Peer Review Rubric Final Project
Have two peers review your project. Discuss results. Make changes. Include rubrics in portfolio.
Student:
Scoring criteria
5
4
Theme/Objective
Clearly and effectively
communicates an introduction
of the theme/objective of the
ethics topic.
Effectively communicates an
introduction of the
theme/objective of the ethics
topic but questions remain.
Role of the ethics
expert.
Clearly and effectively
communicates the fictional
role of the ethics expert.
Ethical dilemma
Explains clearly an ethical
dilemma.
Solution
Explains clearly how the
expert would solve an ethical
problem.
Ethical standards
Explains clearly which ethical
standards apply.
Absolutist and
relativist
Explains clearly an absolutist
and relativist view of their
ethical situation.
Research
websites
Glossary
websites
Wiki websites
Ethics blogs
Ethics topic
websites
Position paper
Has ethics research websites
in portfolio. (4)
Has ethics glossary websites
in portfolio. (2)
Has ethics wiki websites in
portfolio. (2)
Has ethics blogs in portfolio.
(2)
Has ethics topic websites in
portfolio. (5)
Has position paper websites in
portfolio. (3)
3
2
1
Misses point completely in
introduction of the
theme/objective of the ethics
topic.
N/A
Misses point completely in
introduction of the role of the
ethics topic.
N/A
Misses point completely in
an ethical dilemma.
N/A
Misses point completely in
an ethical solution.
N/A
Misses point completely in
which ethical solutions
apply.
N/A
Misses point completely an
absolutist and relativist view
of their ethical situation.
N/A
Effectively communicates
the introduction of the role
of the ethics topic
but questions remain.
Effectively communicates an
ethical dilemma but
questions remain.
Effectively communicates an
ethical solution but questions
remain.
Effectively communicates
which ethical standards
apply but questions remain.
Effectively communicates an
absolutist and relativist view
of their ethical situation but
questions remain.
Does not effectively
communicate an
introduction of the
theme/objective of the
ethics topic.
Does not effectively
communicate introduction
of the role of the ethics
topic.
Does not effectively
communicate an ethical
dilemma.
Does not effectively
communicate an ethical
solution.
Does not effectively
communicate which ethical
standards apply.
Does not effectively
communicate an absolutist
and relativist view of their
ethical situation.
4
3
2
1 or
less
2
1
0
N/A
2
1
0
N/A
2
1
0
N/A
5
4
3
2 or
less
3
2
1
N/A
total