1 SUPPORTING INFORMATION 2 Appendix S1: Tissue nutrient data from T. ornata collected at Gump Reef and Sailing School 3 Reef. 4 Methods. T. ornata thalli were collected from our two sites, Gump and Sailing School reefs, to 5 evaluate nitrogen and phosphorous content. 10 samples of algae from each site were rinsed in 6 freshwater, dried at <60°C, ground with a mortar and pestle, and sent to the University of California 7 Davis Isotope Facility. 8 Results. Tissue nutrients, nitrogen and phosphorous, by percentage of dry weight were 9 significantly higher for T. ornata collected from Gump than Sailing School Reef (see Figures S1 and 10 S2 below). Bittick et al. 11 Figure S1: Graph of tissue % Nitrogen at each site. % Nitrogen is significantly higher at Gump than 12 Sailing School by T-test (p-values <.0001). 13 2 Bittick et al. 14 Figure S2: Graph of tissue % Phosphorous at each site. % Phosphorous is significantly higher at 15 Gump than Sailing School by T-test (p-values <.0001). 16 17 3