Hansel and Gretel (dir. Lotte Reiniger, 1955) Key Stage KS2 Subject PSHE Requirements Trailer: A3 paper, post-it notes, ‘Diamond 9’ template Main Attraction: DVD of ‘Hansel and Gretel’, coloured card (red/orange/green) End Credits: ‘Hansel and Gretel’ (6.10 onwards) Lesson description A lesson that uses ‘Hansel and Gretel’ (1955) as the basis for recognising and responding to a range of risks, focusing on the importance of individual responsibility and decision-making through the use of ‘conscience alley’. Key words Risk, situation, consequence, moral, lesson, reason, decision, choice, option. Curriculum Links PSHE KS2 3e Recognise the different risks in different situations and then decide how to behave responsibly 2f Resolve differences by looking at alternatives, making decisions and explaining choices Media literacy opportunities This lesson will enable students to reflect on the use of silhouette animation within film and its effect on the audience’s understanding of character. Close consideration will be granted to the role of movement in expressing emotion. Lesson work summary Students will generate their own definitions and ideas associated with ‘risk’ by creating ‘thought showers’ as part of a group, developed using a quick ‘Diamond 9’ activity. The short film ‘Hansel and Gretel’ will then be used as the basis for recognising and identifying risks, which children will explore and respond to using a conscience alley activity. Lesson work value Students will learn to identify what constitutes a risk and reflect critically on the degree of risk posed by different situations. Students should develop independent decision-making skills and an understanding of the role of individual responsibility for one’s actions. OBJECTIVE To recognise and evaluate the level of risk posed by different situations, and identify appropriate actions to reduce risk. TRAILER Ask: what is a ‘risk’? Allow students time to discuss in partners and share feedback. Encourage students to consider: How can you recognise a ‘risk’? Can you think of any risks you have recently taken? How did you feel? How did you respond? Would you respond differently in the future? In groups of four, ask students to create a thought shower on a large piece of paper with the word ‘risk’ written in the middle. Students should list as many different risky situations as they can think of around the outside, including people and/or places they associate with these situations – e.g. playing in the middle of the road, or getting into a stranger’s car. After five minutes, groups should swap their pieces of paper, circling any risks they had also thought of and writing down any additional examples. Collect nine examples and write up on the board. Using the ‘Diamond 9’ template, students should write the situations on post-it notes and arrange them in the shape of a diamond to represent their views on the level of risk posed by each. Emphasise that there are no right or wrong answers, but students must be able to justify their order of ‘risk’ by thinking carefully about the potential consequences of each situation. MAIN ATTRACTION Watch ‘Hansel and Gretel’ once through as a class to familiarise students with the story. Explain that fairy tales usually involve some kind of “lesson learned” – a moral that can guide us how to respond to certain risks in life. Re-watch the film using the Stop/Decide/Do strategy (taken from the Cambridgeshire PSHE Service): STOP (Red) – Something doesn’t feel right, I think there’s a risky situation developing. DECIDE (Amber) – What are my options? Should I say something, go somewhere or get some help? DO (Green) – Action taken to reduce risk. Students should hold up a red card when they identify a risky situation developing. Pause the film and ask students to explain their reasons. How did they recognise the risk? The following situations will likely be identified, although students may think of further examples: Playing in the fields instead of the garden. Following the squirrel into the forest. Approaching a stranger’s house. Accepting sweets from a stranger. Each time a risk is identified, keep the film paused and use ‘conscience alley’ to explore the different options available to Hansel and Gretel. The class should stand in two opposing lines, with two students walking slowly between them in the role of Hansel and Gretel. Each line should argue either in favour of or against each situation, and students should take turns to play different roles. Following the arguments from both sides, ‘Hansel and Gretel’ should decide what their decision will be. END CREDITS Re-play the following line from 6.10 onwards and then display the quote on the board: “Gretel wept bitterly and told the squirrel that it was all his fault that they had got lost in the forest and had been caught by the witch.” EXTRAS Other Ideas Ask students to decide whether they agree or disagree with Gretel by forming a continuum from opposite sides of the classroom, with students who remain unsure situated in the middle. Based on the majority’s decision, ask students to decide what the ‘moral’ of the film is – what lessons have Hansel and Gretel learnt? The ‘conscience alley’ activity could be followed up with a ‘telephone conversation’ between two characters – e.g. the mother and Gretel – to extend the argument into a more elaborate discussion. This would provide a good opportunity for modernisation of the story - e.g. the mother could call Gretel on her mobile phone to persuade her to come home and play in the garden. Use of silhouette animation means that the characters are without facial expression – all emotion is expressed through movement and dialogue, which is limited. Students can be given the opportunity to reflect on and empathise with Hansel and Gretel’s reactions to the different risks and situations they encounter through interpretative dance or Read Watch freeze-framing. Students could compare this version of ‘Hansel and Gretel’ against the original story by the Brothers Grimm, in which the children use pebbles and breadcrumbs to avoid getting lost. Cross-curricular links with Geography and Mathematics could be explored through a mapwork activity, focusing on the children’s journey through the forest. Screenonline The original version of ‘Hansel and Gretel’ in the Grimms’ Fairy Tales The Enchanted Screen: The Unknown History of Fairy Tale Films by Jack Zipes (2011) The Uses of Enchantment: The Meaning and Importance of Fairy Tales by Bruno Bettelheim (1976) – a seminal analysis of the psychological importance of fairy tales for children’s emotional growth to enable their preparation for adulthood. Lotte Reiniger: The Fairy Tale Films (BFI DVD compilation) Resources: Diamond 9 Template