Topic 4: Producing Food for the Future GCSE Additional Applied Science About the topic Useful general Websites In this topic learners: develop knowledge of the growing global demand for food and that in order to produce sufficient high quality food to feed the global population, agriculture needs to make use of scientific progress to improve yields and quality. develop understanding of the fact that the use of some production techniques has led to controversy and that this has resulted in the rise of “organic farming” develop understanding of how science is used to study the nature and production of foods, the causes of deterioration, the principles of food processing, and the improvements of foods for the consuming public. People and regulation http://www.food.gov.uk/foodindustry/ Prior learning http://www.beep.ac.uk/content/327.0.html It is helpful if learners know from KS3 Science Plants and photosynthesis Plants for food Microbes http://www.yteach.co.uk/index.php/resources/humus_winter_crop_spring_crop_eutrophicatio n_weed_rhizome_runner_herbicide_crop_rotation_hydroponics_fertilization_eutrophication_ Cultivation_t .html Health and safety Risk assessments are required for any hazardous activity. Model risk assessments used by most employers for normal science activities can be found in the CLEAPSS Guidance. Teachers need to follow these as indicated in the guidance notes for the activities, and consider what modifications are needed for individual classroom situations. http://www.food.gov.uk/foodindustry/farmingfood/ Food production http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/science/add_aqa/plants/plants1.shtml http://www.soilassociation.org/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=nKKZajvOqcI%3D&tabid=280 http://www.ncagr.gov/cyber/kidswrld/plant/nutrient.htm Food processing http://www.microbiologyonline.org.uk http://www.sgm.ac.uk/pubs/micro_today/pdf/020004.pdf Language for learning Through the activities in this unit learners will be able to use appropriate scientific and technical language to clearly communicate their understanding of scientific concepts, conveying their meaning in a coherent and succinct manner. GCSE Additional Applied Science Unit 1, topic 2 1 Out-of-school learning Learners could: Use websites to review information and consolidate learning: Investigate organic and non organic foods sold in local supermarkets Research the nutrient constituents of different fertilisers Good learning Practice Learners should be given explicit level statements, using Grade Descriptors, relating to each activity they undertake. This will enable them to measure and monitor their own performance. Controlled Assessment Teachers are advised to build into their teaching programme time to complete controlled assessment. Controlled assessment activities are changed each year. This will mean that centres will need to review their scheme of work to ensure that the chosen controlled assessments are covered at an appropriate time. GCSE Additional Applied Science 2 4.1 People and regulation Learning Objectives Possible Learning Activities Learners should 4.1.1 recognise that food production and agriculture needs to be regulated in order to protect public safety and maintain animal welfare. 4.1.2 explain the need for enforcement officers to monitor the food chain (e.g. environmental health practitioners and factory inspectors). 4.1.3 recognise that agriculture and food scientists are involved in studying crops and farm animals to improve the quality and yields. They also may monitor the effect of various methods of crop production on the biodiversity of an area. Resources Hook Activities: Involve an expert: a representative from the Food Standards Agency could be invited in to take on the “mantle of the expert”. Prior to the visit learners could work in pairs to prepare a set of questions related to the subject of the regulation of food production and agriculture. The “expert” could be asked to give a short presentation (no more than 10 minutes) and then in turn pairs of learners ask their pre-prepared questions. Learners could then be set a task by “the expert” to design a leaflet or poster that explains why food production and agriculture need to be regulated http://www.food.gov.uk/wales/aboutus_wales / http://www.food.gov.uk/wales/aboutus_wales /contactus/ Starters: What’s in our food, where does it come from?? Working in teams of no more than 3, learners are given a shopping list of 6 items, but rather than buy the items learners have to find out how the food was produced/processed, and the source of the main ingredients. Learners need to complete a given table that indicates the production/process method and source of main ingredient for each food item on their list. When the table is completed and the class is together, each team has to read through their list, describing their findings and any difficulties they had in finding out information Research activity Spilt the class into research teams, to investigate organisations which are responsible for regulation in the food industry. Using books and the internet the research teams have a fixed amount of time (say 20 minutes) to find out and report back on a range of organisations the regulate the food industry, this should include, but not be limited to: Food Standards Agengy, DEFRA, and Environmental health practitioners http://www.defra.gov.uk/corporate/ Main Activities: Interpreting an article: Read an article on a recent “food scare” to the class. Discuss as a class the possible sources of contamination of food in the various stages of production Ask learners (working in pairs) to draw a flip chart poster that illustrates how/where contamination may occur in the food chain. GCSE Additional Applied Science 3 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe13746682 http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/jan/07 /dioxin-alert-eggs-enter-uk-german-farms Points to note Flipcharts can then be displayed and shared. Ask learners to add on to their posters where regulation would occur and who would be responsible for this regulation. Once completed posters can be photographed for learner’s files Leaflet Design: following a presentation by the teacher on Biodiversity and crop production, learners are asked to design a leaflet for the Food Standards Agency will help young farmers understand the importance of preserving biodiversity and how this can be achieved in farming GCSE Additional Applied Science 4 Reviewing work Learning Objectives Possible Learning Activities Learners should learn Review their knowledge and understanding of people and regulation GCSE Additional Applied Science 5 Matching exercise: provide learners with a list of job tiles and organisations. Also provide a list of short statements that matches one of the job titles or one of the organisations. Ask learners (working individually or in pairs), to match the two lists in a specified time (max 5 minutes) Resources Points to note 4.2 Food production Learning Objectives Learners should Possible Learning Activities 4.2.1 know that as crops grow they remove essential nutrients from the soil that need to be replaced (use of artificial fertilisers, soil dressings and organic sources of nutrients e.g. manure). 4.2.2 understand that plants need nitrogen, phosphorous, potassium and magnesium for healthy growth and the effects of deficiencies of these nutrients on the plants. Know that nitrogen is found in chlorophyll; phosphorous is found in ATP, an enzyme involved in energy transfer; and potassium is important in water regulation by controlling the opening and closing of stoma. 4.2.3 interpret data to show how intensive farming increases crop yield by using artificial fertilisers, pesticides, fungicides and herbicides. 4.2.4 draw and label diagrams of plant cells. Understand the function of the following parts: cell membrane, cytoplasm, nucleus; plus cell wall, chloroplast, vacuole. 4.2.5 understand the importance of photosynthesis whereby green plants and other photosynthetic organisms use chlorophyll to absorb light energy and convert carbon dioxide and water into glucose, producing oxygen as a by-product. The chemical reactions of photosynthesis within the cell are controlled by enzymes. Know the word equation for photosynthesis. (Details of the enzymes involved in photosynthesis are not required.) 4.2.6 explain how intensive farming increases food production by using controlled environments. Controlled environments allow the management of conditions such as temperature, light and ventilation and the amount of carbon dioxide that is available for photosynthesis in plants. 4.2.7 know that fertilisers are water soluble GCSE Additional Applied Science 6 Farm visit: arrange for learners to visit an arable farm to see first hand the production methods used, the farms policy on use of fertilisers and pesticides etc,. Visits to two different farms, one using mostly intensive methods and one using organic methods would be of great benefit if possible to arrange this. Resources http://www.defra.gov.uk/environment/natural/ biodiversity/ Horticultural nursery visit. Arrange for learners to visit a large scale nursery operation (many local councils have their own nurseries, or a commercial organisation). The control of the environment to encourage the process of photosynthesis could be highlighted on such a visit Starters: Research activities 1) Advantages and disadvantages of intensive farming and organic farming: spilt learners into research teams to carry out investigations into the advantages and disadvantages of intensive farming or the advantages and disadvantages of organic farming.. Each research team should then give a 5 minute overview of their findings http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intensive_farming http://www.buzzle.com/articles/advantagesand-disadvantages-for-intensivefarming.html http://www.organic-store.co.uk/organicfarms.html 2) What’s the alternative? Explain to learners that biological control of pests is an alternative to the use of pesticides. Research teams now need to identify at least 2 real life examples of biological control and then list the advantages and disadvantages of biological control (if learners struggle with this task, the teacher could provide two examples to help with identifying advantages and disadvantages, good examples to use would be: ladybirds to kill aphids and Myxomatosis virus to kill rabbits) Main Activities: http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/s cience/add_gateway/chemical/fertilisersrev1. shtml Data investigations: Learners are provided with data that forms a “case study” of a particular farm. They need to interpret this data to comment how yield has increased over a period of time, and how much fertiliser has also been used. Different teams of learners could be presented with different data, which they could then join together to discuss. Data should also be provided on measures of http://www.besy.org.uk/Doncaster/SCIENCE%20%20Leaf%20T5AgroBiology%20science%20 broad%20.pdf http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_pest_c ontrol http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myxomatosis Points to note and some fertilisers can be prepared by neutralisation reactions (e.g. ammonium sulphate). 4.2.8 describe how organic farming keeps animals under more natural conditions and that alternative methods are used in crop production such as the use of natural pesticides and natural fertilizers, and mechanical methods of eliminating weeds. 4.2.9 discuss the advantages and disadvantages of organic and intensive farming (food quality, cost, animal welfare, crop yields, effect on environment, public opinion and awareness). 4.2.10 understand the difference between selective breeding and genetic modification. Genetic modification also allows the genes from an unrelated organism to be transferred. The new organism with the inserted genes has the genetic information for one or more new characteristics. Selective breeding is the process of breeding the animals with the characteristics you want with other animals with those characteristics to produce more animals with good characteristics over many generations. 4.2.11 discuss the advantages and disadvantages of selective breeding and the use of GM in the food industry. 4.2.12 assess how crop growth is affected by factors such as plant density, light levels and the use of fertilisers. 4.2.13 understand what is meant by biodiversity, the variety or number of different species in an area, and why it is important. Understand the need for and issues associated with the collection of reliable data and ongoing environmental monitoring. Appreciate how mathematical modelling can be used to analyse environmental interactions and predict trends. 4.2.14 understand the principles of sampling, the need to collect sufficient data and use of appropriate statistical analysis. (Details of statistical tests are not required.) 4.2.15 use quadrats to investigate the abundance of species. 4.2.16 understand how farming methods can GCSE Additional Applied Science 7 biodiversity on the farm as crop production methods have changed. Learners can then interpret this data to assess the impact of different crop production methods on the farm. Learners should also be asked to comment on the validity of the data. Practical activities Effect of deficiencies of N,P and K on plant growth and development Using test tubes containing 5 different water cultures: one with all nutrients in, one with all nutrients except Nitrate, one with all nutrients except Potassium, one with all nutrients except Phosphorus, and one final tube containing just distilled water (i.e. no mineral elements at all). Using 5 seedlings which all appear to be at the same stage of development, place a seedling in each test tube, so that the root is covered by culture solution. Using wheat seedlings works well with a strip of cotton wool around the grain to hold it in place in the test tube but leaves root and shoot free. Seedlings need to be left for two weeks, but water level will need topping up in each tube regularly (and very carefully) each with distilled water only. After two weeks various measurements and observations can be made: leaf colour, leaf length, total root length and weight, How intensity of light affects the rate of photosynthesis. Using pondweed and varying light intensities, the rate of photosynthesis is measured by the amount of bubbles (oxygen) given off from the cut end of the piece of pondweed. Light intensity can easily be altered by varying the distance a light source is from the beaker containing the pondweed. The water the pondweed is submerged in must have be a suitable concentration of sodium carbonate, to ensure there is enough Carbon Dioxide for photosynthesis to take place From field to food. Explain to learners that a field which is currently left uncultivated is about to be used for crop growth. They have been asked to investigate how this could affect the biodiversity of the area. Using standard sampling techniques, transects, quadrats and pooters etc.. Learners work in teams to identify organisms. All the data collected is then combined back in class and there is a discussion about how organisms may be affected if crops are grown. Working in pairs learners are then asked to write an e-mail to the local planning office about the effect of changing the use of the field. Any filed, including one in the school grounds could be used for this activity, if a filed near a farm was accessible, this would obviously make the practical activity more realistic. http://www.field-studiescouncil.org/outdoorscience/diy.htm impact on biodiversity (e.g. use of pesticides, fertilisers and land drainage). Interpret data to assess the impact of different methods of crop production on biodiversity. GCSE Additional Applied Science 8 Research and debate activity: World food supplies and GM (genetically modified foods). Following a presentation from the teacher which recaps on genetics. Learners are split into research teams to find the facts. They need to answer the following questions: How does plant breeding help in the production of crops? What are GM foods? Does the world have enough food to feed its population? What concerns do people have about GM foods? Research teams are now allocated into one of three categories: a)“for” GM foods, b) “against” GM foods, c) the deciders . Those allocated into a or b must now use the information they obtained to make a convincing argument, those allocated into c must decide who is the most convincing and why lhttp://www.channel4learning.com/support/pr ogrammenotes/micro/farmrevealed/prog1.ht ml Reviewing work Learning Objectives Possible Learning Activities Learners should Review their knowledge and understanding of food production Bingo: Ask learners to draw quickly a blank nine square “bingo” grid. Teacher writes on the white board 12 key terms related to food production topic, such as: Biodiversity, pesticides. Chlorophyll, intensive farming etc... Learners choose 9 of these terms and write them into their squares. Start the “game” by reading the first definition of one of the 12 terms and continue in a random order. Learners’ mark of their “card” when the definition read out matches a term they have written on their card. Learners can call out when they have a “line” and they read back both the terms and definitions. The “game” can continue until someone has a full house Reviewing a website: provide learners with a particular website (such as the one given here). Explain that they are a website reviewer, they need to work through the web based activity and comment on what is good about the activity, who could use it, how it could be improved. Learners could work individually on this task or in pairs, different pairs could review different website activities GCSE Additional Applied Science 9 Resources http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/sci ence/add_aqa/plants/plants1.shtml http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/sci ence/21c/food/farmingmethodsact.shtml Points to note 4.3 Food processing Learning Objectives Possible Learning Activities Learners should 4.3.1 be able to describe the use of bacteria, yeast, and other fungi in food production (bread, wine, beer, yoghurt and cheese). 4.3.2 understand the different stages in the processing of yoghurt, cheese and beer. Interpret information on yoghurt, cheese and beer production. 4.3.3 know the optimum conditions for the growth of bacteria (suitable temperature, moisture, and food source) and the significance of this in food production. 4.3.4 explain why non-homogenised milk separates into two layers. 4.3.5 describe how milk can be homogenised. This is achieved by pumping milk at high pressure through narrow tubes and explains how this affects the size of fat globules in milk resulting in an emulsion. 4.3.6 understand that food spoilage occurs. It may be accelerated by storage conditions and is often due to bacterial and fungal action. 4.3.7 explain different ways in which the growth of bacteria is slowed down or stopped (refrigeration, freezing, heating, drying, salting, smoking, pickling (lowering pH)). 4.3.8 understand that pasteurisation is a process which slows microbial growth in food and recognise that it can be used to treat a number of foods including beer, milk and fruit juice. 4.3.9 understand that milk is pasteurised by heating sufficiently to kill some pathogens. This does not sterilise the milk since the food will still deteriorate with time. 4.3.10 understand how food preparation areas are kept free of bacteria (personal hygiene, disinfectants, detergents, sterilisation, disposal of waste, control of pests e.g. insects, mice and rats). 4.3.11 explain how cross contamination of GCSE Additional Applied Science 10 Resources Hook Activities: Food production visit: arrange for learners to visit a food production company to see the production of yoghurt, cheese or beer first hand. This could be linked to talks by various employees on how the a particular product is produced . (from field to fridge) http://www.ukagriculture.com/field_to_fridge/ field_to_fridge.cfm?strcategory=Milk%20Pro duction&strdate=5.00am&intro=no On screen production techniques Pull together a range of online/video clips which all contain examples of food production techniques. Using only a few seconds of each clip to produce a montage. Show the montage and ask learners to identify as many foods being produced as they can http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6vBBW1v uJEk&feature=related http://www.foodafactoflife.org.uk/VideoActivit y.aspx?contentId=163&sectionId=63&siteId= 14&titleId=171 http://www.world-of-cheese.com/cheesemaking/videos.htm Starters: Converting information. Provide learners with text wihich describe the different stages in the processing of yoghurt, cheese and beer production. Working in pairs and using flip chart paper, ask learners to convert this information into a flow chart How should it be stored—practical activity? Using a (fairly ripe) soft fruit such as plums or pears, discuss with learners how these should be stored? Ask learners to come up with a way to test different storage conditions, ask them to think about temperature, moisture, light etc... Leave fruit in different conditions for a week, observe as a class changes in the fruit. Ask learners what has caused the fruit to spoil? Which condition was best for keeping the fruit from spoiling? Main Activities: Resource station research: set up resource stations around the room, which contain a range of information about the different ways in which the growth of bacteria can be slowed down. The information provided at each resource station should be varied—i.e. pages of text, a short video, an audio cassette, website pages. http://www.biotopics.co.uk/edexcel/biotechno l/yog.html http://www.world-of-cheese.com/cheesemaking.htm Points to note food can be prevented. 4.3.12 know that food poisoning is caused by the growth of microorganisms, usually bacteria, and by the toxins they produce when they grow. 4.3.13 give examples of bacteria that cause food poisoning (Campylobacter sp., E.coli, Salmonella sp.) and know the common symptoms for food poisoning (stomach pains, vomiting, and diarrhoea). 4.3.14 interpret data on the growth of microorganism (colony counts, turbidity). 4.3.15 discuss the potential impact of the contamination of food products, with bacteria (e.g. by commercial food preparation outlets). Working in groups of 5, the group has to decide which member of the group to send to each resource station. Within a fixed time limit each learner must make notes about the information at the resource station. Learners from different groups will need to work together at each resource station. Learners then return to their own “home group” and take it in turns to explain what they learnt at their resource station. Food contamination: A local hotel has asked for help in explaining to new kitchen staff how food preparation areas can be kept free of bacteria. The hotel would like the leaflet to include information on the fact that food poisoning is often caused by bacteria in food. The leaflet needs to include information on personal hygiene, disinfectants, detergents, sterilisation, and disposal of waste and cross contamination. . Learners could each produce individual leaflets and then compare and select “the best” or this could be a team activity Alternatively a local hotel manger could be invited to judge the leaflets and select the best one Causes of food poisoning Make a set of cards for learners; with each card noting the name of a particular bacterium that can cause food poisoning if possible include an electron microscope photograph of the bacteria on the card. Ask pairs of learners to select three cards each. Using books and the internet ask each pair to find out the following information about each bacteria on their cards: What disease can the micro-organism cause? What are the symptoms of the disease? Can the disease be treated? Findings can then be shared in class, cards could be displayed on classroom walls Practical activities to investigate the growth of microorganisms: There are numerous microbiology practical activities that could be undertaken. These include a)Finger plate tests on the effect of antibacterial hand washes (this could be linked to the food contamination leaflet activity above, by setting this in a hotel kitchen scenario) b)Altering conditions for growth, temperature, ph of growth medium etc. and analysing growth by colony count or turbidity c)Effect of different disinfectants by using paper discs soaked in c) different disinfectants (or different strengths of disinfectant) d) testing the freshness of different milk samples GCSE Additional Applied Science 11 http://www.sparsholtschoolscentre.org.uk/teac hers/resources/secondary/milk_micro_lab.p df http://www.biotopics.co.uk/edexcel/pracw.html Reviewing work Learning Objectives Possible Learning Activities Learners should Review their knowledge and understanding of food processing Memory board: write down a number of terms related to the topic of food processing (pasteurisation, sterilisation, colony counts, bacteria, toxins, disinfectants etc....). Give learners a minute or so to remember the terms (but not to write them down). As soon as the time is up rub the terms off the board, now ask the students to write down, not the terms themselves, but the definition/explanation of the term. Again give only a specified time to do this then go over each term and discuss the different ways in which learners have defined/explained them , Go large exam questions: Write out an exam style questions on the topic of micro-organism growth at the top of a flipchart sheets. Put these sheets on desk around the class room. Allocate pairs of learners to a particular question sheet. At the word “go” the pair makes a start to answer the question they have been allocated to, at the word “move” learners then move to another question. There needs to be more questions then pairs of students, as only one pair is allowed at a question sheet at anyone time. When at the second and subsequent question sheets, learners need to read the previous answer, add to this or make corrections to any incorrect information. At the end of the activity (say up to 5 “moves”) learners return to their original questions, review and mark the answer that has been provided. . GCSE Additional Applied Science 12 Resources Points to note