UNICEF MOZAMBIQUE REQUEST FOR CONTRACT FOR SERVICES UNICEF Mozambique - TERMS OF REFERENCE Child-centered risk and vulnerability assessment, 2013 1. Background and Context Mozambique faces frequent severe natural hazards leading to disasters as they interface with various levels of vulnerability. This often causes loss of human lives, destruction of infrastructures, disruption of social services and economic activities, and damage of livelihood assets. It provokes recurrent setback of development efforts and condemns both rural and urban populations to slide periodically into further vulnerability and poverty. The country has been also experiencing the effects of climate change whether in terms of seasonal changes, high sea levels, and increase temperature and change in the patterns of rainfall. Mozambique experiences occurrence of multiple hazards; some parts of the country are more exposed and susceptible than others to specific hazards than others. This includes natural, climate change impact driven hazards, and man-made hazards. In effect, 25% of the population lives in areas at risk of multiple hazards and vulnerabilities, lacking disaster-resistant infrastructure, with little observance of disaster-sensitive land-use and planning, while poor or non-respected regulation fail to mitigate risks. The tables below depict the impact of natural disasters occurred in past three centuries and the country disaster risk profile. Table 1: Summary disaster risk profile Table 2: Population exposed to disaster risks Hazard Type Population exposed Country ranking Natural Disasters from 1980 - 2010 No of events: 75 No of people killed: 104,840 Cyclone 233,559 21st out of 89 Average killed per year: 3,382 No of people affected: 23,317,164 Average affected per year: 752,167 Economic Damage (US$ X 1,000): Economic Damage per year (US$ X 1,000): 802,650 Drought Flood Landslide Earthquake 1,356,890 114,760 568 23,309 46th out of 184 24th out of 162 79th out of 162 91st out of 153 Tsunami 8,540 46th out of 76 25,892 Source: see1 The cumulative impact of reoccurring small- and large-scale disasters drain substantial resources from government budgets, hampers national development efforts, depletes coping strategies, and forces UNICEF Country Office to deviate from the planned development programmes. If DRR and Climate Change Adaptation (CCA) are not systematically integrated into government, partners and UNICEF’s plans, programmes, policies and practices, this pattern is likely worsen due to increased exposure, poor development practices, pervasive vulnerability and poverty, environmental degradation and climate change impact. 1 http://www.preventionweb.net/english/countries/statistics/index.php?cid=117 DRR and CCA have been identified as cross-cutting themes in the Government PARP, UNDAF, and UNICEF’s Country Programme Document for 2012-2015. To achieve increased national resilience to disasters, crises and external shocks, the agencies within the Economic Development Results Group (DRG Economic 3) will focus on capacity development and support to vulnerable populations. From UNICEF’s perspective, there is a need to understand that disaster risk reduction and climate change adaptation is closely linked with development in general and in relation to children in particular. Children are recognized as the most vulnerable population worldwide to disasters and climate change because they already suffer the greatest burden of climate sensitive diseases such as malaria, malnutrition, and diarrhea; demand adequate nutrition for cognitive and physical development; and are dependent on adults for their safety during extreme events and under social stress, while they could play a significant role in reducing risks and responding to disasters. For example, in the recent floods in the Limpopo basin in January 2013, around 69,000 school children were displaced and left without schools and lessons, causing severe disruption of schooling2. However, no thorough analysis exists to assess the impact of disasters on children in complex environment in Mozambique 2. Justification Despite the progress in preparedness, our current emergency/crisis risk related planning processes are overlapping and have been developed outside of UNICEF’s core Country Programme process which guides the work and resources of UNICEF Country Offices. Child-centered risk assessment is a fundamental step towards risk informed development programming aimed at seeking both to protect the development investments themselves against hazards including hazards driven by climate change impact and to strengthen community resilience. Such an assessment helps to integrate risk reduction in the development process rather than considering DRR as an end in itself. UNICEF Situation analyses (SitAns) are generally developed for three main purposes: advocacy for children, informing programming at strategic level, and influencing government and partners’ priorities for children. In regards to the second purpose (programming), as an evidence-based organization, UNICEF programmes need to be developed on the basis of a sound child-centered analysis of disaster (including climate change) and conflict risks when appropriate. These risks will significantly impact the realization of child rights and attainment of Millennium Development Goals, and may result in emergencies requiring a UNICEF response. The development of child-centered vulnerability and risk assessment, as a complementary exercise to the SitAn, will help ensure that UNICEF Country Programmes proactively reduce disaster risks for children. The conclusions of the analysis also could provide an opportunity for advocacy and fundraising around Disaster Risk Reduction and Climate Change Adaptation sensitivity of programmes3. 3. Purpose and objectives The overall objective of the consultancy is to develop a combined child-centred multi-hazard-risk and vulnerability analytical mapping. The result analysis of the child-centered multi-hazard risk 2 3 Mozambique floods 2013 - consolidated early recovery strategy, HCT, April 2013. UNICEF Technical Note: Emergency Risk Informed Situation Analysis, August 2012. assessment will contribute to the elaboration of UNICEF SitAn in 2013 as part of the core analysis of the situation of children in Mozambique, eventually to inform and influence programme planning. Specific objectives: i. ii. iii. Propose a set of disaster risk indicators at provincial and district levels. Based on the set of indicators on child vulnerability (under development by UNICEF Planning team) as well as on the identified disaster risk indicators, build a combined disaster risk and child vulnerability index. Prepare and present a technical report on the main finding. 4. Methodology and Technical Approach Innovative and uniqueness of the approach Child centred risk assessment is a fundamental step towards risk informed development programming aimed at seeking both to protect the development investments themselves against natural hazards and to strengthen community resilience. Such an assessment helps to integrate risk reduction in the development process rather than considering DRR as an end in itself. Disaster risk could be measured as the potential damage and loss, due to the occurrence of a hazard (hazards) interfacing with the vulnerability of objects at risk, at specific time and location. Each component or element in the risk analysis could be unpacked and broken down into various parameters that determine its level or value. The hazard(s) identification, mapping, analysis and assessment are initial steps towards assessing disaster risk. This requires gathering and analysing information on pertinent aspects or characteristics of hazards (frequency, magnitude, duration, impacts etc.) in order to assess hazards. These characteristics vary from one type of hazard to another and their assessment or measurement differs accordingly. Measuring risk is a subjective process as measuring of its elements is not a straight forward process where indirect or proxy measures or methods might be used wherever data is not available. For example, while it is possible to estimate the value of potential or actual infrastructure damage, it is difficult to estimate value of human loss (death, injuries and suffering). Therefore, the objective of the proposed assessment shall be an indicative, where the results shall indicate to and inform the country office where the most vulnerable are, why they are vulnerable, for what hazards, and their locations. Methodology There are previous experiences of conducting child-centered multi-hazard risk assessments done by UNICEF Country Offices (Nepal, India, Philippines and Pakistan). They used different methodologies to conduct child centered vulnerability and risk assessment, a combination of qualitative, quantitative and spatial assessment methods were used to give relative measures of disaster risks in different districts in those countries. This is in addition to other types of analysis (e.g. rights-based and qualitative studies) were used to identify rights-holders/duty-bearers and the enabling/disenabling factors that influence children disaster risks in relation to multi hazards. In the case of Mozambique, given the limitation of reliable disaggregated data, time and funding constraints, the following possible methodology is suggested and will need to be assessed in terms of the context of the country. The multi-hazard and child-centered risk assessment will be conducted in parallel to the SitAn in order to provide a comprehensive risk-informed situation analysis and programme plan. Quantitative assessment This type of assessments relies heavily on available and recent data that shall be used to measure the elements and level of risk. The data must be reliable and available to all districts or provinces of the country or where the assessment is planned to be conducted. Such assessment may allow a comparison between the levels of child vulnerability and disaster risk in various locations of the country, and ensure consistency. However, same question as in qualitative assessment will need to be addressed i.e. what indicators will constitute vulnerability, values. There is a need to build a consensus about those indicators and how to make use of them to measure each component with the disaster risk. Relying on readily available data and applying it to calculate risk levels may not reveal or help understanding the causal relationships between the different elements of disaster risk and child vulnerability. Based on spatial analysis of disaster risks and child vulnerability indicators in Mozambique (the latter being developed by UNICEF Mozambique, in particular in the area of health and education) by using DHS data, INE District Administrative data, among others), it should be possible to analyze the effect of disaster risks into the overall child vulnerability by building a combined disaster risk and child vulnerability index. Under the guidance of Emergency Specialist, the consultant will undertake the following steps: Step 1: Multi-hazard risk assessment Disaster risk mapping to be completed based on historical and current data and information available from different sources. This could be done manually (layering or overlaying regular maps of different hazards) or using GIS and database software. Whether a manual or computerized systems or methods are used, information and data from reliable sources will need to be obtained and verified, which could be available from i.e. INE, INGC, UEM. FEWS-Net and line ministries among others. A scientific multi-hazard assessment of Mozambique is yet to be developed, though there are single hazard maps available for drought risk, flood risk and tropical storms. These maps are likely to exist among scientific and/or educational institutions in the country. A disaster risk measurement or index will be needed in order to measure the value of a risk(s) or level of significance of risks in a province/ selected district, and to allow comparison between provinces/ selected districts. Step 2: Child vulnerability assessment The second step in assessing risk is assessing child vulnerability. This will use a child vulnerability index that consists of a set of indicators, that are currently under development by the Planning team of UNICEF (and that will be shared with the selected consultant/s). Step 3: Overlaying multi-hazard (disaster risk) and child vulnerability data Should a manual disaster risk and vulnerability mapping and analysis be done, map overlaying will be used to assess and rank (colour coding could be used for different risk levels) levels of risk across the country. In order to combine a disaster risk assessment with UNICEF’s vulnerability index, a composite index will be designed to allow weighted calculations of child risk and pilot a child-centered risk assessment of the provinces/districts. As follow-up, a mapping of child risks and vulnerability in all provinces and selected districts will be produced. In order to allow for comparisons, all measures could be converted to relative numbers on a scale from 0 to 10 and weight assigned based on the above distribution. Step 4- Disaster Risk and vulnerability analysis Following the assessment of disaster risk and child vulnerability, relative risk levels could be measured. By calculating the value of disaster risk for all provinces and selected districts, a risk scale could be established to allow comparison and ranking between the various provinces and districts. 5. Activities and Tasks Review and discuss with relevant UNICEF staff the feasibility and adjustment of the technical approach defined. Identify, analyze and organize official data sources of information (databases) related to disaster risk indicators. Engage with the government and other UN related partners in the discussion in order to ensure consent by the relevant stakeholders Develop a composite child-centered risk index and measuring methodology and elaborate a technical report of its implications, including spatial analysis. Present and validate with UNICEF staff a draft version of the child-centered risk and vulnerability assessment and incorporate comments and suggestions received. Produce final risk assessment including data, composite index, spatial risk and vulnerability analysis. 6. Deliverables i. ii. iii. iv. A disaster risk index and database on multi-hazard and child development vulnerabilities at provincial and district level (where data is available). Quantitative and qualitative spatial risk assessment methodology and tools are developed and to give a relative measure of the disaster risk index vulnerability of children in Mozambique. Final risk assessment report, including data, composite index on combined disaster risk and child vulnerability analysis, spatial risk and vulnerability analysis. A brief summary analysis document containing key findings to be incorporated in the SITAN as preparation for the Strategic reflection 2013 and onwards. The work of the consultant has been organised to facilitate flexibility in approach as well as support variations in focus and timing through the process. The consultant will develop a work-plan as first assignment which will indicate specific deliverables for completion, based on the TOR. Once approved, this will serve as the foundation for payment in three tranches. 7. Management, Organization and Schedule The Consultant will report to the Emergency Specialist. In addition the consultant will be advised by the Social Policy/SitAn co-ordination team, and will work in direct collaboration with staff from all sections as a part of his/her assignment, and in consultation with the Representative/Deputy Representative as required. The assignment will start 9 September, 2013 and should end by 31 October, 2013. 8. Remuneration The consultant will be paid as follows: This will serve as the foundation for payment in three tranches: Date September 9 , 2013 September 27 , 2013 October 12, 2013 October 31, 2013 Deliverables expected Work-plan and data gathering Percentage to be paid 0 1st month will be dedicated for data consolidation, construction of disaster risk and vulnerability index and database. Submission summary analysis of spatial disaster risk and child vulnerability by September 27. 2nd month submission of spatial analytical report based on the agreed risk and vulnerability index. Final report including executive summary for publication. In English and Portuguese. TOTAL 33.3% 33.3% 33.3% 100% 9. Qualifications and Specialized Knowledge The consultant should meet the following minimum requirements: Master or equivalent level in the Social Sciences, Monitoring and Evaluation or other relevant field area. Conversant in Portuguese and English (written and spoken). At least five years of relevant work experience. Capacity to work in team building environment, and to work with minimum supervision. Communication skills and abilities and written proficiency, including presentations with resource to technology. Confident with the use of Windows and office package: Word, Excel, Access and PowerPoint. Strategic thinking capacities and capacity to stress ideas and recommendations clearly. 10. Conditions of Work The equipment and materials needed to carry out this activity will be supported by the assignment. Condition of work To be provided by UN Agencies Yes No no Field Trip Transport International Travel Visa for internationally recruited DSA no no no Security Clearance no Accidental Death Dismemberment and Medical coverage Health Insurance and Accident no no Remarks Please indicate location and # of travels Please indicate itinerary Please indicate # days covered Not required at this stage if not travelling out of Maputo For Consultants traveling outside their country of residence Responsibility of consultants and individual consultants Office Space Computer Secretarial Services Photocopier services Other supplies Yes Partial no no no no Please specify type 11. How to apply Applications from interested candidates must contain the following documentation: a. b. c. d. TECHNICAL PROPOSAL Curriculum Vitae; Letter of Motivation, with sample of work; Technical Proposal; Copies of recommendation letters. FINANCIAL PROPOSAL The Financial Proposal shall be presented in Meticais or US$ and should include details of the inherent costs of the consultancy as per point 8 above. Please notice that UNICEF accept no liability for any taxes, duty or other contribution payable by the consultant on payments made under this contract. No statement of earnings will be issued by the United Nations or UNICEF to the consultant. SUBMISSION: The proposal (Technical/Financial) shall be presented to the UNICEF Office to the following e-mail: hrmaputo@unicef.org Subject: BID Reference 2013/HR/012-1 Child-centered risk and vulnerability assessment, CLOSING DATE TO RECEIVE APPLICATIONS: 03 September 2013 UNICEF is committed to gender equality in its mandate and its staff. Well qualified candidates, particularly females are strongly encouraged to apply. Only shortlisted applicants will be acknowledged. UNICEF IS A SMOKE FREE ENVIRONMENT