Romeo & Juliet Debate:
We will be holding a class debate on multiple topics dealing with Romeo & Juliet. You will be split into
groups and given a column of the below topics to examine and their respective sides. You will need to
come to class prepared to defend your position as a group. For each topic a new spokesperson must be
determined to allow as much participation as possible. During the rebuttal phase you will need a
spokesperson that is not already reflected for your topic; however you will all work together for the
rebuttal.
We will review the use of Google Docs in order for you to collaborate outside of class on your debate
topics and assign members to compile information. Each member must equally contribute to the topic.
1) Romeo & Juliet are in love
Group 1:
1) Romeo & Juliet are not in love
Group 2:
2) The Friar is at fault for the death of R & J
Group 1:
2) The nurse is at fault for the death of R & J
Group 2:
3) Lord Capulate is at fault for the death of R & J
Group 3:
3) Lord Montague is responsible for the death of R & J
Group 4:
4) Romeo is responsible for the death of Mercutio
Group 1:
4) Mercutio is responsible for his own death
Group 2:
5) Fate & Astrology are blamed for the events of the play
Group 3:
5) Mental instability is blamed for the events of the play
Group 4:
Rules for Debate:
1) Each topic will be given 5 minutes of debate time for each side.
2) Both groups will then be given 3 minutes to gather information for a 2 minute rebuttal.
3) A winner will be decided by the judge (Mrs. Fuggiti) for fun. This has no impact on your grade. Your
grade is determined by the rubric.
4) All arguments must remain civil. Each side will be given turns to speak and should be respectful of
these times.
The winners of the debate will be determined by the following rubric:
1) Clear Arguments
/10
2) Evidence from play to support your argument
3) Addressing of counter arguments
/10
/10
4) Equal group participation in the planning and speaking process
5) Organized and prepared on day of debate
Total: 50 points
/10
/10
Romeo & Juliet Debate Planning Worksheet:
Group Members Names:
1)
2)
3)
Topic 1:
1) Argument –
a) evidence
2) Argument
a) evidence
b) evidence
Topic 2:
Topic 3:
Topic 4:
Topic 5: