Date: March 4 & 11, 2015
Grade Level: 10th
Recommended
Sequence
Objective(s) / Learning
Target(s):
Materials Needed:
Suggested Process:
GHS Seminar
Seminar Meeting
Note: This is a two-part Seminar (March 4th & 11th)
1. Students will understand the relationship between personal
qualities, education, training and the world of work.
2. Students will identify steps which can be used to resolve ethical
issues related to school or work situations.
Scenarios, Dilemmas, & Situations (see below)
Handout 3 – Ethical Decision Making Process
1. Ask students to share any pieces of good news they might have
since the last time your Seminar met (could be school-related,
extracurricular, personal, etc.)
ACTIVITY:
1. Ask students what they think “ethical” means? You can list
some of the key words they use on the board.
2. Once they have done this, start a T-Chart on the board: On one
side, have them list examples of ethical behavior, on the other
side have them list examples of unethical behavior (they can
focus on the school setting or life outside of school if they
want). Examples might be . . .
 Do your own work unless otherwise directed by teacher
 Complete each daily homework assignment with a focus
on what is to be learned
 Refrain from acts of academic dishonesty
 Do not take credit for work done by anyone else
 Cheating, plagiarism
3. Divide students into 4 groups. Then project one of the
scenarios (below) so that the students can read it (if you want
to read it aloud, go crazy).
4. Have students discuss the scenario in their group and decide
which practices are ethical and unethical. The discussion
questions for each scenario are below it:
5. Have each group report out to the entire group the results of
their discussion.
 Do the groups differ or are they similar in their
reasoning?
 Why do they think the way they do?
 Let them disagree, argue, and make good claims about
their reasoning – this is good discussion fodder!
6. Continue with the next few scenarios until you are finished.
7. Lastly, take them through Handout #3
Discussion Questions:
1. Why is it difficult to know what to do in situations related to
making ethical decisions?
2. What are the obstacles to “doing the right thing?”
3. How factors help you make the right decision?
Scenarios, Dilemmas, & Situations
#1) Stephanie was supposed to tell a certain guy that her good friend
had a crush on him. Instead, Stephanie ended up hooking up with the guy,
herself. And to make matters worse, she lied to her friend about it . Now
things are spinning out of control. What's she supposed to do?






What sort of person do you think Stephanie is?
What do you think she should do at this point?
Why do you think she made the choices she did?
Have you ever been in the same place as any of the four people in this dilemma?
What happened? What did it feel like?
Have you or someone you know ever lied to a friend about someone you (or they
might have been interested in?
Do you think girls handle conflict differently than guys? How? Why?
#2) Maria is sure that her good friend, Pam, has an eating disorder.
Pam’s parents are in denial, and nobody but Maria and a few friends
seem concerned. What should Maria do?




Do you agree with Maria? Do you think she should tell someone about Pam?
If so, who do you think she should tell?
What do you think Maria should say if Pam asks her if she told someone?
Have you ever been in a position like this? What happened? Would you make the
same choices if you were in that position again?
#3) What do you do when your friend's dad comes to drive you home
from a party, and you can tell that he's drunk?





What makes this dilemma so difficult?
Put yourself in this person’s shoes. What would you do? Why?
What might have made this situation easier to deal with?
What do you think your parents would do if you asked to get out of the car and
called your parents for a ride? Do you know anyone who would make that choice?
Why or why not?
Describe a time you or someone you know questioned an adult you felt was making
a choice that might impact you negatively.

Describe a time an adult in your life disappointed you? What happened? How did it
change how you viewed him or her (if at all)?
#4) Peter’s longtime close friend, Bridget, is wrapped up in an online
relationship with some older guy on Facebook. Peter thinks it’s creepy,
but Bridget resents his warnings and wants him to butt out. What can he
do without risking their friendship?









How do you know the difference between a challenging situation and a dangerous
one? Which do you think describes Bridget’s decision?
What would you do if you were in Peter’s shoes? Is there anything he can do without
losing his lifelong friendship?
What, specifically, makes Peter’s decision so hard?
What are some reasons maybe Peter should tell someone about this?
What are some reasons maybe he shouldn’t?
Have you ever had a friend you knew was doing something that could get her/him
into trouble? What did you do?
What do you think about Bridget flirting with this guy on line?
Do you know anyone who flirts on line? Have you ever worried about him/her?
What do you think is the guy’s motive in communicating with Bridget?
#5) Brian has the perfect summer job, thanks to his dad. But when Brian
finds out that some of his co-workers (including some with families to
support) make significantly less money than he does even though they've
been there much longer, he feels conflicted. What should he do?






What would you do if you were in Brian’s shoes?
What do you think Rosa meant when she told Brian he was young when she was
asking him to stay silent about their wage difference?
Have you or someone you know ever been in a situation where you were treated
more fairly than someone else? What did it feel like?
Have you or someone you know ever been in a situation where you were treated
unfairly compared to someone else? What did it feel like?
What is the right thing to do in this case? Do you think Brian, the owner of the
restaurant, Brian’s dad, and the kitchen staff would all agree? Why/why not?
Have you ever been confused when you were trying to figure out how to do the right
thing? What happened? What did you finally decide to do?
The Ethical Decision Making Process (At A Glance)
Framework for Ethical Decision Making
Recognize an Ethical Issue
1. Is there something wrong personally, interpersonally, or socially? Could the conflict, the
situation, or the decision be damaging to people or to the community?
2. Does the issue go beyond legal or institutional concerns? What does it do to people, who
have dignity, rights, and hopes for a better life together?
Get the Facts
3. What are the relevant facts of the case? What facts are unknown?
4. What individuals and groups have an important stake in the outcome? Do some have a
greater stake because they have a special need or because we have special obligations to
them?
5. What are the options for acting? Have all the relevant persons and groups been consulted?
If you showed your list of options to someone you respect, what would that person say?
Evaluate Alternative Actions from Various Ethical Perspectives
6. Which option will produce the most good and do the least harm?
7. Even if not everyone gets all they want, will everyone's rights and dignity still be respected?
8. Which option is fair to all stakeholders?
9. Which option would help all participate more fully in the life we share as a family,
community, society?
10. Would you want to become the sort of person who acts this way (e.g., a person of
courage or compassion)?
Make a Decision and Test It
11. Considering all these perspectives, which of the options is the right or best thing to do?
12. If you told someone you respect why you chose this option, what would that person say?
If you had to explain your decision on television, would you be comfortable doing so?
Act, Then Reflect on the Decision Later
13. Implement your decision. How did it turn out for all concerned? If you had it to do over
again, what would you do differently?