The Honorable Governor Abbott Office of the Governor P.O. Box 12428 Austin, Texas 78711-2428 June 3, 2015 The Honorable Governor Abbott: RE: TLC, Consumers Rights GTECH $508 Million Mass Action Lawsuit Sir, I write with questions of concern hopping you would take the time out of your day to address my concerns about the rights of the consumer protection act and its laws that supposed to protect consumers from businesses who may violate consumers protection with fraudulent intent. Sir, it is fact that GTECH a contractor with TLC has printed other FUN 5’s scratch off tickets in other states (Kansa, Indiana, Nebraska, Western Australia) with symbol language on the Fun 5’s scratch off tickets as winning tickets. Kansa and I quote: Complete a row, column, or diagonal line with (MONEY SIGN) symbol, win the Prize shown. Get a “5” symbol in the BONDS box, win “5” time that PRIZE. Different in the use of language as shown above for Kansa Fun 5’s and for Texas language used on the Fun 5’s scratch off ticket as follow and I quote: Reveal three “5” symbols in any one row, column or diagonal, win PRIZE in PRIZE box. Reveal a money Bag symbol in the 5X BOX, win 5 times that PRIZE. Reading the language used on the face of the Texas scratch off ticket and following the rules set by TLC in how to win a prize; you too would think as well you have won the prize in the box as the language read. All a player would have to do is reveal a money bag to win 5X the amount shown in the box. My question is to you sir, as the facts is shown to be clear, who do we as consumers turn to when the AG is not willing or nor would even consider to address our grievance against TLC a business? The legislative body failed to protect those who they consider (The Poor) would purchase Texas Lottery games under the consumer protection act that would have given the players an avenue to redress its grievance. Failing to do so, leave the consumer at the mercy of the legislative body for approval to sue TLC a business, when the consumer protection act should equally protect all consumers from the overreaching hands of all businesses (TLC) that sell consumer produces. Under this current system of design tactic is to deny an equal shield of consumer protection as all other businesses who must abide by the consumer protection laws, when TLC is protected under sovereignty immunity. Clearly a wrong has been done in violation of the consumer protection act against those who play Texas Lottery games. TLC set the rules of how to play Texas lottery games which a player must follow to win a prize. When TLC doesn’t abide by its set rules of how a game is played in order to win a prize then a player needs an avenue to address its grievance. States need an avenue to address the federal government when it feel a wrong has been done (So why not consumers) so that the federal government may not take away rights (As TLC did) by overreaching or a federal takeover of states, so I ask you Sir, Why? TLC has that right to overreach by taking away the consumer rights of protection at will when TLC does not want to take responsibility for its wrong against consumers? No other business enjoys this privilege as TLC. Sir, All I am asking for is fairness and if this is too much please disregard this letter. Sincerely, Charles Grays 805 Speed St Wharton, Texas 77488 979-358-8462 coolwater07@live.com CC: filed The Honorable Lt. Governor Patrick