Ancestor = an ancestral organism shared by 2 or more descendant organisms, DNA testing o Monophyletic Taxa: an ancestral species and all of its descendants o Paraphyletic Taxa: an ancestral species and only some of its descendants o Polyphyletic Taxa: species from different evolutionary lineages o Principle/Assumption of Parsimony: simplest explanation is likely the best o Linnaean System of Classification: **degree of inclusion, relative # of organisms Phyla Family Genus Species Domain o Phylogenetic Trees (show patterns of descent): 4 Speciation (nodes) point in time where ancestral group split into 2 or more descendant groups Termina ends of branches, species can be extant/extinct Common Ancestors shared common ancestor at bottom (most inclusive end) Unique vs. Shared History How Parsimony is used to construct phylogenetic trees most optimal phylogeny is the one that requires the least evolutionary change to explain the data History of Evolutionary Thought: o Biogeography = the study of geographic distributions of plants/animals o Plato perfect creatures already exist (no evolution) o Aristotle scala naturae (no vacancies, no evolution, ladder of life) o Linnaeus binomial nomenclature, study nature to better understand Creator’s plan o Cuvier fossil evidence o Catastrophism = theory that Earth has been affected by sudden, violent events that were sometimes world-wide in scope o Wallace used biotas (all organisms living in a region) to define 6 biogeographic regions o Darwin’s Development of Evolutionary Hypothesis: Influences: Buffon organismal differences related to environments inhabited Lamarck species change through time, life evolved “upward into higher” forms, simplest life forms, use and disuse (larger/stronger w/use) – “inheritance of acquired characteristics” **both suggested populations are changing, importance of variation in natural populations Lyell (Uniformitarianism) geologic processes that shaped Earth’s surface over long periods of time are the same processes as today led to idea that species are gradually and constantly changing Hutton (Gradualism) Earth and its living systems changed slowly over its history Thomas Malthus economist, pop grow geometrically (exponentially), but food supplies grow arithmetically *scarcity of food = competition ***competition for resources means that not everyone survives those w/FAVOURABLE TRAITS SURVIVE **Variation within populations is important **BIG changes can occur very gradually over long periods of time (accumulation of changes) 5 Observations Most organisms produce more than ½ offspring Populations do not increase in size indefinitely 5 Food/resources limited for most populations Individuals within populations exhibit variability in many characteristics Many variations have genetic basis that is inherited by subsequence generations 2 Inferences Individuals within a population compete for limited resources Hereditary characteristics may allow some individuals to survive longer and reproduce more than others o ***a population’s characteristics will change over the generations as advantageous, heritable characteristics become more common Observations/explanations of phenotype/morphology on islands compared to mainland 2 ways that evolution can be observed today o Natural Selection and Cell Theory (2 unifying concepts of evolution): Theory of Evolution by Natural Selection = characteristics of a pop change over time, spp related by common ancestry (descent w/modification), individuals w/certain heritable traits produce more offspring than those without traits *all spp related by descent from a common ancestor and come from pre-existing spp. Cell Theory = all organisms made up of cells, all cells come from pre-existing cells *all single-cell organisms in a pop related to 1 common ancestor, all cells in multicellular organisms descend from 1 ancestral cell **both have patterns, both are 2 unifying concepts of biology, all species are related through descent to a common ancestor Evidence for Evolution o Fossil (any trace of an organism that lived in the past) show extinction, spp change over time; descent w/ modification (eg. finches on Galapagos islands, all diff spp very closely resembled the 1 spp on mainland) o Island Chains = spp disperses from mainland to new island (if succeeds may give rise to several new spp as pop spread to neighbouring islands) How? rapidly buried by sediment which slows decomposition (if no decomposition = intact/compression fossils, if decomposed = cast/permineralized fossils) Incomplete, 2 Bias only represents a fraction, needs the right conditions at right time for fossilization Limitations habitat (organisms that burrow, swampy areas), taxonomic (hard bodied more likely, pollen), temporal (more recent more common, plate tectonics [cause deformation]), abundance (higher pop, more widespread, older species) 6 o o o o o o o o o o Certain locations of fossils make them more likely to be found Transitional Fossil fossils show intermediary species Vestigial Traits = an anatomical feature of living organisms that no longer retains its function Radiometric Dating = dating method that uses measurements of certain radioactive isotopes to calculate the absolute ages in years of rocks and minerals Continental Drift/Plate Tectonics Background Extinction = ongoing standard rate of extinction Mass Extinction 99% of all species that have ever existed are now extinct, caused by catastrophic events (continental drift [originally 1 continent “Pangaea” that split] convergent boundaries) Breakup led to speciation/diversity Endemic Species = a species that occurs in only one place of earth Dispersal = the movement of organisms away from their place of origin Homology vs. Convergent Evolution Convergent Evolution = evolution of similar adaptations in distantly related organisms that occupy similar environments Homology = characters that are similar as a result of common ancestry 3 levels of homology: Structural (anatomical similarities) Developmental (developing embryos go through similar stages) Genetic (molecular homologies, DNA sequence similarity of genes from different spp, developmental sequences + adult structures CAN’T be homologous in diff spp UNLESS their genes are similar) Descent with Modification + Homology Nested pattern of homology o Genetic code = homology shared by all species o More recent homologies shared by smaller groups of organisms o Anatomical homologies are reflected in mlc homologies Homoplasious Traits = characteristics shared by a set of spp, b/c they live in similar environments, but not present in their common ancestor; often the product of convergent evolution Artificial Selection = selective breeding of plants/animals to ensure that certain desirable traits appear at higher frequency in successive generations 7 o Evolutionary Developmental Biology (evo-devo) = field of biology that compares the genes controlling the developmental processes of different animals to determine the evolutionary origin of morphological novelties and developmental processes; how evolutionary changes in genes regulating embryonic development can lead to changes in body shape/form o Genetic Tool-Kit (homeotic genes) = regulatory genes that code for transcription factors that bind regulatory sites on DNA activating/repressing the expression of genes that contribute to an organism’s form All living animals inherited them from a common ancestor alive then Hox genes control overall body plan Pax-6 gene triggers formation of light-sensing organs o Developmental Regulatory Genes/Genetic Switch Between Different Morphologies Small genetic changes account for large changes in characteristics of organisms that lead to different/new morphologies *****GENE SWITCHES? 8