Solar Power Installation Guidelines for Schools Understand the benefits Know the installation process Get the best outcome Contents 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................................................... 2 2. Is Solar Power Best for Your School? ......................................................................................................................... 2 3. Expected Energy Savings and Financial Benefits ........................................................................................................ 2 4. Solar Power System Components .............................................................................................................................. 3 4.1 Solar panels ............................................................................................................................................................... 3 4.2 Inverters .................................................................................................................................................................... 5 4.3 Monitoring equipment ............................................................................................................................................. 7 5. Optimum System Size .............................................................................................................................................. 10 6. Pre-installation checks ............................................................................................................................................. 11 6.1 Building type ........................................................................................................................................................... 11 6.2 Orientation and Tilt/pitch ....................................................................................................................................... 11 6.3 Shading ................................................................................................................................................................... 11 6.4 Power Supply .......................................................................................................................................................... 11 7. Small-scale Technology Certificates (STCs) .............................................................................................................. 12 8. Contractor Requirements ........................................................................................................................................ 12 8.1 Accreditation........................................................................................................................................................... 12 8.2 Site analysis ............................................................................................................................................................. 12 8.3 Electrical Works Request ........................................................................................................................................ 12 8.4 Certificate of Electrical Safety ................................................................................................................................. 13 8.5 Compliance ............................................................................................................................................................. 13 8.6 Signing the Contract................................................................................................................................................ 13 9. Solar Panel Security.................................................................................................................................................. 14 10. Contacts ................................................................................................................................................................... 14 1. Introduction With the help of solar panels, schools have the potential to use clean energy. This can mean a reduction in energy bills and in some cases credit from electricity retailers. It must be understood that the scale of benefits will be different for each school. A solar power installation also provides an opportunity for students to learn more about renewable energy resources and see the results in action. There are many actions that must be undertaken by a number of different parties to ensure that the solar project is successful. Therefore, it is important for schools to fully understand the purchase and installation processes and keep check of the important steps to ensure that they get good service, value for money and, most importantly, an effective solar panel installation. This document is intended to provide: i. A guide to assist schools in the investigating, planning and purchase of solar panels. ii. A clear understanding as to when schools create surplus energy, whether or not your school is likely to receive credit for surplus energy fed into the grid, and the rate at which your school would be credited for that energy. iii. Realistic expectations on both the energy and financial benefits provided by your installation. 2. Is Solar Power Best for Your School? Before looking to invest in a solar energy solution for your school, it is important to understand that often the best way to reduce energy costs is by introducing energy reduction measures, not energy generation measures. Some of the best ways to reduce energy costs are through upgrades to insulation, energy efficient lighting, window shading, timer switches and occupancy controls. This is in addition to basic behaviour changes such as switching off all lighting and appliances not in use. These changes are often much more cost effective than installing large energy generating items such as solar power. For more information about energy saving measures that could decrease your energy bill, visit http://switchon.vic.gov.au/more-ways-to-save/energy-saver-incentive Despite the fact that solar may not always be the most cost effective solution, the introduction of clean, green energy generators like solar will produce some energy for your school. This is in addition to providing a great learning opportunity for students and gives a clear sign to your school community that you care about the environment. 3. Expected Energy Savings and Financial Benefits It is important to remember that the possible energy and financial benefits from installing a solar power system can vary greatly between schools. Variable factors include: School’s location Existing energy contracts Position of panels Size of system Total energy consumption of the school Any energy generated by the system will decrease the school’s overall electricity consumption, which will in turn reduce the cost of the school’s electricity bill. If a solar power system generates more energy than the school actually consumes, the system can feed that excess energy back into the electricity grid. When this process occurs, the school receives financial compensation for the associated energy company via a ‘feed-in tariff’. It must be noted that for the majority of schools, the minimum energy base load that occurs when the school is not in operation (e.g. to power items such as fridges, emergency lighting, standby power on appliances and security systems during night time and weekends etc.) can often be more energy than the solar power system can generate. As such, schools should not rely on receiving financial benefits from feedin tariffs as a regular occurrence. For more information on feed-in tariffs, energy and financial benefits that your school could reasonably expect, read ‘Understanding Solar Feed-In Tariffs’ at: http://www.education.vic.gov.au/Documents/about/programs/infrastructure/solarfeedin.pdf 4. Solar Power System Components 4.1 Solar panels Solar panels are manufactured in three main types (monocrystaline, polycrystalline and thin film) with manufacturers within the solar panel industry divided into three tiers of quality. Tier 1 manufacturers use the highest grade of silicon, invest heavily in research and development, have a largely automated production line and control the supply and manufacture of all components making up each solar panel. Tier 2 manufacturers on the other hand invest less in research and development of their product, have a less automated production line and may not control the supply and manufacture of all components within their solar panels. Tier 3 manufacturers act more as an assembler only by purchasing all separate components of their panels on the open market and then combining these into a solar panel. They therefore have much less control over the quality of each of their components. The three types of solar panels have different strengths, and selection can be determined by variables such as cost, efficiency (size) and performance when hot. Monocrystalline Pros: Cons: Highest efficiency rates (13-17%) Space efficient, ideal for limited roof area (1kW = as little as 6sqm) Perform well in cooler conditions Usually comes with a 25 year warranty Most expensive Reduced performance in heat (~0.3% for every degree over 25C that the panels heat up) Polycrystalline Pros: Cons: Good efficiency (12-13%) Slightly cheaper than monocrystalline per watt. Usually comes with a 25 year warranty High embodied energy Slightly less space-efficient than monocrystalline (1kW = approximately 8sqm), Reduced performance in heat (~0.3% for every degree over 25C) Amorphous Thin Film Pros: Cons: Performance not adversely affected by heat or partial shade Initially higher than expected performance during first 3-6 months ‘breaking in ‘ period Lower manufacturing costs mean they are a cheaper alternative to crystalline models Most quickly evolving type of solar power technology Low to moderate efficiency (6-8%) Requires about twice the roof area of monocrystalline cells, 1kW = approximately 14sqm, Degrades faster, meaning a shorter warranty than other panels Emerging technologies not yet on the market: Organic Polymer and Dye-sensitised Pros: Very stable in heat Promises to be much cheaper than other technologies Cons: Expected to eventually reach efficiencies of 20% Very light, thin and flexible making it very versatile Long life expectancy Not yet available on the market. Recommendations North of the divide, consider Amorphous Thin Film panels due to superior tolerance to heat, particularly if a supportive framework is not required to increase the angle of the panels. If Polycrystalline or Monocrystalline panels are selected, ask the contractor to allow for airflow behind the panels to assist cooling. Ensure that the solar panels selected have a performance-based warranty of at least 25 years, and a product warranty of at least 5 years. Note: ‘Tindo’ is currently the only Australian manufacturer of solar panels. As they are a relatively new company, their performance is not measurable. They also do not make compatible inverters. It is for these reasons that at the time of print this brand is not recommended. More reliable manufacturers of solar panels include Schott, Q Cells and Conenergy. 4.2 Inverters Your system will require an inverter to control the operation of the solar panels and change the solar power from a low and variable DC current to a 240v AC current, suitable for regular use or feeding into the grid. Inverters can be purchased with various data capabilities and at a minimum you should be able to download performance data by cable from the inverter itself, eliminating the need for purchasing additional monitoring equipment. The two types of inverters available on the market are conventional central inverters and the more recently developed microinverters. Microinverters Pros: Allow for one solar panel within an array to be performing poorly due to shading, debris or a failure without impacting on the rest of the array. One model of microinverter can be used on any size array and many different models of solar panels. German made. Cons: More expensive. Take longer to install as they need to be installed adjacent to the solar panel, which usually means they have to be mounted on the roof. More difficult to maintain due to roof mounting. Central Inverter Pros: Installed inside or under the eve of a building and out of the weather, allowing it to be easy to maintain. Less expensive. Cons: An issue with one panel (e.g. affected by shade, broken etc) can impact performance of multiple panels. There are numerous brands of central inverters. A recommended brand is the SMA Inverter. A key benefit of this inverter is that they have the best warranty options on the market (minimum 5 years with option to extend up to 25 years). They also have Bluetooth capability, making it cheaper and easier to install the data monitoring component of the system, including monitoring via the Schools Water Efficiency Program (SWEP) portal (see 4.3 Monitoring Equipment for more information). Other quality brands of central inverters on the market include Fronius, Power-One and Conenergy, which are all manufactured in Germany. These manufacturers all have an online portal for the display of the solar power produced, however those portals are generally not as easy to work with as the SMA monitoring system. Recommendations: The inverter is the most important component of your entire solar power system so it is highly recommended to purchase a reputable brand with the following features: Maximum power point tracking to maximise the output they produce. Grid tie only, not stand alone inverters for off grid systems. High efficiency inverters with a rating close to 98%. Manufacturer must make a wide range of inverters from 2 to 30kW (the latter of which may need several inverters wired in series). A sine wave AC output in preference to a square wave or modified sine wave - modified sine wave inverters can reduce efficiency of the transfer from AC to DC by about 20%. Capacity to export data via a File Transfer Protocol in the correct format at the correct frequency to enable connection to programs such as the SWEP. Note: SMA inverters are recommended for this function. Warranty of at least 10 years. 4.3 Monitoring equipment It is important to be able to monitor if your solar power system is working, and working as efficiently as it should. This ensures that any required maintenance occurs as soon as possible and the school is not missing out on the energy and financial benefits of the system. In addition, through monitoring the performance this information can also provide an educational benefit if included in science and maths classes. There are many different types of monitoring devices with which to view and monitor the performance of the solar panels. These provide varying quality of output, and are purchased at a wide range of prices. Examples include: Wireless monitoring and display device, connected directly to the inverter or a sensor on the power cable itself. Network box, to collect wireless data from the inverter to a PC, a website, or a public display device. Public display screen, showing live data for education and promotion (in an entry foyer perhaps). Meter data collectors, which can add the capability of showing total school energy consumption alongside solar production (this device may depend on compatibility with the school’s main meter). External sensors, to show additional data such as sunlight intensity and solar cell temperature, which could complement the data from the inverter. Web visualisation. Some providers of hardware offer free internet portals. Web visualisation is a very effective way to monitor both the solar energy generation and the electricity consumption at the school, and can be a valuable educational tool. Many different brands of web portal systems are available, with some of the popular brands shown below. Sunny Portal Sunny Portal is a free site, and can be tailored to the school’s preferences. Information is sometimesdifficult to interpret. Information can be publicly accessible or can be secured via password login. Bright Future Bright Future is a publicly accessible site and is visually easy to interpret. Can provide additional information on the system components (system and inverter size etc), and also ‘live’ data such as current air temperature and rainfall. Sunskool Sunskool is a publicly accessible site and is visually easy to interpret. It converts the generated electricity and greenhouse gasses not emitted into the atmosphere into tangible figures like an equivalent number of cars that have been removed from the road. SWEP The Schools Water Efficiency Program (SWEP) site monitors schools’ water consumption via water data logger technology. The program is currently being expanded to allow schools to monitor solar power generation and electricity consumption. SWEP is a Victorian Government initiative managed by the Department of Environment and Primary Industries and the Department of Education and Training. For schools already part of SWEP, or considering signing up to SWEP, this web portal is highly recommended. Recommendations: Consider how you would like to view the performance of your solar panels and ask the contractor to provide this in the quote. Confirm that the system has the required data collection possibilities, and any expansion capabilities to add any monitoring equipment you think you may want in future. If monitoring electricity consumption, ask the contractor to investigate how the consumption is currently metered and verify if the entire school’s consumption can be monitored, or only selected buildings. Ensure that a minimum of two staff, preferably including the school’s IT technician, are taught how to read and understand the monitoring system, and are provided with any login details where applicable. 5. Optimum System Size The amount of energy your solar system generates will be influenced by how many solar panels you have, how large they are, the location of the panels and the direction they face. Variables that might influence your choice of solar capacity should include cost, feed-in tariff rates, available roof area, and the energy demand of your school. The following table is designed to give schools a quick reference guide to the optimum size of solar power system based on the number of enrolments. It must be noted that this table is a rough guide only and does not take into account contributing factors such as school age and location, energy efficiency opportunities, roof size and orientation, and for small schools if the power supply is single or three phase. Schools with single phase power supplies are generally limited to a solar power system of no larger than 6kW by the electricity distribution company. Electricity Retailer Powerdirect Red Energy School Size (Enrolments) Up to 30 31 to 60 61 to 100 101 to 150 151 to 200 201 to 250 251 to 350 351 and above 400 - 600 601 - 800 801 – 1,000 1,001 – 1,200 1,201 – 1,401 1,401 and above Optimum System Size (kW) 2 4 6 8 10 12 13 14 15 17 20 23 26 29 To help understand typical power consumption versus solar power production and understanding how much power you can expect to generate, see the guideline Understanding Solar Feed-in Credits on http://www.education.vic.gov.au/Documents/about/programs/infrastructure/solarfeedin.pdf 6. Pre-installation checks 6.1 Building type Solar panels should not be installed on a relocatable building or a building that may be removed or demolished. This may lead to extra costs in relocating the system, installation or tariff complications, and even loss of the panels. In addition, schools should be aware of installing solar panels on buildings under warranty. For example, if the roof begins to leak for a reason unrelated to the solar panels, you may find that the roof warranty has been negated by the installation of solar panels. It is recommended that solar panels are installed on buildings less than 25 years old and that have an expected long future, or alternatively on heritage listed buildings where it is known that they will be retained in any school development program. 6.2 Orientation and Tilt/pitch When completing an installation, the pitch of panels can be pivotal to the power they generate. The optimum pitch to mount the panels is 22 degrees, and ideally they should be mounted on a north facing roof that is not affected by shade. Mounting solar panels flush against a flat roof instead of at the optimum angle can make a negative difference on the power output. Mounting on a north facing roof will maximise performance year round. If a due north facing installation is not possible, a north west or north east could be considered. Solar panels should never face due east, west or south, and a school should not consider solar if their roof orientation is not acceptable. 6.3 Shading Shading by trees or adjacent buildings will have a negative effect on the output of the solar panels, depending on time of day and for how long the panels are shaded. Any potential shading should be taken into account when positioning panels. 6.4 Power Supply Schools with a single phase power supply are limited to installing systems of a maximum 6kW capacity. Only schools with a three phase power supply can support installations larger than 6KW. When providing a quote, the installer must check the power supply to the school can support the size of the system being installed. As part of the check, an ‘Embedded Generator Pre-Approval’ form should be completed by the installer and sent to the electrical distributor (e.g. SP AusNet) to ensure they approve the system size before final contracts are signed and the installation commences. 7. Small-scale Technology Certificates (STCs) Small-scale Technology Certificates (STCs) are a tradeable commodity attached to eligible installations of renewable energy systems (including solar panels, solar water heaters and heat pumps). Under the Federal Government’s Small-scale Renewable Energy Scheme (SRES), when you install an eligible system, you may claim a set number of these STCs. This is a way of encouraging the installation of renewable energy systems by effectively subsidising them. The number of STCs awarded is based on the assumed energy output potential over the following 15 years (1 STC is equivalent to 1MWh). A reasonable price an electrical contractor would pay for them after taking a percentage might be $30-35 per STC. A school’s location plays a factor in how many STCs they may be eligible for. To determine how many STCs your school’s system is eligible for, use the Small Generation Unit STC Calculator located at https://www.rec-registry.gov.au/rec-registry/app/calculators/sgu-stc-calculator When using the calculator, note that schools are not eligible for Solar Credit Multipliers. It is recommended that schools trade any applicable STCs to gain an upfront discount on their solar power system installation. 8. Contractor Requirements 8.1 Accreditation Installation of solar panels should be done by a renewable energy installer who is certified by the Clean Energy Council. You can search for a Clean Energy Council accredited installer at http://www.solaraccreditation.com.au/consumers/find-an-installer.html 8.2 Site analysis The contractor must perform a site analysis test using a Solar Pathfinder, Suneye or similar device on the roof for a short time to measure the potential performance and shading of a solar installation in that position. Using this information they will give you a formal report about what type of results to expect. This is to ensure that you get the best performance from the system. 8.3 Electrical Works Request The contractor must also submit an Electrical Works Request (EWR) to your energy retailer to allow the retailer to: 1. Arrange for the distributor to set up the meter to allow this solar power feed-in data to be collected 2. Set up its database and your electricity bill to include feed-in-tariffs. In the past, schools have missed out on financial credit for any power they feed into the grid because their meters and billing have not been properly set up. To ensure that the retailer will be able to credit the school for surplus energy, schools should ensure that the EWR states that it acknowledges that the EWR is due to a solar installation, and that it indicates the solar capacity in kilowatts. 8.4 Certificate of Electrical Safety The contractor must supply a Certificate of Electrical Safety (CES) at the completion of the job. An electrical inspector will undertake the inspection for CES usually within 8 business days of completion. The electrical inspector can also ensure the system is connected to the grid. The company you choose to install your system should be able to organise the required inspections as well as complete the required paperwork. Without a CES, the property may not be covered by insurance in the case of an electrical fault. 8.5 Compliance All solar power installations must comply with the Standards for Wiring Rules (AS/NZ 3000), and other solar power system installation guidelines that are published and updated by Standards Australia. The following Australian Standards must be adhered to: AS 3000: 2007 Wiring Rules AS 1786: 2007 Lightening Protection, AS 4777: 2005 Grid connection of energy systems via inverters, AS 1170.2: 2002 Structural Design Actions, Part 2 wind actions, AS 5033: 2005, Installation of photovoltaic arrays. At the time of the installation, the panel used must appear as compliant as per AS 5033. In addition, the inverter being installed must appear on the Clean Energy Council’s list of tested and approved grid connected inverters. AS 4509: 2009 Stand Alone Power Systems is not relevant as all systems will be connected to the grid. Schools are strongly encouraged not to install stand-alone power systems due to the additional maintenance and safety requirements associated with battery banks. All installers will be bound by the Clean Energy Council’s “Code of Conduct” and must comply with this code during all installations. Installers must also understand that the provision of false or misleading information contravenes Section 24B of the Renewable Energy (Electricity) Act 2000. Failure to comply with the Act can result in penalties and prosecution where warranted. Before finalising any payments, it is highly recommended that the installer provide the following to the school: A list of all items that have been installed; Certificate of Electrical Safety; Electrical diagram of the system; and Photos of the system. 8.6 Signing the Contract Careful consideration of both price and quality should be undertaken to ensure your school’s best option. Always get at least three suppliers to quote for the same size system so you are able to compare prices before signing any contracts. When shopping for your system, make sure you understand what the installer is willing to do for the installation price and what you are required to do. Ensure all quotes and contracts provide detailed information on the system components being provided, total costs including GST and timelines for the installation. Final balance payments should not be made until the system is fully operational. 9. Solar Panel Security Although it is rare, there have been instances where solar panels have been stolen from the roofs of school buildings – generally during times of other building works on the site. It is highly recommended that security measures be in place to prevent and deter the theft of the expensive equipment. Security measures could include: Non-reversible screws. These are highly effective, but will reduce the ability to remove the panels at a later date without destroying the framework and brackets, which are connected to the panels. The time taken to remove the panels will also be significantly increased. High security screws, which require a special tool that is registered to the police. Tying the panels together using a heavy braided cable, to make removal more difficult. Ensure that you have a record of serial numbers for your individual solar panels and associated equipment. Ensure that the solar panel system is added to the school’s insurance policy. 10. Contacts For issues surrounding mandated electricity State Purchase Contracts, which cover all electricity supplied to schools, contact your regional office Provision & Planning Unit or email procurement@edumail.vic.gov.au. Billing and other invoicing or supply matters should first be raised with the appropriate retailer. These are: Red Energy – for all sites with usage of >160MWh pa (megawatt hours per annum) Phone 03 9425 0590 or email duff.brett.a@edumail.vic.gov.au Power Direct – for all sites with usage of <160MWh pa Phone 03 8633 6823 or email info@powerdirect.com.au