Writing Course Learning Outcomes (CLO) Key Points Aim for no more than 5-7 CLOs per course Clear and concise language, can be understood by students Contains an active verb (consult Blooms and other taxonomies) http://edweb.sdsu.edu/courses/EDTEC470/sp09/5/bloomstaxanomy.html Should be measurable (avoid verbs like “understand”,” know”, “appreciate”, “be familiar with” which are not observable and cannot be measured ) Includes a context/reason (describes what you envision students doing ”after” and “outside” this academic experience) and a criterion indicating the required standard Addresses appropriate learning, performance levels for the position within the program (e.g. Semester 1 starts with lower levels of learning (consult levels of learning in Blooms and other taxonomies), for the time and resources available and for the requirements of the vocation Are measurable and performance based Are aligned to assessments: assessments use same domain (cognitive, skills/abilities or affective) and level of learning as that stated by the learning outcome Constructing your Course Learning Outcome (CLO) At the start of each CLO there is the following statement stem: At the conclusion of this course, you will be able to: Each CLO is listed after the statement stem using this formula: Do something for a reason or in a given context according to a certain standard or performance criteria. For example: 1. Design marketing communication materials to meet the advertising needs of clients using industry standard technology. 2. Apply theoretical concepts of growth and development when working with individuals and families in the community as required by the public health regulations Common Errors in Writing Learning Outcomes: Pitfall written to reflect specific content written as a process not an outcome not realistic too narrow and so not transferable inconsequential, do not describe significant leaning not verifiable dependent on the way the material is taught or on the environment in which it occurs Unacceptable Improved Outcome Written to reflect specific content Describe the levels of Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs Use theories of motivation to interpret human behavior in non-stressful situations Not written as an outcome but as a goal or a process Appreciate the importance of personal responsibility in mature human sexuality Explain clearly the relationship between personal values and attitudes and mature sexuality Not realistic List the chemical symbol and valencies of all the known elements. Write equations to represent chemical reactions that maintain acid base balance Not verfiable Improve his or her understanding of the laws of electricity Use the laws of electricity to explain the viability of particular circuitry in specific applications Too narrow so not transferable Describe the functions of MS Word 2010 Use word-processing software to prepare reports and correspondence. Describes a specific assessment in the course rather than transferable learning applicable in a variety of work and/or life contexts. Produce a collection of community resources for promoting positive family functioning Select appropriate community resources to promote family functioning Summary Faculty, students, or other stakeholders (e.g. MTCU, parents, community partners, and industry) should be able to read each CLO and understand what a student must do to pass a course. The CLO statement should clearly state what would be considered an acceptable level of performance to pass a course. The CLOs should be verifiable and measured using one of the assessments listed in the Course Outline. Verbs to avoid when writing CLOs. Since outcomes must be measurable it is important that we choose action words that can be measured. Here are some verbs to avoid: The Sinister Sixteen Verbs (from Seneca’s Centre for Academic Excellence) understand know be aware of value appreciate see be conscious of get comprehend accept learn apprehend grasp have knowledge of perceive be familiar with All of these are internal. In other words, they aren’t public and can’t be observed. You can never really know whether someone understands a concept, because you can’t see into the person’s mind. All we can assess are public behaviours that we are willing to accept as evidence of understanding. We have to use verbs that can be measured.. A well-written learning outcome: States clear expectations so that learners know what they have to do to achieve the outcome Is written from the perspective of what the learner does, not what the professor does Begins with an action verb which states ONE performance Can be measured — by an assignment, test, project, exam Never begins with vague verbs such as ‘know’ ‘appreciate’ ‘understand’ and ‘demonstrate’ or any of the sinister sixteen verbs and phrases Has a clear answer to the question – “How will I and the students know that this outcome has been achieved? “ Is aligned with the program standards Is free of ambiguous words and phrases Can be achieved within the time frame of the semester/experience/workshop Does not dictate content, teaching activities nor assessment Elements of Performance The Course Learning Outcomes may have Elements of Performance listed below each learning outcome. The Elements of Performance give more detail and list the stepping stones or embedded skills, knowledge or attitudes requited to achieving the course learning outcome. For examples of elements of performance on a broader level consult the provincial standards for your program. Each Vocational Learning Outcomes(VLO) lists Elements of Performance underneath each VLO. Sample Action Words for Stating Learning Objectives Listed by Domain and Levels of Learning C Ideas Arrange Order Connections Apply Illustrate Extensions Analyze O Cite Outline Assemble Infer Appraise Explain G N I T I V E Classify Paraphrase Calculate Interpret Argue Formulate Convert Quote Change Manipulate Arrange Generate Copy Recall Choose Modify Assemble Illustrate Define Recite Compute Operate Assess Infer Describe Record Defend Practise Categorize Inspect Discuss Relate Demonstrate Predict Choose Interpret Distinguish Reproduce Discover Prepare Combine Judge Duplicate Repeat Draft Produce Compare Justify Explain Report Dramatize Relate Compose Manage Express Respond Draw Schedule Conclude Manipulate Extend Restate Employ Select Construct Modify Give Example Review Estimate Show Contrast Organize Identify Rewrite Explain Sketch Convert Originate Indicate Specify Extend Use Create Plan Label Summarize Criticize Predict List Tell Debate Prepare Locate Translate Defend Propose Match Underline Devise Question Diagram Rate Mate Name Differentiate Relate Discriminate Reorganize Distinguish Score Estimate Select Evaluate Solve Examine Support Experiment Test Value Write A Ideas Accept Locate Connections Adhere Initiate Extensions Act Integrate F Accumulate Name Affirm Invite Adapt Mediate F Ask Point to Approve Join Change Organize E Describe Respond to Assist Justify Defend Revise C Follow Select Choose Perform Display Solve T Give Sensitive to Commend Practise Influence Verify I Identify Use Complete Propose V Comply Select E Conform Share Describe Study Discuss Subscribe to Follow Work Form P Ideas Complete Press Connections Activate Load Extensions Adapt Fix S Demonstrate Pull Adjust Locate Combine Generate Y Distinguish Push Assemble Loosen Compose Illustrate C Hear See Build Manipulate Construct Modify H Identify Select Calibrate Measure Convert Organize O Locate Set up Close Open Create Plan M Manipulate Show Construct Operate Design Repair O Move Sort Copy Perform Devise Service T Pick up Specify Demonstrate Remove Diagram O Point to Touch Disassemble Replace R Practise Transport Disconnect Rotate Draw Select Duplicate Set Execute Slide