April 15, 2012 Wildlife.corridors@environment.gov.au tony.burke.MP@aph.gov.au Bob Debus AM Chair, National Wildlife Corridors Plan Advisory Group Submission Why we need National Wildlife Corridors From Maryland Wilson, President Australian Wildlife Protection Council Inc (AWPC) Thank you Chair, Bob Debus and Environment Minister Burke for this opportunity to establish interconnected, continuous wildlife corridors AWPC will concentrate on Devilbend, a 1005 Hectare Reserve on the Mornington Peninsula in Victoria, which is denied proper Classification A designation change from a ‘Natural Features Reserve’, under Section 4(1)(m) (and Part 3 of the Fifth Schedule) of the Crown Land Reserves Act 1978 to Devilbend as a ‘Nature Conservation Reserve’ under Section 4(1)(0) (and Part 1 of the Fifth Schedule) of the same Act, is absolutely critical if we are to save remaining native species on the Mornington Peninsula. Interconnecting wildlife corridors, through private land, minimum 100 metres in width and rigorous preservation and restoration of Devilbend as a central core Reserve are essential to reserve the area for ‘the propagation or management of wildlife or the preservation of habitat’ Co-operation and support of landowners is needed to link key habitat areas so recolonisation and genetic exchange between populations can occur, and to secure the future of small isolated populations. Australian Wildlife Protection Council Inc KINDNESS HOUSE, 2nd Floor, 288 Brunswick Street, Fitzroy, Victoria 3065 Australia TEL: 03 5978 8570 FAX: 03 5978 8302 MOB: 0417 148 501 kangaroo@hotkey.net.au www.awpc.org.au www.rootourism.com.au Patrons: Professor Peter Singer and the Hon Richard Jones Registered Charity: A0012224D Why wildlife and Devilbend need protecting The Mornington Peninsula’s Devilbend is a watershed opportunity to restore a biodiverse core nucleus habitat to link interconnecting wildlife corridors, with the rest of the Peninsula. This valuable remnant vegetation, and its over 200 species of native fauna has naturally evolved because for the past 50 years, entry to the reservoirs and its surrounding landscapes has been restricted. Indigenous flora and fauna have had virtual protection in this keystone habitat during this time of limited access. Most of Victoria’s native bushland has been cleared. Victorian have lost 35 per cent of its’ wetlands and most waterways are degraded. Devilbend has 42 per cent of native vegetation, with eleven ecological classes present, eight endangered in Gippsland Plans Bioregion. The Swamp scrub is of state significance due to its highly depleted nature and low level protection in conservation reserves; over 216 fauna species, and 19 State significant birds, one nationally significant fish, and the Growling Grass Frog. Genetic dispersal and variation is the genetic key to survival of species. Our fauna depend on being able to migrate between genetically diverse populations. Devilbend must be managed as a central core habitat link for wildlife corridors to prevent genetic drift, as native species need genetic diversity and variability to ensure their survival. Research shows that when native species are trapped in isolated, fragmented areas of habitat, without interconnecting habitat in which to move, breed or live, over time their populations implode and they die-out, resulting in local extinction. The Mornington Peninsula has lost many species – invertebrates, mammals, especially the small macropods, birds and plants. Devilbend Reserve is so important, that, properly managed, it could prevent further extinctions. Our conservation concern for the future of wildlife Malcolm Legg, ecologist, Glenn Ehmke, Birds Australia “When wildlife is lost from a landscape/region, the number of species decline and local extinctions result. Extinction however, is a process, not an event, and the time scale over which species loss occurs is highly variable and species-specific. Therefore, despite the fact that major changes may have occurred in the past, the effects of those changes are in many cases yet to be fully manifested. This “time-lag” between landscape change and species loss is termed “species relaxation” or “extinction debt”. A number of studies both overseas and in Australia where landscape modification is very recent (-200 years) have identified extinction debt as a significant concern for biodiversity conservation in highly modified landscapes. Even in the absence of further direct loss and fragmentation of habitat, degradation of habitats will continue as weed invasions, dieback, edge effects and other processes impact isolated remnants, and isolated populations will continue to suffer the effects of genetic drift, inbreeding and susceptibility to chance events. Thus, the local populations of some species may be expected to decline to extinction over time. This is reflected in the large number of threatened and declining species in the region today.” Source: AWPC Devilbend leaflet www.awpc.org.au Holistic approach is a necessary tool of management for Devilbend Reserve We must act now if we are to save rapidly disappearing native species from certain demise, due to drought, climate change, and bushfires, or we drive them further to extinction. With Peninsula Link- roads & freeways proposed on the Peninsula, dredging on sides, human population growth & increased development, all our native birds and animals are threatened. Recreational uses have been accepted by Park Victoria for Devilbend; it will lose the values for which its conservation features have been declared. Devilbend is not even now Australian Wildlife Protection Council Inc KINDNESS HOUSE, 2nd Floor, 288 Brunswick Street, Fitzroy, Victoria 3065 Australia TEL: 03 5978 8570 FAX: 03 5978 8302 MOB: 0417 148 501 kangaroo@hotkey.net.au www.awpc.org.au www.rootourism.com.au Patrons: Professor Peter Singer and the Hon Richard Jones Registered Charity: A0012224D monitored to a degree sufficient to prevent illegal activities, let alone being able to cope with development on the scale proposed by Parks Victoria in 2012. Devilbend as a wildlife sanctuary Practical Ecology’s Flora and Fauna Assessment, 2 May 2008, p.5 considers Devilbend ‘state significant’ because of its flora, vegetation, fauna and habitats (especially wetlands). ‘There is a demonstrable need to effectively mitigate against loss of species as a result of recreational activities’ (Practical Ecology p.59). Our very strong opposition to developing Devilbend as a playground for recreational users, with all the negative ecological impacts on native birds and animals has been, and continues to be, ignored by government. The Practical Ecology Report stated firmly that “disturbances such as fishing, boating, bushwalking and bird watching have the potential to lead to the flushing of birds from nests, territories or shelter”(ibid p 59) To protect, preserve what is in Devilbend, a management plan should include: Removal of grazing leases, incompatible with conserving,protecting biodiversity; Natural regeneration focus on highest quality areas, identifying wildlife corridors and linking these to neighbouring private properties and public lands outside the Reserve; Kangaroo proof fences erected throughout Mornington Peninsula Shire are preventing safe migration of wildlife, pushing them into unsuitable habitat and causing unnecessary road deaths; smaller species are snared in the fence trip wire and die. Bushland within private properties needs to be secured for wildlife links With relatively few visitors over the past 20 years or so, the reserve should be full of native animals – not foxes, cats, pigs, goats and deer, which must all be removed. Devilbend– the largest new reserve on the Peninsula should be a jewel in the crown of the Victorian government. The opening up of new trails, a new picnic ground, fishing and its infrastructure are likely to further decimate wildlife. “We need not only to protect what is there but also to re-introduce species that were lost over time. It is the long term potential that matters most. This can be achieved if Devilbend is properly protected and managed,” according to ecologist and forensic scientist Hans Brunner, Submitted by Maryland Wilson, President Australian Wildlife Protection Council/ Coordinator Coalition for Wildlife Corridors October 23, 2006 Ian Miles DSE Executive Director Biodiversity and Ecosystems Services PO Box 500 E Melb Vic 3002 re: Link to Devilbend Reserve Continuous, connecting wildlife corridors is best solution to DSE ‘destruction to ensure balance’ mentality, and protect our unique wildlife heritage for future generations. Safe habitat upon which our native wild species depend for survival is essential. Dear Dr Miles, DSE hierarchy is lagging far behind in wildlife protection with their colonial mentality "If it moves shoot it, and if it doesn't chop it down". Your 'balance' approach does not work because wildlife always loses: ~ It is obscene that you treat sentient beings with such callous abandon! Wildlife corridors must be established as a matter Australian Wildlife Protection Council Inc KINDNESS HOUSE, 2nd Floor, 288 Brunswick Street, Fitzroy, Victoria 3065 Australia TEL: 03 5978 8570 FAX: 03 5978 8302 MOB: 0417 148 501 kangaroo@hotkey.net.au www.awpc.org.au www.rootourism.com.au Patrons: Professor Peter Singer and the Hon Richard Jones Registered Charity: A0012224D of urgency. DSE issues 80,000 animal control permits "Wildlife in the Gun" Herald Sun article ~ October 20, 2006 by Sarah Wotherspoon Macropod expert Doug Reilly 'From Conservation to Exploitation in South Australia' Page 36 ‘The Kangaroo BETRAYED” (1999 Hill of Content Publishing, Melbourne ): "In any wild animal if you disrupt in a short period of time the normal reproductive processes that have evolved over tens of thousands of years you are in danger of putting the species at risk. Precedents have been set in other parts of the world where large populations of a species have faced extinctions after widespread and destructive 'culling' programs. Many of these species suffer incursions of exotic bacterias and viruses when their populations contained a critical and unsustainable gene pool." "Where pastoralists (with sheep, cattle and crops) are in competition with any native animal, the government administrators always favour the land owner. Whatever native animal is involved, that animal is marked for destruction." 'The Kangaroo Betrayed' 1999 page 37 AWPC publication DSE policies of death and destruction have nothing to do with 'balance' as wildlife has no voice. Your 'balance' is to cater to landholders who, as proved in Caufield Grammar School fiasco, the permit issued by DSE to kill kangaroos was revoked when the facts became known. Kangaroos would have been murdered, as DSE Officer Tom Thuys gave the permit in the name of 'balance'. Link to Devilbend Map of Mornington Peninsula shows a large 400 acre plot of land on Brown's Rd- Rosebud, that has been allocated to a market garden farmer, displacing and traumatising Eastern Grey kangaroos, whose habitat, this land rightfully is. Without a thought DSE, others think they have a right to trample over all of the other species with whom they share this planet, with no regard for their survival or their welfare, many of which once thrived, plentiful but are now endangered or extinct. The Eastern Grey Kangaroos are ‘supposed' to move to Greens Bush, to join other trapped, displaced, disorientated kangaroos. This is the ‘balance’ that allows horse-breeder Lloyd Williams, the 400 acre market gardener and others with an economic incentive to create more and more misery for kangaroo mobs, displaced, disorientated, traumatised and in the final solution killed, or as they say in DSE 'culled' This scenario is repeated many times. Parks Victoria is paying a consultant to count kangaroos that will be killed at Greens Bush. These mobs are counted so ‘culling’ can occur because ‘there are too many of them’. If there are too many of them it is because humans have stolen their habitat and forced them into Greens Bush or just forced them out. DSE continues to issue permits in the name of 'balance' but the economic imperative over-rides all decisions. Neil Burgess Liberal Candidate for Hastings was happy to tell me at Frankston Train Station, 28.9.06 ..."there are ten times more kangaroos than is sustainable; they have to be 'culled', "The fact that Liberals want to introduce commercial killing is part of the 'balance' process you employ and the reason why 41,378 grey kangaroos were murdered from July 1, 2005 to July 27, 2006. Greens Bush is used as a dumping ground for kangaroos; there are constant calls to kill them. You are obligated to provide safe passage for them in habitat that is connected and continuous and linked to existing national parks, reserves. We must NOT kill them under any circumstances ...as we have the perfect solution to your 'balance' problem: Wildlife Australian Wildlife Protection Council Inc KINDNESS HOUSE, 2nd Floor, 288 Brunswick Street, Fitzroy, Victoria 3065 Australia TEL: 03 5978 8570 FAX: 03 5978 8302 MOB: 0417 148 501 kangaroo@hotkey.net.au www.awpc.org.au www.rootourism.com.au Patrons: Professor Peter Singer and the Hon Richard Jones Registered Charity: A0012224D Corridors- interconnected continuous links to Devilbend/ core habitat Humans have caused this problem; it is up to them to fix it humanely, with empathy for the future survival of kangaroo mobs. Bio-links are the only solution to this abuse of our ethical and moral duty and responsibility we all must share, to protect our wildlife heritage for future generations. Eastern Grey kangaroos are endangered in 20 out of 100 sites surveyed on the Mornington Peninsula, and extinct in the 80 that had none at all, so they are extinct. What an indictment on all at DSE. We are losing our beautiful grey kangaroos. The strongest and fittest must survive to ensure variability in the gene pool. You can fix the 'balance' immediately by establishing continuous, connecting, wildlife corridors all linked and connected and continuous. It is your duty to do so. Kangaroos maintain and control their own populations as they have done for the past 16 million years of evolution before the last 200 years of persecution, in the name of 'balance' Sincerely, Maryland Wilson, President Victoria Requires a Fauna Data Base (Local Government, Shires, Councils) Victoria has no Fauna Management Framework. No one keeps such records. There is a Native Vegetation Management Framework! The state is zoned agricultural, living off the sheep’s back/ wheat crops/ irrigators/ permaculture/ goat/emu farmers.DSE former Dir General, Chloe Munroe, former Premiers, have all stated that Agriculture is their number one priority, (not wildlife). Kangaroos are trapped in suburban sprawl- people hate them, students torment, harass them. Children not taught to respect them which is why there are so many incidents of young people cruelly torturing and harming them. Victoria’s Minister for Planning allows or disallows environmental destruction. Page 20 of AWPC ‘The Kangaroo BETRAYED’, “Victorian Inquiry into Commercial Utilisation of Native Fauna” “Michael Delahunty, professional shooter gave evidence that if there is no commercial Industry in Victoria, the shooting is inhumane and that farmers simply kill kangaroos as they desire and in a brutal way. The hunter from the Shooting Sports Council of Victoria said that the illegal take of kangaroos in Australia is as big as the legal take. Delahunty said that the way kangaroos are destroyed is inhumane and that we Victorians should have a kangaroo industry. He claimed to have lots of visitors involved in wildlife products and that the kangaroo killing industry would be most viable. A most disturbing question came from one of the Committee Member, Mrs Helen Shardley. MP who asked ‘Do you think we have enough people trained in Victoria to kill kangaroos?’ see book Bureaucrats, politicians fail responsibility for welfare; DSE fast tracks permits to kill them. Wildlife Corridors in Shire/ approximately 79 Councils in Victoria- Need to prioritise, identify existing corridors of land as first to be targeted; rural areas easily lend themselves to wildlife corridors, so do some metropolitan Councils; Bundara area where hundreds of kangaroos are possibly facing extinction because of the sale of the La Trobe Uni land to a private developer. We can map out wildlife corridor in Puckapunyal area; including north and south; target those Councils. There are the Cape Schank kangaroos, Hume Shire Council, Whittlesea Shire Council. Maroondah Shire Council and Yarra Ranges Shire Council. Find where kangaroos reside in Victoria and map them. There are two ways to deliver our message to Councils: Firstly, by in-person-submission direct to Council meetings (preferred); Secondly, by written submission to appropriate person, CEO or Mayor, or Ward Councilor for those Councils which make no democratic provision for direct access to Australian Wildlife Protection Council Inc KINDNESS HOUSE, 2nd Floor, 288 Brunswick Street, Fitzroy, Victoria 3065 Australia TEL: 03 5978 8570 FAX: 03 5978 8302 MOB: 0417 148 501 kangaroo@hotkey.net.au www.awpc.org.au www.rootourism.com.au Patrons: Professor Peter Singer and the Hon Richard Jones Registered Charity: A0012224D Council? Each Council is unique and the language of our submission should reflect this. QUESTIONS: Does Victoria have mappings of kangaroo populations in geographic locations? Where are the kangaroos? What do we know about kangaroo populations in Victoria? Does the Environment Minister implementing the Flora and Fauna Guarantee Act Why is there is no Native Fauna Management Framework yet a Native Vegetation one? Connecting, continuous corridors at least 100 metres in width linked to National Parks and existing reserves, sanctuaries, private land continuous and connected is the goal !!! ‘When habitat is lost from a landscape/ region, the number of species decline and local extinctions result. Extinction is a process, not an event, and the time scale over which species loss occurs is highly variable and species-specific’. Our fauna depend on being able to migrate between genetically diverse populations to ensure survival. Devilbend Reserve is an important Bio- Link Why wildlife and Devilbend need protecting Parks Victoria is obliged to use the Precautionary principle: “We must act together to prevent impacts, particularly where there is potential for serious or irreversible damage to occur. A lack of scientific certainty or information should not delay these actions, towards working towards restoration as an intact haven for wildlife.” (Parks’ Guiding Principles Appendix 1 Devilbend Reserve Community Workshop, 22.11.07 P5 Sect. 3) A holistic approach is needed to manage Devilbend Reserve as a necessary tool of management to save rapidly declining species from certain demise, if we do not heed their vulnerable state, now subject to drought and climate change. With roads and freeways proposed on Mornington Peninsula, dredging on both sides of the Peninsula, massive population growth and industrial development, birds and animals are threatened. If inappropriate recreational uses are accepted for Devilbend Reserve, the reserve will lose the very values for which it has been declared a Natural Features Reserve. At present, Devilbend is not monitored to a degree sufficient to prevent illegal activities occurring, let alone development on a scale proposed in the Parks Draft Management Plan 2008. The McPhail Report State of Environment 2008 slates Victoria for failing to protect native species, and clearing more land than any other state in Australia. The critique of Victorian bureaucrats impacts directly on the importance of Devilbend as core nucleus habitat on the Mornington Peninsula. Devilbend must be preserved as a wildlife sanctuary. “When wildlife is lost from a landscape/region, the number of species decline and local extinctions result. Extinction however, is a process, not an event, and the time scale over which species loss occurs is highly variable and species-specific. Therefore, despite the fact that major changes are in many cases yet to be fully manifested… [Something missing here]. This “timelag” between landscape change and species loss is termed “species relaxation” or “extinction debt”. A number of studies both overseas and in Australia where landscape modification is very recent (-200 years) have identified extinction debt as a significant concern for biodiversity conservation in highly modified landscapes. Even in the absence of further direct loss and fragmentation of habitat, degradation of habitats will continue as weed invasions, dieback, edge effects and other processes impact isolated remnants, and isolated populations will continue to suffer the effects of genetic drift, inbreeding and susceptibility to chance events. Thus, the local populations of some species may be expected to decline to extinction over time. This is reflected in the large number of threatened and declining species in the region today.” Devilbend leaflet produced with Malcolm Legg, ecologist and Glenn Emhke, Birds Australia reveals our strong conservation concern for the future survival of wildlife: Australian Wildlife Protection Council Inc KINDNESS HOUSE, 2nd Floor, 288 Brunswick Street, Fitzroy, Victoria 3065 Australia TEL: 03 5978 8570 FAX: 03 5978 8302 MOB: 0417 148 501 kangaroo@hotkey.net.au www.awpc.org.au www.rootourism.com.au Patrons: Professor Peter Singer and the Hon Richard Jones Registered Charity: A0012224D Genetic dispersal and variation is the genetic key to survival of species. Devilbend must be managed as central core habitat link for wildlife corridors, thus preventing genetic drift so species have genetic diversity /variability dispersal through wildlife corridors to ensure their survival. Research shows that native species trapped in isolated, fragmented areas of habitat, and populations without interconnecting habitat in which to move, breed or live, eventually implode and die-out, causing local extinction. We already know that Mornington Peninsula has lost many species – invertebrates, mammals, especially the small macropods, birds and plants. Devilbend reserve, properly managed, could play a major role in stopping such extinctions. Devilbend as a wildlife sanctuary Practical Ecology Pty Ltd considered that (p 5, report 2008) Devilbend is ‘state significant’ because of its flora, vegetation, fauna and habitats (especially wetlands). “There is a demonstrable need to effectively mitigate against loss of species as a result of recreational activities’ (Practical Ecology p 59). It behoves government to pay more respectful attention to the expertise and public opinion that the Devilbend Foundation and AWPC bring to this Draft Management Plan. Government's job is to adapt to our demands, not to impose the demands of developers, big business and specialised interest groups on us or the rest of the people and creatures on the Peninsula. Our very strong opposition to developing Devilbend as a playground for recreational users, with all the negative ecological impacts on native birds and animals continues to be ignored. Practical Ecology stated firmly that “disturbances such as fishing, boating, bushwalking and bird watching have the potential to lead to the flushing of birds from nests, territories or shelter”(ibid p 59) Existing habitat in parks and reserves on the Peninsula is not good kangaroo habitat the role of Devilbend as core nucleus habitat - Devilbend should support a significant kangaroo population but is sparsely populated, due to unfriendly Kangaroo-Proof fencing, hunting in years past by lessees, feral animals ect. We need a management plan that includes: Habitat improvement in existing reserves and parks and the establishment of important wildlife corridors linking Devilbend to Greens Bush, Arthur’s Seat, etc so that range animals like kangaroos can have freedom of movement for genetic dispersal; Removal of grazing leases incompatible to conserving and protecting biodiversity; Natural regeneration/ restoration approaches focusing on highest quality areas to start; Identifying wildlife corridors to link to neighbouring properties/ public lands outside Devilbend Devilbend has lost its populations of Southern Brown Bandicoots, potoroos, echidnas, platypus, koalas and less common gliders, frogs, Water rats and possibly bats. With relatively few visitors over the past 20 +years, the reserve should be full of native animals – not foxes, cats, pigs, goats and deer. Poor management is probably to blame. The Draft Management Plan from Parks Victoria should provide a modern, innovative and effective Plan for managing the public estate – the biggest new reserve on the Peninsula and one that should be a jewel in the crown of the Victorian government. We see little evidence of this in the proposed management; indeed, the opening up of new trails, a new picnic ground, fishing and its infrastructure are likely to further decimate wildlife, spoil any changes of rehabilitation and disappoint the many concerned people in the community. To manage Devilbend reserve as core habitat and to establish corridor-linkage, Re-Classification of Devilbend is critical to preventing the total demise of wildlife on the Mornington Peninsula. A designation change from a ‘Natural Features Reserve’, under Section 4 (1) (m) (Part 3 of the Fifth Schedule) of the Crown Land Reserves Act 1978 to Devilbend as a ‘Nature Conservation Reserve’ under Section 4(1) (0) (and Part 1 of the Fifth Schedule) of the same Act, to save rapidly disappearing native species on the Mornington Peninsula. Interconnecting wildlife corridors, through private land, minimum 200 metres in width, and the rigorous preservation and restoration of Devilbend as a central core Reserve are essential to reserve the area for ‘the propagation or management of wildlife or the preservation of habitat’ Australian Wildlife Protection Council Inc KINDNESS HOUSE, 2nd Floor, 288 Brunswick Street, Fitzroy, Victoria 3065 Australia TEL: 03 5978 8570 FAX: 03 5978 8302 MOB: 0417 148 501 kangaroo@hotkey.net.au www.awpc.org.au www.rootourism.com.au Patrons: Professor Peter Singer and the Hon Richard Jones Registered Charity: A0012224D DSE at work killing native wildlife above! A last resort? Respectfully submitted, Maryland Wilson, President Australian Wildlife Protection Council Inc KINDNESS HOUSE, 2nd Floor, 288 Brunswick Street, Fitzroy, Victoria 3065 Australia TEL: 03 5978 8570 FAX: 03 5978 8302 MOB: 0417 148 501 kangaroo@hotkey.net.au www.awpc.org.au www.rootourism.com.au Patrons: Professor Peter Singer and the Hon Richard Jones Registered Charity: A0012224D Australian Wildlife Protection Council Inc KINDNESS HOUSE, 2nd Floor, 288 Brunswick Street, Fitzroy, Victoria 3065 Australia TEL: 03 5978 8570 FAX: 03 5978 8302 MOB: 0417 148 501 kangaroo@hotkey.net.au www.awpc.org.au www.rootourism.com.au Patrons: Professor Peter Singer and the Hon Richard Jones Registered Charity: A0012224D Australian Wildlife Protection Council Inc KINDNESS HOUSE, 2nd Floor, 288 Brunswick Street, Fitzroy, Victoria 3065 Australia TEL: 03 5978 8570 FAX: 03 5978 8302 MOB: 0417 148 501 kangaroo@hotkey.net.au www.awpc.org.au www.rootourism.com.au Patrons: Professor Peter Singer and the Hon Richard Jones Registered Charity: A0012224D